Question Locked

Allow viewing of documents without being able to copy

0 helpful
19 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I've been given an interesting challenge. We want to be able to give some of our internal people the ability to look at some documents containing our super secret formulas, without them being able to copy them. Since simply assigning read-only access won't cut it, anyone have any ideas?

19 replies

by robo_dev

so without direct supervision, that's a tough one.

If these were PDF files, viewed on a web-browser in kiosk mode, on a workstation setup in kiosk mode, it would be view only.

Look at any consumer-facing computer interface, such as an ATM, Airline ticketing kiosk, etc.....these are view-only devices.

by larryd4

Even if you go in and set permissions so the user can view the file, it can be copied.

Even if you had a way to remove the permission to use the copy command you would need to remove the ability to allow people to do a print screen or screen capture.

Its really not possible and as the other post said, even if you can keep people from doing a print screen a camera would work just fine..

by shasca

Adobe Acrobat has custom security settings. Check their site andd see if this product will do what you need.

This cut from their website

Open secured PDFs
If you receive a PDF that is protected by security features, you may need a password to open the document. Some protected documents have restrictions that prevent you from printing, editing, or copying content in the document. If a document has restricted features, any tools and menu items related to those features are dimmed.

by larryd4

It works good but it still does not get around the fact that you can hit print screen and paste it in to paint.

by shasca

At least I gave him a suggestion as opposed to ridicule. I said it would be something he could look at, not a fix-all. He's the only one that can decide what to do in his environment. Not we........

by oh smeg

First you will need a Secure Environment where these can be opened. Then you will need Display Only Screens that have just the one Document on.

The users who access these will need to be prevented from bringing in any means of performing a Copy such as Digital Cameras, Pen & Paper, Mobile Phone with a Camera in them hell No Phones at all because they could use these to pass on the information by simply reading the screens contents over the phone to some outsider and as there is no Keyboard there is no way to grab a Screen Capture or so on.

Also the People who access these Documents will be required to have their Brains Washed Clean so that they do not remember any of the Secret Formula's and copy then down when they leave the building.

Your simple answer is that if there are secrets involved there is no way to prevent them being copied and even worse opening them up to the Internet is another [b]Attack Vector[/b] to destroy a Company by on selling all of their Secrets to the Opposition or a New Business just starting up.

Col

by larryd4

Wonder how many people here know what Soylent Green is.

Hmm where is the front end loader...

by oh smeg

But I saw that when it was new and a First Release. :D

But I'm willing to bet that not many know what it is.

Col

by thumbsup2

I remember when the movie first came out. It's one of my favorites! ;)

by older mycroft

I had a horrible feeling that only a few of us would have the first flying clue what I was talking about. ;)

by wizard-09

They might just copy it using pen and paper what can you do then about it ?

Just a thought

by sidekick

Yes, I realize that nothing is 100% secure. Access is limited to those who absolutely need it. Another division uses an Access database to retrieve the files, and this is run on a terminal server wtih an ISA firewall in an obnoxiously locked down environment through group policy. The Access database is set to log access to the files as well as printing of them. We will probably implement something like that, maybe using PDFs this time. But I do appreciate the response.

I guess it is the best we can do. There just isn't enough money in the budget for a front-end loader.

by the 'g-man.'

They can just take a photo (with a camera) of the screen no matter what you block.

The Coke formula will be lost!

by sidekick

Let me say this again. I know that nothing is 100% secure. The idea is to make it as secure as possible.

by the 'g-man.'

Let me say it again - no matter what you do there will be a method for somebody to get the top secret data. You best recourse is not to allow unauthorised people to see the data and log when the authorised persons can see it.

Better still when they access, there is some slight difference (for every session, say a digital watermark per session and some on screen data change they are not aware off) that will allow you to determine the who and when if needed.

by sidekick

"Let me say it again - no matter what you do there will be a method for somebody to get the top secret data. You best recourse is not to allow unauthorised people to see the data and log when the authorised persons can see it. "

Yes, I agree with this and covered it in my previous post.

"Better still when they access, there is some slight difference (for every session, say a digital watermark per session and some on screen data change they are not aware off) that will allow you to determine the who and when if needed."

Hmm, now that is an interesting and useful idea to increase auditing. Thank you.

In fact, the whole purpose of this question was not to get a 100% secure solution, as that is not possible, but to get ideas on how to get as much security as possible. And I have learned a couple things from this that might be helpful, so I feel that I have succeeded in my goal.

I suppose I should have been more upfront with my expectations. That is my own fault. I guess I wasn'texpecting to be insulted.

Oh, and as far as the "No", that simply refers to the fact that I'm not stupid. People who are afraid to ask questions for fear of asking a "stupid question" learn less than those who don't. I've learned a couple things today and I am happy with that. Just because you know something that someone else doesn't, it does not make the other person stupid.

This discussion is closed to new replies.