Discussion Locked

2nd NIC

0 helpful
17 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hello all...
I have access to the internet via a cable modem. My ISP uses DHCP for there customers. I'm running an NT server connceted to 2 clients via a small 5 port hub. My question is can I install a 2nd NIC card on the server, use one of the cards for my ISP and the other card have configured for my clients??
Any ideas would be greatly appreciated.
Thank you,
Tim

17 replies

by admin

Let the ISP assign one NIC an IP addy via DHCP and then use a program with NAT or I used to use the MS proxy program. There are quite a few proxy software programs to do this too.

Another idea, that gives you some level of hardware protection, isto get a small router and let it use the assigned WAN ip and then NAT your LAN. I prefer this solution and if you watch pricewatch.com or whatever you can do it for less than 100$

by bc

I have had experience with this exact setup using both a software and hardware solution. If you want to stick with the dual NIC setup and a software solution, you can use Sygate or Wingate with your NT4 Server.

If you dont want to pay for thatsoftware, you can reload that NT box with Win98 and use their Internet Connection Sharing component. Better yet, just add the second NIC to one of your Win98 clients and configure the sharing through that one.

If you're willing to dish out about$100, I'd go with a Linksys Cable/DSL router. And you can simply remove the 2nd NIC from your NT box. We have used this solution for quite some time now and are really satisfied with it because of all the advanced features and configs the router has to offer.

Best of luck
Brian

by ebob

Take the load off of the NT box and let it just continue to do whatever it is supposed to do. Spend the few bucks and get one of those Cable/DSL routers that are all over the place. LinkSYS is good, so is Asante, D-Link, USR, 3-Com, etc. (the list seems endless these days!).

The great thing about this approach is you can work on your NT box without disturbing the users' Internet connections.

In general, the router will pick up an IP address from the ISP, and will also act as a DHCP server(if you want it to) for your internal systems. These have some firewall capabilities, which is real nice.

by mikkawi

Guys I think that the 2 NIC solution is good enough, it separates the WAN from the LAN (keeps intruders from hacking the LAN PCs), and by installing a Proxy server (a freeware on will do) all the LAN will get unlimited internet access. The solution is cheep and more secure. isn't it?

by todd kimbrell

I like Brian's reply due to one simple reason, "Security" I have a SOHO cable router and I can shut down every UDP/TCP port at the firewall, and all hits against your firewall can be tracked. You will find the overall sharing performace much to your liking and the setup procedures are simple and concise.

Good Luck.

by timmitchell

If you've already got your hub in place, you could get a DSL router from Linksys. A single port router will cost you under 80 bucks, and it'll have a built-in firewall and a web interface. I use a similar solution on my DSL network, with the router acting as an interface between the DSL line and my LAN; in addition, the router can also act as a DHCP server on the LAN side so you can free up your NT server from DHCP duties. It's an easy fix, and does not require configuration changes on your client machines.

Good luck!

by timmitchell

Sorry, guys... my page hadn't refreshed and I didn't realize that I was giving the same suggestion as Brian's above.....

by admin

have a NIC and install it yourself etc.
This solution would give an internet addressable ip to the box acting as proxy and it's generally relatively easy to get into this. The proxy may shield the second box more than the first though. Still, sincehe's using the first one for more than a proxy he'd be better off with both behind a router. It's relatively difficult to get into a NATted box on a private address, which they would both then be.

If he's got parts lying around, he could build a box and have a standalone proxy and get pretty much the same effect, but 100$ is cheap insurance and sure to save valuable time later. Both would work, but I again encourage the latter.

by sdavis

Tim, I'm doing somewhat the same thing (minus the NT server). I have 6 Windows machines (95 through ME) in a peer to peer network, all connected through 2 4-port NetGear hubs. I've set up my Win98 machine as a proxy server (dial-up connection); I can run have all my computers on the Internet at once, through the one connection. I can't imagine why you would need a second NIC.

by bearbait

I have 5 pc's all 98, plugged into a linksys 10/100 hub on a peer-to-peer that all independantly access the Linksys router that connects the dsl. I am using static ip and my isp requires PPPoE, which the router supports. The router has a built in firewall, and is totally and easily configurable.

by michael.an

Tim,

I'm assuming that you want to install the 2nd NIC on your NT server so that the other 2 clients can share the one internet connection. I have that exact same setup. I'm running a software from Sygate to share the connection. This software, which can also act as a DHCP server for your local network, uses NAT to allow all 3 of your machines to use 1 Internet connection. Actually, the lastest version of this software can accomplish this with only 1 NIC on your server. Go to their website for more info.

Keep in mind that with this setup, your NT server will have to be on in order for the other clients to connect to the internet. To avoid this, you can buy a broadband router.

Hope this helps. Good luck.

by jennyh

I have this same setup with a cable modem and NT Server but with 30 clients accessing the Internet. I use a PC, as a proxy server running WinProxy. The PC has two NICs; one connected to the cable modem; one connected to a network hub. The internalnetwork uses static IPs and WINS. The ISP does use DHCP but we usually keep the same IP for the external NIC even after reboots of the proxy or cable modem. Even if we are assigned a new IP, WinProxy recognizes the change and updates it's setup.
Added security was a major consideration when I choose to setup the Internet access this way. WinProxy does include a software firewall and TrendMicro Antivirus. Just for overkill I added Norton Security firewall and antivirus to the proxy server. Additionally the *user* for the proxy server has no rights to any directory or service on the NT Server. File and Print sharing is not loaded on the proxy.

You don't need a heavy duty PC to use as a proxy. Mine is a Pentium 266 with 64MB RAM. It needs a reboot about once a month is all. On the clients, the only setup required is to point their browser and mail programs to the proxy's internal IP address.

Good Luck,

JennyH

by dpark68

Hey everyone,
You know all of your solutions are great. I personally would pickup a netscreen 5a hardware firewall appliance. It allows for dhcp on the untrust interface also supports ppoe. it will act as a router but also allows you the capabilty to vpn into your network with 10 vpn tunnels using ipsec compliant vpn software and also allows you the flexibility to configure the firewall to your needs and it is really easy to configure.
It's just a thought. the netscreen 5a lists at $495. I think it is well worth the extra money especially on a cable (shared) network to be able to not only share your connection but you can restrict outgoing traffice and incoming traffic to your lan. One drawback though is that it supports only 10 users the 5xp supports unlimited users and upto 100 sessions at once. For more info goto netscreens website. www.netscreen.com
Just a thought...

by it-sage (bschirf)

One thing that nobody has mentioned yet is the problem with VPN.

If the PCs on the 2nd NIC need VPN access through your cable modem, then you can't use the "2nd NIC" solution.

VPN won't work with "IP forwarding", thus they'll need to be connected to a router, which is then connected to the cable modem.

$0.02

by ebob

The software solution on a 2NIC box is cheaper. I wouldn't go with Proxy, but with one of the software firewalls like ZoneAlarm or BlackICE. But these are still no match for the hardware approach. Those cool little Cable/DSL routers not only do NAT,but most also have some form of "stateful packet inspection", which is central to a real firewall, and they don't have the risk of a well-known operating system running underneath, which itself can be compromised.

This discussion is closed to new replies.