Discussion Locked

An Atheist American President...

0 helpful
384 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I was talking to two of my coworkers. One a liberal and one a conservative. Both said the same thing.."Americans would vote a Black or a Jew as a President, rather than a Atheist". I thought this was a profound statement.

One thing I found it was difficult was that they equally believed that if a person has to have good values, morals and ethics he/she has to be religious. That baffled me.

edited: grammar in the title.
edited: tags

384 replies

by jimhm

I don't believe that an Atheist would make a good leader. I don't believe they would have integrity, morals, values or ethics. It isn't that they have a religon - it is that they don't believe in a superior being - that gave them the rights they enjoy.

Socialist states give those rights to its citizens and thus can take them away. A government that believe those rights are granted by a superior being can not be taken away my government.

It has nothing to do with religon (in my book) - its more of what they believe an individual rights and freedoms come from ... Athesit, around the world trend to be soicalist and believe that the government grants those freedoms and rights.

by fluxit

One moral system out there states that our Universe is morally neutral and that human desire, wants, and needs cause moral instability.

This view assumes that morality has physical properties and behaves under the laws of physics always wanting to return to a ground state of nuetrality like electrons in an atom. Your comments allude to this model.

A morally neutral universe fails the scientific test. Can we place a sample of morality in a lab, have controls, and measure the results? Are there physical laws and principles that are identifiable, measurable, and controllable in hard science? No. We have to turn to soft sciences of psychology and psychiatry where they are attempting to unify the mind-brain theories.

They know that people play out life scripts or that thought processes are perfectly ordered but indeterminant. The concept of free will cannot be dealt with adequately in science.

Overall this model is incorrect. Consciousness, self-awareness, and thought are not of the physical universe. They interject into the physical universe and the effects can act in the physical universe through human action but no other ways that are observed. Otherwise, we would be able to measure it in the physical universe. So where does it comes from?

Another school of thought suggest it is a ethereal thing that spans from another universe into this physical universe. The doctrine that discusses this states that '... we do not wrestle against the physical, but against principalities, against powers, against the rulers of the darkness of this age, against spiritual hosts of wickedness in the heavenly places.'

Once again the wisdom of Leonardo Da Vinci shows us that through interconnectedness there is a link between science and the spititual. The doctrine that gives us an understanding of this spiritual component is undeniably the Bible.

Granted man has misinterpreted it over time and Churches have misconstrued the message. Nonetheless, it has stood the test of time and remains incredibly intact.

by onbliss

Jim:
I know an atheist who is not like that. He is a good human being. He does not think government can give away and take away rights.
I don't think all atheists are socialists.

by john_wills

Not all atheists are socialists: archetypal communists, the sociaists' greatest enemy, are atehists. At another extreme, Ayn Rand was a militant atheist, and she condemned all kinds of collectivism. She also had a thought-out moral system, as it happens. She did not live by it, but Bush and Blare do not live by Christian morality, so that is a secondary issue. I have read the first half of Mein Kampf, and nothing there indicates any normal religous affiliation, so perhaps we can call Hitler an atheist of sorts: he worshipped the goddess Germania, of course, but communists worship some ideal in a simialr way. But Hitler's economic theory was corporatism, of which the extreme is fascism, as the extreme of socialism is communism and the extreme of liberalism is libertarianism, or Rand's objectivism. So by no means are all apparently godless people socialist.

by oz_media

Hey now you can associate a persons religion with their political stand!
Absolutely fantastic! Lets see, who can you incorrectly pigeonhole now?
Perhaps BUSH IS God and that explains why he can F*&#k kill American citizens and still have his supporters stay loyal! It's biblical! Damn, he'll never forgive me now!

Have you guys thought about that? Whether BUSH is justified or not in taking Iraq, would he not be thrown into the fiery pits of hell as one who has ordered the deaths of many? I mean sure there were people that needed to be killed but what about all those who didn't do anything wrong?
They still got injured or killed by his doing. Does that now make him a sinner? You can probably find something that will let him off though, there's ALWAYS an exception to the rule.

Thanks for the laugh, Jim!

by jimhm

You are a mental case there Oz - you just go off in Never-Never Land, and float around some strange weeds and start off about GWB - and fly off the handle..

I think a few of Prozac - and Haldol would do you a world of wonder ... Time to get back on your Med's there .. A would say you needed to be loaded with Physic drugs - to bring you back to reality ...

Earth Calling Oz - time to return for a landing .. Come in Oz - Earth calling ..

by maxwell edison

But this may be interesting to some.

Famous Atheists, Freethinkers, Diests and Agnostics:

--------------------

"The Bible is not my book nor Christianity my profession. I could never give assent to the long, complicated statements of Christian dogma."

- Abraham Lincoln, President of the United States

--------------------

"I have found Christian dogma unintelligible. Early in life, I absenteed myself from Christian assemblies.

Lighthouses are more helpful then churches."

-Benjamin Franklin

--------------------

"My view is that if there is no evidence for it, then forget about it. An agnostic is somebody who doesn't believe in something until there is evidence for it, so I'm agnostic."

-Carl Sagan

--------------------

"I don?t believe in God. My god is patriotism. Teach a man to be a good citizen and you have solved the problem of life."

- Andrew Carnegie

--------------------

"I do not believe in a personal God and I have never denied this but have expressed it clearly. If something is in me which can be called religion than it is the unbounded admiration for the structure of the world so far as our science can reveal it."

"I cannot imagine a God who rewards and punishes the objects of his creation, whose purposes are modeled after our own -- a God, in short, who is but a reflection of human frailty. Neither can I believe that the individual survives the death of his body, although feeble souls harbor such thoughts through fear or ridiculous egotism."

"I do not believe in the immortality of the individual, and I consider ethics to be an exclusively human concern with no superhuman authority behind it."

"If people are good only because they fear punishment, and hope for a reward, then we are a sorry lot indeed."

-Albert Einstein

--------------------

"Faith is the commitment of one's consciousness to beliefs for which one has no sensory evidence or rational proof. A mystic is a man who treats his feelings as tools of cognition. Faith is the equation of feeling with knowledge."

-Ayn Rand

--------------------

"During almost fifteen centuries has the legal establishment of Christianity been on trial. What has been its fruits? More or less, in all places, pride and indolence in the clergy; ignorance and servility in the laity; in both, Famous Atheist & Quotessuperstition, bigotry, and persecution."

"In no instance have the churches been guardians of the liberties of the people."

"Religious bondage shackles and debilitates the mind and unfits it for every noble enterprise."

"What influence in fact have Christian ecclesiastical establishments had on civil society? In many instances they have been upholding the thrones of political tyranny. In no instance have they been seen as the guardians of the liberties of the people. Rulers who wished to subvert the public liberty have found in the clergy convenient auxiliaries. A just government, instituted to secure and perpetuate liberty, does not need the clergy."

- James Madison, President of the United States

--------------------

"Where do we find a precept in the Bible for Creeds, Confessions, Doctrines and Oaths, and whole carloads of other trumpery that we find religion encumbered with in these days?"

"The divinity of Jesus is made a convenient cover for absurdity."

"This would be the best of all possible worlds, if there were no religion in it."

- John Adams, President of the United States

--------------------

"I believe in God, only I spell it Nature."

- Frank Lloyd Wright

--------------------

"I turned to speak to God, About the world's despair; But to make bad matters worse, I found God wasn't there."

"Forgive, O Lord, my little joke on Thee and I'll forgive Thy great big one on me."

"I hold it to be the inalienable right of anybody to go to hell in his own way."

-Robert Frost

--------------------

"I can very well do without God both in my life and in my painting, but I cannot, suffering as I am, do without something which is greater than I am, which is my life, the power to create."

-Vincent Van Gogh

--------------------

"I do not believe in the divinity of Christ, and there are many other of the postulates of the orthodox creed to which I cannot subscribe."

- William Howard Taft, President of the United States

--------------------

"All national institutions of churches, whether Jewish, Christian or Turkish, appear to me no other than human inventions, set up to terrify and enslave mankind, and monopolize power and profit. "

- Thomas Paine

--------------------

"Religion is all bunk."

"I cannot believe in the immortality of the soul.... No, all this talk of an existence for us, as individuals, beyond the grave is wrong. It is born of our tenacity of life ? our desire to go on living ? our dread of coming to an end."

- Thomas Edison

--------------------

"History I believe furnishes no example of a priest-ridden people maintaining a free civil government. This marks the lowest grade of ignorance, of which their political as well as religious leaders will always avail themselves for their own purpose."

"Religions are all alike ? founded upon fables and mythologies."

"I do not find in orthodox Christianity one redeeming feature."

"Christianity is the most perverted system that ever shone on man."

"It does me no injury for my neighbor to say there are 20 gods, or no God. It neither picks my pocket nor breaks my leg."

"The Christian god can easily be pictured as virtually the same god as the many ancient gods of past civilizations. The Christian god is a three headed monster; cruel, vengeful and capricious. If one wishes to know more of this raging, three headed beast-like god, one only needs to look at the caliber of people who say they serve him. They are always of two classes: fools and hypocrites."

"Millions of innocent men, women and children, since the introduction of Christianity, have been burnt, tortured, fined and imprisoned; yet we have not advanced one inch towards uniformity."

"And the day will come when the mystical generation of Jesus, by the supreme being as his father in the womb of a virgin will be classed with the fable of the generation of Minerve in the brain of Jupiter. But may we hope that the dawn of reason and freedom of thought in these United States will do away with this artificial scaffolding, and restore to us the primitive and genuine doctrines of this most venerated reformer of human errors."

? Thomas Jefferson, President of the United States

by jardinier

This list would be very appropriate material for my religious website www.thinking-seriously.com

I would like to give you credit for compiling the list, but if you prefer not to have your name mentioned, I can simply cite the information as: "historical facts" in the public domain.

by maxwell edison

I found it on someone else's Web Site, so you may want to give them credit instead. But of course, if it's like many (whatever that is) other instances, one Web site got it from another, which got it from another, which got it from another.......none of which credits the original source.

Of course, I left a lot of names and quotes that I found off the list - Karl Marx, Authors, Actors, Musicians - as it would have made the list less "impressive" and less applicable as it pertains to this thread, and it would have been more, shall I say, whacko. Who cares what George Clooney or Frank Zappa thinks? (Thought in the case of Zappa - but, of course, now he knows for sure.)

I think my Internet search was for "famous atheists", or something like that.

What I found by Carl Sagen was most interesting to me. He's not an atheist, but rather an agnostic - since the existence of God can be neither proven or disproved.

He also said the following:

"In some respects, science has far surpassed religion in delivering awe. How is it that hardly any major religion has looked at science and concluded, "This is better than we thought! The universe is much bigger than our prophets said, grander, more subtle, more elegant. God must be even greater than we dreamed." Instead they say, "No, no, no! My god is a little god, and I want him to stay that way." A religion, old or new, that stressed the magnificence of the universe as revealed by modern science might be able to draw forth reserves of reverence and awe hardly tapped by the conventional faiths. Sooner or later such a religion will emerge."

Carl Sagan - Pale Blue Dot (1994)

by thechas

The real truth is that an atheist would never make it through the primary process to get on the ballot for the general election.

The real question, is which will be first:

Black
or
Woman

Chas

by road-dog

In this matchup, my dollar's on Condi, and here's why...

Condi garners national attention, while Hillary is predominantly a New York figure. Condi is in a position that gets attention, but doesn't usually tick folks off. Hillary has 5 years to open that shrill pie hole of hers and degrade her chances.

Cynically speaking, Clinton fatigue will still be a factor in 2008.

This '04 election, with the Clinton backing of Wesley Clark, shows that the Clintons will undercut their party to face a non-incumbent Republican candidate in '08. They could have backed any one of the Democrat frontrunners, yet they chose to muddy the waters with Clark.

This is not going to help Hillary with '08 as party backing is essential in the primaries. I suspect that Terry McAuliffe will be removed as DNC Chairman after the serious drubbing the Democrats are going to take in '04. The Clintonian headlock on the DNC will no longer exist.

The black vote will lean more toward Condi. (10 percent republican swing of the black vote would throw this thing)Hillary's lock on the women's vote will be weakened or cancelled.

OK, printscreen and toss this bad boy in the time capsule....

by maxwell edison

As I suggested on a different thread:

Rudy Giuliani will beat whatever Democrat is sent to the sacrificial alter.

by jimhm

If she were the best canidate - supported what I felt was important - Yes she would have my vote -

by mrbill-

One of Condie's main problems is she is single, the voters like a married canidate, more stable. Or at least percived to be.

by road-dog

Guliani got busted screwing around.... He's dead in the water with the reactionary right. I know he's America's Mayor, and he kicked major a$$ in the Big Apple, but stick a fork in him, he's done. I wouldn't mind seeing him go after Hillary's Senate seat, though. That would have implications on her march to 1600 Pennsylvania.

by maxwell edison

Read Rudy's book, "Leadership".

Better yet, get the company to spring for a ticket to one of his speeches. (or both the book and the live speech)

He can really stir up the audience - and he's genuine to boot.

Ski season opens in a week! There's snow in them there mountains. (Too bad I don't ski.)

That's........all..........for.........now.......looking.......for.....the.....oxygen.........tank..........gasp........gasp..........

by road-dog

Give a speech. His last appearance in Orlando was $100 a seat and I won't spend $100 to hear anybody speak. I'm just a tightwad that way. I'm self employed, so my boss is a tightwad as well.

As for skiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiing, don't feel bad about it. I live a few minutes from Cocoa Beach, and I don't go there.

by oz_media

You say that they would vote for a Black or a Jew before an atheist.

Does this mean that voting for a Black or a Jew is not something one would NORMALLY consider? In the same sense as saying "I'd even vote for a Clown before Bush"

I think their racial statement is as offensive as not voting for an atheist. There shouldn't be ANY comparison between religion, color and politics, that's what wars are started over.

by road-dog

That struck me about the statement also. It appears that some of us do have a ways to go as race relations go.

What's ironic about that is that to put atheists so far down the totem pole indicates that the coworkers in question were possibly (probably) Christian.... and bigoted. Ya' know, I don't think that kind of thinking looks good in your file when the big employee evaluation happens after you depart this world....

As for not voting atheist, I don't think that's bigoted. Atheism is an idea, a rejection of religion. If one were to lump say, catholics in place of atheist, it would be the same deal.

by onbliss

...they are pretty good souls. They are knowledgeable, well travelled, aware of different cultures, traditions, practices, people, regligions. Nope, I don't think they are racist. They were making a remark on the general public. Their assessment could be wrong or not politically correct.
I know they are good people. To me it looked like any one of the commentaries about real life facts.

by Member 32001153

Isn't it a reference to I would vote for a black person or a Jewish person before I would an Aetheist mean, I would vote for one of two, out of three who have never served as President of The United States? That was the way I read it. It seems your perspective was quite defensive. Perhaps there are hidden issues?!

by thechas

Oz,

With the exception of JFK, ALL US Presidents have been White Anglo-Saxon Protestants.

(JFK was Catholic)

It is less of a racist statement, than it is a cold reality that it may take a while before the US electorate will vote for a black, woman, or any other so called minority for President.

While neither may happen in our life-times, a black or a woman is MUCH more apt to be elected than an atheist.

Chas

by jimhm

The reason that only one catholic has been elected - - in my op. Is that according to their religon the Pope rules your life. As a catholic (I am not one - but that is my understanding) he is the supereme authority and must be obeyed or you end up in hell or something like that. Same with other religons that requires the followers to submit all decisions to another. There were many worried about the Kennedy's and the catholic church.

by oz_media

That in such an advanced (in our minds anyway) world that we still see this form of racism being practiced by the most respected and influencial people. (Hey you guys just got me saying respected about your government! Am I going soft or becoming American?)

I would LOVE to see someone who is considered a minority take the reins and prove the rest of the nonbelievers wrong.

by onbliss

...I don't know their intentions.
They were not commenting about themselves. They were passing their assessment of the general public. And, those two are nice people with a great deal of common sense and practicality.
They are not racist and were not when they made that comment.

by oz_media

as I said above, I do respect your defense of your friends and think that you have made your point well. I apologize for taking a crack at them as they are not able to defend thier points themselves.

by maxwell edison

A woman will never win the Presidency if she runs as a "woman".

A black (I hate racial labels) will never win the Presidency if he/she runs as a "black".

And on and on.....

I would vote for an one-eyed one-horned flying purple people eater if he/she convinced me that he/she was a person of honesty and integrity, believed in smaller government and taking personal responsibility, realized that lower taxes were not only fair but would increase revenue and spur economic growth, believed that local or individual control of schools was better than the huge federal education department, and believed in a strong defense so that we could continue to expand liberty to those who sought freedom.

There ya' go. I'll vote for the purple.

by Member 32001153

I'm boycotting purple people right now but I mostly agree with your statement. I would vote for the person as to their leadership capabilities, their trustworthiness, their honesty, all of the references made above except I think there should be a federal use tax instead of a federal income tax.

That being said, I would never vote for a known aetheist. I have no faith in someone who believes this all just happened by chance.

by maxwell edison

...lower "income taxes", I just said lower taxes - from whatever source they're derived.

I, too, don't like the tax on income. It's taxing productivity. I believe in the thought that if you tax something (productivity) you get less of it, if you subsidize something (welfare), you get more of it.

Amendment XVI

The Congress shall have power to lay and collect taxes on incomes, from whatever source derived, without apportionment among the several states, and without regard to any census or enumeration.

Amendment XXVIII

Section 1. The sixteenth article of amendment to the Constitution of the United States is hereby repealed.

Section 2. (Insert the new - and fair - system here - in 30 words or less.)

Well, I can dream, can't I?

All of that would make for yet another "off-topic", but interesting, thread.

by oz_media

That no matter WHAT good someone can do for a country, no matter how positive their intentions, no matter how well they can perform their duty, some will always se them as black, Jewish, Purple or whatever.

Even sadder is that this label will almost certainly be implied by the press before it is carried by the people.

by jkaras

Mc Donalds will be pleased for some positive media attention. The ultimate underdog! He's purple, fat, eats unhealthy food, uneducated, and hangs with a strange lot.

by oz_media

I've said before that BUSH should run for mayor of MacDonaldland. Mayor MacBush could probably even catch the Hamburglar and those dreaded fry guys.

With Bush running arounf and trying to free MacDonaldland it would leave plenty of time for a real president with positive leadership qualities to run the country. Perhaps, as you say, Grimace or why not even Ronald himself? Mind you, I guess he's busy running MacDonaldland, maybe BUSH could get a few pointers from him. If you gave all the pissed of Iraqis a Happy Meal they may change their ways.

by jardinier

give you the credit. I can say, for example: "This list was selected by Maxwell Edison, from a much more extensive list."

And thanks for the quote from Carl Sagan. I hope his prediction is correct. Actually I have found that many adults who were raised in the Christian tradition, have dismissed most of the dogma as irrelevant or absurd, while retaining a basic faith in a higher power. As for myself, I don't take much notice of what individuals profess to believe. I have met many very nice atheists, and many very nasty "Christians."

And by the way, I describe myself as an agnostic relativist: agnostic because I don't know, and relativist because this is a school of philosophical thought which accepts that any number of different belief systems may be equally true.

Incidentally I classify atheism as a form of religion because I believe it is just as irrational to disbelieve in something which you can't disprove, as it is to believe in something which you can't prove.

by tomsal

As long as they are qualified, elected on their platform and not scandals, under handed tactics, etc.

I DO want (and except) morality as well as responsibility in our President. The problem I have with the different races and religions of people running this days isn't because they are of that race or color - its because they themselves are racist, bigots, jerks, punks, losers, etc.

Like I say when asked..."are you prejudiced Tom"...my answer is "of course I am...I'm prejudiced against a-holes!" ;)

by oz_media

I agree they are all pobably very kind and considerate people. Sometimes people make a racial slur without intending it to be one.

My point was that to use such a comment as a basis of argument was weak because it was full of holes itself.

No offense to your coworkers and I hope they realize that you go to bat for them in their defense.

by jkaras

the history of religons only faded from existence due to government telling the people which to believe in or practice. Whichever religon you believe in they are always concerned with it's survival spreading the word. Also people need factors justifying who they voting for to feel better about voting on their economic situation. The issues are in my opinion a smoke screen. It's silly to vote upon religion rather than the person that will do the most good. This type of discussion points out just how far we have evolved.
By the way I thought Lieberman is Jewish?
As for Hillary it's sad that she will be the first female president. The only silver lining in that cloud will be seeing ole slick willy holding her handbag in a secondary role reversal. I'm confident that that presidency will revive Saturday Night Live as well as every comedian's career.

by cactus pete

I wish we had the sales tax. The rate of taxation could be different for items classified different ways, and some items would be exempt, of course. But in 30 words or less?

"The Congress shall have power to lay and collect taxes on sales, from whatever source derived, without apportionment among the several states, and without regard to any census or enumeration."

30

by road-dog

Corporate taxes should be abolished, no B2B sales tax, it just gets passed to the consumer anyway. It's a "hidden tax", done under guise of getting rich folks and evil corporations to pay their "fair share".

The national sales tax should exempt $5000 per citizen per year, this paid as a check for 5,000 x percent sales tax, at the end of the year as a reimbursement of the sales taxes paid that year. A family of 4 would have the first 20 grand tax free, so as to eliminate the inevitable "taxing the poor" cries that will result.

After going online, this tax would be difficult to increase, as ALL revenues would be seen by the taxpayer on their receipt. Even a 1 percent increase would be hard to justify.

There would be NO other exemptions, as this is the primary source of political graft, lobbying for favorable tax treatment....

Think about all that grey market money that will find it's way into the treasury, and all those millions of manhours no longer spent on income tax preparation.

by cindy - extraordinary brat

I don't get it? I mean, there would millions of us (NorthAmericans)dead from Anthrax and plane crashes, and nuclear bombs if not for the Bush family.

Could YOU have done a better job?

- and to answer your original question - I would never vote for an atheist, because no matter how moral, loyal, or regal they might be, someone would shoot them.

by oz_media

"I would never vote for an atheist, because no matter how moral, loyal, or regal they might be, someone would shoot them."

As amusingly funny as it may seem, it's probably unfortunately true as well.

" I mean, there would millions of us (NorthAmericans)dead from Anthrax and plane crashes, and nuclear bombs if not for the Bush family. "

I don't believe that for a single second. If anything I feel he is the reason for so many recent attacks on America.

I'm not going to put down your military, they are hard working and brave people who will always have my support as they fight without questioning the political motives, there job isn't to question orders but to follow them, which they do very well.

I will question the person who sends them to die in a foreign land without the needed support that WAS offered. Unforunately BUSH decided that he'd take matters into his own hands and then lok to the rest of the world for support even though he is acting out against the wishes of his allies.

No matter if BUSH had attacked when he did or not, others would have looked further into the issues of concern before declaring war and would surely have seen a reason to rid Iraq of Saddam. He is not the uestion, his methods are not in question, his objectives although not confirmed are still a matter of concern.

This could have been MUCH neater and MUCH quicker with less of an impact on the American economy. Your Allies are just that Allies, not worker bees.
Other troops would have probably supported the effort to rid Iraq of WMD if further evidence was shown. They definitely would have joined to remove Saddam and his regime from power and helped save a few if not MANY American lives. Being in the military yourself, you must be aware of the USA's need for Canada's high speed recon and advanced detection systems.

BUSH being a republican warmonger decided F*&K the rest of the world, if they won't join me, I'll take iraq by force. Soldiers died in a tank ambush due to a lack of front line knowledge that is normally supplied by Canadian troops.

As soon as the initial infiltartion of Baghdad was complete, BUSH then declared an end to agreesive combat to save millions in soldiers pay (nice slap in the face for doing a good job?), now we get people saying the rest of the world has let America down by not joining the effort, I've seen it come from citizens in roadside interviews as well as hearing it on the radio.

The people who have always spouted how America saved the world in WWII are now even more assured of their convictions by feeling that the world (who they saved) has let them down. It's self centered, it's ignorance, it's hatred toward others.

Where did all this stem from? Your President making a rash decision without supoprt from his allies. Why make alliances if you are not going to work with them to achieve a common goal? It's not humane, it's killing people, YOUR people.

I think that is the part that pisses me off the most, you have a country full of extremely loyal citizens, probably MORE loyal than any other country on the globe, you have a choice, join forces and eliminate a threat or kill your troops out of a fear of attack.

Unfortunately YOUR troops died. Now I know that manyt are safe and hope to return home asap, but what about those who didn't, what did they dies for? Did they rid Iraq of WMD? NO. Did they capture this crazed man who is killing his citizens?NO. Have they toppled Saddam from power? YES. Your allies didn't argue this though.

by cindy - extraordinary brat

Cmon now Oz, where are you getting that information? Canadian media? Cnn? Larry King? I really don't feel like you do at all. I think everyone's losses have been minimal due to the war in Iraq and Afghanistan. I don't think it's over either... There's at least 3 more countries to defend immediately, and more terrorists to deal with before this ordeal ends. It'll take 10 more years to finish this - if ever -

All of the world, especially our immediate neighbors should be so thankful for what the Bush men have done for us all. I mean that so wholeheartedly. It took huge balls to take on all the criticism and skepticism to save our countries butts... protect us all... and knowing all the while they'd both loose the presidency possibly - while doing what is best for us. The hippies of Vietnam have united, and are quite loud with theier insults and criticism.. but a lot quieter than they would be if Bush had not moved as masterfully as he did - They'd be screaming HELP! and OHGOD! and THAT BURNS! and HELP ME BURY MY KIDS! and other such things without his bravery.

The liberal media has obviously taken over your brain processes. Do some homework, clear your mind and your heart, forget all you've been told, and listen to the right Right for a day - a whole day - and then tell me how thankful you are that you aren't sitting in a hospital with one leg and anthrax burning your brain, and mad cow disease eating your skin, and unemployed, and a widower. We should all realize just how awful terrorism is to Iraqi citizens, living in it for real for 30 years.. daily, walking to school terrified, hiding all day, watching what you say, hoping for a good meal, praying for your dead children's soul to an unknown god.. I can't imagine the lives they've lead, so used to slavery that it wasn't even scary, while I ponder what color shoes to wear on my way to my cool job, in airconditioning, without shotguns crossing my mind at all.

Egads.. wake up!

by jimhm

Oz - again question why do you care who is the head of the USA when you don't live here. What does it matter to you who heads up our country.

I didn't read any of your posts about Hire Clinton and Serbia when the Clintons went after Solvadan M. I didn't see your hatered of a womanizing - flaming socialist like the Clintons. Why is that - what is the difference between the invasion of Serbia by the Clintons and Bush and Iraq ???

And again - I ask you why do you care about who leads America - You have said in numerous post before you don't care about who leads the US - but then you speak as if you are of Knowledge that even the most informed American has no knowledge.

Why do you care - about our military and the sons and daughters that are willing to server and obey their commander and chief. Why - are you jelous of the strength of the American people, that you don't see in yourself...

I don't expect a open answer from you - that is one for you to ponder on your own. Numerous posts from you - I don't care about the leader of america - or to those words...

You know dude ... you are like a willow in the wind - you sway and bend rather than standing for a position and not wavering ... If you were in the Nam - you would of never made it home .. frag'ed big time..

by oldnavy

Out of any crowd. Got posters of Fidel and Che Guevara in your house don't you! C'mon you can admit it! He He He! I love to see liberals going all cuckoo over a Republican in office.

by cindy - extraordinary brat

A bunch of whiners, whining for the sake of being heard, filling each other up with miniscule data, no big picture, and no repercussions (thank God for our freedom so speech) and just want to ramble in disgust that a few have died. Yes, a few.. minor losses in the eyes of an entire country, a continent, a very realistic possibility with nuclear threats all over the middle East... We give, we give, we protect, we give more.. be grateful for your safety, your freedom, your jobs, your health. Without America, it wouldn't be so good. Without Bush it wouldn't be so comfortable.

I am still suprised at people who don't love their mom's - who gave them birth.
I am still suprised at people who don't worship their God - who gave them life, who shed His blood for you.
I am still suprised at people who don't defend the lives of their brethern, but complain instead, when blood is shed, for all, because it's hard to look at, and you have no control over it, doesn't make it wrong.

We had to go to war -
so you could have a job, a car, a meal, a future, a wife, a family, a haircut, an education - without bullets flying at your head.

by fluxit

First, where do Atheist get thier values? If there were no other God oriented faiths on Earth and just Atheist, where would morals come from? Would it be called morals? How would it be determined what was moral or whose? What about morals involve with the body? These morals do not directly impact others but because private self and public self are inseparable those moral values carry through to public life?

In 1892 in a case heard between The Church of Holy Trinity and the United States Government. The Justices wrote, "These are a religious people. This is a Christian Nation." They then provide a parade of evidence to this effect. A question that eludes me is how the Court can establish a precedent as powerful and compelling as the 1892 ruling then contradict itself about 50 years later in a 1948 ruling declaring the 'Separation of Church and State'. Would the Court not loose credibility? How did the court justify the paradigm shift?

Most Presidents have been religious and most were Christians. Abraham Lincoln stated on many occassions despite being a religious man that he was not a Christian. Then he made the decision to become Christian and intended to proclaim this publicly just before John Wilkes Booth shot him. President Clinton I doubt is a Christian. President Nixon was a Quaker which is a derivation of Christianity. Thomas Jefferson called himself a Christian but was not. George Washington was a Mason.

I am not confident that an Atheist could execute the law in a manner that is consistent with the United States faith based heritage and demonstrate the humility and compassion that is requisite of such a man in that position.

by maxwell edison

1857 - (Dread) Scott versus Sanford

The Supreme Court ruled that slaves were property, not citizens.

Thankfully, later courts reversed the trend.

1972 - Roe versus Wade

Was the Court right in this decision?

Will later courts reverse the trend?

by fluxit

The Court ordinarily acts based on precedence and evidence. The court case in 1892 paraded a litany of evidence to support its decision.

There are other times such as 1948, 1857, 0r 1972 that the opinion appears to be written more on conjecture than precedence. I would have to review those court cases to determine the weight of the evidence in favor of the ruling. I imagine it would be slim.

There are appealing political views that are not necessarily good for society or mankind. However, man in his desire to advance these ideas sometimes overlooks hurtles that are in the way.

Usually when the court reverses its opinion with a new ruling there is some compelling evidence. In many cases that may not have been the whole truth.

by cindy - extraordinary brat

I've been prolife all of my life.. and my kids' lives..

The pro-death advocates that imposed that evil ruling surely will see what comes around... and goes around.. one day in time.

by road-dog

as I am agnostic, faith eludes me (or I elude faith). I feel that abortion is wrong, but from a secular viewpoint. Secularly, abortion is wrong because murder is both wrong and illegal for the good order of society.

No person can make a determination as to which lives should be allowed and which are not. Otherwise, where is the point where killing is acceptable or not? age minus 6 months, or 100 years, or anywhere in between?

Life must be protected, if we do not in the case of the unborn, then we have no reason that murder of an adult should be prohibited.

THE FOLLOWING IS A REQUEST FOR INFORMATION, NOT AN ATTACK ON FAITH, please answer it in the spirit with which it is intended.

As for the biblical stance, as I understand it, God hates all sin. This being the qualifier, then the religious right's stand on abortion is solid under the 6th Commandment.

OK, All sins being equal (under God), then shouldn't working on Sunday be illegal also, to force compliance with the 4th Commandment?

My question (it is indeed a question):
Those who wish to illegalize abortion in keeping with their beliefs and to avoid being complicit in sin, are they not still complicit in sin by not pushing for a law against working on the sabbath?

How does one reconcile the two? A rational mind distinguishes between the two as murder being a "big" sin and working on the sabbath less so.

Christians apply an intense amount of spiritual force toward ending abortion, yet nearly none on protecting the sabbath(other than a few blue laws here and there). Where does it end, and why? Where do Christians draw the line of using law to enforce scripture?

by dstatic8

Not everyone that have good values, morals and ethics are religious...That person should come to Guyana where i live...and see.

But you guys have it good over there...Your president is a Godly man...But in our country ours is not a Godly man...

He thinks nothing about God...I guess we`ll have to pray for him....

Cheers...dstatic

by oz_media

"The hippies of Vietnam have united, and are quite loud with theier insults and criticism.. but a lot quieter than they would be if Bush had not moved as masterfully as he did - They'd be screaming HELP! and OHGOD! and THAT BURNS! and HELP ME BURY MY KIDS! and other such things without his bravery."

Very uh, how should I say....DRAMATIC!

" forget all you've been told, and listen to the right Right for a day "
-Here we go again, with the "MY political stand is correct" crap. This is a discussion forum not a right wings-r-us debate. You see, popular to cintrary belief, your political beliegs are different from others, no kidding! There are actually people who don't like the Repubicsn agenda and sactions! Go figure, not EVERYONE thinks as you do, huh.

"The liberal media has obviously taken over your brain processes. "

And yours has taken over yours, are you implying there's a difference between YOUR political beliefs and mine that proves YOU are right? I didn't think so.

"I can't imagine the lives they've lead,..."

http://tinyurl.com/t6t2,
http://tinyurl.com/t6t6,
{From the 1880s onward, however, mob violence increasingly reflected white America's contempt for various racial, ethnic, and cultural groups. African-Americans especially, and sometimes Native Americans, Latinos, Jews, Asian immigrants, and European newcomers, felt the mob's fury.}

"...so used to slavery that it wasn't even scary, while I ponder what color shoes to wear on my way to my cool job, in airconditioning, without shotguns crossing my mind at all."

Can you imagine how any country could treat people this way!

Saddam's repression of the Iraqi people and the need to remove SADDAM was not in question, never was, never will be.

Saddam's ability to launch a trans-Altantic missile attack on the USA is, I don't think you've given him those weapons yet.

Right wing (to me) = FEAR, fear of your opponent, fear of color, fear of difference, fear of non-conformity.

This is MY opinion, NOT one that you have to believe, but one that 'discussion' welcomes.

I listen to everyone else's rants about how America is envied by all other countries, how everyone in the world wants to live in the USA. Yet I know MANY people who COULD live in he USA if they chose to (including me) but chose NOT to. So how does that fit? Yet if I speak MY mind, MY opinions are instantly shot down by some gun toting Republican who thinks he/she has it all figured out. Well, why am I still alive? (and don't for one minute think it's because of America, that's why your attitudes aren't too popular in other places).

by oz_media

You say how you read my posts yet yuo ask a redundant question.

One more time for the slow guy,
I don't care WHO runs your country. I don't care WHERE you decide to look strong.
I don't care about America at all, it wouldn't exist if I had my way. HAPPY?

NOW:
YOUR PRESIDENT IS IN MY FACE ALL DAY BY MONOPOLIZING THE NEWS, RADIO, NEWSPAPERS and those horrible Presidential addresses! It is in MY face so I am in YOURS! I hope you don't see this as NOT answering your question again, otherwise it's back to school for you !

YOUR president asked for help from the other supposedly allied forces injoining the US in their attck on Iraq.
His motives (stated quite clearly as ridding Iraq of WMD)and confirmed by Cindy ...

"They'd be screaming HELP! and OHGOD! and THAT BURNS! and HELP ME BURY MY KIDS! and other such things without his bravery." ( I love that one!)

were questioned by the other supposedly allied forces and they refused to take hasty action AT THAT TIME.

Bush's sources, still questionable and argued by many, convinced him that WMD existed, then denied saying it but that's just politics. BUSH then decided to be the world's saviour once again and show the people of America that he wouldn't tolerate the FEAR instilled (by BUSH and themedia)on the American public and decided to SAVE the free people once again.

He did it without the needed forces and people perished because of it. YOUR people.

Now, if he could stay out of MY face, I'd stay out of YOURS. Unfortunately, Americans MUST be heard, they MUSt go to other countries and wave their flag and people don't like ti, so it is just a matter of time before i call your NEXT president an idiot for repeating the same.

by fluxit

All sins being equal (under God), then shouldn't working on Sunday be illegal also, to force compliance with the 4th Commandment?

You are referring to exodus 20:8-11 "Remember the sabbath day, to keep it holy. Six days you shall labor, and do all your work; but the seventh day is a sabbath to the LORD your God; in it you shall not do any work, you, or your son, or your daughter, your manservant, or your maidservant, or your cattle, or the sojourner who is within your gates; for in six days the LORD made heaven and earth, the sea, and all that is in them, and rested the seventh day; therefore the LORD blessed the sabbath day and hallowed it. "

The Biblical definition of work often relates to the sequence in which Faith leads to salvation which in turn leads to good work.

Please refer to Matthew 12: The Pharisee's were upset with Jesus and the Disciples for working on the Sabbath. The point Christ makes is that life calls us to work on the Sabbath from time-to-time when the work is for good. Matt 12:11-12. In Matt 12:33-35, Christ goes on to point out that man's work is either evil or good based on how he fills his heart. Good work is for the Lord.

Christ also points out that rules or laws of man are not always in keeping with the Holy Spirit. Additionally, Christ dying on the cross makes it possible for humans to achieve the glory of heaven through Faith or trust.

Those who wish to illegalize abortion in keeping with their beliefs and to avoid being complicit in sin, are they not still complicit in sin by not pushing for a law against working on the sabbath?

First off all humans are complicit in sin. It is how one deals with sin that is important. Recognize that you are a sinner. Ask for Forgiveness. Then work to be a new kind of creature. Some call this being 'Born Again' since that was the term Christ used. It is the transformation step.

Your thought process that it is hypocritical for Christians to insist on the right to life is incorrect. I addressed the working on Sabbath issue already. I would say that if working on the Sabbath was for the Lord then by all means put your heart and soul into it.

How does one reconcile the two? I believe I answered that already.

Where do Christians draw the line of using law to enforce scripture? James Madison (a forefather) remarked, "We have staked the whole future of American civiliazation, not upon the power of Government, but upon the capacity of each and all of us to govern ourselves according to the 10 commandments." Isaiah 33:22 is where the Separation of Powers came from to balance Government. As well as the earlier comments point towards methods of prudence.

by road-dog

So this Commandment doesn't mean don't work. I have heard all my life that this was not just a "day of rest and introspection". I see your point.

My question remains. Where does the enforcement of scripture by law end?

Were say, the King James version of the bible used as the model, what interpretation would be used. I suspect that most secularists (like me) have a problem with is that if religion were made law, even if enacted via valid democratic means, then the battles over interpretation would continue. That nut David Koresh read the same bible as many of us, and you wouldn't think it was the same book.

Also, isn't forced virtue false? If one doesn't get an abortion because it is illegal, but would if it were, then that is not virtue.

I guess my point is that I don't see enacting law by the prevailing interpretation of the bible, as being a valid way of paving folk's way to heaven.

Also, I'd really hate to see laws enacted on the more "out there" interpretations of scripture. If the Pentacostals got hold of the Legislative branch, then my wife's great fitting jeans would probably be outlawed....

by fluxit

First off wayward interpretations of the scriptures has been around as long as the scriptures. In the Seven Letters to the Seven Churchs found in Revelation, there are varying degrees of right and wrong. Seven being significant because it means complete or all the Churches. In Revelation its also discusses that Jesus stands amongst the Seven lampstands. Once again seven meaning complete and lampstand is significant because it is symbolic of the church. The meaning of that phrase is generally accepted as meaning Christ is in all the churches of which there are varying degrees of right and wrong. God also gives a warning to those who take away or add to his word - the Bible. Rev 22.

The only way to be as accurate as possible is to thoroughly study the scriptures, history, and our world. Most Theologians do not have incredibly different interpretations of the Judeo/Christian Bible except for minor minutia or details of which most do not have an impact on the message at all. More importantly, it is each persons responsibility to study and learn for themselves. We have the gift of knowledge and choice. Use it prudently because misguided efforts result in God taking away your share in Heaven.

2 Corinthians; 'Where the spirit of the Lord is, there is Liberty.' The United States Government was designed to be a nation for a religious people and as a Christian nation. This is undeniable when a full study of the US founding is made. They also designed it to be polymorphic that allows society to shape itself with some checks and balances in place. So through participation in Government (voting, public service, and lobbying) laws can be passed to manage society with civility.

The US Judicial system, itself, is founded on the 10 commandments and the principle that all men are created equal so that no man is above of the law, Acts 10:34 that states that God is no respecter of persons above others.

The forefathers of this great nation, 'The United States of America', built a nation on Faith and the Bible. They place a TRUST in God. It is an inseparable part of not only our heritage but our future. The only reason the United States is great and has not fallen to the wayside as so many others is because of our TRUST in God and our alliance with his people, the Jewish.

You remarked that you are agnostic. Did you see the news report from Scripts Ranch in San Diego? Every home, 2100 homes, were destroyed by fire except one. On his fax machine was a message - 'God Bless this House' No flame damage touched the home. Granted he replaced the roof recently but San Diego law requires the same roof on every home. If that is not a testament to God then you have made your choices and refuse to acknowledge anything else.

We are without a doubt a moral nation founded on the principles in the Judeo/Christian Bible. Contrast the United States success with that of a nation built on Islam. May God continue to be with the United States.

by fluxit

"Christians apply an intense amount of spiritual force toward ending abortion, yet nearly none on protecting the sabbath (other than a few blue laws here and there)."

Christians who violently oppose abortion by bombing clinics and killing doctors mis-understand the scriptures and/or use them to justify thier misguided efforts. It is not Christian values inwork.

Likewise, jewish people who conduct acts of terror by blowing up an occupied plateau to build a temple are not acting out thier faith and are misguided as well.

However, these should not be confused with people who commit terror in the name of some other religions when the pure and honest practice of the other religions makes calls to conduct hostile activities against non-believers and even believers should they not adequately comply.

I wanted to address this issue because there are many who are attempting to make equivalencies of this. THERE IS NO EQUIVALANCY.

by mrbill-

Sunday is not the Sabbath. Saturday is the true Sabbath. The Jewish people have been tracking the calendar longer than the Christians and they maintain it is Saturday. The Christians met on the first day of the week, Sunday.

by john_wills

If we say that Ancestral Judaism split into Christianity and RabbInical Judaism when the Christians left Jerusalem in 70 CE, then Christians and Rabbinical Jews have been tracking the calendar equally long. If we say that the two new churches were founded at the Councils of Jerusalem in 50 CE and Jamnia in 90 CE respectively, then Christians have been tracking it longer. But Mr Bill is right enough: in Spanish, and some other languages commonly used by Christians, the name of the 7th day is "sabado" or something similar. Christians have done that tracking. The first day is the Lord's Day, "domingo", from the Latin "dominus", menaing lord. But Christians by and large think the command to hallow the Sabbath now applies to the Lord's Day.

by fluxit

message. As the firestorm was bearing down on his neighborhood, the owner faxed a document. The recieving party, not God, faxed back, 'God Bless this House'.

I lived in Southern California. Those firestorms with some wind can travel at 42+ KMH with a 20 Meter+ wall of flames. This man and his family probably got a only a short notice to evacute based on the fires path and trajectory.

I find it fascinating that this natural force caused by natural events - naturally burned everything but 1 home? Perhaps it was more supernatural at that point.

by av .

Religion and politics don't mix. Everyone is entitled to their own beliefs and it shouldn't be a part of government. If someone is an atheist, that is their choice. Its not my choice, but if they can do a better job than someone else, I'm not going to hold that against them.

When I vote, I look for the person that can best serve the interests of the people. I research their voting records and affiliations. I look at their track records.

If a candidate is black, jewish or atheist it doesn't affect their ability to do the job. I can't judge them on who they are and I don't care. I care if they can do the job.

by fluxit

How do you reconcile that there is no separation between one's personal, professional, private, and public life?

How do reconcile the infusion of personal values into government when laws are enacted? For example, someone who thinks that fellatio is by someone outside of a marriage is not cheating on the spouse? Or for that matter that fellatio is morally okay? Afterall it does not hurt anyone? Then that individual in public office is required to sign or sponsor a bill supporting marriage values. What kind of values will this person purvey? Will the values be principled or a standard that we all aspire to achieve. Where would those values come from?

Does this individual's values impact his ability to do the job? It is an affiliation that this individual is endorsing by the action.

by av .

Public life is an image. Private life is more true to the individual. Someone may be great publicly, but fail miserably in private life. There is a separation between public and private lives - its 2 different things.

Do you really know your neighbor or co-worker?

I really am offended by the rest of your email. Specifically, your reference to fellatio. I don't think this is the forum for it.

by jimhm

Maybe that guys house was build differently then his neighbors homes. Like that community (forget the name) where it every home was built to NFPA wild life fire standards... Stucko - Tilted roofs - tripled glazed windows ... not following the greenie weenies laws about planets and following the NFPA...

Not one home burnt - where in another commuity lost 99% of the homes... that followed the Calf greenie laws...

I would say - it could of been construction methods used - as well as a little prayer ...

by john_wills

According to this rather interesting website, there are 20 members of Congress who call themselves "Jew" and 20 who call themselves "Catholic", rather a different proportion from that in the citizenry. On the other hand the pro-life movement is dominated by Catholic women, who drag their KC-begarbed husbands along to demonstrations, so we can't say Catholics aren't interested in public affairs. But it is conceivable that there is something in electoral politics which Catholics tend to see as nasty and to avoid. It is noticeable that prominent U.S. Catholic politicians - e.g. Ted Kennedy, Gray Davis - seem to embrace the nastiness of politics, so perhaps other Catholics are avoiding temptation.

by john_wills

Taxing luxuries more is a good way to keep things luxuries which might otherwise become commonplace. Indirect taxation, like Europe's VAT, hurts the poor especially, and governments then decide they "have to" increase the tax rates to afford larger welfare payments, whereas a progressive income tax, especially with the U.S.'s clever "earned income credit" or negative income tax for the lowest earners, keeps the hierarchy of wealth by work while allowing the overall tax burden to be lower for the same general welfare.

by john_wills

What does Mr Miami mean by a U.S. alliance with God's people, the Jews? At the beginning of the Common Era the Ancestral Jewish Church split: the majority became Christian, perhaps defined at the Council of Jerusalem (Ac 16) ca. 50 CE; a significant minority became Rabbinical Jewish, defined at the Council of Jamnia ca. 90 CE. I get the impression that Mr Miami is a Christian, so presumably he thinks Christians to be God's people, the Rabbinical Jews being an errant sidetrack. What kind of alliance should the U.S. have with Christianity? A special relationship with the Holy See?

by oz_media

I'm a Liberal now, last month I was a socialist. Perhaps next week I'll be tagged as a democrat or republican!

We had a discussion about this before. How Americans must place a political tag top everyone they meet in order to form an opinion of ones character.

Fortunately, I'm in Canada and couldn't give a toss about politics or what party I'm associated with. Nobody else really cares either.

this is the big difference between OUR political views and yours. Politics don't matter when you're busy living your life. In a society where your political stand builds your personality, it is easy to be blind to the actions of your politicians. You get so wrapped up in what party is speaking you seem to forget to look outside the box and see through the political bull that ALL politicians feed the public.

Perhaps why there is more coverage of American politics on TV than Canadian, it seems to be important to you.

by oldnavy

Oh please!!! All your rants are obviously political (war-mongering Republican) but you are Canadian so you are above it all? You can whine all you want, and try and fool yourself, but you ain't fool? in me bub! You Canadians always like to bash The greatest nation that has ever existed on this planet in all of history, because your country has never done anything of any value whatsoever. This country doesn't need the rest of the world for squat. Just work at keeping up with us OK.

by john_wills

Aristotle no doubt had a religion, but he developed morality separately. Thomas Aquinas, the greatest Christian theologian, certainly did believe in God, and certainly thought morality derived from God, but used Aristotle's techniques for deciding what morality actually was. What Israel had been teaching all along quasi-experimentally confirmed Thomas' arguments. The purpose of speech is to convey truth; it is therefore unnatural, or sinful, to lie: that is essentially the kind of argument used in natural-law theory.

by fluxit

What is truth? How does one determine what a truth is? Is my truth your truth?

by john_wills

You are misusing the word "truth". In the specific instance, you know when you are lying, so there is no problem. I have a note somewhere of Thomas Merton's multiple definition of "truth", and it might be quite valuable elsewhere, but it would really not help you in this matter because you are being deliberately obtuse.

by onbliss

...and it can not vary from one person to other. So your truth and my truth would be the same.

by onbliss

...comes from us. You can say it originates from established values of right and wrong. Comes from our thoughts.

by fluxit

"The purpose of speech is to convey truth." "You are misusing the word 'truth'." "you are being deliberately obtuse."

I am seeking to understand you and the origin of truth without me influencing or steering your comments. This begs of simple questions. I was listening.

But if I must...

Truth has many definitions. Humantically it could mean a statement proven to be or accepted as timeless, theoretical, or static often founded in fact. Biblically one meaning is that which is considered to be the supreme reality, to have the ultimate meaning, and value of existence.

I ask you who's truth do we employ? You suggest a morally nuetral universe. One in which human want and desire cause inequilibrium and results in pain and suffering. Therefore, society desires to correct this and bring it back to an equilibrium state. But then this raises the question of where did the original ground state for truth come from?

Other questions are raised about self-awareness, free will, and greed? These are not natural forces like wind and surging tides? They originate from a consciousness not a physical system.

How do you reconcile this in relation to your model of truth?

by jimhm

They make a good Beer - Ah ... Have Cheap Drug Store websites - Take a load of our dead beats and keep them - keep some of our crimials that are facing the death penitly ...

Hey they also are Keeping OzMentalCase - on Prozac and Haldol and some other physic drugs... but sometimes I don't think it working ...

by oz_media

"It isn't that they have a religon - it is that they don't believe in a superior being - that gave them the rights they enjoy."

Your statement equates someone having a belief in a higher being being apt to run a country.
One that does not have faith in an unknown, unseen being isn't suitable to run your country?

" don't believe that an Atheist would make a good leader. I don't believe they would have integrity, morals, values or ethics."

So in order to become a stable and suitable leader, you MUST believe in some higher being that miraculously CREATED the Earth and all upon it?

So to repeat myself for YOUR clarity:
"..now you can associate a persons religion with their political stand!"

I know you guys couldn't survive two days without politics to discuss and leaders to praise.
You guys see a persons political stand BEFORE even hearing their name, it's ridiculous! Almosy like how dogs sniff each others butt when they first meet, "Woof...Are you a Democrat? If so, I'll bite you"

A question to you or anyone with a decent answer; What the difference does someones political preference make when it comes to judging someones character and personality??

by oz_media

"You Canadians always like to bash The greatest nation that has ever existed on this planet in all of history, because your country has never done anything of any value whatsoever."

Duh, no wonder I see Americans as arrogant morons!

The greates nation that has ever existed on this planet! LOL

by john_wills

The United States is not actually a nation but a multinational or polyethnic citizenry. Attempts to make this citizenry a single nation are as likely to be successful as the now abandoned attempts to make the many nations of South Africa many citizenries.

by oz_media

You can't expect me to think you believe this right?
"The greatest nation that has ever existed on this planet in all of history, because your country has never done anything of any value whatsoever." LOL

What a freak! That's almost worth putting up as a poster to describe the American attitude!
You are definitely either completely retarded and have NO idea or you simply learned that fancy book schooling and think you're right. The latter scares the hell out of me!

When I've made statements saying Americans feel this way, I have often been told that's crap and Americans don't think they saved the world. Now I have proof that you're mentality is that of a cardboard box.

by oz_media

You say that America is the greatest country to ever exist on this planet and that Canada has contributed nothing.

I'll accept your idiocy, if YOU can back it with facts.

Show me where America has benefitted me and my family. Then show me how Canada has NOT contributed to mankind. We'll leave out the Canadarm on all of YOUR space shuttles just to be fair, forget we made it. As for Canada's Coyote recon vehicles that you rely on in times of war, we'll forget they exist too just to make it easier for you.

NO wonder your president decided to take matters into his own hands, noone else would be dumb enough. Your troops have died because others didn't join you, does that not make you realize that you NEED your Allies in times of war due to your own military deficiencies?

What a nutter!

by oz_media

Without intending to start a rant,

"One of Condie's main problems is she is single, the voters like a married canidate, more stable. Or at least percived to be."

This doesn't seem to be YOUR views but those of the general boting public.

Does it make any sense as to why? I'm not saying Canadians are or aren't the same, just that the concept is completely nutty.

by bjbrn

Agnostic and Humanistic views of morality and ethics make a place for religious conviction. The problem with the Atheist approach is that it denies the validity of religious conviction. In that sense, it's no less intolerant than any of the ultra-right religious crazies. Most people have spiritual experiences. The average person is no more comfortable with an atheist telling him those personal experiences are nonsense she is with some Ayatollah telling her she's a satinist because she won't cover her head in public.

If you had asked the question, would Americans prefer an athiest or an ultra-right religious conservative or a black panther, the answer might have been different. We're begining to understand that fanatics are all dangerous.

by onbliss

..on this. Infact I did not ask any question in particular. We were just talking generally about beliefs, faiths...

I agree an aethist fanatic is as danerous as an ultra-religious fanatic. Oh yeah...I know few aethists who are highly intolerant of religious people.