Discussion Locked

A modest proposal (or two) for the finance industry

0 helpful
100 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Anybody who has spent his whole adult life looking at credit card statements and marveling at the business arrangement in which he finds himself trapped must wonder: what's the difference between this and a con game?

The answer is, there aint' no diff, except what the finance industry does is permitted by law. Regulation is not poison to the financial industry; it depends on it. The finance business couldn't live without law: they depend on the sheriff and the courts to enforce their terms of payment. I don't think it would be harmful to the industry if we enforced, by law, a little more transparency and fair dealing. So, I've got two proposals.

You remember 20 years ago when you got credit card offers, there was this tiny spreadsheet included in the offer that showed you all the essential terms in simplified form in large type, and to compare two offers all you had to do was hold them side by side? The spreadsheets looked the same except for the numbers in the boxes, because that was the law, and the consumer was thereby protected against trickery in finance. That was instituted in the 1970s, because government saw that dirty tricks were going on, and decreed that the terms had to be explained in a standardized format so obvious that a near moron could tell what he was buying into. In the 80s and 90s the rules were relaxed, I guess because the Republicans took pity on the heartbroken bankers who felt locked out of easy profits, and today, it takes an accountant and a lawyer to explain you the rules of a credit card. My proposal: bring that simple spreadsheet back. Give me clarity again.

The second proposal concerns the flexibility the cards have to adjust your interest rate. If you borrow too much money from other people, they can raise your rate. If you fail to make on-time payments to your electric company, your credit card company can raise your rates. That's fair as far as extending you new credit goes, but they can raise the rates on money you already owe. That's not pricing the cost of doing new business according to risk... that's restating the terms of doing old business! And, you don't even have to harm your credit card company to be robbed this way... if anybody in the financial universe got a late payment from you, they get to reprice your old loan! So, my other proposal is this: when you borrow money from a credit card, the prevailing rate when you borrow will stay the same for that piece of debt until you pay it off. And, the creditor will apply payments against your debts in the order they were incurred. If you borrow $2000 at 10%, then $1000 at 7%, your first payments go against the first $2000. And if you default on some other bill, they can raise your rates on new loans to 20% or even cut you off, but that original money stays at 10% and 7%.

This won't force lenders to subsidize bad customers. It'll just force them to be clear-eyed about the business they take on. It's an honest deal for the lenders and borrowers alike. It's needed, because the only thing that keeps finance indistinguishable from three-card-monte is law and regulation.

100 replies

by tonythetiger

[i]That's fair as far as extending you new credit goes, but they can raise the rates on money you already owe.[/i]

Ex post facto should apply.

Weren't there some congressional hearings recently about this very thing?

by deepsand

As a result, credit card issuers have, voluntarily:

1) Begun modifying the contracts so as to define "default" in a manner that deals only with the relationship between the cardholder and the card issuer, to the exclusion of all other creditors; and,

2) Increase the minimum required monthly payments, so as to pay down the balances more quickly.

While both of these are not unwelcome steps, they fail to go to the root of the problem, that of usurious rates and fees.

by delbertpgh

I'm not clear on the point you're making, "what power do you wield when you don't? (You don't have to buy into it.)" Do you mean you should give up using plastic, or eat whatever terms they throw at you? It doesn't seem like justice to me. It's a social agreement, enforcable by the courts of the people, and I don't like it.

The borrower, under current practice, doesn't have the power to stake a deal at an agreed rate... the rate fluctuates at the pleasure of the lender. The only guarantee the borrower has today is that his charges can't rise above the "default rate", which is usually 29% or 33% or some similar high value. A mutually advantageous variable rate contract would be something like "prime plus 5 per cent", which is language you sometimes see in your contract. However, if you read on, you see that it will only hold if the lender feels you continue to be a good payer and a good risk, and good risk status can be nullified by just about anything. If you read on further, you find that you have also agreed that if you think the lender is breaking the terms of the contract, you must put your complaint to an industry arbitrator and not to a court. Arbitration by industry professionals favors the industry, of course. You basically have no defense against your credit card company changing the terms of the deal, and no recourse to a venue where you have strength.

Law and regulation have set this game against you. Law and regulation should set it fair.

by tonythetiger

[i]You basically have no defense against your credit card company changing the terms of the deal.[/i]

When they change your terms, they are required to notify you of this change and offer you the opportunity to "opt out". If you choose to opt out, your card is deactivated and can you continue to pay on the balance at your then-current rate.

by dadspad

You are referencing a time where there were more people with good ethics and value what they did in life. Investors realized they invested for the long term. CEO's and other executives worked for the good of the company, now it is for the investors.

It is not all put on the banks, though. Although they are a large part of the problem, do not forget the people that get into large credit card debt without having any kind of emergency spending. Credit card debt is considered to be a large problem today. This allowed the banks to take advantage of everyone. If the majority of people paid off their credit cards when the bill is due, the banks would sing a very differnt song.

by deepsand

ineffective and/or insufficient for regulating this particular form of inter-state commerce, exerted it's authority under the Commerce Clause of the US Constitution, and then proceeded to - do absolutely nothing.

By way of contrast, the the insurance industry is still regulated by the States, under the McCarran-Ferguson Act of 1945, as a result of the US Supreme Court decision in [i]U.S. v. South-Eastern Underwriters[/i].

How is it that the States are deemed capable of regulating the insurance industry, but not that of banking in general and credit cards in particular?

And, why is it that the Fed's idea of regulating is, in this particular case, one of adopting a hand-off approach?

by jdclyde

is suppose to be going into effect, so the cc company can't send you a bill for an amount they KNOW will never pay off the balance.

Of course, some are dumb enough to think this is a bad thing... :0

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]The second proposal concerns the flexibility the cards have to adjust your interest rate. If you borrow too much money from other people, they can raise your rate. If you fail to make on-time payments to your electric company, your credit card company can raise your rates. That's fair as far as extending you new credit goes, but they can raise the rates on money you already owe. That's not pricing the cost of doing new business according to risk... that's restating the terms of doing old business![/i]

I know, since the government isn't doing it (directly!), the Constitution's protection against being punished (tried, literally) twice for the same crime doesn't (directly) apply. But, the guarantee not to stand trial for the same crime twice is based on a human right, to pursue primarily one's own happiness and never to be compelled to pursue someone else's happiness. If customers don't like the services from an electric company, we don't generally form neighborhood associations to protest our complaints. They do. Maybe we individuals should re-think our dealings with corporate interests. A hefty dose of their collectivist medicine is just what they've been asking for.

by tonythetiger

[i]Maybe we individuals should re-think our dealings with corporate interests.[/i]

All one really has to do is wait around for one of those "zero percent on transferred balances" offers (even though I've opted out, I still get these at least once a week) to come in the mail, get it, and transfer some or all of your balance, pay that off, then cancel it.

by john.a.wills

I incurrred a lot of debt during a long period of umemployment (a previous, longer period had already destroyed my savings). Once I got a job I transferred my debt to 0% special offers, then to new ones when those were about to expire. I have been doing this for 6 years, with occasional upticks for special reasons (e.g. a sewer problem). The newest expires in July 2009, and one more extension should get me debt-free.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

but when is the last time you tried to organize something like that? People think it's great until they have to do without something they want and/or think they need. Then they find the damndest excuses to back down.

Oooh... a bit pessimistic there.

by delbertpgh

"If you choose to opt out, your card is deactivated and can you continue to pay on the balance at your then-current rate."

Actually, if you opt out, you pay at your current rate until the renewal date, at which time you have to pay it off in full, or continue the account under terms they dictate. I had this happen once... they raised the rate, and I had a phone call with them, about 60 days before the annual membership on the card elapsed. It was, basically, "Pay it all now, or spread 'em a little wider, son." So, I pulled hard, and made a little more room for Citibank.

It's probably the case that if you get a special offer ("4.99% for the life of the transferred balance") they have no lawful way to raise the rate on you, unless you're late with a payment or two.

by tonythetiger

[i]Actually, if you opt out, you pay at your current rate until the renewal date,[/i]

I've had the same account for 25+ years and my "renewal date" comes around about every 6 years. I also have Citibank and have never had a problem with them. I especially like the virtual numbers (good at only [b]one[/b] online vendor).

by delbertpgh

If you are carrying some moderate amount of debt on your Citicard, say $10,000 at 9%, and you're happy with that and pay it on time; but you get a Discover and a BankAmericard, and charge up $30,000 on those two. Maybe your small business is hitting a rough patch or your wife has to go in for chemotherapy. Citibank is free to make the judgement that owing $40,000 total, and having put the last 30K on in a hurry, you're a bad credit risk. And then they raise your rate on the $10K to 18%.

My renewal date is once a year. Usually they don't touch my rate. If you were unlucky enough to live in Pennsylvania, you'd find that credit card companies don't have to notify you before a rate change.

by tonythetiger

I wouldn't exactly call $10,000 a "moderate" debt. And if I needed anything like that amount, I wouldn't use a credit card for it.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

or is it somewhere in the vicinity of appalling to anyone else that 'finance' is an 'industry?

by tonythetiger

They want it ALL and they want it NOW, they don't want to have to save up for it.

They're fine with it as long as [b]their[/b] greed is being sated, but when it's time to pay the piper, they accuse the piper of being greedy.

Normally it would be a case of "tough noogies" but the problem is, the person who did everything right... who wasn't greedy... ends up paying for it too.

I don't know what the answer is... Eliminate bankruptcy court? Bring back debtor's prison? Pass debts, as well as assets, when you die? Restrict unsecured personal loans to bona fide emergencies?

by $$$$$$$$$$

The arithmetic of usury laws cannot be all that complicated. The reasoning is even easier. If the general economy grows at a rate in the vicinity of 2% annually, it is not reasonable to expect borrowers' incomes to increase rapidly enough to pay off loans at 20%, because if they had such earning potential, they wouldn't be seeking a loan in the first place, now would they?

20% interest rates are typically explained away by the credit worthiness of the borrowers. That means unequivocally that such loans are a [b]calculated risk[/b] on the part of the [b]lenders[/b]. Being bailed out, for example by Ben Bernanke, is not being a man about having taken a calculated risk, and lost. It is being a loser and a coward.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

All scheming aside, how is it there is a bigger fish than 'oneness' of thought?

Time for a new sub-thread. I get 'lost' once they get to the response point the other one has.

by santeewelding

You say for asking: fuzzy 'oneness' put distinct from thought.

They make two, which fortunately is arithmetic and not mathematics of the quadratic and more. For, if you are like me, I count zero, one, two, and then "more."

Lazier still, I count zero and one with the administrative abstraction of "two." I deal then in my sloth with the remaining improper, escapee primes.

Then I laugh with the question of which is thought and which is one and which is prime?

Exact obscurantist scheming.

But pressing. The internecine, for one...

Nah. Couldn't be. What possibly could this have to do with anything?

It is nothing.

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]Yikes! I wouldn't exactly call $10,000 a "moderate" debt. And if I needed anything like that amount, I wouldn't use a credit card for it.[/i]

Tony, there is no such thing as a one-sided transaction. Why do foolish, greedy lenders deserve a bailout that isn't extended equally to their borrowers?

To the "little guys," Bear Stearns is a lender, but to some other "big guys" it is a borrower, as well. Why is it legal to bail out large borrowers first, or at all, without equal or greater assistance to all of those who [b]borrowed from[/b] Bear Stearns?

by santeewelding

To recognize commodification of a specie and to turn it over and around in the mind, investigating the ins and outs, can be enlightening.

I say "specie" for a reason.

Expand it to include that specie known as "business," investigating Roman corporate doings and going forward.

One that occurs most readily to me, and may naturally to you, is that specie known as "word."

Commodification, anyone?

by tonythetiger

[i]Why do foolish, greedy lenders deserve a bailout that isn't extended equally to their borrowers?[/i]

... they, essentially, have been stolen from. Whether or not they are also a thief makes no difference. I have seen people arrested for stealing illegal drugs from another, for example.

[i]Why is it legal to bail out large borrowers first, or at all, without equal or greater assistance to all of those who borrowed from Bear Stearns?[/i]

I would think that it would be at the discretion of the creditor. If two people owe me money, I can sue one for recovery without being legally required to sue the other.

And if one person owes me money, and a second person owes the first one money I have no standing to tell the second person that he doesn't have to pay the first one back.

by tonythetiger

on the [b]definition[/b] of usury may be more helpful. How about double what they pay savings accounts?

by randytwester

In Canada, the definition is that an agreement, or actual receipt of payment at a rate exceeding 60% per annum is a "criminal rate".

Some years ago an electric utility was nailed on this one - their statements had a 5% penalty, which they compounded on unpaid bills - 79.5% per annum. They weren't allowed to charge interest at all until they printed new statement forms. Not really the tarring and feathering we would have liked, but better than nothing.

by $$$$$$$$$$

Nor are you.

[i]Why is it legal to bail out large borrowers first, or at all, without equal or greater assistance to all of those who borrowed from Bear Stearns?[/i]

[b]I would think that it would be at the discretion of the creditor.[/b]

Which Amendment offers Bernanke discretion to ever act as creditor?

by tonythetiger

[i]Which Amendment offers Bernanke discretion to ever act as creditor?[/i]

Everything's legal until it is not.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

Both of you. Do either of you know how intimidating you can sometimes be?

edit: Methinks I could have used a less 'fearful' word than intimidating. Unfortunately I am at a loss for a word that comes close, less the fear factor. Some days...

by santeewelding

I tried thinking of myself in your position. I had your response to be something like: Oh, shlt. Yours was pretty close.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

first thought no sooner that I got halfway through his sentence. lol
Yall are too much fun.

edit: 'tis Finals week. Better get real comfy.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

It?s now, or sometime next week when finals and grading are finished. At which point I prefer to be in the garden until the summer semester begins.

[i]Preamble:[/i]
I view the world and reality as significantly more than the material thing/s that we sense. Worldviews coloring perception and understanding as they do, I am not likely to be able to ?prove? in hard core material terms much of what I ?see?. About the only time I have a problem with this is when trying to put things into words that will make sense of what can be called my intuitive knowing. Lest offense be taken at the term intuitive knowing, intuitive knowledge is an epistemologically valid form of knowledge within philosophical circles. He//, all you geeky types make a pretty huge fuss about ?intuitive? interfaces. That?s because intuition is a form of knowing. Blast away if necessary, but I ain?t a gonna budge or argue that one.

I do not in any sense reference time in using the word ?immediately? below.

Let?s just start with the notion that I find ?finance? as an ?industry? appalling. This is largely due to the fact that I see money as an inefficient and degrading medium of exchange due to its more subtle and effective utility as a class-producing, community splitting, obfuscating layer between people and other people as well as between people and that which people need to survive and thrive; which includes being valued for the simple fact that they are in addition to the talent and skills they possess. I also see money as a tool for acquiring that which one cannot immediately acquire by one?s own inherent talent and skill. A no brainer that last, but with implications not often examined.

One has 2 ways of going about getting something needed done. One can trade on one?s skill and talent in what is a personal transaction, or one can offer money for a product or service in what is an impersonal transaction. If one trades, a personal relationship between 2 beings is established based on respect and appreciation for each other, not limited to but including each other?s skill and talent. If instead one purchases a service or a product, no personal relationship is involved or established in direct, immediate response to meeting that need nor is any respect earned or proferred. The relationship is one of commodity to commodity as opposed to person to person. Thus, money obfuscates one?s view of oneself, one?s view of others, one?s worldview, and one?s place in the all encompassing scheme of things.

Additionally, by commodifying money the ease with which it can be obtained is lessened; furthermore it requires having money to acquire money. We have now reached the point at which an often difficult to obtain commodity is first required in order to acquire the necessary commodities for life. I think this is ridiculous as well as indicative of significant blindness on the part of most people as they certainly and obviously accept it without hesitation; worse yet they attempt to play the commodities game with the experts and lose.

Can I prove any of the above with ?facts and statistics?? Maybe, maybe not. This is my intuitive take on things, though here and there glimmers of subtle evidence surface when I have the time to dig deeply for it, which these days I rarely do. So don?t ask for evidence. Just ponder from an extremely large perspective. Then make up your own mind as to whether or not there is something here worth looking at more closely. Further related opinion on my part is here: http://tinyurl.com/5ydhmm

[i]Sharia[/i] ? Islamic law, inexorably theological in origin and once absolute to the State. That system of law which sprang from that theology and is now slowly being expunged to one degree or another from the State ordinance in the Islamic world [quite likely] for reasons of expediency (filling the coffers of the oil field holders), and conformation to the world monetized system of functioning. What a battle Islam has thrust upon itself in the name of expediency and conformity!

[i]Sharia, too[/i] ? mother to the industry that is jihad.

Now to Jed?
The classic tale of the Beverly Hillbillies with all their foibles and in all their relationship/s is a ripe metaphor for many systems. Or at least I think it so.
[i]Jed[/i] ? the pretty sharp old patriarch, mediator between extremes, upholder of right and good.

[i]Granny[/i] ? the extreme fundamentalist who refuses to give up the old ways, also refusing to even make a decent examination of the new ways, resorting to various levels of threat and violence to keep her dying worldview intact and untainted by the evils of the new.

[i]Ellie May[/i] ? The attractive, fairly sharp herself, middle of the roader. Keeps the old she finds useful, embraces the new she finds useful, is primarily her own person with some intent to be just that.
[i]Jethro[/i] ? the impulsive, blowhard, balls to the wall dump all the old crap no matter how useful in order to embrace all the new crap no matter how useless.
[i]Mr. Drysdale[/i] ? the greed king sitting in the wings pretending to be one thing while spending all his time and brainpower trying to figure out how to get more, more, more. All in all an excellent representation of the current reigning paradigm of self-interest above all else.

I leave the dots for you to connect.

edit tags

by santeewelding

You intuit one dot to the next in a satisfactory way, saddled as you are, as we are, with a legacy of words that needs be (man)handled to do the will, or in your case, felicity.

I asked after Sharia almost knowing what you would have to say of it. You click.

I really, really must get to bed.

by $$$$$$$$$$

Money certainly has drawbacks as a means of regulating personal exchange, so I have to admit the possible existence of a better means of doing things. To exchange only by barter, I don't know. I tend to look for small adjustments to make first, but that was a good read. Thanks.

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]One has 2 ways of going about getting something needed done. One can trade on one?s skill and talent in what is a personal transaction, or one can offer money for a product or service in what is an impersonal transaction. If one trades, a personal relationship between 2 beings is established based on respect and appreciation for each other, not limited to but including each other?s skill and talent.[/i]

I'll not be penalized for trading you [b]only[/b] my skill and talent.

by $$$$$$$$$$

TonytheTiger: [i]Everything's legal until it is not.[/i]

The ____________ of the United States of America grants some specified powers to the Fed(s), and reserves all others to the States and the Citizens.[/b]

by santeewelding

I've been trying and none too successfully to divide my time between this and studying isotonic and hypertonic transfusion ratios for a test tomorrow.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

Introductory and Intermediate Access, PowerPoint, Introduction to Excel, Internet Fundamentals, E-Mail/Information Management while juggling my Continuing Ed 'Simple Home Repair for Women' projects. These latter need to be checked for missing parts, and then reassembled in correct - to code - fashion before the class meets tomorrow night. Plumbing is on the table tomorrow, Monday was Electrical. Extremely time consuming, all of the above. And not as much fun as racking my brain for answers to you and the persnickety one.

I suspect you will do quite well with your exam/s.

by tonythetiger

You should have asked about the Fed, and not used a citizen's name. My not knowing who someone was (so sorry I cannot hang on every news item... as "I" have a real life away from the computer.) is not "flunking US Law 101", it is responding to a poorly written question. My answer was correct for "a citizen".

You sir, appear to be a fake. You pretend to espouse liberty, justice, and personal responsibility, but apparently have this unquenchable desire to control (belittle, ridicule, bully) those who have ideas different from yours or who dare challenge yours. You can only get by with such because you're hiding behind your keyboard. I can learn nothing valuable from such a person, so I will no longer try.

by delbertpgh

"Usury" used to be the crime of making money by lending it out at interest. Mohammed, St. Paul, and a whole bunch of others thought it was an unnatural act. I guess they had a mental image of somebody who had piled up wealth and now used it to make more money passively, exerting power over his neighbors, getting fat and gaining yet more power without breaking a sweat. Lending money was an excommunicable sin in most of Christendom for hundreds of years; rulers who realized their countries were stagnating, because wealth could not reach the people who could use it best, got around the problem by importing Jews. Jews could lend and not go to hell (or were going to hell anyway, so what difference?)

Today's surviving usury laws say that lending is okay, but some interest rates are just too much. Usually the rate cap was something lawmakers pulled out of thin air during the Eisenhower administration, or something like that, with the idea that people should be protected from greedy bankers and loan sharks. Most of the usury laws took a big hit during the inflation of the 1980s, when even home mortgages got up to 16%. Usury is a popular idea at times, like flag pins, that helps somebody get elected.

Usury is a nonsense idea, and in the modern world it has negative impact. There are some risky ventures worth a gamble, and the payoff could be big for the lender and the borrower, but who's going to lend money if some ancient usury standard caps rates at 11 per cent? A usury law just guarantees that some good business will not be done, and it does nothing to stop bad business.

And, hey, where do you get the idea that Bear Stearns was bailed out? They agreed to be devoured by J. P. Morgan at a 90%discount. If anything, Morgan got the good deal, with a loan on easy terms from the Fed and relief from default risk. If Bear had failed it would have taken a half dozen top banks with it, and you would have seen money dry up in every bank in the country like hasn't happened since 1931.

When you've got a fire in one apartment, you bust down the door and put it out before the whole building is in flame. You don't wait for a law to be passed to let you in, or stand outside worrying about the morals of "bailing out" the idiot who was smoking in bed.

by $$$$$$$$$$

My lesser experience at locker room games of grab-a** may be the culprit, but I suspect that your vagueness is more the root my difficulty understanding that remark.

by delbertpgh

My example of somebody running up $10k on a credit card is nothing unusual in this age, and saying that five-figure installment debt is foolish so we shouldn't worry about the terms is kind of like living in bygone times. Folks live on debt, and thereby does the economy, and all of our jobs.

Sometimes a credit card is the best way to borrow $5000 or $10000. Your bank may want a rigid payment structure, pledged (and insured) collateral, pre-payment penalties, and a higher interest rate. Been there, done that, one time when I wanted to buy out my leased car. The credit card was by far the best deal, and I was able to arrange it without fuss. Another time I got myself into an installment loan on crummy terms with a company that was more vampire than lender (a vacation timeshare; don't ever buy into that con), and converting that to credit card debt was a money saving deal.

By the way, would you be interested in a sweet little property in New Orleans for one week a year?

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i](so sorry I cannot hang on every news item... as "I" have a real life away from the computer.)[/i]

And, this is not some obscure little news item known only to computer geeks. The Senate promptly had a hearing, because they were interested to know that the power over the treasury that the Constitution delegates to Congress was being used, at the discretion of only the Federal Reserve Board and two corporations, to give $30 Billion to a private entity, on the basis of no merit other than their previous failure.

[i]My not knowing who someone was is not "flunking US Law 101", it is responding to a poorly written question. My answer was correct for "a citizen".[/i]

False, thrice.

1. "Bernanke" is a name you should know, if [b]you[/b] really "espouse liberty, justice, and personal responsibility." He's spending your money, if you're really a US citizen. And if you don't know it, there's this thing called Google.com, which you really should try.

2. The question was written for a person who's adequately-informed to offer the opinions that you already have. It was excellently written, and poorly answered. My question served its purpose, better than I had hoped.

3. Citizens have the right to spend only their own money. Bernanke spent every citizens' money. Had your assumption been correct and he were not the Chair of the Federal Reserve Board, his gift of our money to Bear Stearns (your ignorance of which is still no excuse) would only be more obviously outright theft from the citizens, to a corporation.

[i]You sir, appear to be a fake. You pretend to espouse liberty, justice, and personal responsibility, but apparently have this unquenchable desire to control (belittle, ridicule, bully) those who have ideas different from yours or who dare challenge yours.[/i]

You belittle categorically, on the basis of fallacies. I single out those that do so, and expose the invalidity of your premises. TS.

by tonythetiger

taking on an unsecured debt for an amount I couldn't pay back out of my next paycheck unless it was a dire emergency (and in such a situation, I would, as soon as possible, get a secured loan at lower interest rate and pay off the card). People who use their credit card to buy a plasma TV this month and new carpeting next month, etc. don't deserve any sympathy about high interest rates in my opinion. They're spoiled brats who deserve to be spanked. It takes less time to save up for your toys than it does to pay them off on credit, and the wait teaches the value of money.

If you feel you were misled, defrauded, lied to, etc. you should go after the person who did it, not all of the others who didn't do anything to you.

[i]By the way, would you be interested in a sweet little property in New Orleans for one week a year?[/i]

Hmmm... What weeks you got open?

by boxfiddler Hot topic

I had thought THAT heavily implied in a complimentary post I aimed at you recently. ;)

In any case, why else would I think Oh Sh/t if not the challenge?

And thank you.

etu

by boxfiddler Hot topic

See what you miss when you're gone?
etu = edit the usual
Highly predictable typos and/or afterthoughts. So predictable in fact that Hal has had an excellent joke at my expense in the podcast thread wherein Max asked the question of the week re: greatest technological achievement.
I may be capable, but I am rather goofy. ;)

I got tired of typing the full phrase and started using the acronym a few months ago.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

we are so deeply entrenched in our current 'monetary' paradigm that I see no way out short of significant, world-wide catastrophe. Those cultures actively engaged in the attempt to maintain their 'old ways' are slowly disappearing into the sunset. Consumerism as philosophy and deliberately cultivated (by the providers of consumables) world view is in its established infancy - truly a bizarre and interesting phenomena.
Rather a pity as well.

by $$$$$$$$$$

Before complicated changes to the monetary system, simply striking down the legalese that elevates corporate rights above citizen rights would go a long way toward achieving our mutual goals.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

the dots comment was meant to specifically reference the Clampett analysis.

Apparently breaking that line from the Clampett paragraph was a bad idea.

"I'll not be penalized for trading you only my skill and talent."

Gotta think about that one a bit.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

why would you [b]be[/b] penalized for trading me [b]only[/b] your skill and talent?

edit:
Further, you have reinforced my original point by allowing for commodities to absolve either you or I or both of us of the responsibility/ies of relationship, thereby obfuscating your view of yourself and of others as well as my view of myself and of others in the process.

[i]Dots connected: "commodity to commodity" has its place.
I'll not be penalized for trading you only my skill and talent.[/i]

etu

by $$$$$$$$$$

Money compels those who would deal dishonestly to deal instead via an objectively-defined medium -- or at least, so it was, before our fiat currency replaced the Gold Standard.

by $$$$$$$$$$

As a special favor, you can specify what subset of dishonesty you request that I discuss more delicately. In consideration of your kind attention, I'll take it under advisement.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

It strikes me that dishonest dealings are much easier engaged in at an impersonal level, than at a personal level.

It's a lot easier for me to sell you a piece of cr@p than it is for me to come work with and beside you building a piece of cr@p under your watchful eye. I build you a piece of cr@p I'm likely to lose out on the dinner that you swapped for it.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

should I sell you a real piece of cr@p, you bring it back, exchange it or get your money back. I return that piece of cr@p to the cr@pmaker. Neither of us is particularly injured, or held to much account in relation to that piece of cr@p.

In the event however, that you are a hothead, that piece of cr@p that I have built you for my dinner may cost me more than just my dinner. (Which gets to your original point about being penalized point a bit). But are you in fact being penalized for my lack of skill and talent or for your hot-headedness?

We both learn significantly more about ourselves and others, in addition to how to do things in the second instance.

by $$$$$$$$$$

Dishonest purveyor of crap claims to get 15 widgets from Smith down the lane, in exchange for one ton his high quality crap, "fertilizer-quality manure." In truth, he's never gotten more than 3, but he's talking to the new farmer in the neighborhood, and plans to fleece him.

[i]In the event however, that you are a hothead, that piece of cr@p that I have built you for my dinner may cost me more than just my dinner.[/i]

You think money affects the likelihood of retribution for being cheated? I should think law, enforcement, and fairness of both are much more relevant there, than the medium of exchange, or absence of one.

[i](Which gets to your original point about being penalized point a bit).[/i]
No, not at all. You want to make all exchanges "personal;" you want to impose your person on financial dealings. I won't have it.

[i]But are you in fact being penalized for my lack of skill and talent or for your hot-headedness? We both learn significantly more about ourselves and others, in addition to how to do things in the second instance.[/i]

No, I said I won't be penalized for not dealing personally with you, and I mean it.

by santeewelding

Rushing by...gotta check in on you both with a big smile...lots to say with all the personal honesty of some Jesus or another...anon.

by $$$$$$$$$$

I don't know exactly; but I do know that that complaint signals an irreconcilable difference.

"Take out that stupid word, and from any else you write from now on."

A word is neither stupid nor clever. Intelligence or stupidity is a quality of the speaker or writer, not of the word, and that was very stupid of you. The imperative form is also not your purview.

by santeewelding

Dishonesty, sir, with a "dis".

I have no problem whatsoever with honesty. I extend that concept to your post, to include your imperative about purview.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

I would not have caught the below without Absolutely! bringing this thread back to life. Thanks for that.

?Money compels those who would deal dishonestly to deal instead via an objectively-defined medium? ?

Money compels those who would deal [b]thought[/b] to deal instead via an objectively-defined medium?

D@mn slow on the uptake, there.

edit tags and title

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]Dishonesty, sir, with a "dis". I have no problem whatsoever with honesty. I extend that concept to your post, to include your imperative about purview.[/i]

No, you do not. You extend your dishonesty to claim purview, fraudulently. The word I used was "dishonest[b]l[/b]y" not "dishonesty."

[i]"Money compels those who would deal dishonestly to deal instead via an objectively-defined medium..."

Money compels those who would deal thought to deal instead via an objectively-defined medium...
D@mn slow on the uptake, there.[/i]

Then I'm still "slow"; What does "deal thought" mean?

by boxfiddler Hot topic

I will respond to that bit.

[i]Money compels those who would deal thought to deal instead via an objectively-defined medium...[/i]

As an extreme example, the mass media in this nation, and probably others to some degree, the propaganda machine of the Communist Party, the state controlled news machines of the various dictatorships all 'deal thought'. There is nothing objective about the various media viewpoints, as can be determined by chasing down a very wide variety of news sources and comparing them.
Over the course of decades these media machines shape the thinking of a populace as a whole. How to 'objectively define' a medium of exchange for thought? Now there I haven't a clue. Is it possible? I don't think it likely as thought is quite subjective to the thinker. If as yet we as a species appear incapable of objectively agreeing on very little of import, how are we to agree on something as profound as an objectively defined medium for thought?

[i]D@mn slow on the uptake, there.[/i]
Meaning that I skipped right past it when it was originally brought up and only recognized it just now.

etu, and tags too

by santeewelding

The germ of a thought has taken interesting root in your fertile mind: word > specie > commodification, or some such order.

It may struggle on account of a structural element in the soil.

I wonder how it would bloom freed of subjective/objective dichotomy?

by boxfiddler Hot topic

Proper tilth, nutrient, balance is in time developed only with great patience. Still, without unwavering attention to the micro-nutrient health does not attend. To be honest, unwavering has its tedious moments notwithstanding spectacular reward.

by santeewelding

I'm not all that anxious to run it down, either. There are bigger fish in my lying, dishonest, obfuscatory scheme.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

"Yeah
I'm not all that anxious to run it down, either."

That particular implication was not intended. Please ignore that implication in favor of that which is popped on the page in black type only.

edit: remove emoticon

by santeewelding

Further, I do appreciate the light grace of graphics and sundry emphasis by those who teach such. Then, there are the learners taken whole by their learning.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

Emoticon removed due to a certain easily foreseeable and unwanted implication, distinct from that previously mentioned.

edit afterthought

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]As the below is quoted from my post...
I will respond to that bit.
"Money compels those who would deal thought to deal instead via an objectively-defined medium..."
As an extreme example, the mass media in this nation, and probably others to some degree, the propaganda machine of the Communist Party, the state controlled news machines of the various dictatorships all 'deal thought'.[/i]

All true, but not as much to do with money as with regulatory schemes that discourage "upstart" competitors, and withhold "prestigious" press passes from any that do succeed in the un-free market. Biased media coverage has more to do with the legal system than the financial, by my estimate.

[i]There is nothing objective about the various media viewpoints, as can be determined by chasing down a very wide variety of news sources and comparing them. Over the course of decades these media machines shape the thinking of a populace as a whole.[/i]

They try.

[i]How to 'objectively define' a medium of exchange for thought? Now there I haven't a clue. Is it possible? I don't think it likely as thought is quite subjective to the thinker. If as yet we as a species appear incapable of objectively agreeing on very little of import, how are we to agree on something as profound as an objectively defined medium for thought?[/i]

Too abstract for the Internet, or for this d@mn hot Saturday afternoon, but an interesting thought.

[i]"D@mn slow on the uptake, there."
Meaning that I skipped right past it when it was originally brought up and only recognized it just now. etu, and tags too[/i]

Then [b]I[/b] was slow on the uptake elsewhere than I supposed. Still close enough for corporate work.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

I 'pushed my luck'. :D
It is a good thing I am at semester break. My garden needs tending.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

To my seeing has everything to do with all.
Short of [i]mutual[/i] destruction (used in a very very very large sense).
Thought, one, prime -- triunity. Not impossible though unfathomable.
Nothing? Everything. Immaterial.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

I break from tending to the garden, refresh, to find laughter with one who is, or seems to be. The day is bright, indeed.

by santeewelding

A! is right to say I skirt the issue.

You observe, along with him, my odd and curious way with words. He lays my periphrasis to intentional obfuscation, with a dark moral side.

You allow as how the issue is not easy to begin with. This, then, is for you, within earshot of him. And, for any few others who may care.

The issue is the Absolute.

You used the word once, that I know of. You wrote that you were an absolutist. Other of what you have said leads me to think that you also feel the pull of a black hole.

He is right. I skirt the event horizon. Words get bent. Language takes a hit. Not for me, of course. But to an observer...

by boxfiddler Hot topic

The issue has always been, and will always be the Absolute. All else is but bits and pieces of that ? bits and pieces with which we distract ourselves from the deep and gnawing question/s. You inquire as to how (or so I am led to believe by your musings), I inquire as to why. Both are imperative. It is but our bent that directs our path.

I would not name it a black hole, irresistible though the pull may be. It is oddly welcome. I do not know what I would name it, in case you determine to ask. Silence perhaps, as I sense it best when alone in the woods listening to the drip, drip, drip of the ice melting from the trees. Paradox though that be.

Your periphrasis fascinates. I am drawn to a mind that blatantly seeks not the picayune and paltry. You click ? to quote you. With it you introduce inklings of '?' to my mind.

There is a song by Garth Brooks ? ?Standing Outside the Fire?. You do not stand outside the fire santeewelding, you jump wholemindedly into the flame. Few do.

One does not observe life if one is to live it. This temporal moment is brief.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

quasms is a rather perfect word in this respect. I liked it the moment I saw it.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

in that moment. In that moment I am full of myself to the heedless exclusion of you
I am deeply sorry.

by santeewelding

Were you not to exclude me, how would you know your ass from mine?

There. Let's see how that tap-tap about distinction and identity works; you know, the "how" stuff.

"Why," occurring to me later, along with who, what, where, and when one is, amounts if you think about it to an administrative abstraction, as in "two".

Further, that "but" and "however" and like distinction/exclusions are only possible in one direction. They are not possible in the other.

Not too far from that lies love without restriction or condition.

Don't you be mooning yourself.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

do not stop with the 'garble'. Should the gravity well stop its pull, continue anyway.

And...

:D :D :D
I am still laughing. I think I will giggle in my sleep. It seems a good thing to do.

And...
Be happy too, you.

edit - addition, rephrase, etc...

by boxfiddler Hot topic

in momentary tumult. In tumult I drown in myself subsuming heartless disregard for you. This I would not do.
I am deeply ashamed.
Forgive me please, santeewelding.

This discussion is closed to new replies.