Discussion Locked

Anyone else make the mistake of buying an Xbox360?

0 helpful
141 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I just got done dropping my MONTH OLD 360 off at the UPS drop off store to send back to MicroSoft. As soon as I walked in with the white shipping box MS sends you to return the defective product, the guy behind the counter said "oh, another xbox".

It all started with the RROD [i]"Red Ring of Death" [/i]

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xbox_360_technical_problems

The store I purchased it from, GameStop, politely informed me that this $450 system I had purchased from them 3 weeks early was NOT something they stood behind. [i](Never would have got it through them if I had known they didn't stand behind purchases)[/i]

My only recourse, call MS. The lady that was clearly not in the US walked through it all with me, and it became evident my only option was to have them send a pre-paid box for me to return the defective product to them for repair. Five days later, I got my box.

They had also told me SPECIFICALLY not to write XBOX on the outside of the box. Hmmm, think they were getting stolen during shipping? Naaaaaa. Turns out after talking to Mr. UPS, EVERYONE knows what that box is already because there is such a flood of them.

I have been told I will get my system back in 2 to 3 weeks. Wonder if they do anything to try to make up for the considerable lost "goodwill"?

Wish I would have gotten the SPS3. I had given my boys the choice and they wanted the 360. I should have known better.

Has anyone else gone through this?

141 replies

by hal 9000

Mainly because I was about to buy a 360 when I was told that 1 in 3 don't work new out of the Box.

Seems that M$ not only sells second rate Software full of bugs but also Hardware as well. One day when the 360 is no longer UG I'll pull one apart to see what's inside the thing in the way of Circuitry. They have to have something really Cheap & Nasty in there and I'm interested to see the Poor Design.

Col

by the scummy one

they will be less than $50 on ebay.
Just from my personal observations, they aint worth sh!t in the first place.

by the scummy one

I got one for Christmas last year. Although the problems I have had are different. My little bro got 1 and has had to send it in 3x for repairs.
But, dont expect it in 2-3 weeks. The last 2x my bro sent his in it took 6+ weeks before being returned.
The problem with mine is in the middle of playing (at random) it will freeze, or stop and tell me that the disk inserted is an XBOX 360 game and to insert the proper disk into the drive.
WTF, the friggin 360 tells me the disk is a 360 game, but it decides it is not a 360 anymore so it cannot continue with it???

Nah, this POS is never being returned to MS to make more money. I already dealt with their support on this issue for more than a week and a half. MS can kiss my A$$ if they think I will send this POS to them and pay them for it. When it dies, I got a nice hammer waiting for it.

by jdclyde

figuring by NOW they would have a decent working system instead of the crap that it turns out they are pushing out the door.

I am so pissed about the whole thing.

Sounds like they need to revamp the things and put a big fan in the side of it to keep the little piggie from burning up. Most of what I have read said the failures are triggered by heat. Sure, using the wrong sodder and sh1t parts doesn't help PREVENT heat problems.....

I also read that MS is trying to say if you buy one of the aftermarket coolers, they suck off so much juice that THEY will kill the system. Need a cooler that has it's own power source. [b]Sounds like a job for Morty![/b] Time for him to make another hacking/tweeking blog, this time, "saving your xbox". :D

by the scummy one

before I even plugged it in, I got a 3 fan set with its own power supply.
I also plugged the POS into a UPS. Maybe that is the reason that I havent had the red ring prob.. However, the freezing up is too annoying to bother with often, and telling me to put in a 360 disk is more than annoying. So the POS just sits there most of the time.
I think after the first few months that I have had it, I probably only have about 20 hours (or less) on it. It gets an average play time of 3-4 hours every other month.

Personally, I am now avoiding everything made by MS. Wont go near Halo, or MS mice/keyboards, or anything else that has their stamp on it.

by timbo zimbabwe

... is how I referred to my PlayStation, or NoPlayStation. Nothing but probs with it, sent it back, told them to keep the damn thing.

My 360 has purred like a kitten from day 1. No problems, but I did take heed at the potential for overheating and set it up accordingly. Keep the PS3... I'll take my 360.

by phimuskapsi

Whereas the 360 has a reported failure rate of 30-35% which is just unacceptable.

However, I have a 360 and I had to send mine back as well. It wasn't because of overheating the drive no longer opened, I take care of it too. Just one day it wouldn't load games anymore.

by jdclyde

I knew about the original problems with the power supply, but hadn't heard anything about the RROD. I can't believe I didn't google it BEFORE wasting so much money on an MS product.

Maybe I will be more sypathetic to people looking for product keys, just because MS has pissed me off so much.

But hey, it is early. Maybe they will turn this around and make things right? Doubt it.

by jdclyde

On a weekend with a friend or two sleeping over, that thing can be one more hours in the day than it is off.

Especially because we like to play the FPS games, so you have to take turns. After a few [i]hours[/i] it is someone elses turn.

A lot of time, but then again, it is better than watching TV, which I almost never do.

by smorty71

I purchased a unit just after launch in December of 2005. I've had it replaced 3 times already.

With each subsequent repair, the turnaround time has gotten longer.

The first repair used overnight shipping to get me the empty shipping box and to get it to and from the repair facility. Turnaround time was about a week (would have been shorter, but it was sent in just before Christmas, so the repair facility was closed to 2 days).

The last repair I had took about 5 days to get the box and about 27 days to get the repaired XBOX back.

You can read more about my XBOX 360 repair ordeal here:

http://www.smorty71.com/2007/08/got-my-4th-xbox-360.html

by jellimonsta

I am glad I no longer play games. Only play online Dora and Curious George with my 5 year old daughter. :D

by jdclyde

I WOULD have just gotten a PS3 instead if I would have only known.....

I am thinking I will be leaving the system on for a week straight when it finally comes back. If it is going to burn up, let it be right away while it is fresh in my head.

Question, are you running a cooling unit on yours now?

by smorty71

I have multiple fans in my entertainment rack that pull heat out. Didn't seem to make a difference.

The rep on the phone told me it was a design flaw in the original design. She claimed that they had figured out how to fix it now.

by jdclyde

less than a month old, and it has been running in the equivalence of a "refrigerated room" for the last few weeks. Between 41 and 55F average.

by andy.nelson1

Yep ? seen loads having this problem here in the UK. Don?t know if there?s a spec difference here but they tend to go into what seems to be a ?safe mode? before actually getting destroyed. I?ve sorted 4 for friends who have bought them ?dead? off ebay for ?20-30 a piece. Then you just grab some good silver based heatsink compound, a larger piece of aluminium, strip, replace and add an extra bit of heatsink material and hey presto!!

Anyone wanting to do this, check out the simple instructions here:-

http://arstechnica.com/journals/thumbs.ars/2006/6/16/4353

by sublimedragon

Check around on Google also for xbox mod sites... some sell packages with custom heat sinks and cooling systems... I've even seen a liquid cooling system!!

by jdclyde

but was wondering if you ran anything directly on the 360 or not.

I even read where MS claimed that some of the fans would leach too much juice and burn the system out. can't win for losing.

by hal 9000

Several years ago I did mount some extra fans onto a Audio Amp that was used professionally and was constantly overheating and clipping.

I got a good laugh out of the next time that the Service Guy came out and claimed that the fans where overloading the Transformer causing the problem. Apparently he thought that the fans where 12 Volt when they where 240 Volt [i]Mains here[/i] I just let him rave on attempting to get out of repairing the unit and then asked how the Mains could be overloaded?

The moral of the story is that they will try anything to get out of fixing/repairing a faulty design. On that one they not only replaced the unit UG but as a Factory Modification they incorporated my Fan Idea on all the existing units. The new ones also had the same thing fitted so that they would keep working. Of course the Power Transistors kept burning out and stopping the unit but they needed replacing with the correct rated components not the cheap rubbish that they where fitting.

Maybe I should have kept the stupid thing and charged them for the cooling solution to their main problem. :D

Col

by jdclyde

I picked up a Saturn just before Christmas (gets about 35 mpg). The problem with it? The locks they use suck ass. About 1/3rd of the time, you could not remove the key from the ignition. :-X One day, I was so pissed, I gave it a good yank, and now the key will come out in any position.

When I had talked to the dealer about this, their first question was "how many keys do you have on your keyring"? Yeah, having more than three keys on my ring will ruin the ignition? I have never had this issue with ANY Chevy or Chrysler product.

by seanferd

I believe all issues must be handled through MS. I don't the that the retailer has a choice in this, either.

by jdclyde

they will just give you a new one if you get a defective product.

It used to be 30 days, but there has been such a flood of these defective 360's they had to go to 7 days instead.

I am surprised they will even carry it anymore.

I wish I would have bought it at Target. they have their 30 days, satisfaction. I would have returned it and got the PS3 in a second.

by d.neal

Sent my 360 back after the RROD, shipped it in my own packaging so I didn't have to wait for MS to send me a box and 8 days later I got the same one back working better than before and with one months free xbox live. OK so the problems shouldn't be there to start with but at least I got quick service.

by d.neal

I used to get a lot of can't read the disk errors, especially mid game when cut scenes etc were loading. Since it came back this doesn't happen anymore.

by guillaume.finance

I went just 7 days before my 1st year warranty to Game (UK store) and luckily they replaced it with a brand new Xbox 360 Premium with the HDMI - hurray !

The guy told me however that the problem of breaking down is probably still the same with this one... :(

Such a shame that there are so many problems as it's a nice gaming console...

by techrepublic

Has anyone had a problem with the newer versions, i.e the ones with the HDMI port (the Halo version or the Elite)
My understanding is that these models have an improved cooling system, and are less prone to failure.

by hughclinton

I have owned an xbox for nearly 2 years, but have hardly ever maanged to use it. Whenever I do, something else breaks or goes wrong. The RRR appeared when I was returning my intermittently locking up xbox to the store.
When I got the new one home the wireless adapter stopped working. I returned my working Xbox steering wheel which seemed to have been quietly recalled, and when I got it back (very quickly I must say) It didn't work at all.

I have never had so much trouble with a single device - and I have worked on more computer systems than most people have had hot dinners! What a mug I must be - it's been a truly awful thing to own. The PS3 is sooooo much better - quiet cool, more powerful, blue ray drive, and ...... IT WORKS.

by graham wilson

Because as far as I can tell, the PS3 cannot yet comepete with the Xbox on its primary function; a games playing unit.

Okay the PS3 may be the more reliable, cooler, quieter hardware but its missing the most important thing a games console needs and thats games to play on it.

At the moment I am ashamed to admit that if my 360 broke I would put the purchase of a new one on my credit card while the broken one was off to M$ for repair.

This is because I dont yet have a realistic alternative console available to me.

I cannot under any circumstances justify buying a PS3 yet because there simply isnt enough available on it.

by jdclyde

The single most important thing about any product is that it is a quality unit that will work well.

It doesn't matter HOW many cool games there are, if you can't play them because of defective hardware.

by jgraun

The 360 is by far the console out there, just look at the sales vs. PS3. MS is crushing Sony. They may have won the Blu-Ray Battle but they lost the Console War.

by stangg

... apart from the odd freezing. Though after a while i did find it became a very effective room heater in those cold winter nights. That was over a year ago now though and i sold it in the first quarter last year as well, looks like i sold it just in time from what i read.

by sdkfljg

I've never had a problem with mine (yet I suppose). I usually only play with my xbox 2x a week, but for up to 8 hours straight on a good night of CoD4. I did have issues playing Fable, but I just chalked it up to playing a regular xbox game. I may have jinxed myself, but I still love my 360 and if it requires hacking the box to keep it running, so be it.

by yponson

I've had the same problem, after about one year of the purchase. I got my X-box replaced by Microsoft. And now? Well, my hard disk crashed and now I have to get a new one. I hope nothing else breaks down.

by rcampos79

I bought a PS3, after a month it stopped reading discs--ANY disc, dvd bluray u name it. I got the box, returned and got a shiny new one in two weeks. I hope it doesn't break after the one year warranty...

by iainb

I've never had a problem with my PS3, but my mate had a hoorible time with his 360, to the extent that after playing Heavenly Sword one night at my place he exchanged his 360 console and games and bought a PS3! All I remember about his 360 was that it was SO noisy!

by src-brian

I just recently got the RRoD, and am waiting on my prepaid box to be sent to me. I bought my 360 used and it was manufactured back in 05 according to when i had it registered with MS. I'm not a hardcore gamer, so waiting 3 weeks or however long it takes is not a big deal to me. My particular error code was a general hardware error, and wont cost anything to get fixed. I'd like to get a PS3....but they are too expensive, and all of the games for PS3 are also for 360...so I'm not gonna run out on pay for an overly priced PS3 when I have a 360.

by mongo_xbl

I am currently on my third 360 (first one RROD, second one RROD). Now the third one has lost the ability to communicate wirelessly with anything. Spent an hour on the phone with XBox support telling me to hit some bizarre combination of buttons on the controller. I had to laugh and ask the person - "do you understand what you just requested? Hard to do when the wireless controllers don't work!"

Meanwhile, the Wii has been flawless and I keep thinking about picking up a PS3.

by mongo_xbl

btw - I am not a hardcore gamer and hardly use the system. The system is very well ventilated and I have a cooling fan attached to it.

by symon.l

Most retailers wont cover any console's like this that is what the warrenty is for, MS Xbox have always dealt with these fault I used to work on the Tech Desk for Xbox but it those days it was a case of calling up explaining what the fault was and we would arrange a courier to pick up the Xbox and swap it there and then like for like. I had 2 normal Xbox's go wrong and 2 360's go wrong, I dont know why these consoles are so doomed but never go to the shop you got the console from especially MS's consoles go onto www.xbox.com call the toll free number this will save you alot of hastle in the long run.

by quasar kid

Both of my sons saved up their money and bought their own XBOX...from Gamestop...never had any problems with the XBOX or Gamestop. Now if you want to talk about the last American made car I bought I can give you some horror stories...

by davidota

These are crap. My son's has died 2x. The second death got lost in their access database and took two month to get a replacement. His WII is still working.

by jdclyde

When I went in with my boys to get our 360, the display showed you get the two games included with the system. I tell the clerk that was helping me that was the system we wanted.

He went in the back room, carried it up to the counter and put it directly in a bag and said it would be waiting for us when we were done shopping. (needed to get extra controllers and a few games).

We pay and leave.

Putting the system together, and there were no games with the system. When I called them, they said they must have run out of systems that have the free game, but there wasn't anything he could/would do about it.

I talked to the manager from a different location, and she was dumbfounded when I told her what had happened. She took the game out of her stores inventory and hooked me up. I promptly went on-line to do the survey on the register slip. I gave her a shining review.

I trashed the GameStop in the Midland Mall, here in Michigan, and informed them not only will I never go to that store again, I will make sure that everyone I ever talk to will know about how they do business and will do my best to steer everyone away from them.

by loonit

Yeah man, my first x-box I had for about a month and it crapped out so I just brought it back to Wal-mart for a new one. The second one lasted about 3 months. The return policy on electronic items is like 30 or 90 days at wally world or something so I had to return my second x-box to Microsoft in their coveted little white box. I went through the same shhhtuffff that you described in your story, UPS, 2 to 6 weeks. It was more like 2 to 6 months, however now that I have gone through all that and have gotten my console back it works great. I have heard several different reason why this is happened to these machines but the reason that makes the most sense is soldering. I was told that there is a small soldered connection that breaks loose inside the machine when it runs for a very long time. The machine gets so hot inside that the solder softens. Thats enough babbling from me, anyway, the refurbished system works great, and xbox live is fun with friends, and Call of Duty 4 rocks man. Good luck

by hal 9000

Electronics Solder Melts at 310o C it starts to soften at 250o C so if the unit is producing so much heat to heat up the internal components to temps like that the actual Electronics must be frying long before the solder can begin to [i]soften.[/i]

While the idea sounds great it's just more of the same old story poor quality components making a poor quality product. But they save a very small fraction of a cent per unit when they make them so it's OK.

Not to mention the costs involved in running something like this it must cost about as much as a small room heater if it's getting that hot so I would be expecting Horrendous Power Bills after playing one of these. But as it's mostly kids who use these I suppose it's the Idiot Parents who get lumbered with the bill. :D

Col

by jdclyde

Gets hot, gets brittle, then snaps.

Hey, I read it on the internet, so it MUST be true, right? B-)

by loonit

Settle down there Captain Flux. I said that is what I was told. I could understand your mild outrage if I had said this was a solid conclusion after hours of experiment in a controlled environment. Awe who gives a $4!t anyway. cheers!

by rbtechguy

I made the bigger mistake of letting my 17 year old son purchase one from ebay. 20/20 hindsight always bites you in the aft end.
After two weeks of use, it quit. Well, no returns from ebay seller, no Microsoft support. I did some research and found the list of problems that plague the system, and actually implemented some of the fixes....erasers, heat gun, etc... The tricks seemed to work, and the 360 has been running for two months, no problems. It's a shame that customers have to resort to extreme measures to get the problem resolved.

by noads

Owned an xbox, in all the useless packing material came several notices about correct placement and heat issues. being the paranoid SOB that I am, purchased additional cooling before using. Never had a problem.
Upgraded to the elite last summer, and although noisy with the intercoolers, again, never had a problem. My son, however didn't have the same experience with his PS3. After numerous replacements for disk read errors and lockups, He now stays parked on my elite.
Lucky me.

by phake

It is certainly possible for too much weight on the keys to mess up all of the mandated key and engine electrical security features...

My wife will often have her cell phone and mini-wallet attached to her keyring and she occasionally gets a brief engine cutoff in her Chrysler minivan.

I never get that problem with my keys (vacation driving) although I "only" have about a dozen keys....

by theoracle1001

I've had my box for several years now and I have yet to have any problems with it. (Knock on wood.) My wife had hers less time than I did and she had to send hers in. She didn't have to wait long because they sent her a replacement. So be sure to copy or get your stuff off it before you send it in!

by jdclyde

they have you remove your harddrive and faceplate.

At first we had been worried about losing our saved games, until they told us not the send in the HD.

by sigman

Bought a 360 late fall of '06. We had the disk scratching problem just after Christmas '06, sent it back, got another unit in two weeks, this one has worked well since - even the wireless adapter.

Not trying to rain on anybody's rant here, but ours gets 2-8 hours of use per day and its been great.

by jdclyde

it is ONLY about 1 in 3 ( 33%) of all systems that are bad.

You hopefully can stay part of the 66%.

by dpeter

I have to admit to did get the rings of death while playing Gears Of War. I did the towel trick and was able to get the Xbox working just long enough for me to beat the game. I returned the Xbox to Microsoft with no questions asked. The first thing I did though was go buy one of those cooling fans for the back of the Xbox and have not had a problem since. I guess its been about a year now.

I am just glad I did not buy the HD DVD add on!!!!!!!!!!!!

by techniquephreak

I bought one the night the came out, one of the early ones with video card issues. Sure, it died within two months, but Microsoft sent me a replacement via next day delivery. I haven't had a problem with the replacement, and it has been running hard on a daily basis for almost two years now.

Your boys know what they're talking about. A good rule when it comes to consoles and video games? Defer to the wisdom of your children. It's about the gameplay, stupid! Xbox Live is the ultimate reason to have an Xbox 360. PS3 and Wii have nothing comparable. No contest.

And yeah, I'm a Halo fanboy, so Xbox is where it's at for me. Disagree and I'll pwn your ass. ;-)

by franmill

Same here, XBox was defuncto from the word go..
Gave up after two returns and new problems, accepted fate and relegated it to the old computer box closet...
Bought a Wii and could not have been happier, it fits all of us from the 7 ear old to the 60 year old adoptive parents...
fmillmd

by jdclyde

we don't do "cutesy" games, and that is the Nintendo nitch.

First person shooters all the way, which is why we went with the xbox.

Sony always spent more time on sports games, which is not our cup of tea.

by jdclyde

Your saying you had OTHER defects with the system beyond the RROD, and they fixed the system to how it should have been in the first place. How nice of them?

I thought you were going to say it PERFORMED better during game play than when it was new. THAT would be an improvement, not just what is expected.

Cool that you got it back quickly.

by daveaaa3

If the XBox and PS whatever's are causing this much trouble, it's time to start thinking about using a PC for your gaming.

by jdclyde

the pc games win out every time over ANY console, no questions asked.

The problem is, we are comparing a $400 system to a $2000 system to play games.

I also have twins, and two people can play on a console, two people can not play on the same PC. (actually, need a third for me....)

I do have several game systems, but they are not high end systems.

by jdclyde

Following the tracking, and MS now has my 360. Wow, did they go cheap on the shipping, because it took them a week to get it.

Of course, they never sent me a confirmation that they got it, but that is probably standard for them.

Will post more as I get more information on this. I WILL be having a marathon session with this system when I get it back. Have my boys have some friends spend the night, and have the thing go for 48 hours straight. Might even connect it to the projector from work and run it through the surround sound. that would be cooooooool. B-)

by blackdiamond

Hey,

Ours was delivered today, we sent it out on Tuesday the 19th. We have never received any notice from them about them getting it on any of our exchanges.

One of ours was lost on its return trip and they did not even let us know. After a very long time and not receiving it we called them to ask status and they said they were waiting for us to call about it because it was lost on the return trip.

Keep an eye on service.xbox.com for status, if you registered your original 360.

by jdclyde

to see when they got it.

I plan to keep a close eye on this pig.

Not to mention, everyday the boys are asking when the xbox will be back...... :D

by blackdiamond

Hey,

We have had our launch day 360 replaced multiple times. Right now ours is "Out for delivery" in Texas, this will make number 5. This one did not even make it two months. This time for not being able to read any disc inserted. Only had the RRoD once in all of these problems.

The thing I hate is that to get all of your downloaded items to work again you have to do stupid human tricks for MS because your content is associated with the 360 it was originally Dl'd on. Which means more time on the phone and less time playing.

Last time they did include a free 30 days of Live, no big deal as we already are paid up for a year.

We know five people with a 360 and each and every one of them has had it replaced at least one time with our five times at the top of the number count.

Not a contest we want to win.

by jdclyde

I know some people have been reporting some of both.

I have my serial number, so am curious if I get mine back or just a referb.

You would think they would have a stack of them referb'ed and ready to go, to reduce the turn-around time on these.

by osirisb

There is another headache that occurs when a 360 dies and is replaced. Apparently the licensing or DRM for downloaded content is matched to both your gamertag AND the console. This means that if your console is replaced you have to be connected to XBLive to access this content, presumably to verify your gamertag's rights to it.

I found this out the hard way when I recently took my newly replaced 360 on a weekend getaway and found that all of my arcade games had reverted back to trial versions, I couldn't access new Halo3 maps (THAT I PAID FOR!!), and I couldn't watch most videos. Downloading the content again doesn't help.

This may not be a problem for most people, but I take my xbox on trips and to LAN parties where this is a big issue.

A mistake buying the 360? Probably.

by blackdiamond

Hey,

What is even worse sometimes is that the content is not available even when online. Our Crackdown content does not show that we have ever DL'd it and even when it would let you re-download some content with charging you again it would not work for any account but the main account.

We called MS and they had us create another gamer tag and then several weeks later they called us back and gave us codes to input for the amount of money we had paid for everything. The problem is that now we have this gamer tag that we don't use and can't be deleted because the stuff is also associated with it.

There has to be a better way. Seems like they could go into our account and associate the new/replacement 360s serial number.

by stumanca

I don't think anyone's mentioned anything about the HD-DVD player for the 360, yet. That brings all kinds of ire to me. The demise of HD-DVD standard to Blu-Ray really upsets me. What am I to do with all those HD movies when the player dies??? Use them for target practice down at the range??

by jdclyde

should be selling them on ebay while they can.

That or put them away for 30 years and then sell them as antiques.

by jamesrl

At least the HD DVD player can play standard DVDs too.

I remember in the 80s the RCA laserdisc, a 12 inch platter that was out when DVDs were a dream. When they were done, they were useless for anything new. What you had was all you would ever get.

James

by sublimedragon

After seeing some of the posts on here, I have to wonder... how long are you running the machine for at any given time... in the manual for the system it says not to run the machine for longer than 6 consecutive hours without a cool down period. I faithfully adhered to that rule for a total of 11 months and then one day the kids were off from school and they ran it for something like 12 hours with no break. The next day (MY day off) I went to turn it on and lo and behold... the dreaded Ring o' Death.

My only problem was how long it took to get the system back (6 weeks, and only a 1-month live card for my troubles)

When I got my system back (a totally new system) I found that certain games I had would not play (Gears of War and Tiger Woods 07) other than that the system was fine and I just traded my two games that didn't work for Assasin's Creed.

Before I even played it once, I went out and got myself a 3rd party cooling device which is basically a series of 3 computer chassis fans that clips onto the back of the xbox, I gotta say it REALLY DOES WORK! But even with the cooler I still never run it longer than 5-6 hours without a cool down...

XBOX 360 for me has been a great experience, especially for the games it has to offer.

by blackdiamond

Hey,

They come with a manual? :-)

Ours is on all the time especially on the weekend, with watching movies, streaming music or videos and video chatting with an out of state daughter. Our first 360 which lasted longer than any of the others, over a year was on all the time as well.

I would think that 6 hours would be a suggestion only. No one at MS has every questioned us about the amount of time the system is running.

by sublimedragon

I admit I've also ran my xbox longer than 6 hours while streaming, downloading, using Media Centre etc etc, but none of those activities really 'pushes' your xbox hardware at all. Try playing a game like Bioshock or GoW for any length of time and you will certainly see the temperature rise considerably...

it seems to me that there are varying reports from all over the world about the xbox... some people have problems right out of the box.. others like yourself don't seem to be having any issues. Obviously there are some serious quality control problems at the MS camp. (gee, who would've thunk it.. MS with poor quality control?? lol)

by the listed 'g man'

Will do not good. The cold air needs to pass over the components and then out the back, not blown in from the back only to be passed back out & in & out.... - this will make things worse!

by dave

I would expect MS to do something with most of the ones that come back, they just want to get you a replacement sooner than they can fix yours. So they send you one that someone else returned two months ago which they think they have fixed.

Nothing wrong with that except of course where there is a fundamental design flaw and they don't have enough of the redesigned units yet.

From what I hear, if you get one back with a second heat sink and a heat pipe cooling the processor, that is a 'fixed' unit or interim production unit, and may be reliable. Early repairs which did not include the extra heat sink were still problematic. You can only be truly confident in the new manufacture (lower power, cooler chips) units, and even those may have other problems than heat to contend with.

by richardroles

It took 3 attempts to even get my plain white box from them. 1 month later the thing shows up so that I can return the blasted thing!, In all it took 2 days shy of 2 months to even get it back from them. I am not impressed with their so called "Customer Service" either No compensation what so ever except for a month of free xbox live! WTF that does not cover it. Microsoft can bite my shiny metal A$$ ! ps After I had my xbox back a week later another empty white box show up at the door! I am keeping this one in case I need to return it again! And yes it all has to do with heat! I have mine up on stand so that air can flow freely even underneath. Just don't block any air holes proping it up!

by jdclyde

as soon as I walked into the UPS store, they guy behind the counter says "oh, an xbox, huh"?

by jdclyde

I had mine within the first few weeks of owning the box.

limit to six hours, huh? yeah, that is going to happen, not. about the only time it isn't on is when we are at work/school, or asleep, between my two boys and myself. Easily 10 hour stretch, taking turns playing the one player games.

by jdclyde

if you pop it open to put on a different heat sink, bye-bye warranty.

You did hear they extended the warranty covering the RROD out to three years, right?

by jgraun

I got mine about a month after the launch and I havent had any problems. I do have a lot of ventilation where mine sits. PS3 isnt much better a friend of mine has one and he is on his 3rd one, hopefully 3rd time is the charm.

by mellis

I bought my son an XBOX 360 at launch as a Christmas present. Bought one for myself about 6 months later. Got my son a Wii the following Christmas. This past Christmas, got my son the PS3. My Xbox, which was the newer one, failed with RROD after about 6 months. My son's failed with RROD about two years after purchase. Microsoft promptly extended the warranty (twice) and replaced both xboxes (total turn-around about 2-3 weeks).

Microsoft obviously has a hardware design flaw related to heat. However, they were quick to repair/replace them and I feel like they have supported me well. Much better than some other companies I have dealt with.

Having 2 xbox360's, 1 wii and 1 PS3 in a single household has allowed us to evaluate the positive/negatives of each system.

The XBox360 has the most and best games (IMO). The online experience (gamer score's, marketplace, etc.) is much better with XBox. The wii is fun, but is not comparable in graphics or power. The PS3 is probably the most powerful machine but its potential, at least in the games we have, has not been fulfilled. The games seem more washed out and the graphics are not as "next" gen as the Xbox360--at least IMO.

So, even though both of our XBox360's have failed with RROD, it is still the favorite of both my son and myself. A great gaming experience, the extension of the warranty to 3 years, and breadth of games on XBox360 causes me to make some allowance for its failures.

PS3 made a powerful system that is apparently harder to develop games for than the XBox360--maybe they got the hardware thermal design right, but it just isn't as much fun--at least not yet.

by hal 9000

So it melts at a lower Temp that other Solder. Typically somewhere around 310o C give or take 5o C.

If the unit is getting hot enough to make any Solder go soft the Component must be at least 15o C hotter than where the Leg enters the Solder. These Components are rated to 40-50o C maybe and quite often a lot less so they should [b]Self Destruct[/b] long before they get hot enough to have any effect on the solder.

But even if they are only getting a tenth as hot as was claimed above they are one Power Hungry Resistor and I would personally hate to be paying for the Electricity that these things are using as they are wasting a lot of it as heat. That in itself is a [b]Sure Fire Sign[/b] of a [b]Very Poor Design.[/b]

OH now that is on the Internet it must be so true mustn't it? :D

[b]The M$ X Box 360 chews more power that a small room heater and sends the users and their Parents Bankrupt.[/b] Hey after all it is M$ we are talking about here. :^0

OH BTW my electronic Soldering Irons do not exceed 312o C and I've yet to run into any problems with not being able to melt solder. Of course the cheap Soldering Irons without Temp Control are a different story and I've seen someone who shall remain Nameless attempt to use one of the Electronic Weller's to solder up something with Plumbers Solder. Besides turning the Iron Black it wouldn't even come close to melting that solder even when it had bits cut off it in an attempt to stop the heat leaching up the Solder Stick. Still I had to replace the tip just in case of Contamination.

It was a lot of Fun teaching that one not to mess with my Tools. :^0

Col

by hal 9000

To get you to buy more XBoxes. You know just like M$ and Windows Vista, because I do business work I've been told by M$ Marketing to sell a new computer with a Vista License [i] Something like Vista Basic because it's not going to be used[/i] and then install another License of XP onto the system and charge for both. One computer with 2 M$ Licenses for it. Sure sounds good for M$ at least.

Actually I'm not actually sure that the guy was kidding either. :(

AS for the X Box 360 maybe it's M$ idea to get customers to buy several so that they always have a working one while the others are in for repair. :D

Col

by graham wilson

If there are no quality games to play on your choice of games console (and you bought it for actually playing games on) then ones chances of having fun playing games are not much more than 0%.

However, if there are many quality games to play on a console and more on the way that at least arrive at some point rather than just reamining in the pipeline/pipedream for ever then ones chances of having fun playing games are much higher. Admittedly thuis can all come to a crushing end one evening mid play but even so.

Dont get me wrong and tar me as some M$ lover and Sony hater. I have no alliegencies to any one hardware or software maker because thats rather silly. They make products I like or dislike just like anyone else that sells goods or services. I want competition in the marketplace because it benefits me, the consumer in the end. I do not wish failure any any one console maker, I want them all to survive, compete and force each other to innvoate more and keep trying to provide the better products and services.

Its annoying me that right now its a one horse race. I want Sony to get off thier backsides, release some worthy games and make M$ sit up, take notice and improve!

by jdclyde

when it was the ps2 vs xbox, sony was sitting in the drivers seat.

Between the xbox live game play and more action games for the teen and mid 20's people, (the main audience), sony fell behind. they have some cool games, but their focus was always the sports games. that was the main reason for going with a 360. MORE games to my liking. ps3 would have still kept me amused.

by graham wilson

PS2 was definately streets ahead of Xbox when the Xbox was first released because Xbox had no games and was expensive. M$ though saw where games were going to go (online) and made their console online ready at release with the needed hard drive so as not to limit the online possibilities for patches, extra maps, modes etc.

As time moved on games started appearing for it though and although there was alot of pc game conversions the console eventually became worth buying.

I took the plunge myself and slowly but surely my PS2 was getting left behind. Sony never delivered the the much needed hard drive which pretty much made the console completely obsolete as it eventually became near useless for online gaming. Fortunately, Sony's gaming arm survived on fanboyism and people who still hadnt made the jump to online games. During this time Sony wasted time and money on crap like the PS2.5 and PSP instead of fixing their primary product.

This current situation could now go the other way if Sony would stop doing their usual trick of promising but not delivering and going off getting involved in other projects once the money has been made on the one that still isnt as good as it should be.

I hope they do sort it out because PS3 could be something good. I have also heard they have dropped the ball somewhat once again with the online implementation. Shame that. Should have just shamelessly copied the M$ online implementation like Nokia have for their next N gage. hehe.

by jdclyde

well, technically, they kept it for a month and then sent me back a different system.

If they were going to swap it out, why would/should it take them three weeks?

They must have been having a lot of problems with UPS because they switched over to Fedex now.

Will wait and see how long THIS system lasts.