28 replies
Isn't what all those 'town hall' meetings this summer were for, so they could listen to their constituents?
I agree they need to drop the partisan bickering but if they didn't listen earlier, what's to gain by giving them an excuse to stall even longer? This type of legislation has been under debate since the first Clinton administration, if not before. Haven't we had a long enough period of (not) listening to the people?
I've got a better idea than waiting until after Christmas: DON'T GO HOME AT ALL UNTIL YOU FINISH THE DAMN JOB WE'RE PAYING YOU TO DO. I don't care what the results are any more, just take some kind of action. Time to stop cutting bait and start fishing, and don't stop until you've put dinner on the table.
by jdclyde
Should there be back room deals that payoff "holdouts" to get the votes?
Is it really valid that a single state should be exempt from State contributions for proposed Medicade increases, when all the rest are not?
Even in the same party, it is all politics and corrupt payoffs to move this from a bi-partisan effort to stop the legislation to a partisan effort to rush it through.
But that doesn't make this legislation different from any other. Why choose this legislation as the one where the buck suddenly stops? Look at any defense bill; they're always porked up with hardware the DoD insists it doesn't want but keeps constituents employed.
A 'line item' veto is the only solution to that problem, but Congress is too obsessed with preserving its own power to pass a version the Supremes won't find violates the separation of powers. Hell, we have a line item veto here in SC and the legislation still overrides 90% of the vetoes, so even that may not work.
Regardless, taking more time off won't strip the fat out of the bill. Indeed, it will give them opportunities to stuff in even more lard.
by jdclyde
You have a great idea, and it should be a requirement, but it isn't the real solution.
The REAL solution is to ban campaign contributions from any entity not registered to vote in the candidate's district.
by jck
Members of Congress should not be allowed to hold jobs with:
- any organization
- parent of an organization
- child of an organization
- any organization in which said organization has any holding/investment in
If the primary organization has, during their tenure, donated monies or other form of compensation, to their campaign or to any group or organization which gives or handles contributory stakes for the congressperson or their party from the time the congressperson first runs for office until they leave office.
That keeps them from taking that "cush job" when they get out of Congress for 6-7 figures a year for being a "good friend to the cause".
You have to stop the money letting all together. Otherwise, you would have that.
Or, they would just all run on campaigns funded by front companies established in their district.
Happens all the time with LLCs here in Florida.
by tonythetiger
by tonythetiger
by jck
Do you think you could live with just the tax monies collected by your locality?
I think after you saw the degrade in roads and services in your area that are paid for by personal and corporate tax dollars from states like NY, CA, TX, IL, FL and PA...you would change your tune.
Almost 50 percent of your nations population are in those states, and that is where the majority of this country's tax dollars come from.
I believe once the reality of Ohio only having Ohio resources hit home in about a decade and your interstates and local roads and police departments and fire departments were deficient, you'd probably want back federal taxes.
Or are you happy with potholes and sub-standard public services?
by av .
They need to pass health care legislation. Its too bad the Republicans decided to sit on the sideline again. All they talk about is whats wrong with the bill instead of trying to work on making it better.
AV
What about the Dems originally opposed to this legislation, who knuckled under to special considerations for their states and districts? Do you think they'd still think this was such a great bill if their pork was trimmed?
There isn't two cents worth of difference between how the parties treat us.
by jck
gives ya a list of some concessions that were made.
by jdclyde
As from the beginning, the Republicans have never had the ability to stop anything about this bill.
It has been up to this point, a bi-partisan effort to keep this from steamrolling through in a cloud of secrecy from our new "transparent" Administration.
Other point, we are not talking about Health CARE legislation, but Health INSURANCE legislation. I have seen nothing to make me think this will make health care better, or reduce the costs other than to bury costs in the tax code so we pay more, but indirectly.
by jck
I recently got a personal letter from my representative in the House of Representatives. She and I correspond quite a bit on various issues.
I told her that I was not happy right now with Republicans or Democrats.
Republicans want to axe out everything that they don't like (which doesn't do what their corporate friends want).
Democrats want to put in too much plus are bickering amongst themselves about what should get left in (again, to make corporate friends happy).
I told her that 2 things need to happen in healthcare reform.
a) The waste and fraud have to get stopped, or at least minimized.
b) People need to be given basic healthcare so that things from simple colds to potential outbreaks of highly communicable things can be stopped, e.g.- TB, MRSA, H1N1, etc.
I want America to have simple healthcare, whether it is that they get to go to their own doctor of choice for checkups and get free basic antibiotics or cold meds, or they go to state-run clinics for free which would take the task of routine basic healthcare off the privatized medical community and insurers.
Either way, both sides need to get their head out of their butts and get things done that will matter and cut the costs of the damned program rather than letting it run on to 2013 or 2014 like it is written to do.
by jdclyde
"If the primary organization has, during their tenure, donated monies or other form of compensation, to their campaign..."
'Organizations' cannot register to vote. If an entity cannot registered to vote in the candidate's district, it should not be allowed to make campaign contributions. No businesses, no lobbies, no non-profits, no unions, no PACs, no one living in another district. If you aren't registered to vote in a district, you cannot donate money to those seeking to represent it.
by jck
"Or, they would just all run on campaigns funded by front companies established in their district."
Got a neighboring district sewn up for your party?
Hire people from outside the district...to...say stuff envelopes.
Rent them housing in your district for $100 a month.
They can establish residency there, even though they may not live there.
Another way to get around it: college kids. Their permanent residence is not in your district, but since they are "full-time" residents at the university they attend they can switch to vote in that district.
There are a LOT of ways you can get around things.
Hell, they had hundreds of dead people voting for George Bush in West Palm county down here in 2000. That got overlooked because of their crappy punchcard voting system.
You never know what lengths SIGs and PACs will go to for their "friend of the cause" in politics.
BTW...I am totally against a union or any other representative organization in the workplace taking bulk contributions from employees and allocating it either one way or the other. I've seen that all too often, and I think it unfair.
by jdclyde
I thought Mr Hope N' Change was suppose to end that, instead of leading the way, full speed ahead?
There is an interesting quote from him in 07, claiming that the reason the Clinton Health Insurance efforts failed was because they did it in secret backroom deals, instead of in the open, with every meeting on CSPAN.
Just more empty talk, business as usual.
Why should we start now? How about the price tag on this?
by jck
a) Obama controls Congress about as much as Bush did. You forgave President "Noo-Kyoo-Lurr" Bush and a Republican congress for sending people to the Middle East to die over oil money for years. At least Hope N' Change is trying to change things for the better.
b) Read the NY Times. They document what backdoor deals have been made. And oh, btw. Utah and Wyoming (both states have 2 Republican senators) are getting millions in kickbacks. Don't think that was a "backroom" deal?
You need to write your senators too. Seems they got a big juicy package for Michigan.
Maybe chastising the naughty kids in the school who misbehave rather than the class president for their actions is the right thing to do?
Of course, I have to say this: Obama better get a better strategy than what Axelrod said it is in DC. Otherwise, he's gonna be a better-educated, better-articulating, younger version of Bush in the end.
Oh, and one other thing.
Obama has pushed for $871B in 10 years on medical reform that will save $100Bs.
Bush pushed for $750B on corporate bailouts that are never guaranteed to be repaid, and if they are return no interest.
by jck
preventative does more good usually (medically and fiscally) than on-demand care.
Both for contagious disease as well as diagnosis of unknown conditions.
Case in point: prostate checks, mammograms, pap smears, etc.
The rallying point isn't the issue. Congress needs to worry less about what "rallies" are going on, and do their jobs.
And yes, it needs to be the simple, regular care.
Don't believe me? Go look at the numbers of people who die of breast, ovarian, cervical, prostate, colon and rectal cancers every year because they didn't have health insurance to pay for a $50 screening...or could have been educated about the signs and symptoms of what to check for themselves.
You catch it early, it's almost always treatable. That's what "routine" exams are for. That's basic, or simple, health care.
by tonythetiger
[i]Do you think you could live with just the tax monies collected by your locality?[/i]
I meant that almost the same amount of total tax be taken out, and most of it kept locally and in the state instead of sending it to the fed.
by jck
Look at everything the "fed" pays for via grants, etc., in your state.
The states with the most to gain from those are ones with high unemployment, high home foreclosures, etc., since you're not paying as much federal or state or county taxes in.
Ohio, MI, CA, and FL all fall in that category.
Texas and NY are not suffering near as bad, since their economies are stronger.
But, that'd be up to you. I'm sure that the rest of the US would be okay with Ohio deciding how to fund all their own projects without the financial backing of workers across the nation.
Personally, I say we ban lawyers from running for office. Or, anyone with higher than a Bachelor's degree.
Seems this country got screwed up by letting the over-educated, aristocratic, and legally "adept" (notice the quotes) run this country.
Make a difference. Send a farmer to congress. :)
I favor requiring some form of national service before being allowed to run for Congress or president. Either military, Peace Corps, or similar service.
But then, I favor requiring that in general.
by tonythetiger
[i]Look at everything the "fed" pays for via grants, etc., in your state.[/i]
We could do it ourselves, without paying the fed to handle the money on the way out and on the way back in.
[i]Seems this country got screwed up by letting the over-educated, aristocratic, and legally "adept" (notice the quotes) run this country.[/i]
Narrow that down to "people who like to think they know what's better for people than those people themselves."
I know a young mother who was afraid to put her bay down on the floor. he was three years old and couldn't walk. She was arrested, charged, and convicted of criminal neglect for not allowing him the chance to learn to move around on his own. I think these "do-gooders" should be similarly charged!
[i]Make a difference. Send a farmer to congress.[/i]
Reminds me of one of my pet peeves... Why basic gardening isn't REQUIRED to be taught in schools is beyond me. There aren't many people in this country eight years old or older who couldn't be taught how to grow most of their own food, and spending less than an hour a day doing it! How many billions of dollars a year could be saved?
by dwdino
This bill and this "representative" body should be done away with. Both are appauling (save a few).
This bill has only one goal - authority. It has nothing to do with helping the needy, nor improving health care, nor controlling costs. Its goal is to centralize authority and create dependents.
It is also illegal.
It is time for the American people to take action since the "representatives" have failed us.
1) Remove all beneficiaries of any pork or add ons during next election cycle. (Failure to represent)
2) Remove all supporters of the bill during next election cycle. (Public opionion opposes bill. Failure to represent.)
3) File your next tax form (W-4) as exempt.
The American people have been lazy and the storm is approaching. We are about to receive what we have asked for, and many will be doomed.
Edited for errors.
I agreed with the notion that if people wanted to continue electing a rep, that was their choice, however ill-advised.
Recently I changed my mind. The rules governing the House and Senate reward seniority. Them that's been there longest gets the mostest. It benefits the constituents to repeatedly elect the same bum, not because of his experience but because he eventually becomes a big enough hog to get the most from the trough.
This leaves at least two choices. Change the rules so power is evenly spread across all members, and we know they won't do that. The other option is limit the number of years an elected official can serve. That one we may have some control over. There are probably other options; I'd be interested in seeing them.
by notsochiguy
The problem on setting term limits is that you'd have to find politicians willing to vote for it.
I almost think we'll see the Presidential limit of 2 terms eased before we see those bums limit themselves.
by tonythetiger
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Trending After Hours posts
Sort by Trending