Discussion Locked

A conflict of interest: a friend or a manager

0 helpful
34 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hello all,

I have a staff member who has been working for me for the last two years. He is also a good friend of mine as well.

Base on his performance and experience, I have paid him as much as I think is appropriate. However, he still believes the company is not paying him enough. I have conveyed my thought to him already however he has not changed his mind. He is also not happy with the culture and the operating procedures/processes. Being his first job, he wants to venture out to get the experience.

He is using "personal emergency" as an excuse to be missing from work for 2-3 hours for interview. Despite that he still made up the time but that put a negative perception of him by the team.

There are two situations that I could do:
1. Leave him be & not tell the CEO, with the acceptance of when the staff will leave. The staff can stay here until he can get the next job. I would be wasting my time to train him any futher.

2. Tell the CEO of the situation so I can recruit someone and get that person trained up to replace the staff. If the CEO knows then the staff will get sacked. However, I have more stable team.

Anyone has a opinion on this? Which one I should do?

34 replies

by zlitocook

That you are looking for a replacement. Let him know that in leaving for another job that he will need to train his replacement.
As for Telling the CEO of the situation be careful that you do not let him you knew before hand that he was looking. It sounds like your staff knew about this too. Have you shown your friend the wages for the type of work he is doing? And for a first job is the wage right?
Have you given or is there someone who gives performance reviews?
Things like this are good reasions not to hire friends. If you hire a friend you feel a responsibility to help them make it, even if they are bad at the job.
If he feels he can get a better paying job at a better company, tell him that?s great and good luck. If he has a great offer he will leave but if he is trying to get more money, you will see it right away.

by vncoder

I have told him my conflict of interest and that I would not tell the CEO that I need a replacement until my friend got the next job. His experience is in line with the current market salary (actually, slightly more than the average) would be for his experience, skill and responsbilitites. However, he believes he should getting more - at least 20K more. I said Goodluck to him already....
However, this is going on too long (almost 2 months now). I don't want to be left in limbo - wether to get the replacement in or keep on training my friend. I believe I need to give him the ultimatum - leave within certain period of time (2 months) or stay for at least certain period of time (2years+).
Is this a good tactic to follow through?

by zlitocook

Would give him a time frame and let him know that his looking for a job has affected your team. If need be pull him aside and tell him that he is lowering productivity because of his attitude.
This is the time to be a boss and set your friendship aside I know it is a hard thing to do but that?s the reason you lead.
Let him know that his replacement is ready to take over and he needs to take his great job by a certain date. And at that date he is to leave.
I know this sounds hard but you will find that there are a few people out there that do this on a regular basis. You need to let them know that they will not disrupt the company or the team.
There are the back stabbers, the people who ride the back of others the people who can get a better job and the people who just complain about every thing.
They need to be pointed in the right direction or be let go. You need to document every thing and keep a paper trail, in case it comes back to you.
I have been through the same thing a few times and it is not fun!

by proejctmanager

As you're working for the company and you're in a reputable position, you should make friends, however ensure that you don't mix up friendship with office as it will cause you lot of overhead and inconvenience and it will also play a big role during decision time within the team, It's better to tell him positively and black & white during the review, As you need not worry about this and it's the person who should take it seriously.

by vncoder

Thanks for that. I had the same feeling as well. Just want to be 100% sure that I am doing the right thing. Will talk to him in a few days time.
Thanks.

by wayne m.

First, sit down and determine what the issues are and then take steps to resolve them. One should not be in the position of running to the CEO to deal with minor personnel issues.

What precisely are the issues that you are concerned about? Is the employee following the operating processes and procedures? Is he continually missing work? Does he have a bad attitude that is infecting the team? Is he working on a high risk task where losing a team member may put it in jeopardy?

Take a careful situation and separate the issues that actually affect the team from those that merely irritate you. He's not happy with whatever? Let him know where he needs to improve. He's been job hunting for two months now? Probably nothing is going to happen; if he really wanted to be out of there, he wold be. Is he staying within acceptable use policy of "personal emergency time"? If so, just let the rest of the team deal with it. If not, let him know the guidelines and hold him to them.

The key is to identify how he is affecting the team and let him know what steps are needed.

by jdmercha

If you're paying him better than market then you can assume that he won't be leaving. Yet your two situations assume that he will leave.

by vncoder

Yes, both situations (scenarios) assume that he will leave. Had a couple of talks with him already but he is undeterred and still want to find another place.
I pay him above the market because I value his input and that he has the potential to grow. However, that was before he told me that he is looking for another place.

by jdclyde

that he is just saying he is leaving to either get attention (you begging him not to leave) or a bid to get more money out of you?

You have already stated he for some misguided reason thinks he should be making even more than he is, so he is probably hoping you will give him the raise so you can "keep him on".

Like I said in my other post, this guy is going to ruin your friendship if he keeps working for you because he is using your friendship to take advantage of you and the company.

This is NOT a good person to have as a friend.

by jdclyde

would not take advantage of you, nor put you in such a bad situation.

You need to tell him flat out, do his job or give his notice.

Do not allow someone to pretend to be your friend and get you in major trouble at work. Anyone that was a REAL friend would NEVER put you in such a sistuation.

by chipshopman

I've had good friends work for me before and I've always made it clear up front where my loyalties lie during work hours, always the company, never the friend.

This is up to you to manage, not the CEO. Have a meeting with your team member (for that's what he is when he's at work, not your friend) and deal with it in exactly the same way you would if it was any other member of the team. Set out your expectations and explain the consequences of not doing so, i.e. If you are having interviews, they must either be outside work hours, or you must book holiday with at least a week's notice, or disciplinary processes will follow...

However, it does sounds like your friend needs a chat with a mate outside work to bring his expectations of work/salary/experience back in to balance. Take him down the pub and talk to him.

by pijin

The reality here is that you have a staffer who's already left the company. Maybe not physically, but in his mind he's no longer concerned with the benefit of the organization.
When hiring anyone my worst nightmare is a mediocre employee. A truly crappy worker you can fire and be done with, a great staffer and all is well with the world, but when they're not bad enough to merit firing, but not good enough to provide any substantial contribution you're stuck in that limbo left feeling inneffectual.
You know in your heart he's gone and yet you don't want to fire him and leave him in a lurch.
You need to get authority to hire a replacement and make it happen right away. Let him know he's training his replacement and will need to find new employment in the next 30 days. Dragging it out will just make you miserable.
Complaining to him about what he's done puts control of the fix in the hands of the one who created the problem. The best you can hope for is that he will learn from this experience and not blame others for a situation he caused.

Managing is a crummy job when you care,
Cameron

by andrew.carrington

Option 3 is to act as this guys manager. Discuss the matter with your friend and be very open and honest about things.

Your friend needs to know that you have responsibilities to the CEO and that unless he can 'find another way', then you have little option but to discuss matters with the CEO.

It might cause a bit of awkwardness at first but things will settle down especially if he then goes on to another job.

Andy
IT Manager
regs4ships Ltd (UK)

by dilipj

Hi

1. If he is a good friend, he must be understanding your feelings.
2. If he is good to work then after his leaving there will be a vaccum till new one arrives
3. better talk to CEO and convince him to recruit a person who can comfortably take over your friends work within a month's period by working with him.
4. Tell to your friend that what arrangements you are going to talk with CEO.
5. Also this is an indirect message to your good friend that he has to leave within a month's period. Because in no way he can put you in trouble in your job. SO he must be decide the timeline.
6. Be a Professional. Personal relations has to do nothing on office floor.

by dominick-murphy

Be a manager and run your department, bring him up on disciplinary actions for his behaviour, advise him that "family emergencies" have been too much and are unacceptable and that he needs to buckle down and be part of the team, department and company or else you will take the disciplinary to the next level...

Anybody I would consider a friend wouldn't put you in the situation you are in...

Tell him thanks but time to go...

by simplyx

My boss was and still is one of my best friends. He knew I was not happy, same as your worker. We basically came to an understanding that as long as it did not interfere with my current duties, that I gave the expected 2 weeks notice, and helped train my replacement, that I was free to schedule interviews when appropriate. I did not abuse our understanding and always kept him in the loop. To this day I help him out with IT issues even though it's been over two years since I left. I believe that if we were just co-workers, I would not have had the chance to improve my career and the company would have suffered from a demoralized employee, because after all, we're not robots. It was this kind of attitude towards me that earned my respect and loyalty. I gave him four years of my best, not the company. The company owed me nothing, and I owed it nothing. A company is just words on paper, it's the people that matters. Now, as a manager, I find myself in the same situation with a 21 y/o employee, and learning from my old boss, the situation is working out well. How do I benefit from holding somone down? Ultimately it comes down to respect, to the position, to your fellow co-workers, to clients, etc. Respect the fact that what one does affects everyone somehow and work with it, not against it.

by derksens

I make it a point of discussion when I interview for a position with our company that a "good hire" is the intersection between our company goals and the goals of the new staffer. I will go so far as to say that when those goals change for the staffer, what I need is open and honest exchange, and I will do my best to contribute to making things better for us both. I have a lot of contacts in IT and I will help a person to leave if life's changes demand it. The fact is that when they decide to look - they have laredy decided to leave and what is left in the job is an employee with less heart than what you hired.

I'd far sooner know when that intellectual line is crossed and support the change so that I can manage the change and the timelines of the change.

By the by - many of my staff have been here now for over 5 years. We have had some turnover, but the way you deal with weeding out the ones who don't contribute to the team will add to the longevity of your long-term folks. The ones that have left have left saying that the time with us was the best environment in their career.

Seems to me that you have that honest exchange with your buddy that wants to leave, so you should become more involved in helping him out the door so that you can manage the replacement process. By doing so, you will have a better efffort from the person leaving in training a replacement etc...

by rb_itprofessional

Your duty at work is to be a manager, and a leader your team. Sounds like this person is testing your loyalty to that commitment for his own personal gain. His excessive absences during work hours for ?personal emergencies? as he calls it ?pushes your buttons? and he knows it. Would he attempt to pull this sort of thing off on another manager who didn?t happen to be his personal friend? Who knows, but I?m inclined to believe that he wouldn?t. The fact that he has done it continually for the past two months signals to me that he has a lack of respect for you as a friend and as a manager.

I would imagine that some of the hostility amongst your team stems from their perception that he is using your friendship to get away with things that they themselves would not. If you let it continue, it will ruin the camaraderie of your team and your reputation as a manager.

You absolutely must leave the friendship at home and be a manager. The CEO cannot be bothered with the your personnel matters, that is your job. If he is violating company policy for absences and personal emergencies then take the appropriate action. How would you handle this situation if this person were not your personal friend?

by bythebook

In your position as a manager you have a duty to inform the HR manager. You should tell your "friend" you are obligated to inform the HR department and let the chips fall where they may. Then the problem is no longer yours.

by andrew.carrington

Hi

I have tried this one and it really isn't helpful. Shifting the issue to someone else will not earn you their respect or the respect of the worker. It may also damage relationships with other members of staff especially if the 'office gossip' gets arround.

Andy

by todder

Shifting the issue to someone else will definitely not help your cause in any way, shape or form. ESPECIALLY if you pass it on to HR, who, in my opinion, is a department to be very leery of. HR tends to have carte blanche when it comes to employees but they don't have the training, experience or expertise to handle it well. You need to address it yourself and if you need guidance you should go to your manager for some insight. I also agree with other posts that there is some other underlying issue that is in play.

by seckerman

First off, how did you friend come to work for you? I am sure I know. Now on to how to deal. Nothing ends in this situation unless it ends badly in most cases. I would not allow him personal emergency leave for interviewing as I am sure the team know the real deal. Secondly, if you have a relationship with your CIO that is easy going I would consult; otherwise not. The team dyanmic cannot suffer as a result of 1 person's actions without you taking action to prevent it or they will lose respect for you and you will not be able to manage which is a larger issue that the currrent situation. Hope this helps.

by surbhi.thukral

Hi

I feel that you should talk to the CEO and explain him what has been happening.According to my opinion work and personal relations are seperate.I also believe that why should the tem suffer because of one person.It further depends on the responsibility you have.With high responsibility you are putting yourself in troubled waters.
Work and friendship are seperate.Dont mix them and dont let the whole team get de-motivated by this one person.

by kilbey1

I would take him out for a coffee/beer/whatever after work and
talk to him - as a friend - about the money portion of this issue.
If this is his first job, it sounds as if he may be young, and
possibly new to being out on his own. Has he taken the time to
lay out a budget, to really get his finances in order and work
with what he's got? Are there other things bothering him that go
deeper than the workplace - ie. self-confidence?

Money won't solve all his problems. If he plans to stay in the
career he's in, he's got some growing to do. Just changing jobs
won't necessarily improve the atmosphere, team members and
procedures. Like the song says, "Meet the new boss, same as the
old boss."

He might consider getting out there and doing some freelance
work, assuming your company allows it.

by andrew.carrington

This is sound advice. I always try to take my staff 'out to lunch' to talk things over that are perhaps better discussed away from the distractions of work, especially if it is likely to be the root of the issue(s).

Andy

by zaferus

In a culture obsessive with careers my opinion is likely to be unpopular:

This person will be your friend long after they are your employee, unless he feels betrayed.

Make sure this person's job description and organization for advertising is "handy", and make very clear that "if you ever catch him using time inappropriately or hear of it from other people he'll be reported and face the consequences"

Now, "don't ask - don't tell". If he's foolish enough to blab that he's using time inappropriately or get seen - he's been warned. If he's discreet about it then you know nothing.

I faced a similar situation several years ago (7 years I believ) with a person who I worked closely with and we were near the end of a big project that I was responsible for that he was a key player in. He confided in me as a friend that he was looking for another job and he would be "sick" the next afternoon.

I told him that as the project manager if I ever found out he was inapproprately misusing company resources I had a responsibility to report him. I then told him "as a friend: Good luck". He got the message, and no one else ever knew that he wasn't sick. He got the job but asked for 4 weeks before starting with his new employer and worked with us in that time to finish the project and even had a few days to do some training for his replacement. I didn't sell him out, and he returned the favor.

Now we both work for different organizations but are still good friends. You have your choice to make on this, but try to look at the bigger picture if you can.

by cynth113

On the other hand, keep in mind that friendships change and fade, but your professional reputation will follow you everywhere. Don't allow a situation to continue which has the potential to tarnish your reputation and poison the pond you swim in. Friendships are important, but so is integrity in your performance of your job. If his salary expectations are not realistic, the situation could drag on endlessly. Be honest with him, but expect him to allow you to maintain integrity in your job performance as well.

by onbliss

Can he turn into a contractor to your company instead of being an employee? And then slowly the contract can be terminated on a mutual basis. This way he will be around train the new hire, and have a little added flexibility for him to scout around. And, also this can be used to convey to the upper management on the need of new permanent hire.

by gloria312

I'm not clear if the friendship developed before or after you hired him. However here are my 2 cents. Rule #1 - never hire a friend who will be working directly for you. Rule #2 - don't befriend someone who works for you. As a professional, it's a faux pas and can be perceived as unethical. Most likely other team members will look at the manager as showing favoritism towards this person (teachers pet) and/or you may not be as objective towards him as you would to others. It's great that you had a conversation about salary expectations, but because it's his first job, he may be unrealistic and still wet behind the ears in terms of understanding corporate culture, processes, salary caps, etc. He'd be doing you a favor if he left. Until that time, set clear expectations.... for example, advise him that interviews should be scheduled around his lunch or at the end of the day and you should be made aware in advance. I'm not sure if by stating he is "missing from work" implies he is MIA without letting you know first... if so, check with Human Resources on your dismissal process. I.e. Give him a verbal warning that he cannot take off without notifying you first either voice to voice, cell phone or email, in that order. If he still takes off without notice, give him another verbal, followed by a write up and give him a copy. It can be stated if he does it again it's grounds for termination. As far as telling the CEO, it's always a good idea to keep your boss informed of someone who is not performing well or someone who is causing problems. Not sure the CEO can fire the person without following the path of some type of verbal/written warning process or improvement plan. OTherwise you leave yourself open to unfair firing practices.

by bharat nerkar

Once upon a time, there lived a King who, despite his luxurious lifestyle, was neither happy nor content.

One day, he came upon a servant who was singing happily while he worked. This fascinated the King; why was he, the Supreme Ruler of the Kingdom, unhappy and gloomy, while a lowly servant was so joyous.

The King asked the servant, "Why are you so happy?"

The man replied, "Your Majesty, I am nothing but a servant, but my family and I don't need too much -- just a roof over our heads and warm food to fill our tummies."

The king was not satisfied with that reply. Later in the day, he sought the advice of his most trusted advisor. After hearing the King's woes and the servant's story, the advisor said, "Your Majesty, I believe that the servant has not been made part of The 99 Club."
"The 99 Club? And what exactly is that?" the King inquired.

The advisor replied, "Your Majesty, to truly know what The 99 Club is, let's place 99 Gold coins in a bag and leave it at this servant's doorstep."

Next day when the servant saw the bag, he picked it up and took it in. When he opened the bag, he let out a great shout of joy... so many gold coins!

He began to count them. After several counts, he was at last convinced that there were 99 coins.
"What could've happened to that last gold coin? Surely, no one would leave 99 coins!" he wondered. He looked everywhere he could, but that final coin was elusive.

Finally, exhausted, he decided that he would have to work harder than ever to earn that gold coin and complete his collection.
And from that day, the servant's life was changed. He was overworked, horribly grumpy, and castigated his family for not helping him make that 100th coin. He stopped singing while he worked.

Witnessing this drastic transformation, the King was puzzled. When he sought his advisor's help, the advisor said, "Your Majesty, the servant has now officially joined The 99 Club."

He continued, "The 99 Club is a name given to those people who have enough to be happy but are never contented, because they're always yearning and striving for that extra one, telling themselves: "Let me get that one final thing and then I will be happy for life."

We can be happy, even with very little in our lives, but the minute we're given something bigger and better, we want even more!
We lose our sleep, our happiness, we hurt the people around us; all these as a price for our growing greed and desires.

by rikke_vp

Hi

I was just reading this post and can only say this story is a perfect refelection of the todays world... Many people strive for that extra 1 percent but never find it.

I will remeber this story for life since its a great guideline true life

by mandrake64

As a manager you have a role beyond the day to day business. Most people develop friendships over time and it is all too easy to favour a friend over someone who is simply a colleague.
So in your role as manager, you would have set your expectations of those who work for you and one of those expectations would be honesty. There is nothing wrong with one of your team members looking for work elsewhere if they believe they are underpaid but they have to be truthful when it comes to absence from work for an interview.
There are only so many dead aunts and uncles that can provide the funeral excuse although my own boss at one point had to rescue a cat that his wife ran through their washing machine.
If he really believes he is underpaid he should cough up the facts - data on qualifications and skills that show the salary relativities in the industry and prove his point.
Everyone has to work with procedures they are not happy with, policies that are set on high and a culture that sends shivers up their spine like a clawed hand running down a blackboard. But he's only stuck it out for 2 years, hardly enough time to earn respect from higher up the food chain. If he really has a problem with culture but is not willing to step in a make a change then maybe the best option is for him to leave.
If his problem is with experience and he feels unchallenged by his current position, then set him up with a real challenge, something that will stretch his capabilities and force him to seek and master new skills. This could be as simple as tasks which are outside his normal work or involvement across some other part of the company or that provides contact with personnel beyond the IT profession.
But you are really the one who is in the best position to choose an option. No one else has as much information about the situation as you do. No one else will be as impacted as you will in this decision. And I'm sure the CEO also has this expectation of you. Just do what you believe is right.

by amarojossy

Dear VNCoder

Thank God that you have only spent two years with this character, its never too late or early for you to take an appropriate action.

For how long are you going to have sleepless nights thinking about the wayforward? and leaving him to spoil your name out there among other friends,besides your job is at risk. my simple advice is;
1. Talk to this guy and seek his mind as regards working with you is concerned.ref him to the terms of contract/work he signed and if he is not able to abide let him sign to withdraw.
2. seek other team members opinion about his weaknesses and strength.
3.Recruit his successor in the name of avolunteer to perform his tasks and involve him in training that volunteer.
4. Draw aleave schedule and after afew months ask him to take his leave as the volunteer works
and try as much as possible not to consult him to show him that you can do without him.
5. If the volunteer is performing well confirm him on atemporal position close to his, and when he returns from leave reduce his tasks. be open with the help of the HRM and even reduce his salary if possible.
6.Assign all staff to set their own tasks and deadlines to meet. so that his failure to do it will be exposed during performance appraisal.all staff have to be appraised.

Thanks

Yours Faithfully
Josephine

by navendu_kumar

It looks to me as if you are afraid of this person And if not then why are you let him doing this to you. Remind him of the contract which you have with him and if still he doing that then throw him out.

This discussion is closed to new replies.