25 replies
by itisforme
You stated "I have an employee" are you his boss? What is the Gender break down of both your department and the company a.k.a. how many men and how many women? What is his title and job duties? What is his rank in the department? Can you give a couple examples of his "Bad Attitude"? Are there others past or present that also have bad attitudes? Is there any thing going on in either the department or company that could be a catalyst? What are his skills? Is he a specialist? Are you getting complaints about him from others? What do they say? What is his salary and work load? How does his salary and work load compare to the others in the department. How long has he been employed at the company, position and department? Did he replace someone? If he replaced someone why did they leave?
What you have stated so far is just to vague for me to comment on with out more information.
Is the person a friend or relative or a relative of a friend of your boss or a VP or someone in HR? This would be a department managers' nightmare. I've often thought about how I would deal with a bad but protected employee, Maybe you can isolate him from the rest of the department. Put him on duties that don't require a lot of interaction with the rest of the department.
I've always thought that an employee who was hard to work with should be dismissed on the grounds that their behavior negatively impacts the work and morale of the other people in the department, as well as people in other departments that have to interact with this person.
Legally this URL may help:
//www.myemploymentlawyer.com/
You could search Google for similar legal assistance web sites.
Good luck.
by jrowe
by judy62
by jimhm
I am with the other posters - need more details about it .... to highlevel - swag would be given (Scientific Wild Arse Guess)...
1) You appear to be female (by handle) - was he up for the position you are holding? Was he passed over for a promotion you gave to another women? What is the Mix of Male/Female management (is the major female since you took over?)
2) Is there a home problem occuring in his life? Is a someone in his family termially ill? Sick Child? Sick Spouse? Sick Parent?
3) What type of bad attitude does he present? Is it that he doesn't appreciate stupid questions or is it any question? (How about some examples of his behavor) ...
4) Is it personality between you and him? Do you present a challenge? (Nothing personal but) Where the two of you hooked up before and had a falling out?
We need much more than what you have provided - please adedum the post with the additional info and the TR's will be more than happy to prove our 2 cents / Shillings / dracma's / franc's - whatever to your problem/solution.
by sleepin'dawg
1: Drugs and/or alcohol - if so shape up or ship out. Try to be supportive but unless a demonstrable effort is shown then it,s time for the door to be shown. You didn't poor it down his throat nor did you stick it in his arm. You and the others are entitled to a safe and secure work environment.
2: Bi-polar disease- under no circumstances should he/she be confronted alone.
As with everyone else I would say a lot of info is needed before any reply is possible.:|
by judy62
Yes you are correct.
1. He was never offered the position. I am his Manager and I have another 4 males in my team, none of which I have any issues with. I am only one of around 8 girls in the entire IT department of about 40 staff.
2. He lives with his wife and 2 daughters. I have an understanding there are issues at home, but that is exactly where they should remain.
3. He is rude and abrupt to not only myself, but other team members and IT staff. My boss and HR have labelled him to have a 'disability' as he is not able to handle difficult situations or admitt when he makes a mistake.
He is a 'Senior Operator', responsible for all overnight processing, backups etc. A big responsibility.
4. HR believe that we have a personality clash. I have never nor will I ever have any involvement with him. We have a saying here in down under land of "small man syndrome", which I believe is what his problem is.
He is very shortly going to be formally warned about a serious performance issue, and to this day he still believes he did not make the error. How do you deal with someone like that.
I have ried to speak with this person, who only errupts into a very vocal response. One can take being yelled at for no reason so long. I have formally raised this with HR, but I believe it is going to get me nowhere.
He works 12hr shifts, mainly nights. He is on approx $60,000 AUD, if that make any difference.
by knudsenmj
Bad news is, you can't do anything about him being foul tempered and generally unpleasant.
Good news is that you can manage specific behaviors.
Outline what specific behaviors you find unacceptable. I would imagine these would be something like:
- yelling
- swearing
- leaving meetings before they are over (storming out of the room)
You can tell him that specific behaviors are not tolerated and call him on it when he does them. It's much more difficult to tell someone they cannot be angry or confrontational since these are less easily measured.
by jimhm
Sounds like to me there could be a couple of issues, brewing under his belt - that have nothing to do with the office.
First: When you speek with him - I would have a HR representative with you :D I would make sure it was a male from HR, just for your own safety.
When speaking with him - I would define the inappro behavors you have witnessed (dates and what) - Then explain what is appro behavors you will accept from a suborinate - what you will not accept - and what will happen the next time he act inappro to you or any of your staff. HR can back you up here -
It could be he is tired of working late shift and needs to switch to daylight - maybe 12 hour days are getting to him - Does your company have a policy of 8 hours except ot as needed. Could be a family problem with his wife messing around on him while he is at work?
And be careful of the Short man - thing - that is liable in the USA - and you would be doing the same thing he is - except you are representing the company. Keep a professional attitute during this entire event - do not stoop to his level - You and the Company will Lose big time...
Just from the info - It sounds like to me; he having some family problems or a drug problem. Does you company have a drug testing policy? - There is something underlying this behavor - I don't think its you or the other employees - its just he is under stress from somewhere.
A big mistake you are making is believing that HR Hype that - problems at Home Stay at Home... They never do and never will - just like problems at work should stay at work - Never do.
Think for a second - If your husband or child is very sick and in hospital - do you truly leave that at the front door of your home when you go to the office? - If you husband was cheating on you - while your at the office (he works nights you days) you wouldn't think about that during office hours, you wouldn't be under additional stress?
You have some great ideas - then pump out that HR bull crape about "Problems from home - stay at Home." - and shortman thing. That is BS - from the mouths of the Heartless HR department... and only a fool would believe that, and caution - you are and the company are walking on liable grounds of "Labelling Him" - at least in the USA you are. I am sure Down Under you would be there also... Stay Professional - Keep your Cool -
Offer assistance from the company - this keeps you and the company always on the side of supporting your employee
Best of luck ... :)
by itisforme
by judy62
He works three 12 hour shifts a week. It is also his choice to do a vast majority of nights.
Total hours 36.
Company policy, he has to work 37.5hrs a week. He makes up the extra hours by working one saturday in five for around 8hrs.
by itisforme
Well from what you have given us to work with it sounds as if this guy has a medical issue that both your Boss and the HR person are aware of. They seem content to let the chips fall where they may with this guy. You have pled your case and have been over ruled. I wouldn?t press the issue much further.
It sure sounds like you are going to need to grin and bare it with this one. You are his supervisor and it is a shame that things have been so politicized that you can't be informed in confidence of what the issue is and why they are going to accept it. If you knew the symptoms you could learn how to see the signs and avoid some of the abuse. You would also have the ability to learn how to avoid the catalysts that provoke his illness and cause his abusive behavior. Keep in mind that normal behavior is different from abnormal behavior do to an illness. What would seem as a just or proper response to the situation just isn?t so and it?s unfair to all those who suffer from not being given the knowledge to deal with and avoid it. I would demand that they find several ways for you and the rest of the folks to have some sort of reprieve from him. They owe all of you that much. You need to be able to just walk away or close the door with out their retribution. You should also be able to ignore him as if he were not their with out their retribution. All of you need safe zones where he is not privileged to be so you can get away from the abuse. By saying ?their and they? I?m referring to your Boss and the HR person. I hope that they would not go as far as to punish someone who harshly verbally returned the favor to this guy seeing how they have you all handcuffed and blindfolded. You certainly have my sympathy, you are in a difficult situation.
by judy62
I had every intention of the performance management with related to our company policy and principle of good conduct. However I was 'not allowed' to do this by not only my manager but HR. 'Lets just have a coffee and a chat' alot of good that did, he still continues to do and say as he pleases. They sent him on a Stress Management course, but from everything I can see and hear, that was just a waist of time and money.
I have to deal with him as though he has a 'disability'. I have now no faith in HR our other managers. What do I do now???
by judy62
by dilbert-tom
Have you tried a supportive approach, such as "You seem to Anger quickly, why are you angry ? Can we do anything to help ? Have you checked with your Doctor to see if a chemical imbalance may be causing depressed behavior ?"
All HR can deal with is specific issues of "Harrasment" or "Threatening Workplace", and the way to get those reported is to encourage co-workers to make specific complaints to HR (best if using the words in quotes above in the specific complaints - because there is Federal Law that applies to these, which would be all that HR really cares about - minimizing litigation or Federal investigations regarding "Safe Workplace". Once several workers have made formal complaints, HR will take increased interest, especially if repeated complaints are escalated to State and Federal authorities.
If HR discovers that you are encouraging such complaints, they will work to assure you do not prosper there, however.
I relate this to a case I knew of involving such a worker, who was subsequently diagnosed as Bi-Polar. Medicated, he was much less of a problem - but he would also stop taking medication and become a problem again... after three co-workers complained of feeling that they were threatened while he was not taking his medication - he was terminated. HR's concerns are again to minimize litigation, and to assure that enough documentation is filed to prevent former employee from suing for "Wrongful Termination" while assuring that no litigation was initiated by threatened employees. HR is really concerned with legalities, and not perormance issues per se.
by joyp007
by judy62
This person thought he had it over everyone, until I was moved in to a project for 3 months. He then reported to another Manager, who basically told him a few home truths and within 48 hours he had resigned and was marched from the premises.
Was I pleased, you bet, but believe it or not, my career has now suffered as a result. Just goes to show if someone does not want you to excel, especially if you are female, no matter what you do or say, your career is ruined.
I now report to another manager, who totally disagrees with everything that has happened to me in the past 6 months. We both now have to prove to the 'powers that be' they were all wrong.
by slapdash
I am a male in a company with more females in top management.
I feel the same way you do.
If you are not part of the "clique" you dont grow much in my company in terms of Sallary, recognition etc.
But you have to grow above it and concentrate / spend energy on more positive or constructive things.
by jennl
Judy62,
I hope the others in the department realize you are trying to do something about the situation and how your hands are tied. I work with someone who constantly swears and has an extremely negative attitude - it's enough to make me not want to come in! Everyone knows about his walkabouts, long periods of time strolling around the building and causing trouble - yet nothing ever seems to be done. I have to hope something is being addressed privately... it is so hard for me to keep a positive outlook and still perform at 100+% when you've got someone with a bad attitude that close.
by mrafrohead
Does he have any actual doctor found problems?
If not, fire his ass. If so, you're playing a scary game...
by judy62
I just want to thank all who have posted their thoughts and ideas.
I am hopefully moving on to bogger and better things with a new manager.
Thanks alot.
by jonas g
by judy62
As it so happens, this particular individual eventually resign, however, not after he got in every males ear on the floor. It was because of him, that I was eventually made redundant. I far as I am concerned, it is the laymans excuse for saying you are fired/sacked.
If I every see him of the so Manager I ended up with, it will not be too soon. This manager hated all females that were in a management position under him. I was the last to go, so now he is happy.
If only I could express in words, my exact thoughts on both these men.
Sorry to all you law abiding males, but this really gripes me to no end.
by win
by judy62
Thanks. I know, not all males managers are like that.
Anyway, I am now working for a wonderful bunch of people, in an all male environment.
Cheers
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Trending IT Employment posts
Sort by Trending