Facebook wanted to make sharing photos a little easier. Instead, its gallery suggestions have landed Meta an $887 million fine in Italy over access to Android users’ photos.
On Nov. 14, Italy’s privacy regulator said Facebook had failed to clearly explain how the feature used phone galleries or obtain specific consent, affecting about 20 million Android users. Meta has 60 days to disable the feature by default and request separate permission, although it plans to appeal.
The ruling also raises questions for users and app developers across Europe about what people actually agree to when they grant an app access to their photos.
Facebook’s photo suggestions triggered the €805M penalty
According to Italy’s Data Protection Authority, the investigation concerned Facebook’s “Get suggestions from gallery when browsing Facebook” feature, which has been available since 2023.
The feature recommends photos and videos from a user’s phone gallery as potential Facebook posts. However, regulators found that Facebook requested gallery access through a single authorization covering several app functions.
The permission request was preceded by a generic notice about enabling additional features. It did not adequately explain that accepting would also enable gallery suggestions.
The feature was also enabled by default. The regulator said granting full gallery permission could allow the app to access an entire photo archive on an ongoing basis, without users being able to verify exactly what information was used.
The investigation began in July 2025 following a complaint from a consumer protection organization in Bolzano, Italy.
The authority considered the approximately 20 million affected Android users, the duration of the infringement, and what it described as Meta’s insufficient cooperation when determining the penalty.
Meta disputed the decision.
“Users must grant permission on their device before the feature can operate,” a Meta spokesperson said in a statement reported by Reuters.
The company said users could change that permission through their device settings and confirmed plans to appeal.
Italy’s ruling puts European app consent under scrutiny
Italy’s decision could have consequences beyond Facebook. The case centers on a question that affects mobile apps across Europe: Does giving an app permission to access photos also authorize every feature that uses them?
The Italian authority based its decision on Article 122 of the country’s Privacy Code, which implements the EU’s ePrivacy Directive. Under those rules, accessing information stored on a smartphone requires specific, informed consent, even when the information remains on the device.
Meta challenged the Italian regulator’s authority to investigate the case, arguing that Ireland’s privacy regulator should handle it. Italy rejected that argument, explaining that the ePrivacy framework does not use the GDPR’s one-stop-shop enforcement mechanism, which generally allows a company’s lead EU regulator to oversee certain cross-border cases.
Although the ruling applies to Meta’s conduct in Italy, similar photo-sharing, editing, and recommendation features could face scrutiny elsewhere in Europe if users are not clearly informed about how apps access their data.
The case also adds to questions surrounding Meta’s handling of personal information in Europe, including the data protection and profiling rules affecting its AI agents.
For app developers, the dispute brings renewed attention to default settings and permission requests, particularly when an existing authorization.
Meta must disable gallery suggestions by default
Italy’s regulator gave Meta 60 days to disable Facebook’s gallery suggestions by default and introduce a separate consent request explaining how the feature accesses photos and how users can turn it off.
The changes must also apply to people who previously granted Facebook permission to access their galleries, not just those installing or updating the app.
Meta must inform the regulator within 30 days about the steps it has initiated and report the measures implemented within 90 days. The authority said changes introduced after the original complaint were insufficient because they came too late and applied only to users who updated the app.
For companies offering mobile apps in Italy and other European markets, the decision raises questions about how new privacy controls should apply to existing users. Updating a permission screen in the latest app version may leave people using older versions with settings that no longer meet the regulator’s requirements.
Android users can review Facebook’s photo access now
Android users do not need to wait for Meta’s response to the Italian ruling to check their current permissions.
According to Google’s Android support documentation, users can manage which apps have access to their photos and videos directly through their device settings.
Three checks can help:
- Review Facebook’s gallery access: Open Android Settings, select Apps, choose Facebook, and navigate to Permissions, then Photos and videos. Review or change the access granted to the app.
- Check Facebook’s gallery suggestions: Look for gallery suggestion options in Facebook’s settings and disable unwanted features. The original Italian consumer complaint identified separate controls for personalized suggestions and suggestions shown while browsing.
- Limit access where supported: Android’s photo picker allows users to share selected images with compatible apps instead of granting access to their entire gallery.
Available controls may vary by Android version and device manufacturer. Restricting permissions may also affect Facebook features that require access to photos or videos.
For businesses in Italy and elsewhere in Europe, the case also raises concerns about personal and work-related information stored on the same device. Employees may keep photographs of company documents, meeting notes, or other sensitive material alongside personal pictures.
Italy’s investigation did not establish that Facebook accessed corporate information. However, organizations that allow employees to use personal Android phones for work may want to review how apps access locally stored files.
IT teams managing company-owned Android devices can review app permission policies, while businesses supporting personal devices can consider Android Enterprise work profiles to separate managed work applications and data from personal content.
Meta’s AI photo processing remains a separate question
The investigation did not establish whether Meta used the affected photos or videos to train artificial intelligence models.
Meta denied using the material for AI training, according to the Italian regulator, which said the issue was outside the scope of its investigation.
The authority may also examine a separate feature introduced in 2026 that allows Facebook to process photos and videos from users’ galleries in the cloud. The €805 million fine does not cover that feature.
Meta plans to appeal the penalty, leaving the final outcome of the dispute uncertain. Any investigation into the newer cloud-processing feature would be a separate matter.
For the approximately 20 million Android users affected in Italy, the next development to watch is how Facebook changes its consent requests and whether people who previously allowed gallery access will be asked to approve the suggestions feature separately.
Keep up with Europe’s latest technology, AI, and cybersecurity developments. Subscribe to Tech Insider Europe for essential coverage of the region’s evolving technology landscape.