Are there any good managers left?
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
IT Employment
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by old-timer
Same ole' same ole'. After 20 years it never changes.
We the unwilling; managed by the clueless.
by maldain
There are a couple of issues you raise. The hair's on fire kind of management style is typical of small to medium sized shops which are understaffed, under trained and miss applied. That means the hair really is on fire and it's not just a managment approach.
The phone calls every 5 minutes about a specific project usually means that the project is more politically charged than normal.
As far as committing to provide a service or impletmenting a solution with out talking to staff every manager on earth does this and always has reguardless of the field. The fact is these decisions are generally made in a meeting where this idea is sprung on the manager and a response is demanded. Your job is to help your manager out of the mess by either delivering or coming up with a reasonable explaination why the service or solution can't be delivered with in the requested time frame or if it can't ever be delivered. All of these happen to good managers. The difference is that with the good managers they don't get paniced by them and they don't pass the panic down the food chain. The bad managers do panic and do panic the troops which causes the failure of the project.
As far as a lack of respect, welcome to the IT world where everybody who's ever picked up and glanced through a copy of PC Magazine feels they know how to do your job better than you do. It's the only profession in the world where Joe from marketing will put in his two cents on the approaches to a project just be cause he knows where the power switch on his monitor is located. That's the life you chose it's just the way it is and by the way while Joe in marketing thinks he knows your job, he's downright positive he knows your bosses job.
Just a word about myself I started writing assembler business programs back in the late 1970's. I also wrote micro-code for terminal controllers (we'd call them servers now). I coded in everything from machine language to APL to SQL. I became a database administrator back in the early 90's and am currently in charge of a data center with a few hundred servers. I'm responsible for the operations, applications and user perception of my department. And yes even the owner's secretary believes she knows more about my job than I do. The only one that doesn't believe that is my boss. Guess what he's the only one that counts.
by plodge
by avid
by conquistador
by golfloon
Judging by the comments I have seen here I am appalled by the huge rift that seems to still be dividing our profession. On one hand we have managers taking the high ground and on the other technical staff who feel undervalued.
As an IT Manager I know my ability to deliver is based largely on the very able team of people who work for me.
Whilst I was once technical the reason I can still command respect from my team is not the fact that I can configure a cluster but the fact that I listen to them, I take time to understand their problems and above all I take the flack when things go wrong or the heat is on.
I communicate upwards and don't constantly ask for updates from my team as they understand the importance of communication and update me with any progress as soon as it happens in a crisis situation.
At the end of the day good managers still exist as do good techies the really sad thing is as a profession the one skill we seem to have lost is the art of communication.....
by pedwards17
I couldn't agree more, and it does appear as though we baby-boomers are the parents at fault. I think it's the responsibility of every generation to make it better for the following generation. The main difference, as I see it, is that the baby-boomers KNOW they have it better than their parents. The offspring of baby-boomers believe that they DESERVE to have it better than their parents, hence the entitlement. I'm sick of it.
I'll stop now.
by stephen
Hey sorry to break this to you, but it's not just IT that has bad managers. At the ripe old age of 34, I've been in the Army, IT recruitment, IT support, dot.coms and various other jobs/roles and can tell you that bad managers are in every field, in every career. Ask a mechanic, plumber, doctor, solicitor etc if they have bad managers who want something done yesterday, loose it in a crisis etc, they all do because these are management, no... human failings that everyone has!
Perhaps you think you'll be a better manager when it's your turn?????
We all think that, but where do these "bad" mangers come from??????????? These managers probably thought the same way you did when they were young, what's to say you wont end up the same?
Stephen
by cottay
Work, all things considered both the good and the bad, should be a positive factor in your life. If it isn?t, change it. If you can?t change it, find other work.
If, along the way, you get fired ? and many a good person does get fired ? make sure you are fired for reasons of which you can be rightfully proud.
In your situation, I would suggest these steaps.
1) Stay aware of the job market and your many potential niches within it.
2)Seriously ask yourself what behaviors of yours are contributing to current problems. Do what you can to change them. Document your efforts.
3)Seriously ask yourself what new behaviors of yours could perhaps make the situation better. Do what you can to make them happen. Document your efforts.
4) If you are still unhappy on the job, find other work just as quickly as possible before some important part of you dies.
On my first job out of college I felt much the same way. I do not know how you are, but I was eager, and very intuitive. I hated "office politics" with a passion then and still do some 25 years later.
I had almost a sixth sense. I spotted the major problems the company had, and acurately predicted what must be done to rectify them. And when I tried to put forward my ideas, I was poo-poo'ed simply because of my age and supposed "lack of experience". Hogwash. You will likely find that your age and lack of experience will be used as an excuse by those who are threatened by your insights. Within 6 months of my analysis, the directors fired the CEO. The new CEO came in fresh, just as I did, performed an analysis, just as I did, and then implemented every corrective measure I had recommended (and then some!).
You must be VERY careful who you express ideas to. If you choose not to play office politics, fine - but you must at least be aware of who is who at the zoo. If you say the wrong thing to the wrong person you could get fired. Or even worse, you could have a "more experienced" co-worker steal your idea and take credit for it. That happened to me a couple of times. When you protest, it is like there is a mental block in many managers that you could not possibly come up with a good idea because you are so "wet behind the ears".
This is not to say that every idea you have is good. Sometimes management does not communicate the "big picture", and you don't know the whole story.
Basically, the best advice I can give is cover your butt. Document everything you can IN WRITING. Don't let people take credit for your work and ideas. And practice prevention - know who's who, be aware of office politics. But some times you simply will not be one of what I call "the chosen" or "the pets". Some people have honed the fine are of butt kissing to a science. You will not move your career forward being around such people - or the managers that allow themselves to be kissed up to like that.
And finally, you need to consider the excellent advice others have offered here! Sometimes a bad manager literally creates a "toxic" work environment. If it is clear that upper management is not going to do anything to remove this person - or worse if upper management IS the problem, then you might seriously consider a change of work venue! You know what they say, it is easier to get a jon while you have one!
hth
Five years of experience as you say. Give me a break and grow up. You are going to find out the hard way in life that the world does not go the way we want it. Get some experience first, learn a little humility and patience.
You're 23 and yes, you still don't know everything. We ALL have something to learn
The world is far more complex than you could ever imagine and not quite as simple as you think it might be.
Remember this as well. When life serves you lemons, make lemonade!
by old guy
About a year ago I had a co-worker do this to me. It was our Operaitons Manager (who is NOT part of senior management). I was a seasoned coordinator who was also the acting department head (different department). He made a commitment that required me to drop everything "at once" so that I could do my part prior to delivery to a customer.
When I called him on it - in front of the company owner - he tried to make light of it. I was VERY firm with him about this. I insisted that he NEVER make such a commitment involving MY time without at least asking me first. In this case I had already made commitments regarding my time.
Because of this man's inconsideration, I had to call in favours to reschedule other people and projects - all to accomodate his offhand attitude.
I gave it to him with both barrels right in front of "the boss" - "You don't make commitments involving my time without asking first - this is a matter of respect and I refuse to be treated like this! Don't do it again."
Funny thing, he has never done it since. The worst part is that he is a fair bit older than me (late 50's) and has, supposedly, had much more experience than I. This is something I would NEVER do! It is a provervial no-no. On the whole he does his job well, but he has to be watched like a hawk. If he thinks he can by-pass policy or procedure to take a short-cut to suit himself - he will. Sometimes he gets caught, and it leaves me wondering what we might eventually find out after he has retired!
Be that as it may, as a professional you deserve respect regardless of your age. Just make sure you SHOW the same respect for those that have been around longer than you have.
If you cannot get treated with respect by your co-workers and management refuses to rectify the situation, then it is time to polish up the resume.
If you can get that respect, then try to align yourself with someone who is on the inside track - perhaps someone that can mentor you. This does not have to be your boss. It could be someone who you get along with that is in another part of the company. Once you have established a level of trust with this person, express your concerns and LISTEN to the advice that you get in return.
As others have said, bad managers are everywhere, in every work place, and in every profession. The best you can do is learn to navigate around them, and - hopefully - learn not to get used by them.
by ajebakumar
Hi There,
Calm Down Mate, We are the HI Tech Labour Force That includeds me :) (I call it any way). :(
by desmodeus
by jennyn
I have seen good & bad.
Firstly:
"I get frustrated by low pay, a company who does not wish to invest in me, managers who throw me into... "
If this is your work environment, this is probably your manager's too. They may not be trained on how to manage, how to build a team, how to communicate or any of the necessary skills for thier job. They may have just been good techs, good visionaries, good initiators or just good schmoozers. Unfortunately management skills don't necessarily come with the above, and need to be learned and supported. If you want to be a good manager in future - get cracking on developing the right skills for it.
On to your criteria for bad managers:
"inability to grasp basic tech details" this is not necessarily a managers job. You will find that after you've been in the biz 10+yrs, you aren't so interested in the all the little tech details. That's what your team is for. They can hold that knowledge. The manager holds the big pic. Just take a look at old GW Bush - plenty of vacations - not so much concern for details... the little folks look after those.
2. "solutions for which staff doesn't have adequate knowledge" unfortunately this is true of most new tech solutions. They are normally a learning process for EVERYONE. Expect a life-time of that.
3. "failure to consult staff" - this is a managed hierarchy, not a cooperative. I have a cooperative management style & I like flat teams. I'm lucky enough to work in a flat team now. Both flat and hierarchy have their pros & cons. Perhaps what you are experiencing is a manager with poor listening skills. It is a good thing for a manager to hear the concerns of a team - even if those do not sway the final decision.
The other two are certainly issues often called - "crisis based management" and "micro management".
Go learn some organizational development (OD)theory, and some grounding in group dynamics to go with your tech skills, and you can be the manager you never had.
This can also give you a keen insight into where your org is going and what they might need to get there, and you can become highly respected by other non-tech managers and be set for future IS director.
The whole of his writing indicates a company run under "total crisis management".
How do companies survive, obtain and retain good wpoeple when all they do is careen from one crisis to another?
by maldain
by keyguy13
Nothing here that a solid dose of Project Management couldn't cure.
A decent PM certified project manager and an assembled team should be able to exorcise the "total crisis management" you are experiencing.
by ou jipi je
This discussion is seriously starting to resemble the british sitcom "The Office". Yes, there is a moon, the grass is green and bad managers exist.
Answer your self three questions and you will never post a useless post like this again:
1.) What is important _to you_?
2.) What are you afraid off?
3.) What is the problem, really than?
Howgh.
Do they ever practice what they preach? Hell no,when they fail to get all the customer's info..that's o.k. but when an employee doesn't get all the customer's info..different story!
And why can't a manager answer the phone or dial a phone number!
The manager knows all under his/her charge is their personal resonsibility, and the members of the crew are joint owners - the manager is presumed to be able to do all task he/she expects and needs members of their crew to do. a rewarder, and mentor.
The khan takes no personal responsibility for either the crew or the work, usually a punisher and not a rewarder, usually a finger pointer not a mentor.
by professordnm
Re: amcol
"The younger generation. My God, what have we as parents done to you that you all have this insanely overdeveloped sense of entitlement and self-assured smug arrogance? "
Maybe we should have sold these children to passing caravans in the night?
by raycatch9
by golfloon
Whilst I am business savvy enough to read a balance sheet and P&L and understand that technology is a business enabler not the end product. I still run with the ball and lead from the front and challenge bureacracy at every turn.
As for being castrated I haven't found a CFO big enough or brave enough to try yet.....
by n_clarke
Jim,
One of the things I take pride in is my respect of others and their opinions, you obviously have issues with certain aspects of my posting, however they are just my menial moanings in a discussion that I thought I might be able to contribute.
How did your reply contribute to this posting?
I found my style of management got the best out of the team I was leading and surpassed all KPI's, I have worked my way up to become a director of every company I have worked for.
I have tried several styles of leadership and I have found this one works best for me. I ensure everyone is rewarded for what they do, its the team that get the fat bonus at the end of the year and everyone performs to the best of their ability.
Every one is different. I respect your comments but until you have experienced my management style in person, you really have no grounds for comment.
And yes there are positions available.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending