The two main issues are how much the AV software slows down your computer and what is it's typical detection rate.
'Typical Detection Rates' are like earnings from a stock investment....actual mileage may vary, and if you get the one virus that's new, the other 99.99% detection rate is meaningless.
AV software won't stop the latest and greatest malware, since the AV does not know about it.
For example, I use Sunbelt Vipre on some machines, Microsoft Security Essentials on some, Avast on others.
I like Vipre since it uses little processing power, so it is good for a netbook.
But realistically, unless the PC is locked down, the browser is something other than IE, and user knows to stay away from bad sites, there will be viruses that walk all over the AV software, since it's that one virus that's not in the signature file that gets you.
I've never used Bit Defender.
The one app that I am testing at the moment is the new version of Webroot.
Webroot bought Prevx, and Prevx is very good, so I would guess their products would reflect that combined goodness. Still testing, though...