Discussion Locked

A Sad Day for Israel

0 helpful
201 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

It truly is a sad day for Israel. Moreover, it is a sad day for humanity, decency, and for all those things that make us more than animals. Israel has been repeatedly attacked over, and over, and over again. Hezbollah has declared their intent to destroy Israel. They will not relent until every Jew is eradicated from the face of the earth. This is not war; it is genocide. So why is it that the world seems to have sympathy for Hezbollah (or Hamas for that matter?)?
We have seen the honor of the Palestinian who returns coffins and body parts in exchange for their so called ?heroes? who are nothing more than cold blooded EVIL child murderers. Hezbollah declared that this is an official defeat over Israel. If history is to teach us anything it is that Israel is not so easily defeated. Israel for their part have allowed this kind of thing to occur by deviating from their tough stance and hard lined approach. They have mistakenly believed they could negotiate with those who would rather see them dead. Enough is enough. The only way for Israel to survive surrounded by people who would see them ?wiped from the face of the Earth? is to return to the policies of Benjamin Netanyahu and deal harshly with those who threaten Israel. Time was where Israel would respond en mass to incursions into their territory or attacks on their people. What has happened to the IDF?
Israel ? If you hear my plea it is to destroy those who advocate your destruction and work with those who offer you peace. The Hezbollah are murderers, liars and thieves and they should be treated as such.

201 replies

by the scummy one

How about Lebanon a few years back! Right along with all
of the news stories about how Israel was acting too harsh
and such.
The International community came down hard on Israel,
and tries to 'Tame' them.
However, I too think that Israel is in a different position
than other countries that try to set policy for them. When
your neighbor wants you dead at all cost, just sitting back
and getting screwed is not always the answer.
Personally, I feel Israel is justified to military operations
for Every Single rocket that flies into her borders, Every
Single act of aggression against her.

by jeanl1

The world need another world war. That's is international force aim at Islamic states with extreme fundamentalism, wipe them out once for all. In order to do that is to let them have what they wanted, empower themselves with nuke and wait for them to use it, directly or indirectly. We may encounter some heavy casualty, but it would be good for all humanity for the future generation. During this period we have to focus on 3 things: 1) self sufficient renewable enegy technology and green energy sources. 2) new technology counter all nuke weaponry and advance detection system. Re-invent much more powerful Mother of all boom that could wipe out all living within 100 sq mile with one boom without any long term contamination. 3) reform United Nations and disqualify nations consider a treat to security of it's neighbors or it;s own people.

by tony hopkinson

reply when you've joined and some bullets have gone past your head. Mind you given this brainless drivel, one smack in the forehead would do little more than get you a bollocking, for not having your beret on right.

by jdclyde

where intelligent people gather, is a good place for "this".

You saw the title before you decided to come into the discussion and read it. If you don't wish to be a part of such discussions, don't click on it.

Off-topic discussions are allowed here by Tech Republic, and it is not for you to presume to speak for them.

No offense, of course.

by tony hopkinson

is Israel honouring their commitment to their conscripted soldiers. Dead or alive you're coming home. A no man left behind sort of thing.

So wrong about that, and the rest of it....

Been there, done that, blood stained tee-shirt on show.

Couldn't work didn't work, won't work. That sort of violence needs to be specifically targetted. Some more missiles through terrorist leaders windscreens fine. Lobbing bombs, bulldozing settlements, building tyhe isalmic wall, understandable, but self defeating. They aren't shutting the enemy out, but themselves in.

by john.a.wills

The Israelis started the wars with the Nakba, which is still being continued and extended, currently in the Jordan Valley. If the Israelis wanted peace they would allow the exiles (who are, be it noted, Israeli citizens under the terms of the Partition Resolution) home and give them their property back. This is a necessary condition for peace (as the Nakba is the central violation of peace), and probably sufficient too. Of course, there would be no Israeli state because the majority of the voters would then vote for a single secular state throughout Palestine. But states aren't sacred, they're instruments for the current situation.

by protiusx

One man's "catastrophe" is another man's "Independence". So, based on your logic American natives have the right to launch missiles from their reservations and should be exalted when the blow themselves up in a crowded market place in the hopes that "the white man" will eventually give them their land back? I suppose its okay in your mind to bash the brains of a four year old child in with a rifle butt because of something that happened in 1948.

by jellimonsta

I thought the white man won the US lands in a game of chess? ?:|

Maybe we should just rebuild the Berlin wall and reconstruct the USSR too?

by Member 25348569

You can't judge the actions of the eighteenth century Americans by the moral codes of today. You have to judge them by the moral codes of the time.

Israeli actions CAN be judged by the moral codes of today. If we judge both Israel and Hezbollah then the only conclusion that we can come to is "A plague on both their houses".

Of course it is not OK "to bash the brains of a four year old child in" but it is also not OK to scatter cluster bombs over South Lebanon and ignore the consequences. those consequences being dead and maimed children.

We do not know the names of the Lebanese children.

Protius - and others if you wish - Please try and answer this rationally as it puzzles me greatly.

WHY does the United States so uncritically support Israel on almost every issue? WHY do your politicians praise Israel as "the only democracy in the Middle East". WHY does the US provides Israel's main financial backing when the result is the hatred of the USA throughout the Arab world?

That hatred is transferred from Israel. Why? The justifications given for the founding of the state of Israel are 1) that God gave that land to the Jews or 2) the Holocaust. The first reason is deeply insulting to Arab Muslims who are profoundly religious - but of another creed and the second reason means that the Palestinians Arabs had to pay for a crime that they did not commit.

How SHOULD the Arabs react to the "law of return" where any Jew, anywhere may emigrate to Israel and become a citizen, while those Arabs who fled in 1948 - or their children - can not. Or that Jerusalem, claimed to be Holy by three religions, has become the "eternal capital of the Jewish people". And only them!

Why does the US not react the same way to the overtly racist Israel in the same way that they reacted to overtly racist South Africa - eventually.

WHY does the USA consider Israel as an ally? What do they do for you? You are embroiled in Iraq, desperately trying to get out and leave some stability behind you and yet your "ally", Israel, attacks Gaza and Lebanon and further alienates the Arabs. In the Middle East, the main charge against the United States is that it is pro-Israel, because it lets itself be "manipulated by the Jews".

I see on this board and in the USA's media an almost total lack of understanding of the Arab viewpoint on Palestine, and, in particular, of the racist nature of the problem.

The reason Israel acts as it does is that it possesses its "all-powerful army", funded and armed by the US and tested again recently in Lebanon, and the inexplicable control over Washington policy-making and US public opinion.

Peace in the Middle East can only come when this feeling of Israeli superiority is shattered. Pursue a foreign policy based on [b]your own self-interest[/b] and that will happen.

Neil :)

by john.a.wills

The problem is that the Nakba is still going on and indeed being extended. And as for murdering children, the Israelis do that pretty well every week, don't they? BTW, Native Americans are allowed to live anywhere in the U.S. and their private property rights are protected by the courts. It is private property rights of the exiled Israeli citizens I was referring to; national claims are largely irrelevant to me.

by jdclyde

With it hard to convey tone, it was an effort to inform a new user (you) of what is and isn't condoned, without intending to sound hostile.

Chill and enjoy the ride.

by trrrr

I am truly new to this forum but not to tech stuff. I noticed the name of this Forum was TECH REPUBLIC not ISRAELI / HAMAS REPUBLIC. I have friends who are Israeli and I understand the frustrations that the region has had for many years. I apologize for my ignorance of your ignorance. I will never post here again nor shall I even look here. I will assume you may reply GOOD RIDDENCE. That is how i see it too. A tech forum about the middle east BS

by jellimonsta

TR is also known as a 'virtual water cooler' to many folk here. Things from music, jokes, religion, politics, world affairs, climate change, and everything in between are discussed.
Don't get bent out of shape, snoop around and enjoy the ride. It is truly a great site for both technical and non-technical discussion.

by jdclyde

Having never had other exchanges with you, I have no way of knowing if you leaving is a good or bad thing.

If you are that easily offended (especially when I was trying to be nice), then maybe TR isn't the site for you, though.

TR is more of a place for techs, than a place for tech.

We can come here and discuss things that non-technical people don't understand, from a point of view they can rarely relate to. Ever seen that glazed over look when you try to share something really cool in the tech field with a non-techie? You don't get a lot of that here.

We do discuss both technical and non-technical. My discussion during my divorce a few years back is still the second largest discussion in the history of TR, with the number one being about [i]whispers[/i](evolution)[i]hope no one heard that[/i].

It is a good site, and as long as your message isn't hateful or overly crude, then it is pretty much fair game.

If you do chill and check things out, you might find a new home. Just pick and choose which discussions you wish to be a part of, and don't presume to dictate to others.

Stay or go, your choice. Leaving will be your loss though, because it is a great site, full of great people.

by jdclyde

I think that the "native Americans" should be suing FRANCE over the Louisiana Purchase. We DID buy the land, fair and square, right? Not our fault if France jumped claim, huh?

by jiminpa

can anyone tell me how to write a script to hack the HVAC system??? It is terribly hot here in the dungeon :D

by john.a.wills

... not to the Jews but to the Israelites before they split into Jews and Samaritans. Israel is not a nation (Nm 23:9) but a church. Centuries after the Samaritan/Jew split, the Jews split into on the one hand Rabbinical Jews and on the other Christians. About a tenth of the Palestinians are Christian. And Muslims are very close to being Israelites within the meaning of Joshua - they are certainly not polytheistic idolaters like the Canaanites.

by charliespencer

More people with unprovable beliefs killing others with conflicting but equally unprovable beliefs because that's what they've always done. Strip them of their religious bindings and much of this goes away. No wonder I'm an atheist.

by jdclyde

or as nice as I can be, ya know?

Other than telling him he was out of line for coming in and dictating to others something he has no standings to dictate on, there shouldn't have been anything for him to get his feelings hurt on?

oh well...

by boxfiddler Hot topic

but my ears are great. I heard that JD.

Moving on to the cyborg thread, now. ;)

etu

by jdclyde

Many in the Democratic party are very anti-Israel, anti-jew, pro-muslim, pro-Palestine.

I would say many support Israel simply on the stance that they are surrounded by nations that want nothing more than to wipe them from the face of the planet.

People also see the cowardly attack upon citizens on a regular basis, and so think that Israel has every right to defend and strike back hard on all comers.

The world has also seen what happens everytime Israel does make concessions, it is never enough and the attacks on them continue.

The difference we also see, the recent "hostage trade" of a few corpses for living prisoners (murderers).

by protiusx

I was thinking how I was going to write this long diatribe in response to my good friend Neil BUT you beat me to it (and did a more concise job of it too!).

by jdclyde

It did take several rewrites to keep it short and sweet.

I have learned, the more you write, the less people read.

May not cover every issue that was asked, but to trie to explain from my boots what I see, was all I could do.

by Member 25348569

I am, I admit, going somewhat further than my real position with a bit of Devil's Advocate spin on my true position.

"A plague on both their houses" is closest to the truth of my feelings. I used to be, to a certain extent, a supporter of Israel but I find that I approve of very little - nothing, really, that they have done over the last twenty years. I now truly believe that Israel is out of control and they believe that they are invincible and can do anything that they want to. The US is hanging on to the tail of a tiger.

I have absolutely NO IDEA what you could do to let go but I do believe that you should try.

Neil :)

One really strange thing, though, which goes against Israel's normal ruthless, calculating attitude.

The hostage exchange was one of the most bizarre happenings in this whole crazy Middle East, though. Israel negotiated as if did not matter whether their captured troops were dead or alive and thereby allowed itself to be placed in the position of negotiating without even knowing what it was negotiating about.

One of the cornerstones of Israeli Defence force morale is that soldiers know that everything will be done to bring them back if captured. But how relevant is that with respect to the return of dead bodies? I would guess that the troops would NOT want any concessions on the scale of this exchange.

It is hard to believe that Israeli Defence force morale will be improved by a negotiating strategy that will have the inevitable effect of removing all incentives for the proper treatment of Israeli POWs.

by Member 25348569

I'd be interested to hear what concessions that you think Israel has ever made.

I'm also interested in your immediate finger-pointing at the hated Democrats, given that Obama has gone on record saying Israel's security was "sacrosanct" and "non-negotiable". He also said he would do "everything" to stop Iran getting a nuclear weapon.

Sounds like more of the same, to me.

Obama said last month that "he would work from the start of his administration to achieve a Palestinian state alongside an Israeli one, but with Jerusalem as the undivided capital of Israel". And you wonder why the Arabs are pissed!

The picture of Israel in the minds of the US citizens is, of course, "that they are surrounded by nations that want nothing more than to wipe them from the face of the planet." It is true - now - but what I'm really interested in is WHY this is the case. I'm also interested in what you think that those neighbours can actually DO about Israel.

I really do believe that the Israeli government endangers every American with its current policy of terrorizing the Middle East. Israel is the reason why the US policy in Iraq will fail.

The problem is that Israel is too strong and too ruthless and calculating to be defeated as long as the US supports them with their money, and the Arab world is also too strong to be defeated - they just have too much money of their own. Neither side can defeat the other. I don?t wish the Israelis harm but I do wish they would stop harming their neighbours. The US has to admit that Israel is a failed state and withdraw their encouragement and support for Israeli atrocities. THEN the world would be a safer place.

Neil :)

by jdclyde

I feel sorry for these mentally retarded individuals, lost, looking for government to be the solution to every problem they have. I don't hate them.

Obama is making a dash to the center now that the primary is done, just like he had made a mad dash to the extreme left to GET through the primaries.

He is making up time, because he knows if he is seen as weak on key issues like this and his back peddling on Iraq, he won't be able to win. He is not going to have enough of "the black vote" to overcome this otherwise. He has already shown he is just another politician, and we have seen that he is a great speaker, if he has a teleprompter to read off, but can't think on his feet and speak so greatly.

It is just a shame that McCain is not someone I can/will support, because that will make the difference with many.

Israel is the terrorist nation in the Middle East now? Interesting.

by w2ktechman

" I'm also interested in what you think that those neighbours can actually DO about Israel."

How about launching several thousand rockets?
How about kidnapping, tunnelling, suicide bombs, etc...

C'mon now, what can they do? This is just a small fraction. They CAN do lots. Israels neighbors can form another alliance and start a war. They CAN and WILL if nobody was backing Israel. Instead they support activities of terror and pledges for destruction.

" really do believe that the Israeli government endangers every American with its current policy of terrorizing the Middle East. Israel is the reason why the US policy in Iraq will fail. "

Israel is Terrorizing the Mid-East?
Hmmm, how many Israeli suicide bombers have you noted in the other countries?
How many unprovoked missiles get launched from Israel, to, say, Iran (where a good chunk of change and aid comes from to fight Israel with terrorist activities)?

So, we withdraw all support for Israel, then what???
Then Israel is overrun in a matter of weeks. Genocide would rule the region. Then there would be peace (for a short time)!
After Israel is gone, Who is next? There are many groups, just Israel was a common hate. After Israel is gone, would the new Palestine be next?
There is a lot of hatred in the mid east. All that will happen is a new focus/target.

by ic-it

Democrats. Both sides support Israel and it's right to exist. I would like to see some solid examples of politicians that are "very" anti. (And no minor left-wing idiots, because there are likely more minor right-wing nuts that have expressed anti views).

by jiminpa

could've seen you were trying to be nice. I know what it looks like when you go after somebody. I noticed he only joined on Wednesday. He's like the people out here that build their houses next to a pig farm and then complain about the smell...

by jdclyde

you didn't just open that one up, did you? :0 :p

damn trouble makers everywhere! ;\

by jellimonsta

I wasn't trying to cause trouble... honest! :D ;\

Edit: Also, being as Neil knows I am a limey, he will surely take it in jest. :D

by jdclyde

but I could see some certain other members around here (not talking about Neil) that have seen that so many times and just come UNHINGED. B-)

The action/reaction might have kicked in BEFORE they realized who was saying it and HOW they were saying it.

And just because it is TRUE doesn't mean we need to say it! :p :^0 [i]hello pot, let me stir you a bit![/i]

And after all that, you would think they would talk PROPER English.... [i]lord, how deep can this go?[/i]

if nothing else, would have helped get rid of all the extra "U"'s that get so liberally sprinkled in every other word? It is like the printers had a surplus of "U"'s, and had to use them up and figured no one would notice! B-) [i]make him stop, for the love of God, make him stop![/i]

B-)

by Member 25348569

I find that dispassionately assessing the role of Israel in the region over the last fifty years unearths some facts that seem at odds with the general perception of Israel as the "good guy".

We - well, your CIA - defines "terrorism" as deliberately inflicting injury, death and/or destruction upon a civilian target sufficient to cause horror, revulsion or despair among civilian populations and their leaders, with the goal of causing those populations or political leaders to act in a way desired by the terrorists.

One example of many I could post:

In its struggle with the Palestinians Israel always kills a hugely greater number of civilians than it suffers casualties itself.

In the fighting up to the evening before ceasefire in Lebanon, Israel stated it suffered 167 killed, of which 114 were military personnel and 53 were civilians. The Lebanese figures are less easy to verify but reported casualties were 1071 killed, of whom the great majority were civilians.

So, Hezbollah's struggle was mainly military on the border. Israel's attacks were widespread attacks on civilians in Lebanon.

The leaflets dropped by Israel on Beirut as the ceasefire came into effect openly proclaimed what I consider to be a terrorist message: "Can you pay this price again? Know that the Israel Defence Forces will return and will act with all necessary might against any terrorist act coming from Lebanon that touches Israel".

Neil

p.s What are the controls on the Israeli nuclear arsenal? What is the chain of decision and control of Israel's weapons? How susceptible are they to misuse or theft? With no open, frank, public debate on nuclear issues in Israel, there has accordingly been no debate or information on existing safeguards.

Israel has consistently refused to allow international inspection of its arsenal and facilities and is among the very few states in the world that have refused to sign the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty.

Yet your government criticises Iran?

I would suggest that Israel has the US by the nuclear balls. The day that the US pulls back from total support of Israel or reduces its military or financial support is probably the day that we will see Israel use some of that arsenal. Now THAT frightens us all, the US included.

by gate keeper

people why do we have to piss in our pool i.e politics on a tech forum ????

my apologies for the long title but that is what i think of your post Mr. ProtiusX.

everything you said is equally if not more true of the Israili government against palestinian civilians .. perhaps a dose of objectivity would have done your post some justice.

by Member 25348569

I, personally, have no problem debating Protius. He's a right-wing, American religious nutjob (from my perspective as a rational, left-wing, atheist Brit) but he's a NICE right-wing, American religious nutjob and he's a mate of mine so leave him alone. :)

The topic here is "off-topic". Not "networking" or "operating systems" or "management". All of those exist and there are blogs and discussions enough to warm your toes. "Off-topic" is an area where techs such as me can indulge in a bit of cut-and-thrust debate about absolutely anything. You don't HAVE to join in.

:D

by gate keeper

I would but i got pretty heated when it comes to politcs .. so i will not venture into that teritorry.

thanks for the heads-up regarding the off-topic stuff ... bear with me while i learn to navigate the murky waters that is techrepublic forums :D

by jdclyde

While not American, he/she has shown which side of the fence he/she is on....

So not everyone thinks that Israel is in the right here.

by Member 25348569

That is exactly my point. It is only the Americans who support Israel whatever they do and whoever they do it to without question.

Why? Seriously, what is in it for you? I just don't see it.

Neil :D

by Member 25348569

The primary definition in my dictionary for both arsenal and armoury is as a storage place for weapons. Each has the other as a synonym. The definition of arsenal alone, though, also includes "a collection or supply of weapons or munitions" such as Israel's collection of nuclear warheads.

Boom, Boom, Boom, Boom,
Boom, Boom, Boom,
Boom, Boom, Boom, Boom,
Boom, Boom, Boom

:)

by maxwell edison

Answer this question. In regards to the whole Israel/Palestinian/Arab issue that we struggle with today, how did it all start, what event's stoked the fire, and how did we get to where we are today?

The best [i]in a nutshell[/i] answer (as judged by yours truly), free of editorializing or the interjection of personal bias, and using 500 words or less wins the prize! (The 500 words request is a guideline. If you have to exceed it a bit, that's okay.)

by tony hopkinson

Kane killed Abel, and things went down hill from there.

10 words....

Or my personal favourite.

The start of the conflict was lost when those who started it were killed.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

gone out of hand with the passage of too much time and too little affection.

etu

by Member 25348569

It started with the Zionist movement and their idea to create a predominantly or completely Jewish homeland. Starting in the 19th century and continuing up to the present day, the Jewish National Fund bought land in the name of the Jewish people with the proviso that it could never be sold or even leased back to Arabs.

The Arab community, as it became increasingly aware of this agenda, strenuously opposed further Jewish immigration and land buying because it posed a real and imminent danger to the very existence of Arab society in Palestine. For whatever misguided colonial reason, the Jews were able to continue to purchase land with the military backing of the British. The Arabs' opposition to Zionism wasn't based on anti-Semitism but rather on a totally reasonable fear of the dispossession of their people from a land that they had occupied since the Seventh Century.

A quote from Theodore Herzl, one of the founders of Zionism, "We shall try to spirit the penniless [Arab] population across the border by procuring employment for it in transit countries, while denying it employment in our own country... Both the process of expropriation and the removal of the poor must be carried out discreetly and circumspectly".

Neil :)

More tomorrow, maybe...

by tony hopkinson

to marxist principals...

Bibble.

Says it all doesn't it, even an intellectual elite, can be as dumb as the hole in a cow's arse....

If the plan had succeeded, those who at least considered themselves to be the previous 'owners', theye were going to say , "our bad", and just take it on the chin.

So we get to the real cause of the the arab/israeli conflict, arrant stupidity.

by jdclyde

As we see, the neighboring nations refusing to take in the "refugees", after generations, shows their concern is NOT FOR the refugees, but AGAINST Israel.

If they HAD cared about the refugees, they would have taken them in after they saw that the combined middle east wasn't a match for Israel. BUT, if they did that, then there would no longer be a group of people to be leveraged in the Anti-Israel hate.

That they do not show Israel on their maps is interesting.

That they deny holocost openly, is interesting.

by the scummy one

"So, Hezbollah's struggle was mainly military on the
border. Israel's attacks were widespread attacks on
civilians in Lebanon."

First I want to mention -- what are the normal targets for
Hezbollah? Where are the missiles launched from? Are
those deaths/injuries included? What about the terror
message there?

As for the message dropped, basically stating, F**k with
us and we'll be back! -- I dont see a big problem with it.
they are trying to get the word out that they will retaliate
for attacks against them. However, it does have an
influence of other intentions and should/could have been
worded better.

So, how should Israel respond to rocket attacks? How
about with the knowledge that the rockets being used are
getting better and better?

by jdclyde

I suppose you don't see a difference between a military force that almost exclusively targets civilians, the whole time, intentionally hiding among civilians, and the need to retaliate when attacked?

Yeah, they should just twiddle their thumbs, and refuse to strike back, right?

Yet the same REAL terrorists that cowardly hide among the citizens are locally seen as heros, the whole time it is THEY that intentionally put the civilians in the cross-hairs HOPING the civilians would get killed so they could show how bad Israel is.

So, civilian targets almost exclusive on one side, while intentionally putting civilians in harms way on the other. Tell me about about the counts?

by tig2

An excellent reply! I commend you for taking Neil's words at face value and choosing to not react childishly.

Around this time of year, you'll see a few threads about breast cancer too. We periodically debate global warming. Come October and November, you will see any number of threads on politics. Post election, God Himself only knows what may erupt.

TR is a great place to visit and learn. There are good, intelligent people here who have any number of viewpoints and are willing to share them. You can find yourself deep in a discussion of routers one minute, anti virus the next, and gun control the next. That's the beauty of this joint- something for everybody. I'm a blog contributer. Got something you want to see researched and written about? PM me. Got questions that the FAQ doesn't answer? PM me.

Welcome to TR. I hope to see you back again and again. :D

by Member 25348569

"What are the controls on the Israeli nuclear [b]arsenal[/b]?"

and

"Israel has consistently refused to allow international inspection of its [b]armoury[/b]", that being the installation at Dimona.

You happy with that?

:D

by jdclyde

you just HAD to go THERE.... :0

To think we would be running around saying things like "Pip pip, cheeri-O!"

[i]which I have NO idea what a "pip pip" is....[/i]

by jdclyde

If the [i]Frogs[/i] hadn't "saved" us from you, would we have been in a position to "save" them in return? :0 ;\ B-)

by jdclyde

Why is it non-Americans are AGAINST Israel whatevery they do? Hmmmm.

Why the pro-middle-east, anti Israel? Who has shown themselves to be a greater threat to people outside of that region? I don't recall the last time Israeli's attacked the UK.

by Member 25348569

Could it be that there is, now, very little to be "pro-Israel" about when you view the actions of Israel dispassionately? We are allowed to say what we want and most people now say exactly that, mirroring the change in MY attitude to Israel since the 1960s. The label of "anti-Semitism" isn't slapped on anyone who dares to criticise Israel over here in the same way that it is in the US.

The criticism of Israel in the UK comes from all shades of people, multi-ethnic, multi-religious groups and it includes many British Jews.

A couple of years ago the Israeli ambassador said that Britain was a "hotbed of anti-Israeli sentiment".

Then again, we have a huge groundswell of anti-Islamic sentiment as well.

A plague on both their houses.

by Member 25348569

There were a couple of revolts by Palestinian Arabs during the British Mandate period but these were quite ruthlessly suppressed. I can't find out why, though.

Partition was the next key event. By setting up the State of Israel, the UN breached its own charter. There was no reason, political, historical or emotional why the Arabs should be dispossessed. But they were and are.

US and British history of the immediate aftermath of partition suggests that the surrounding Arab nations attacked immediately and were also responsible for the flight of the Arabs from within the Israeli borders (get out now and you can come back in a couple of days). The Arabs say different and refer to Israeli atrocities such as Deir Yassin where over a hundred Arab villagers were killed by Jewish troops.

Whatever the truth of any of this, there were 700,000 refugees, descendants now numbering 4 million, who aren't allowed back.

1949 and now they REALLY, REALLY don't like each other...

by charliespencer

From your previous post:

"It started with the Zionist movement and their idea to create a predominantly or completely Jewish homeland. Starting in the 19th century and continuing up to the present day, the Jewish National Fund bought land in the name of the Jewish people with the proviso that it could never be sold or even leased back to Arabs.

The Arab community, as it became increasingly aware of this agenda, strenuously opposed further Jewish immigration and land buying because it posed a real and imminent danger to the very existence of Arab society in Palestine."

Why was the potential of a Jewish state seen as a danger to Arab society? I can't answer that question, but it seems to me there must have been some preceding events fuel these fears.

Doesn't Islam come from the same Pentateuch / Old Testament background as Judaism and Christianity? Doesn't all this stem from Islam's break from Judaism?

by tony hopkinson

Or some one sold them a bad camel.

Maybe it was even that arab joke about sheep's eyeballs being a delicacy, maybe they laughed too loud when a well meaning jew ate one?

Perhaps their first ambassador was left handed?

How far do you want to go back?

You pick an event, there will be one before it that 'justified' a round of atrocity.

by tony hopkinson

with the jewish population while we were administering the place.

I just fail to see the point of trying to get to who did what to whom, it no longer matters, if it ever did.

It's like trying to defin who started up the 'Irish problem'. How far back do you want to go.

Patrick and Edward fell out over a sabre tooth tiger haunch?

Pick a side, write your own justification, just like every one else ever has.

by Member 25348569

They took quite a lot of it by force of arms. And they haven't - ever - given any of it back.

A quote from a document authored by some US Jews, "Arab rejection was based on the fact that, while the population of the Jewish state was to be [only half] Jewish with the Jews owning less than 10% of the Jewish state land area, the Jews were to be established as the ruling body".

As for the refugees, WHY should the surrounding nations take them in? The refugees originally wanted to go home. Their descendants don't really know WHAT they want as the whole thing is now mythology.

The Israeli government passed the "Absentee Property Law" in 1950, which cleared the way for the confiscation of the property of refugees. This basically says "You can't come back because we won't let you and if you don't come back we're going to bulldoze your village and set up a Jewish settlement".

They are re-applying that law now in East Jerusalem.

This is all common knowledge if you look past the media hype about "poor little Israel" who is "surrounded by enemies". "The only democracy in the Middle East" is just bollocks. Of the ten million or so population, four million aren't allowed to vote! Bet you can't guess who THEY are. If you take Israel's [b]legal[/b] borders then a good chunk of the voting population - including most of the government - live outside of Israel! All of this is Apartheid worse than South Africa.

Neil :)

The combined Middle East is surely a match for Israel except for the $4 billion that you pay them each year and the fact that the most sophisticated US military hardware is made freely available. Oh, and the fact the the IDF is brutal.

by sleepin'dawg

The collective sense of guilt is what helped Israel become established in what the Jewa considered there homeland and which it was prior to the establishment of Islam. Why another place couldn't have been found for a Jewish homeland, is still a matter of intense debate.

Neil you have it wrong about the IDF being brutal; they adhere fairly closely to the Geneva Convention, unlike the the Arabs who torture, rape and kill most of their prisoners. The IDF isn't brutal so much as it is efficient.

As a matter of curiosity, what can be expected from the Arabs as regards Israel, if and when they ever get their sh!t together and defeat Israel.

Ever here of the right of conquest. Without that the Normans would have had to give Britain back to the Angles and Saxons, who in turn stole it from the Britons, Scots, Picts and probably numerous others. In that light the Israelis are mere amateurs.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by Member 25348569

If you use any argument for the formation of a "Jewish Homeland", you have to alienate the Arabs. They took no part in the Holocaust - either overtly or by omission - and therefore should not share in the guilt. There hadn't been more than a handful of Jews in Palestine for over a thousand years so that argument doesn't wash. The final one - that God gave Israel to the Jews - is hugely insulting to the Arabs who, in their own way, are every bit as religious as the Jews or the Christians who were feeling the guilt.

The IDF is brutal. The occasions where villages, apartment blocks and the like have been razed without regard for "collateral damage" are innumerable. You might call that efficiency, I call it brutality. Israel's actions in the last Lebanese incursion were certainly NOT according to any convention - Geneva or otherwise.

The thing that you have to take into account is that the Israelis are consistently held up as paragons of virtue - "the only democracy in the Middle East". The US sees fit to label the surrounding Arab states as "terrorist states".

The Arabs will never defeat Israel. Israel has both sophisticated nuclear weapons AND the necessary delivery system. They would use them at the drop of a hat if it were not for the fact that this would probably cause the US to stoop supporting them. The US fear of Israeli nukes is what keeps the US buttoned up to Israel through thick and thin. The commitment by the US to keep Israel better armed than Saudi Arabia means that it costs the US $4 billion per annum and gains, in return, hatred.

The right of conquest is generally not recognised as a reasonable foreign policy by [b]civilised[/b] nations. You make my point for me.

I think that just about covers it...

Neil :)

by tony hopkinson

as long as you do it properly.

Israel could lose but it could never be defeated. Their desire was very simple they wanted somewhere where they were the majority. Quite rightly they don't trust anyone to treat them humanely, and no european nation should ever ask them too.

For many reasons jews do not integrate, so if they are a minority they are all going to be outsiders and different. People don't like different, never have.
They are no more accepted now, than they ever were, we just like to look more civilised than our forebears, so we tolerate them.

That was the real lesson of the holocaust.

by w2ktechman

Umm, did they not withdraw from Gaza? They were told the attacks would cease because there was nothing more to fight over. Funny, then there were MORE rocket attacks after their withdraw (under fire).

Ok, Spoils of War for other areas. They all tried ganging up on Israel, so Israel defeated them and claimed a bit of land in the process. Why SHOULD they give it back?? So that the rockets will be fired from closer? So that when rockets are used, they will be more likely to hit a more worthwhile target?

As for
"This is all common knowledge if you look past the media hype about "poor little Israel" who is "surrounded by enemies". "

First, I pay little attention to the media, and when I do, often it is not "poor little Israel". it is "Israel launched an offensive", "Israel bombed", "Israel fired rockets", "Israeli tanks crossed UN lines", etc..

You keep trying to make it sound like we all just get reports that Israel is getting picked on because nobody likes them.
This is untrue, the media here has been pretty harsh with Israel, as well as Hezbollah, Hamas, etc.. However, because of the actions of their neighbors, they often appear to be 'the good guys defending themselves'. And if it means taking more land to help secure their borders, then so be it!

Take a look through History for the region! The Palestinions have never ruled in their region, it has always been under rule from abroad. How did that rule happen? What is different here? Heck, even Britian had rule established there! BTW, How did Britian gain so many islands and other lands??? Oh, was that by Force???

You act as though because you are British, your way is right and every other way is wrong. Isnt that why they call it British Arrogance?

by Member 25348569

We have a few bits left which we're sorting out. Northern Ireland is as close a parallel that we have complete with terrorism - funded by you nice chaps in the US through NORAID. One difference, though, is that Catholics in NI have the vote.

The Scots will get the vote to see if they want to go their own way.

I'd give Gibraltar back tomorrow and (before you ask) the Falklands didn't have any indigenous people.

As for Hezbollah and their rockets. What you have to do is provide some evidence that Hezbollah would exist and would be firing rockets if Israel didn't occupy portions of Lebanese and Syrian territory.

We have a cycle of violence. Israel reacts - hugely over-reacts - to Palestinian terrorist attacks and it keeps going round. If Israel is such a moral bastion, the only civilised country in the region (as we are consistently informed) then THEY have to take it on the chin and not (over)react to stop that cycle.

I don't remember too many cross-border incursions into Irish territory chasing the IRA. [b]We[/b] didn't send a Harrier jet down to Dublin to put a rocket through IRA headquarters. "Bloody Sunday" is the worst that we did and it was stupid and wrong and only made things worse.

Neil :)

by charliespencer

I've often wondered why we support an 'ally' who routinely spies on us. I wonder why our political leaders feel compelled to cater to the desires of the relatively small pro-Israeli special interest groups (and the even smaller anti-Castro groups). I suspect we wouldn't be as interested in Israel if it wasn't in the middle of the Oillandia.

by Member 25348569

but if you examine that a little closer then I'm not sure it holds up.

Israel has no oil. Support for Israel gets the US, in return, nothing but hostility from the Arab nations who DO have the oil. You'd get a lot more support from Arab nations in the "war against terrorism" if the support for Israel wasn't so strong.

What is it that has made the US use its UN security council veto so many times to shut down UN Resolutions critical of Israel? I really do want to know and it's why I'm posting here.

I can see why the US would support Israel on moral grounds but then I don't understand why US support was much less in the early years of the Israeli state, when they really needed it AND when they were more democratic, but has ramped up as Israel's military power has grown dramatically and its repression against Palestinians in the occupied territories has increased.

So I still don't know why...

by w2ktechman

however I dont know how much water it holds.

Information -- Israel has very detailed information on their little area and neighbors.

Also, as their military equipment gets used, we probably get to do research to advance our equipment. Nothing is better to learn from than actual use!

just 2 things that may put together part of the picture.

by j-mart

By defeating Germany in the Battle of Brittain the oportunity to invade Brittan was gone for the Germans as they lost the battle for air superiority required for invasion. The US contribution joining later on was in where the line between between Soviet controled Europe and the rest would be.

by jessie

Why, aside from the whole "religious homeland" thing, were the displaced Jews of the holocaust not given Germany? Seems to me there would have been enough collective guilt from those Germans who stood by and watched their friends and neighbors getting rounded up and put on trains or stuffed into ghettos that the Germans would have given up the goods without a fight... but we (the royal U.N. "we")had to go "giving" land to a bunch of people who'd never lived there, that we didn't own, hadn't purchased, and that already had people who'd been there forever?

Strikes me that the Palestinians and the American Indians have a lot in common... but the American Indians had been decimated enough that they couldn't fight back too much when we gave them the American waste lands as a consolation prize.

by tony hopkinson

It was almost pretext for Nuremberg as far as the big three were concerned. As societies we weren't aware of the full horror until much later.

Stalin certainly didn't want a nation of Jews next door.

The americans wanted to ensure peace, so while the idea is just, putting them as far away as possible from their enemies must have seemed like a good idea.

And everyone was conscious of Versaille, as our last attempt to kick the germans while they were down didn't work out too well, in terms of world peace.

by tony hopkinson

not many, but everyone we could get was valuable. They came over to help out, nvere mind what the government wanted. Real freedom fighters.

Lend lease as unfavourable as it was, helped.

The big plus though was Hitler, as military commander he was a very good corporal. Let's go invade russia, it will only take a few months....

by sleepin'dawg

[i][b]There hadn't been more than a handful of Jews in Palestine for over a thousand years so that argument doesn't wash[/i][/b]

Various Arab government have had Jewish cabinet ministers and advisors. Wouldn't you consider that strange for a mere "handful of Jews"???

by sleepin'dawg

[i][b]There hadn't been more than a handful of Jews in Palestine for over a thousand years so that argument doesn't wash[/i][/b]

Both "Jews" and "Arabs" are of the same racial stock; semetic. The Semetic peoples were a pain in the ass to western civilization even prior to the Roman Empire. The Phonecians, Carthaginians etc. were semetic in origin. Ask yourself what was the predominant religion of the area prior to Mohamed??? Prior to the Diaspora, the predominant religions of the area were Coptic Christianity and Judaism; with Judaism in predominance. Long before Islam had invaded Europe, Jews had spread throughout Europe but being the newcomers met with the antagonism of European Christianity. The Jews had never practised rights of conquest, what they did do was assimilate; witness the differences between Ashknazy Jews and Sephardic.

Even after the establiishment of Islam, there remained significant populations of Jews throughout the region, so much so, that several "Arab" governments have had Jewish cabinent ministers and/or advisors. Witness Morocco, Jordan {under Hussein) and Iraq (under Sadaam). Even Quaddafi is said to have several Jewish advisors.

This isn't to say that Jews aren't persecuted; they are but they were persecuted by the pogroms in Russia and several other supposedly civilized Western states. Remember Edward IV threw the jews out of England as did France and Spain.

Palestinians are being led by a savage, brutal gang of religious fanatical thugs. Paleastine would have much more to gain by achieving peace with Israel than by continuing conflict. Both Jordan and Egypt have befitted by a cessation of conflict with Israel.

Israeli technology is much more than it's nuclear weaponry. Its irrigation and desalinization technologieswould and could do much for the people of the area.

Also while going about being an apologist for Islam try to remember Islam first invaded Christian territory; at both ends of the Mediterranean.

I doubt you've ever been in the Middle East but it seems you've been buying into Arab propaganda, assuming, that is, you haven't already been bought and sold. Just be thankful you weren't riding a bus or in the tube when the bombs went off.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by r_o_l_a_n_d

first of all, i assume we all subdue to the world peace concept that the UN is based upon.
moreover, i assume once again (hopefully im not mistaken) that we all agree to the human rights and every single right given to citizens of the world by natural order or UN's affirmation of such rights.
with that in i quote the following:
According to 1982 UN resolution that affirms, ?the legitimacy of the struggle of peoples for independence, territorial integrity, national unity and liberation from colonial and foreign domination and foreign occupation by all available means, including armed struggle."

now reading such a statement, i assume that every foreign occupation gives the citizens of the occupied country the rightful and sacred right of resistance.

now once again having such a concept in mind, let me run this scenario for you all.
i'm happily married living living in my own house, where suddenly some powerful gangster decides to give half of my house to some poor family.
that family endured a lot! a serial killer went after it and almost exterminated it which gave the gangster a kind of soft spot for them.
now on the other hand, that family had real presence in that gangster's organization, and since that gangster was in for a hell of a fight with another gangster trying to broaden his domain of control, he came with the idea of strengthen his inner house so to speak to be able to have a stronger infrastructure for the mess hes going to get into.
in return for that, he promised that poor family to give them a house of their own, and suddenly he picked my house! and as he is the powerful gangster on the scene, he got away with it at first.
naturally, i didnt like the idea, i tried my best to kick out the new family, even though their poor life story was heart breaking, though that doesnt give them the right to occupy my own place does it!

now after a few years of resistance, where my kids got murdered, starved to death, the women of my family ended up working for those who occupied my own house. some far away smart ass, decided that the resistance that my family is giving to fight off those who occupied my land, is a pure form of terrorism.

thats the end of my lil scenario :)

now to get back to what you actually wrote.
if i read your article 2 years ago, i would've completely agreed, actually i wouldve supported you 200 %.
though right now! well let me share something with you:)

i'm lebanese,i used to have the same point of view about hizbolla and lebanon as a whole that you have at the moment.
last summer, i was spending for the first time a 1 month vacation in lebanon due to the fact that syria finally went out of lebanon.
and suddenly! israel started bombing lebanon.
at first i said, wtf is wrong with hizbolla to do such a thing and abduct these 2 soldiers, till i witnessed how israel returned the favor by to lebanese innocent citizens by showering them with shells that they got from the states and UK.
i will never forget the =videos of lil israely kids writing on smart bombs that are to be dropped over innocent lebanese civilans "from israel with love" something that i sent my US partners copies of, and now they share the same point of view as i.
i went to "dahia" the place that israel bombed the most to find that hizbolla supporters arent that different than me! they believed in one cause, and thats the indepe of their country. after speaking to so many of them, after staying nights visiting more than one family that loved hizbolla to death. i came to one conclusion.

zionism, is the new age nazism.
it actually made me proud to be lebanese again, and as you can see i moved my entire family and buisness to lebanon. and i encouraged 4 out of 6 american partners that i had back in the states to moove with me to leb.
and i'm telling you! for the first time in a long time, i am proud of the lebanese resistance . i am the son of that land that israel occupied. that israel bombed its countrymen. that israel killed its innocent women and children.
now what made me laugh, is you saying that hizbolla wants one thing and only one, and thats to kill every jew, well hey ! guess what! my wife is a lebanese jew, she and her entire family believes in hizbolla and supports them. a while back i was in my bro's in law barmitsfa. and almost everyone there stood still watching "nasralla" talking about israel.
and they all started swearing at the zinosim that made jews the new age nazist.
my wife's grandmother shes 104 years old, shes german, she lived through the nazi age. she doesnt speak english much, she only speaks hebrew and german.
her only english words are, "jew isnt zionis" wht she means is that the jews has nothing to do with zionism.
so i wonder how people half way around the earth saying that hizbolla are terrorists and not a legit resistance, and they want to exterminate the jews, when the jews that i know who are lebanese and living in lebanon, believe the actual opposite and wish that hizbolla eradicated zinoists from israel!

hmm i wonder..

by Member 25348569

I made the point that serious Jewish immigration into the area started late in the 18th Century and that there was, relatively speaking, very few Jews in the are until then. I hold to that point.

For the majority of the Second Millennium, the Palestine area was a sparsely populated, poorly cultivated and totally-neglected expanse of eroded hills, deserts and marshes.

Firstly the Marmelukes wiped out most of the cities in the area in the 13th century. poisoning wells and generally making Palestine almost uninhabitable and uninhabited. The Black Death in 1351 just about finished the place off. The population dipped as low as 200,000. It is after this period that area became repopulated mainly by Levantine Muslims moving in from the area that is now Lebanon, Syria and Jordan.

During the Ottoman Empire period, 16th to 19th Century, the Jewish population rose as high as 20% after the expulsion of Sephardic Jews from Spain by the Catholic Church, before the population dropped again following a number of massacres. Ashkenazi Jews started to move in from Eastern Europe towards the end of the Ottoman Empire.

The lowest estimates claim there were about 410,000 Arab Muslims and Christians in Palestine by 1900 with other estimates running at 600,000 or so. At this time, the number of Jewish immigrants to Palestine was still negligible by all accounts. I have seen ratios of non-Jews to Jews at 90/10 and as low as 95/5 for the mid 1800s.

Those who favour the Zionist version of history suggest that Arab influx into Palestine was mainly prompted by Jewish development of the area. It is unlikely that Palestinian immigration prior to 1900 was due to Zionist development.

I don't say that there were NO Jews in the area from the ending of the original Jewish state by the Romans. Jewish communities did continued to exist despite the fact that all of the successor governments tried to eliminate the Jews at one time or another.

I just said that there weren't many.

There weren't.

Neil :)

No offence, Dawg, but don't tell me what I don't know.

by Member 25348569

Should I hate the Irish?

I take mild offence at your suggestion that I have "bought into" Arab propaganda. What possible reason have I to favour the Arabs? What possible reason have I to favour the Israelis? Both are behaving in ways that any civilised person or state would - should - condemn.

As a matter of fact, it was British-born Pakistani Muslims who blew up the tube trains and Saudi-Arabian Muslims who brought down the Twin Towers. Should I hate the whole Islamic religion? According to you, I should. according to me, I'll be a little more particular about who I hate and why.

I'm not an "apologist for Islam". At its very best it's just more mumbo-jumbo and flawed interpretations of The Book used to control people. Like some other religions that I could name.

What I AM is someone who thinks that Israel should be taken to task for their excesses.

Neil

By the way, "typical" of what?

p.s. key point which I've obviously got to keep making. My problem is not with JEWS, it's with ISRAEL.

by john.a.wills

If the Israelis rule the Holy Land by right of conquest, they are obliged to protect the population, not engage in ethnic cleansing. And, of course, they should respect property rights, which they do not.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

is another rationalization that people who like to kill other people use for doing so.

edit: lose a word