20 replies
Five years experience and Exchange 2003 was the original request at a guess.
As for the plonker you talked to, bet he didn't know 2003 was a year.
If either of us had become a recruiter, we'd have rung the client back and said this is bollox, politely of course :D
Still don't get it me, like going into a major high street retailer and asking advice on what PC to buy.
Another recruiter, who was probably very desparate to close a deal and simply fill a position with just anyone, wanted a copy of my resume before I even knew what the position was all about. I know their game and am not stupid, so I first asked him if the company was willing to pay my minimum salary requirements, because I have learned from experience not to waste time on interviews that end up in me getting lowballed because I wasn't informed about what they can pay. Needless to say, the recruiter said that they are willing to pay that salary and asked me for my resume. I asked him for a detailed job description, which he did send to me in exchange for a copy of my resume. OK, but he isn't getting a copy of my resume in MS Word format to botch up with his company logos. No, I sent him a PDF version of my resume which is locked down against modification or printing. After that, I never heard from that fool ever again. If he or any other dumbass recruiters think they can peddle me off as some cheap laborer, then they are very wrong. I tell them straight out that I don't have time to waste on interviews if they are looking for a low paid Jack of all trades.
Am I arrogant in a sense? Yes I am, because I know my market value, and I don't like having my time wasted on companies that don't know what they want in terms of skills.
put me forward for a job before he asked me. When I said it wasn't suitable, he said I was over valuing myself, and that he had my best interests at heart!
The only reason to sell yourself cheap, is you can't sell yourself expensive.
by lisamorgan
My pet peeves are: 1) the recruiter who calls you for the job in Wisconsin or Seattle or Georgia when you live in Virginia and have stated on every board that you won't relocate, 2) the recruiter who sends you the $12/hr help desk job when your entire resume and salary requirements indicate that you haven't made that little since high school, and my favorite, the ones who blast-mail every opening based on a partial key-word match. I have received numerous "We found your resume and think you would be a good fit for..." e-mails for Oracle, Java, XML, C# MySQL and Unix jobs...all of which would be fine except I am a SQL server, VB.Net developer with no experience (express or implied) in any of the technologies indicated in the requirements.
I know these ffolks have to cast a wide net, but would you want to work with someone who can't even be bothered to read your resume?
by barrygraham
.....what people write and what they really mean might be two different things entirely. In a case like yours, if you really were interested in pursuing that job, I believe it would have been more prudent to read into the job posting, not necessarily take it verbatim. Get an idea of what they're looking for, research the company a little bit, and structure your resume accordingly. For example, listing on your resume something like, [i]Ten years experience with Microsoft Exchange, the latest version being Exchange 2003[/i], would certainly fit the requirement as you know it to be.
It sounds to me like you got into the preverbal pi$$ing match with a recruiter over what may have been an insignificant oversight. If you really were interested in pursuing the job, you probably hurt your own chances. Why would you want to do that just to make a point to someone who probably could neither care less or have the first clue about it. Recruiters don't necessarily know all the nuances of every job they find candidates for.
I've said it a gazillion times, finding a job is less about "qualifications" and more about attitude and presentation. And getting worked-up to the point of showing what may be perceived as a bad attitude could not possibly help your case in any way whatsoever.
As so often is the case in successful communications, what they mean (and what they really want) is what one should focus on, not necessarily how they say it. And as Richard Carlson wrote, [i]Don't Sweat the Small Stuff[/i].
Yup. The requirements were screwed up. Happens all the time. I am a senior Development Manager for a certain very large accounting firm.
I get asked a few questions by our HR people when I recruit a new developer.
Question 1: Is this a junior, intermediate or senior position?
Question 2: What are the essential skills?
Question 3: What are the essential personal qualities?
Question 4: What are the nice-to-have skills and personal qualities?
So, here are my answers (for the last position that I needed to fill):
1. Senior
2. ASP.NET
3. Good communication and client-facing skills
4. J2EE
So the advertisement goes out.... and the requirement is "Wanted, developer with 8 years experience in ASP.NET"!!!!
WTF???? The HR person explained it to me:
Seniors must have 8 years experience. I said that ASP.NET is the requirement - so it has to be 8 years in ASP.NET.
Luckily, we got applicants who said that they had 8 years in ASP.NET, and the HR person duly forwarded those resumes to me (I duly forwarded them to my shredder).
by jamesrl
At my office, I don't let HR send anything out for a position I am hiring for, unless I've reviewed it. I write the job description, HR reviews it, if the position is going to be advertised, they get me to approve the copy.
Sure its more work, but a little work up front saves a lot of pain later.
My favorite one was in the mid 90s, when Java had been out for 3 years, someone from Sun told me they saw an ad wanting 5 years experience. He said the only person who qualified was James Gosling, who "invented" java, and had obviously been working on it for a few years before it was released.
James
And my response is "HELL NO" because I know my market value and if this dumbass of a recruiter can't close the deal at the salary/rate I desire, then perhaps he/she isn't such a great recruiter.
If they want cheap labor, I can introduce them to a few guys named Kumar, Pratesh, and Patul who have H1-B visas, but I won't work for peanuts.
by s.mcgahan
One told me on the phone that I couldn't turn an interview down purely on the basis of the money involved in the post. I laughed and told him that's exactly what I was doing.
Another set me up for interview to do desktop support when all my recent experience indicates that I haven't been responsible for desktop support in almost 10 years.. oh and it was paying well below my salary expectations.
To summarise, recruiters are *****.
by barrygraham
Wow... I'll be surprised if you ever find a job that you are happy with! Recruiters are working for their clients and are paid to find what the client is looking for. Just because you may not be named "Kumar" does not make you any better than them and just shows that you are somewhat arrogant?
Good luck in demanding your way through your career!
by jasondloving
by jamesrl
If you read the resume from top to bottom, you don't see that. But if you are searching for Desktop or SQL or Cisco, you see all of those things in your resume.
I used to have a resume stylistically like yours, but at a workshop I went to, I learned to simplify it down a bit which did improve my response rate. You shouldn't have to explain every task you've done or every piece of software you have used.
Instead, what were your accomplishments at each of those positions - and often that means projects that improved things - made the systems more stable, saved the company money, and so on. That is what we are looking for - acheivers. Your current resume says you filled a role, it doesn't tell me how you excelled in the role. And thats what you need to do to stand out among the 500 resumes that hit my desk.
James
by rclark2
The company is locally headquartered, but globally scoped. So I was interested. I did the phone interview. The IT director on the other end obviously either was very, very good, or didn't know a thing about computers. But ok, I can do the no glory thing if it pays enough.
So I wrote out an employment contract with no frills but locking everything down with the "The company shall provide....." verbage and sent it to the recruiter. He calls back and says this won't do, that the company will negotiate all this stuff but won't be locked into it on the getgo. Told him not to call back until he had a prospect that wasn't afraid to sign on the dotted line for what it promised. Haven't heard from him again.
by pgm554
Ex2K3 was product of the year in 2003 and it wasn't out of beta according to Infoworld.
The recruiter is full of sh!t and hasn't a clue.
They did the same thing when AD was introduced in W2K server.
They were asking to to 3 years experience on a product released in 2000 in the calender year 2000.
by ic-it
First, you are responding to a thread that is 17 months old.
Second, consider their points; it is a waste of the recruiters and the potential recruitee's time and energy to forward asinine opportunities to them. They clearly do not want, nor would they desire a position that they are either not qualified for, or is clearly below their parameters (which have been clearly defined).
Perhaps you should re-read this thread to understand the thinking of potential candidates. Especially if you are a recruiter. This would give you a bit of insight on how to screen jobs and applicants in order to land the big fish rather than to keep on insulting them and forever losiing the opportunity to work with them.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Trending Software posts
Sort by Trending