Question Locked

AD on a ISA 2004 server - is this a good idea?

0 helpful
3 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hi,

I've just recently taking over a site where my predecessor installed a ISA 2004 server and also made it a backup AD (Domain Controller) as well. I've also noticed that there have been a few servers removed from AD that are causing some errors in the Event Logs. My questions are;

- Is this a good idea to have a ISA server as a AD controller as well?

- Any suggestions as to how to remove the servers from AD even though the accounts are no longer there?

I'm planning of replacing / migrating the existing servers to new hardware so I'm keen to get this all cleaned up so as not to 'inherit' any legacy problems.

Thanks,

Matt

3 replies

by cg it

the MS's Small Business Server Premium Edition comes with ISA 2004 and it's installed on the DC. Without knowing your particular network setup, it would be diffucult to say whether an ISA server on a DC is a good idea.

further, ISA is a proxy firewall and can be used in a number of ways. It can be a perimeter firewall, clustered with other ISA servers in a DMZ area for multiple network segments.

by rfdswa

Thanks for the response.

Your right I should have explained more, the server in question is 2003 Server not a SBS one. Apparently after some more investigation I've been told that the previous admin was of the opinion that all of the servers should have AD installed. Worst part is that when they decommissioned a server it was simply shutdown and removed without running DCPROMO.

This combined with legacy issues of DNS and DHCP do have me rather stretched at the moment. If it wasn't for the fact that we are a 24x7 organisation I'd rip it all out and start again.

The ISA box in question is supposed to be our outer firewall to which I was always under the impression you shouldn't have AD on a server sitting on the internet connection.

Thanks.

This discussion is closed to new replies.