Discussion Locked

Anti-Virus Software

0 helpful
37 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Here's something we all have in common.The virus.What programs do others use,and why?
I use to use Norton,untill it was taken over by Symantic,got hacked so many times on the web,that it was'nt worth installing,plus,trying to uninstall the damn thing took forever,and usually wrecked my original configeration.McAfee,Anti Vir,AVG,the list is endless.Any thoughts.

37 replies

by ni70

I've been using avast! antivirus after my Symantec subscription ran out. Try it for 60 days and if you want it's free for a year for home users who register. After one year you can re-register. avast! is very user friendly, offers "On-Access Scanner", and automatic updates. Also offers P2P, IM, Internet Mail, Outlook (SMTP, POP3), Network, Standard, and Web Shields.

I tried Grisoft's AVG about a year ago, didn't really like the interface etc.

EDIT: With avast! you can actually schedule a virus scan during the boot process, and I haven't seen or figured out if Norton or others can be configured to schedule a boot scan.

by morrellf

I went down the NIS road, almost to ruin. I bought the 5 user CD for 4 PCs. reinstalls failed time and again.
So I jumped ship to protect my LAN and bought NOD32 from ESSET. I have not looked back since.

Cheers

by computers

I have been using CA's etrust antivirus for a number of years and am quite pleased. I started when the personal version was available for free over the internet, and continued after I had to pay for it. Currently, there are two versions available for desktops of which I am aware. There is etrust 2005, which is marketed through stores in the States (I am located in Israel, where we don't have it in the stores yet, but remember seeing it almost everywhere I looked on my last trip a year ago), which is easy to install, and takes virtually no configuration.

There is also etrust 7, which is the version for use on networks. This takes a little configuration after installation. It updates as often as you set it for, and has 2 virus engines. I have this installed on my machine, and frequently use it to clean viruses from hard disks taken from machines that had Norton, McAfee, and AVG installed.

Another good antivirus is ESET's NOD32. It will disconnect from a website that tries to download a program to the computer, but can't clean viruses in memory.

The Etrust is good at cleaning viruses in memory, and at giving me full information about the occasional infected files it can't clean, so I can get at them in safe mode. Definitely my first choice.

by pjs38

I had the same experience. Used to use Norton, but had so MANY problems with it, particularilay when trying to uninstall, that I removed it from all of my machines. I have used AVG for some time now (the Free VErsion) and think it is a really good program.
I just recently loaded Avast on my grand-daughter laptop and that too seems to be a pretty neat program. I would recommend either of those as my first choices.

by anandu

We use corporate Symantec version 8 in our environment. So far it's OK. We are thinking to upgrade to Symantec 10. This new version is claiming that it can also detect Spyware. I don't know how much true it is, but anyone of you has experience with new version 10? Do you think it can also detect Spyware? I read some where that even though they are claiming about spyware, their engine is not designed to catch spyware.

by heathlair

We are using Symantec Corporate 10 and are quite pleased with its abililty to detect spyware. I especially like the feature that allows you to get information about the spyware detected through a simple hyperlink in the scan history.

by k.dingman

I upgraded our Symantec Anti-Virus Corp to version 10 in early Feb. We had been using V9.x very sucessfully (10 servers and about 50 workstations)

Almost immediately we began to have problems with "losing conection" with the primary SAV server. Symantec tech support was not very helpful but did not seem at all surprised that I was having this issue. I tried every "fix" that they recommended.
Only a complete uninstall of the product fixed the problem. Client versions work fine but the management server has caused my organization nothing but problems. I only have 1 server version that is "behaving" properly on the WAN. And it took many hours to get it working properly.

I normally like the SAV product and am hoping that they come out with a patched version that does not cause these issues. Until then I am running the clients unmanaged.

I may end up going back to v9.x since it worked fine.

My personal feeling is that all the new functionality that they added to V10 has caused these issues...

Just my 2 cents.
Kent

by schuylkill

We use CA eTrust in our desktops and servers, but it does not get much of a workout, because we also have SurfControl e-mail and web filters in place that do an amazing job at blocking all kinds of unpleasantness.

For those computers that are off our network (laptops, home users, and whatnot), we had been using Norton Internet Security 2003, 2004, or 2005, and also Symantec Client Security 2.0. We are moving to ZoneLabs Internet Security Suite, which includes an antivirus piece. We are making the switch away from Norton/Symantec because Norton requires that users be local administrators of their computers in order for updates to download (big security hole, since this allows spyware to install). We chose ZoneLabs based on the security baseline in Brian Livingston's Windows Secrets Newsletter, which in turn is based on a PC Magazine Editor's Choice Award.

by jee_grover

I agree that ZoneAlarm is a very strong product.

Symantec's flaws are always visible to anyone who uses their products. However, I must say that I've been using Client Security 3.0 in my network and finally I can say that a Symantec product works well.

Jee

by Erik Eckel

Ah, I just saw this post. I posted a similar question just this morning (https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-11193-0.html?forumID=81&threadID=180932&start=0). Had I known you'd started this thread, I would have tacked it on here.

I've always recommended Norton. And, I've always had great luck with its AV products. But now I find myself in a situation where the copy I've purchased won't update itself, and I've been unable to find a solution on Norton's Web site.

I suspect I'm dealing with an OEM issue. My Sony system's registry failed, so I had to proceed with a system recovery (returning the system to its original configuration). The original configuration included Norton Internet Security (2003, I think). Well, I'd already bought Norton AV 2004, so I uninstalled the NIS 2003. Then I installed Norton AV 2004, but the program won't update. Without recent virus definitions, it's useless. I suspect Norton didn't unpublish all its NIS 2003 files, and for that there's not much of an excuse. Now I'm essentially dead in the water (unless I want to try another system recovery, which takes hours). Not going to happen.

Wishing I'd bought a G5,

EE

by cbartek

I have used Symantec products for years with mixed results. Unfortunately, The harder they try to protect them selves from piracy the harder it becomes to uninstall or reinstall. (If you think software piracy has no cost then you are wrong.) They do offer help on there site for how to correct these problems.
Anyway, Not one virus scanner on the market At least not one I've tried has been able to clean every virus out there. I have run NAV, AVG, House call, and McAfee on the same machine and found viruses with each. Now granted this was a pretty bad off machine but this happens pretty often.
Normally We use AVG, a good firewall and lots of spyware software on Home computers and SAV, NAV or NIS on business computers.

by jee_grover

I think Symantec is far from the best solution for the consumer field. Their corporate solutions however are very good but lets not get into that.

Currently I have Norton Internet Security 2005, and once this lousy subscription expires, I will be using the software that I use on my other computers, ZoneAlarm and TrendMicro.

Jee

by garyrw

Great antivirus, especially zero-delay online heuristics; VG on-demand scanner w/signatures. Optimized for small footprint and lowest system resources impact. Expanding to include non[virus threats.

by lordshipmayhem

Why do Windows users seem to think that having to install antivirus and antispyware software is NORMAL?

Why don't they insist that their OS be made with better security?

by jaqui

after all, I have more system resources for my applications by using linux, no anti virus, anti adware needed.
:)

not only don't have to spend a fortune on buggy software, don't have to spend a fortune on additional hardware to cope with the extras the buggy software needs to have to run.

by nzbn

No offense intended but no viruses on Linux? there are plenty its just that less are written for Linux but there are definitly viruses out there and these ones are often designed to do real damage because Linux is used on so many high end platform and servers, hang Apache is on how many million web servers around and 99.99% of those are some form of Linux / Unix and they DO get viruses.

by ddelano

I have used this antivirus protection since it was free to download about 5 or six years ago. Of course it is no longer free, but does provide me with all the protection I nee. In all this time, I have had one virus, and this was because I had not updated the scanner first. Now EZ Antivirus downloads and installs automatically. This is the best scanner and protection I have ever used and will continue.

by compumarc

For some time I had used Symantec Norton Anti-Virus. However, the fact that I needed to pay an annaul subscription to download the anti-virus libraries, along with the fact that Norton Anti-Virus consume a lot of resources on Windows Systems, I decided to switch anti-virus software.

There are many choices and flavors outhere but I decided to give a try to Grisoft AVG Anti-virus software. I've been use its anti-virus software for more than a year and I found it at outstanding piece of anti-virus software. Not only it consume less system resources than its counterpart Norton, but you get FREE updates for life as long as you are the owner of the FREE license installed in your system.

Grisoft AVG-Antivirus automatically update itself if you are connected to the NET thru a high-speed connection. AVG-Antivirus has nothing to envy Norton or the other products out there. It detected in my system all virus threat at thte momenet and have protected my computer from been infected since it was installed.

I am confident that I am protected from a virus attack by using Grisfot AVG Anit-Virus without the headaches created by Norton Anti-Virus (crashes, high used of system resources, low system performance, etc.)

by jee_grover

I would have to agree that AVG is a very good piece of software. Only yesterday I switched to Avast, which is also great.

I guess the main reason that made me change from AVG to Avast was the interface. Otherwise, very solid program.

by danieldaletilton

ive been using avg for 2 years and on a daily basis i would download the free virus librarys there are alot of virus out there and i found that avg is the most advanced in it use of protection
as long as you first down load the daily dosage of new virus def's kind of like a rubber you snoze you loose and the info loss wellll need i say more
use avg right and wow

by impbait

I did a test at home on a troubled PC. I ran AVG and then AntiVir, both with updated definitions and both set to detect only so no changes were made. AVG detected 17 viruses and AntiVir detected 28. Two of the ones that AVG detected AntiVir did not.

by nzbn

to start with?
If you were un-aware of what was on the PC to start with you may well be getting false detections from one or both. AVG has a high false detection rate and a low real detection rate. AntiVir dont even feature themselves in the VB100% records so thier product is probably extremely un-reliable as any AV product that does not feature in the VB100% is hiding something.

by myplums

NIS 2003(NOT NIS 2005) for firewall, combined with Sophos AV..... Has been a bombproof and failsafe combo for 3years now.

by jdgretz

If you want a product that just sits there and works, give the stuff(tm) from TrendMicro a try. From PC-cillin for the desktop through Client Server suite for non-exchange servers to email and anti-spam solutions.

I use it myself and strongly recommend it to all my clients.

by tdmccu

I just wanted to agree that TrendMicro does the job... low overhead, easy to use interface and from my research... lower cost than Symantec and McAfee... been a user/supporter for 3 years now.

by beads

I read the above posts and your thread start but still haven't recieved a definitive: I am trying to secure (A/V wise) this type of environment.

PC Desktop only - PCillian by Trend.
SMB with a email server?
Large Corporate - Trend NeatSuite.

Do you need POP3/IMAP4 support (Web based email)?
Is speed an issue or just performance?

Frankly, I have used just about everything under the sun including a few not listed above. Symantec used to be very good but is now slow and lethargic.

McAffee is still good and does a good job but no longer like the interface as much. Used to get this updated on neat little 3.5" floppies - lol.

Kaspersky is very good but again. I'm not always comfortable with the interface -or- their marketing. Its a personal pet peeve but the software works very, very well and should be considered as a AV product with say Webroot or Spyware Doctor in backup.

Trend used to suck hard rubber but is actually a very excellent product. So I am using NeatSuite as its contains the only real multi-layered approach to virii. Does a decent job, not perfect, with spyware but getting better after buying InterMute. InterMute was the first to successfully and consistantly remove CoolWebSearch from PCs. They have a bit of time to go to get the spyware intergrated into PCillian and NeatSuite. I understand that it will be late Q1 or Q2 of 2006 with an update in a couple weeks as to how long the engineers need to intergrate the new technology into to Trend products.

The biggest problem for the traditional AV vendors is that for the most part many were found a bit complacent when it comes to spyware. This is changing rapidly but its still going to take some time.

At the moment or last time I checked, West Coast Laps hasn't certified any of the AV vendors as 100% guaranteed to remove all spyware. If anyone has a shot at being first I'll put my money on Trend as they have been working on the Spyware portion longer than Symantec or McAffee.

It depends on what your trying to secure.

- beads

by antuck

Beads,

Acutally, Intermute bought CWShredder from Merijn. If I remember correctly, it became to much (to many variants) for Merijn to keep up with it. Merijn had done an excellent job of developing and keeping CWShredder up to date. At the time it was the only tool to successfully remove the CWS trojan. Intermute Purchased it 10-04. They did a great job of keeping it up to date. Then a few months ago I saw Trend have it on thier web site. I was kind of surprised as I didn't hear any news of Intermute selling it.

I aggree with Trend being able to remove the spyware. Symantec and McAfee seem to be able to detect the garbage ware but unable to remove it. I personally wish they would just leave it alone and let others deal with it. What good does detecting it do, if it can't remove it.

andy

by beads

Really! Thats quite interesting. As bad as knowing how many products make up Visio now published by Microsoft. Theres atleast three that I can remember off the top of my head. Maybe a fourth. Ahhh.. what comes around goes around even in the software industry.

Untill the 'Big 3' get there collective acts together your probably still better served using a standalone A/S system as well. This will change but for now none of them is doing the complete job. Plus! No one company can agree with another company as to the definition of spyware. Some companies are more lienient (Trend)other more harsh (SpyDoc).

- beads

by beads

I read the above posts and your thread start but still haven't recieved a definitive: I am trying to secure (A/V wise) this type of environment.

PC Desktop only - PCillian by Trend.
SMB with a email server?
Large Corporate - Trend NeatSuite.

Do you need POP3/IMAP4 support (Web based email)?
Is speed an issue or just performance?

Frankly, I have used just about everything under the sun including a few not listed above. Symantec used to be very good but is now slow and lethargic.

McAffee is still good and does a good job but no longer like the interface as much. Used to get this updated on neat little 3.5" floppies - lol.

Kaspersky is very good but again. I'm not always comfortable with the interface -or- their marketing. Its a personal pet peeve but the software works very, very well and should be considered as a AV product with say Webroot or Spyware Doctor in backup.

Trend used to suck hard rubber but is actually a very excellent product. So I am using NeatSuite as its contains the only real multi-layered approach to virii. Does a decent job, not perfect, with spyware but getting better after buying InterMute. InterMute was the first to successfully and consistantly remove CoolWebSearch from PCs. They have a bit of time to go to get the spyware intergrated into PCillian and NeatSuite. I understand that it will be late Q1 or Q2 of 2006 with an update in a couple weeks as to how long the engineers need to intergrate the new technology into to Trend products.

The biggest problem for the traditional AV vendors is that for the most part many were found a bit complacent when it comes to spyware. This is changing rapidly but its still going to take some time.

At the moment or last time I checked, West Coast Laps hasn't certified any of the AV vendors as 100% guaranteed to remove all spyware. If anyone has a shot at being first I'll put my money on Trend as they have been working on the Spyware portion longer than Symantec or McAffee.

It depends on what your trying to secure.

- beads

by antuck

I was half proud and half feeling over geekish over knowing that :)

You are right that a stand alone A/S is best served now. Even at that you still need a min of two A/S and maybe more. I have been really impressed with Trends online scanner. By far the better of any online scanner. If you work with cleaning up the garbage ware, another site worth looking at is ewido.com. They have a beta online scanner that picks up a lot of trojans and spyware. I have used the online and stand alone products and both are great. The only down fall is they can be used on 2K and XP only.

Side note: I noticed you have Chicago as your location. Are you in the city itself? I'm in the south suburbs, Lansing. GO BEARS!!

by nzbn

The only Antivirus / Antispyware I use is NOD32, No other AV has a higher detection rate, no other AV has a faster scanning rate and uses less resources. Huersitics features detect viruses without signiture updates ( 92% tested success rate after 3 months with no updates for viruses in the wild ) I have not met a virus or spyware infection I could not cleanse with this AV, check out the following reviews to see the results:

NOD32 VB 100
http://nzbn.co.nz/site_images/nod32/NOD32_VB100.pdf

Why the Auckland University of Technology chose NOD32
http://nzbn.co.nz/site_images/nod32/NOD32_AUT.pdf

Independant comparison
http://nzbn.co.nz/site_images/nod32/Virus_comparison.pdf

Anyone want to know what thier current AV stands out like let me know what it is and I will post a link to It's VB score and any other info I find on it.

Cheers

NZ

by michael_orton9

I use Frisks fp-win for my windowws Pcs and F-prot for the Linux ones.
They have very frequent updates, often more then one a day, automatic.
If you enable both Heuristics and Neural Network and set it to RENAME reathe than disinfect /delete, it is recoverable if it renemes some vital system file in Windows.
(I just pop in a Knoppix bootable CD and reneme it back after a floppy scan.. It will find vxe, vom, vll files and disinfect them).
I find even the fp-win will detect a linux keyboard sniffer that I have zipped in a fat32 partition, I though it would be safe there, and it also finds Windows sniffers compressed in ReiserFS partitions.
Norton's doesn't, not does it find compressed Linux virus collection in the fat32 partition.
Its not for the PC illiterate to load, you have to download it as a compressed executable, save to a folder, then double click on the Windows version.
The Linux one comes asan RPM and in SuSe you have to install other files via YAST2.
Also from the same site the FREE F-Prot.
I use this for "ethnic cleansing" of infected PCs.
You make up a set of 4 write protected floppies ( or bootable CD), boot.
A:/f-prot/disinfect/hard "ethnicaly cleanses" boot sector viruses.
the.
A:/f-prot/loddef just feed it the floppies, when asked, then run the "Ethnic Cleanser" and it has always "exterminated" them for me.
I have one person with over 250 infected files and it "ethnically cleansed" the HD with no problems.
I didn't even bother to remove the HD to my "data recovery PC," the floppies did it.

Fp-win blocks access to infected files, try it with EICAR.VOM the test file in the help section.

http://www.f-prot.com 25 euros/year for up to 5 home PCs... bulk terms available for more.

However I do use Nortons Utils to repair HDs that "can't be formatted!" I get loads for free that then can go into old scrap PCs for locals, the run 98se or Linux very well.
I did try Nortons AV and their firewall but find that there are far better and much cheaper solutions, (ZoneAlarm+VisualZone Report Utility)
Microsofts free Beta anti-spyware, etc. They all work OK with FP-win and have no problems with dual and triple boot (GRUB boot-loader).

by dbucyk

The software AVG is a good software, but it seems that you are being hacked.

Do you have zonealarm on your computer. You can get the freeware version. Make sure you set the preferences so you are in stealth mode.

Next, run applications like adaware se on your computer and go through the options that you can enable. Run this one and Spybot Search & Destroy v1.4 and keep them up to date.

Next, make sure your operating system does not have the hide known file types checked off on your system. You want your system to recognize these threats.

Also, go into your email. If you are using outlook express, make sure that you have disabled the preview pane. If that is disabled and you go through the options to automatically purge and empty your deleted items upon exit, you are almost there.

Finally, clean up your temporary internet files daily. This will clean up your tracks on the internet and make it harder for spam to check your surfing habits.

Back to AVG (or any antivirus for that fact), enable heuristic scanning and, in AVG, make sure all of the options have been enabled.

What I am trying to say is that if you use all of these programs on a weekly basis, daily updating and checking to see if there are critical updates for your system, you'll more than likely not fall victim to viruses and spam.

Just keep on your toes and you'll be alright.

by nzbn

I would advise dropping Symantecs antivirus products alltogether, They take up to much resources, are slow dont detect and remove all threatware and eventually crash your PC on you. Go with NOD32 you can visit my site www.nzbn.co.nz and at near the top right is a bunch of comparisons between many antiviruses and reviews. Tech support is fantastic, (Recently for a large college here that I implemented it into NOD32 Hueristics had a false detection on some software that they wanted to install due to the nature of what it did and within days of e-mailing tech support for NOD32 they had the false detection fixed) Network discounts available, Fast, covers all threatware, easy to use interface (including the remote management console which is according to my customers the easiest they have ever come accross.)

by ethorne003

I've been trying forever to uninstall NIS 2006, but there's a barrier everywhere I turn ... on Add/Remove programs, and on Symantec's own so-called Removal Tool. Is there any surefire, no fooling way to get that stuff off my hard-drive?

This discussion is closed to new replies.