Discussion Locked

An Aussie viewpoint on American politics.

0 helpful
24 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

The author of this article, Phillip Adams, is highly respected down under especially for his role in promoting the Australian film industry, and also as a commentator on current affairs.

I find it interesting that, while being a lifetime
avowed atheist, his personal "faith" does not colour his comments.

I was especially intrigued by Carter's comments on pro-lifers, in the last paragraph.

Over to you, guys and gals.

"When I was a boy I was told that anybody could become president; I'm beginning to believe it." ? Clarence Darrow (US defence lawyer, 1857-1938)
"Extremism in the pursuit of the presidency is an unpardonable vice. Moderation in the affairs of a nation is the highest virtue." ? Lyndon B. Johnson.

WE'RE deep in the dark ages of the worst presidency in US history. There have been some great fools in the oval office, but George Bush Jr has wrested the joker's hat from their heads and, in a strutting, jaw-thrusting performance not so much reminiscent of that pugnacious Republican Theodore Roosevelt as of Benito Mussolini, he has scrapped his nation's diplomatic traditions and cost it its international friends.

Jerry Brown, who preceded Ronald Reagan and Arnold Schwarzenegger as governor of California, entered the presidential race in 1976. Two years later, he said: "People want a dictator these days, a man on a white horse . . . a politician can do anything as long as he manipulates the right symbols."

Arriving on his white horse from Texas, Bush was soon the man on the grey aircraft carrier, wearing the US Air Force jumpsuit, claiming final victory in a war that had hardly begun. With the unpardonable vice defined by LBJ, he's got everything wrong, but manipulates those right symbols ? the trinity of God, flag and power.

Now one looks back at mediocre presidencies with renewed respect. At Eisenhower, who knew enough of wars to keep the US out of them, and who left the White House warning of the dangers of America's "military-industrial complex". And at the hapless Jimmy Carter, who has redeemed his White House years with his ongoing role in public life.

Carter lacked Bush's ability to do Benito impersonations on television. He lacked Bush's skill in lying. Unlike Bush, Carter wasn't backed by the traditional vested interests. He wasn't bankrolled by the wealthiest corporations. He came from peanut oil, not Saudi oil, or Texaco's. Modest and moderate, he was brought down by a single military misadventure ? an inept raid to release US hostages in Iran ? whereas Bush was re-elected despite responsibility for the greatest military folly since Vietnam, a war that has resulted in tens of thousands of American and hundreds of thousands of Iraqi casualties.

Carter's greatest failing? He was an unlucky politician. Devoid of Bush's theatricality, he hadn't the cheek, charm and charisma of another governor of another southern state. Carter was no Bill Clinton who could, like Bush, lie through his teeth. And when Clinton's gift for deception on personal matters was no longer enough (it worked with Gennifer Flowers only to fail with Monica Lewinsky) he could talk his way out of trouble with an acting skill not even Reagan could rival. Apart from his bad luck, it was Carter's candour that killed him.

Because of two public admissions, he was seen as a religious nutter. A Baptist, he agreed he was "born again" (quoting basic doctrine from John 3:5) and confessed to a Playboy interviewer that, yes, he had "committed adultery in [his] heart many times", a reference to Matthew 5:28. That was about it. He'd made a decision never to bring up religion in the campaign but "had to answer reporters or be criticised for dodging the issue".

My favourite US commentator, the Roman Catholic scholar and philosopher Garry Wills, has followed Carter's career since 1972 and defends the man in an essay in the New York Review of Books: "His attendance at church was not announced; we reporters had to ferret that out ourselves. Carter is an old-fashioned Baptist . . . the firmest believer in the separation of church and state. Unlike most if not all modern presidents, he never had a prayer service in the White House. His problem, back then, was not that he paraded his belief but that he believed. All this can be seen as quaint now when professing religious belief is practically a political necessity, whether one believes or not. There is now an inverse proportion between religiosity and sincerity."

Now, at a time when religion and hard-right politics are hand in claw in many a country and culture, where it's a major issue in the US and increasingly in Australia, Carter has published Our Endangered Values: America's Moral Crisis (Simon & Schuster). A stern admonishment to those of his faith who've surrendered their moral autonomy to powerful and reactionary church leaders, Carter's book attacks a new fundamentalism that embraces self-righteousness, rigidity and compulsion ? in marked contrast to what Carter sees as the teachings of Jesus.

Carter reaches his crescendo in an analysis of the so-called "pro-life" movement, whom he sees as pro-death in their cruel policies regarding everything from AIDS in Africa to the death penalty and foreign policy. And he apportions blame to "pro-life" on abortion itself, for opposing family planning, sex education and the use of condoms. I hope to be talking to Carter in the next few days and will report back. In the meantime, dear Christians, read the book.

24 replies

by deadly ernest

Some good points here but I think some major ones have been missed. First I admit that I have NOT seen the stats for the last few elections but I remember seeing an interesting article on USA Presidential elections about 10 years back.

Point 1. The most important point for me was that the electorate seemed to be totally complacent and not interested - average turn out being about 10% of those eligible to vote with about half the population being uneligible to vote due to criminal record or underage or mental health etc.

In some elections the percentage is lower, a few a bit higher. The article went on to say that about 80% of people who do vote are permanently committed to one party or the other before the election race starts. That means that the final decision on the presidency is decided by less than 1% of the population, on average. And the electoral college system can reduce this further.

Is it any wonder that things can be so easily manipulated and controlled. Then the mud slinging style of the election makes it even crazier.

Add into the mix that a lot of presidents are more interested in maintaining office until their third term - you don't see them tackling any real issues in the first two terms if they can defer them. And then some get left as too hard - leave for the next guy.

Point 2. Duing Carter's time I felt he was more a statesman than a president - he played a more concilitory role on the international scene. But then the times were different and the public attitude was different. That makes it very hard to compare with the current administration.

Point 3. For the first time in 200 years the general public in the USA are frightened and running around with their sanity and emotional heads cut off.

Add these three points together and you can see the why's of the curent administration's attitude and what is happening. Then the military industrial complex money men and the warhawks in the Pentagon add to the mix. Boy am I glad I am not in the USA, it could get ugly if not handled right and the mix is like nitro - likely to go boom at the slightest bump or may not, too unknown.

- - - -

Re the abortion issue - I am not going to take a pro-life or abortion stance. But I will say this much. Anyone who claims that you must pass anti-abortion laws because it is against Christian doctrine is a bloody liar and not a true Christian.

Christ taught that God gave us free choice - the right to choose to do what was right o wrong in God's eyes; and God will hold us to account for our actions. Christ also taught that each of us had the right to ask God for help and advice and that God would provide it in God's time. Christ taught that you should be considerate of others and that you should never judge them.

No one has the right to put themselves above God and say 'You should do this or not do that because that is what God wants.' If God wanted to stop a particular abortion God would instruct the person not to go through with it - end of story.

So if you are pro-life you should be saying 'I don't like this.' not 'God does not like it.'

Another point is in Matthew 22: 36 - 40. For a true Christian there are only two commandments - the Ten Commandments of Moses are a topical guide as they are pat of the law that was completed and closed with the appearance of the Saviour. Christ's crucifiction ended those laws. Thus those laws can no longer be used as a scriptural arguement on this issue.

God gives us each the right to choose - then let the people choose. And do not judge them as many appear to do.

by jardinier

American presidents are only permitted two terms.

Their electoral system is crazy and as you have no doubt figured out, it has degenerated to the point where only very wealthy people are considered as candidates.

Much as I dislike John Howard and everything he has done (or undone) I much prefer the Australian system to the American one.

Thanks for taking the time to post, and for your balanced views on Christianity. The American evangelicals are fanatical ratbags.

Julian

by deadly ernest

I know their first term is usually solely focussed on getting re-elected, and I thought they had a legal maximum of three terms. My apologies for the error.

I do prefer the USA system of the election on a set weekend every four years and would love to see it emulated here. Sadly when that was recommended to Bob Hawke and Paul Keating by their great, and expensive, Constitution review committee - they, and the ALP Caucus, refused to put that to the public. But did put to extend from sometime in three years to sometime in four years - got knocked back. Bob Hawke was lucky to go two years between elections. He did a lot of god things and some bad things - ike most PMs. I would also like to see the PM elected seperately - stand and take your chance sonny, all or nothing.

Although our system could do with some tweaking (as per above and others) it is vastly better than the USA system. I would like to see members forced to see out their term when elected or forced to pay for the by-election themselves; too many quit part way through because the spit the dummy when they don't get their preferred ministerial appointment or similar.

Re John Howard, I agree with some of what he has done and disagree with others. However, the really frightening thing about Howard is that he is a much better choice than what has been offered by the ALP since Hawke got pushed out by Keating and fraction in fighting. If you think Howard may have screwed things up, just image what Beazley would have done - this is the same guy who, as Defence Minister, spent many millions on spcific hardware that was not wanted by the services. The only thing they had in common was that the made good press news for Beazley. He also signed off on an agreement to lay off several hundred defence personnel (mostly civilians) when a certain restructuing program he initiated finished - then, several years later, when the program finished and the dept laid them off - he started abusing Howard for cutting back on defence civilain staff numbers - and yes he was fully briefed before hand.

The ALP has not offered a decent alternative government since Hawke left, but they do offer a strong opposition - opposition to everything regardless of what good it will do. They oppose the good moves along with the bad, and that makes them look just silly. Especially when Howard introduces changes that were originally ALP policy, the item suddenly goes from being good to being bad, great thinking.

My best judge on this is - that I am, overall, better off now than I was in 1992 to 1995.

BTW I think they should have split Telstra to retail and infrastructure then sold the retail end while keeping the infrastructure bit.

Re the point on Christianity - true Christians believe that Jesus is the Christ, the Saviour, the Lamb of God who was the living sacrifice to close out the old law. That being so his teachings replace everything in the old testament and they are of a higher order than the epistles and things written by others. Christians follow the teachings of Christ. He taught love and tolerance - "let he who is without sin caste the first stone". Why, oh why do so many still believe in the concept of 'original sin' and an 'eye for an eye', yet claim to be Christian.

by tonythetiger

A couple of things.

It's bad but not that bad. 10% is kinda low. The lowest I remember was in the 30s I think. Also, Mental health? Unless you are committed to an assylum, mental health is not a bar to voting (or was that too obvious :)). And of course, we do not allow children to vote.

If "80%" were committed to one party or the other, Republicans would never win a national election. Many people jump the fence one way or the other because the candidate for their team is too extreme. Most "people" are at least somewhat liberal in their personal beliefs, but wouldn't necessarily want their government run that way.

While the US follows many democratic principles, the fact is, it is *not* a democracy, but a representative Republic. A fact that even many of its own citizens either do not know, or do not understand the significance of. Pure democracy doesn't work well, and is completely dis-interested in the rights of those who are not in the majority.

It's not easy being the United States sometimes. The individual states are like separate countries in some ways, each with their own laws and to some extent soveriegnty, but with many things in common too. It would be like if France and Spain and Germany and other 'states'were to join together and... Oh wait, they did, din't they?

And....

"No one has the right to put themselves above God and say 'You should do this or not do that because that is what God wants.' If God wanted to stop a particular abortion God would instruct the person not to go through with it - end of story."

Hmmm. So if God wanted to stop a murder, or a bank robbery, He would instruct the person not to do go through with it and since he didn't he must have wanted it so the law should not punish those who do it? (that could also open up a can of worms at trial, with all the "God told me to do it" defenses).

"God gives us each the right to choose - then let the people choose. And do not judge them as many appear to do."

Sorry, we're not perfect... we do judge ... God will forgive us for that too.

by deadly ernest

Those in assylums are not allowed to vote and my udnerstanding, from correspondence with USA health care workers, is that some people under treatment in the community are also not allowed to vote due to their conditions.

About 80% of voters are committed to one party or the other, it emans that 80% of the votes are not going to vote for the other party. The split may be 40% for each party or 38%/42% whatever. Just that the experts had done surveys and polls and find that about 80% of those who voted had voted for THEIR party and will always vote that way.

God gave us free agency and we can choose to do as we wish. The point I was making was that people who claim they want certain laws because it is what God wants are people who are full of bullshit and trying to make laws on what THEY want but ascibing it to God in order to give it some authority as they have none.

by jardinier

Hi Deadly

If you wish to discuss these issues further, it would be best to contact me directly. Send a message through the peer directory and we can take it from there.

I don't know why there has been no response from Americans to this post, because I know that a lot of American TR members would agree in principle with what Phillip Adams has said.

As a member of the Labor Party I am horrified at the mess they are in. I am sorry that Mark Latham became ill, but he has since demonstrated that he was not suitable for the position of Prime Minister.

Now if I could only go back into the past and change things. Mark won the leadership ballot by only one vote. If Beasley had won, and subsequently lost three elections in a row, he would be out of the picture. His performance in this current term is pathetic.

I think Julia Gillard would be the best choice as leader because, apart from her excellent performance on the floor of the House, she would be the first female leader of a major party and would presumably draw a lot of votes from women.

There is a plus and a minus to the US system. If you get a really good president, he can only remain in office for 8 years. If you get a bad one who keeps his fly zipped up (or lies about it), he can scrape into a second term and create havoc.

I fully agree with your view on the current opposition.

As for American evangelical Christians, I am quite familiar with this breed of animal. I have been participating in discussions at two websites:

http://www.meetchristians.com

http://christianmingle.com

They are absolutely fanatical and at meetchristians especially, they spend as much time exchanging rude insults as they do addressing the topic.

Membership of meetchristians is free, so you may feel like checking it out for yourself.

Julian

by cubeslave

One reason no American's have responded is simply because of when the post went up. I happened to see it a few minutes ago, the date I saw on it was the 25th, a Saturday. You may get a few more responses once people come in Monday morning. Remember, most of the US is UTC -5 to UTC -8.

Since I know nothing about the Australian system (or Parliamentary Democracy in general) I can?t say which is a better system.

I agree that we need a more informed, educated and responsible electorate than we currently have in the US, but I don?t think either major party (especially the one in power) really wants that. There is no way to tell what would happen if the mainstream electorate started making educated decisions for themselves.

One item from an earlier message that I only wish was true is that our elections happen over a weekend. Although regularly scheduled, elections are only one day events, and they never happen on weekends. The fact that the polls should be open longer and on weekends (when people can get to them) keeps getting brought up, but nothing ever comes of it.

I and many others wonder what would have happened is the Highly contested election in 2000 had been decided the other way. Since the other party would still be in control of congress there would have definitely been some election reform. On the other hand, if the state of Florida (the state that caused the problems in 2000) were a third world country, the US and UN would have started monitoring elections there a long time ago.

As for the religious observations, I will agree with you. Many of those who wave the banner or Christianity the most visibly seem to be doing so for political reasons, or to strike at people and issues they do not approve of with little regard of the damage done.

by jardinier

All elections in Australia -- at all government levels (local state and federal) are held on a Saturday, with polling booths open from 8 am to 6 pm.

There are also the options of pre-poll votes, and absentee votes.

Participation in all elections is compulsory. Well that is to say, you have to register at one of the set polling places. If you don't wish to vote, than you can simply place a blank ballot paper in the box.

by deadly ernest

can you think of a bigger virus threat than politics - no you can't, nor can anyone else. Consider, it causes a lot of trouble, wasted money and resources while pretending to be something sueful and worthwhile.

by cubeslave

I didn't see where it was located, I just noticed the entry on the Hot discussions sidebar.

by ontheropes

It's a good thing you're from Australia because Dubya will likely have you watched as a "terroristic" threat. At least when you go home you can get out from under the loss of freedoms and the new debts that are being shoved down our throats.

I'm pretty well convinced that the current Administration doesn't care about anything other than lining their own pockets at the expense of my fellow citizens. It's been happening for years.

It's also been my experience that most Americans are apathetic and/or ignorant about American politics, current legislation and such immense issues like what really happened on 9/11, FEMA's response to Katrina, our $2.7T budget, our $1T debt caused by the Iraq debacle, etc.

They don't know, don't care and refuse to believe anything unless it's on the 6:00 news, preferably FoxNews.

by deadly ernest

Years ago I had a teacher who was born and raised in the USA mid-west. We had no idea how he ended up teaching in Australia, we figured it must have been a mistake. His map of the world only included contential USA, Alaska and Canada (it was marked as a potential new state), and an inset with Hawaii.

I correspond with some people in Colorado and we were all amazed that our news service here carried more about Katrina than their news services. Katrina hardly rated a mention until after it hit, for their local news.

To many in the USA if it did not happen within the country it did not happen.

by ontheropes

...the dumbing down of America. If you want a clear example of our educational system in action all you have to do is read some of the posts in the discussion "Unionize IT!" on TR. The spelling and grammar of my fellow Americans is generally appalling.

As far as anything happening outside of our borders being of little interest to the average US citizen, you are right. There are only 5 media companies controlling the bulk of the media most people see here. As short a time ago as 1991 there were 100+ (I can't remember the exact number. Seems like it was 151 but... I can't remember.)
My point being that unless one of the major media networks reports it, in most American minds, it didn't happen. I believe that fact is used to good, strategic advantage by our Legislative body in Washington D.C.

I can't tell you if any of the major news networks, besides maybe CNN, have much of a presence overseas anymore. They probably cut expenses because truthfully we don't see much about what goes on elsewhere.
Right now the news is all about Iraq, Iran and Israel. Oh and I almost forgot Paris Hilton, American Idol, Tom Cruise, Michael Jackson and Britney. You MUST keep up on what they're doing or you can't possibly be informed, right?

If you live here and want to know what's going on in the US, and anywhere else, you have to take it upon yourself to either search the Web and/or watch the BBC news.

by deadly ernest

What would happen if no one turned out to vote? Sadly the party faithfulls would turn out anyway and thus create a result of some sort.

I also wonder what would happen in the USA if they got a 90% voter turn out - probably scare the shit out of the party leaders.

by tonythetiger

If a person is "well enough" to function by themselves in society, they are well enough to vote.

There is no condition short of senility that bars voting except for criminal ones.

"About 80% of voters are committed to one party or the other, it emans that 80% of the votes are not going to vote for the other party. The split may be 40% for each party or 38%/42% whatever. Just that the experts had done surveys and polls and find that about 80% of those who voted had voted for THEIR party and will always vote that way."

I think it's more like 53/27 in favor of Democrats. Many people Register as Democrat, and vote Democrat locally, but Republican nationally. I believe Ronald Reagan got more Democrat votes than Mondale.

"God gave us free agency and we can choose to do as we wish. The point I was making was that people who claim they want certain laws because it is what God wants are people who are full of ******** and trying to make laws on what THEY want but ascibing it to God in order to give it some authority as they have none."

I can't comment on that, as I cannot ascertain what God has or hasn't told anyone.

by deadly ernest

There are many people with mental health problems who are not fully functional on their own who are in the community under supervision as they represent no danger to the community and have been moved out of the institutions due to overcrowding. This applies to most 'western' countries.

You could be right on the party split, the articles I have seen rarely go into that details, only cover how man are already committed.

It is clear though, that if God wanted a specific piece of legislation to be enacted and was telling people to have it made, God would tell everyone.

by tonythetiger

"There are many people with mental health problems who are not fully functional on their own who are in the community under supervision as they represent no danger to the community and have been moved out of the institutions due to overcrowding. This applies to most 'western' countries."

And in the US, they are allowed to vote.

"It is clear though, that if God wanted a specific piece of legislation to be enacted and was telling people to have it made, God would tell everyone."

Maybe He did, but only a few heard! :)

by deadly ernest

they lowered the drinking age and the younger people were shorter and could not reach up to the older bars as they had not yet grown that high.

The real problem in education is that a few decades back some academics got the govts to accept the idea of failling exam being a lifelong pscyological blight on their life. Thus they dropped make or break exams at the end of each year.

by tonythetiger

is the cookie cutter approach to education. Children are not identical. They have different strengths and weaknesses, and learn at different rates.

Making a child take first grade reading again because they failed first grade math and science is stupid.

by ontheropes

When my daughter began the 1st grade at a public school, the school sent home announcement with the students that there was going to be a parent/teacher conference about the schools curriculum. Approximately 750 students and my wife and I were the only parents that showed up. The school canceled the meeting to advertise in the local paper about a rescheduled meeting. Apparently they thought that the kids just threw out the announcement.

At the second meeting, only my wife showed up. I HAD to work.

The following week I enrolled my daughter into a private school with 180 students. At their first parent/teacher meeting, which I attended, over 300 other parents and family members showed up.

I guess, maybe, you get what you pay for.

This discussion is closed to new replies.