Discussion Locked

Best Way to Install an OS?

0 helpful
10 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have a debate going on here regarding the best way to install an OS on a standard desktop workstation. I would like to ask for the forum to settle the debate. ;-)

My side of the argument:
Install a single partition to the primary HD, and load Windows XP onto the full capacity of the partition, labeling it C:

The other side:
Paritition two segements on the primary HD, loading XP on the 2nd partition, and DOS on the first. The idea being that DOS can be used to recover the second partition if things go bad.

Let 'er rip...

10 replies

by ltop

Hi,

My preference,

Create a C: partition on the primary and install XP and all relevant service packs, software, etc, onto it.

Then create another partition of approx same size.

Take an image of C: partition (using ghost or whatever flavour software you prefer) and place it on the second partition.

Give the user a third partition for them to save all their data onto that they want.

Burn a copy of the image onto disc. If there is plent of space inside the workstation case, and without covering any ventilation openings, or getting in the way of any cabling, etc, tape the cd/dvd to the case so it doesn't slide around.

If anything goes wrong with the drive or the partition, you know there is a copy of the image in the case and you don't have to look around for it amongst the hundreds of discs (I have) you may have lying around.

Although unlike me, most of you are probably better organised and have a filing system.

cheers

by cg it

My preference is having 2 drives. On the first I create C: partition of about 20 to 25 GB. Install the O/S on it and all hotfixes, service packs, yadda. This leaves enough room for whatever comes down the pipe in service packs, hotfixes and the page file [unless I have a fast drive somewhere else.

I then create another partition where I install all programs. On the second drive I create a partition and this is wwhere all documents are saved [I change where documents, pictures, music files, vid files anything I don't want to lose is on this partition.

I also leave about 5 GB of free space on each drive.
This way if the O/S takes a dump I can reinstall it without losing critical data. I don't use dynamic discs so if I happen to run out of room on the C: I can use some free space and parititon commander to increase the size of C: [or D or whatever partition is on the drive that houses C:

If I need to dual boot to gain access I've got 5 GB to install a minimal XP [or W2K] on either drive.

[I use this same setup for single drives where critial data is not on C but another partition]

by hal 9000

Well that would work but it's not my preferred option as DOS is unable to read NTFS partitions so if you are using an OS like NT, Y2K, XP the DOS partition will be useless.

I always try where possible to have at least 2 HDD's installed as I do not like different partitions on the same drive as it slows down the system as the one drive attempts to read both partitions. I keep Windows on the first drive and all the programs and Data on the second HDD and make sure that regular backup are done as failing drives are not an uncommon occurrence. I currently have a customer with a 40 GIG IBM Death-star who can verify this. He did regular backups of his business data but forgot about all the other data on the Drive like pictures of his Grandchildren and the like so when the drive died he lost all of his non business data currently he is complaining about the cost of recovering that data. :D

If I have to gain access to a dead drive I either fit it to another computer to recover data off it or use a Live Linux CD to access the contents of the HDD and write them to another form of media. Of course that only works if the Windows installation has been corrupted and the system will no longer boot from the Windows drive. If there has been physical damage to the HDD there is very little that you can do.

Col

by wcp

It all depends on what you want and how you are willing to organize.
The simplest way is one partition and this fits to most users.

The other side is to partition the following way. Why stop at two?

1. C: (Fat32) Minimum of 125MB. This is the System partition with Boot files; boot.ini, NTLDR, and Ntdetect.com. If any of these files gets corrupted, Windows does not boot and you resolve the problem by replacing the file(s) with a Windows 98 Startup disk. All you need is to copy those files to a Windows 98 Startup disk when you first installed Windows.

2. D: (NTFS) this is the Boot partition with System files (Windows or Winnt folder).

3. E: (NTFS) Program partition. This is where all programs will be installed.

4. F: (NTFS) Data partition. This is where all the data are created including My Documents. Data backup will be a lot easier because you know where all your data are.

5. G: (NTFS) this is for the Page file. By assigning the page file in a separate partition, it will never be fragmented.

6. H: (NTFS) this is an unallocated partition of at least 2GB in case you need a parallel installation of Windows to repair your original Windows or to access your data.
Better yet, install Windows here right after the original Windows installation and hide it from Boot.ini. If Windows does not boot and you want to repair Windows or access your data, boot from Windows 98 startup disk and change Boot.ini file. Then boot Windows from this partition.

Of course, these partitions can be combined (D through G) or ignored (H) to your need.

All you have to do is to decide what you want and select the number of partitions.

by wcp

The beauty of C: being FAT32 is that you can format it and create boot files from scratch without affecting the rest of the partitions.

by p.j.hutchison

We use three partitions:
C: = Boot, OS and Programs
D: = Work and Temp area for data files
Hidden = For images (this is NOT copied to workstations but used to store an image when developed - license issues).

You cannot always guarantee you can install programs on partitions other than C:.
D: is always good as you can keep that and reimage C: if it go's bad and still keep data on D: (incl a copy of user's profile).

by b_pope

Your side of the arguement.
A single partition is ok if you only have a small HD (40GB or smaller), but with 200GB to 300GB & larger HD's your system will take a performance hit as a single partition with the OS installed. Another problem is file corruption or viruses will affect everything on the single partition.

The other side.
Loading XP or any OS on the 2nd partition is just plain silly, you've just lost performance right off the bat, the HD has to travel father for reading & writing. While DOS can be usefull, it's not needed today when you have a program like Norton Ghost.

My choice.
Create a minimum of 3 partitions for drives 80GB & larger, only 2 partitions on 40GB & 60GB HD's

The 1st partition in the area of 15GB to 25GB. Base the size on what you plan on installing, if games & large programs like Auto Cad are being installed move towards the 25GB size, always keeping mind that to be able to properly defrag a partition it should have 25% free space.

The 2nd partition 10GB to 15GB, I use this for storing documents, system drivers & updates, along with the software I'm using & there updates, & other personal stuff. You need to backup the data on this partition, use CD-RW. The other reason for this partition is it's size & location, if you decide you need to expand your C:\ drive you can easily move the data from this drive to either CD/DVD's rewritables or to your 3rd partition.

The 3rd partition will be the balance of space left, which should be a minimum of 30GB on a 80GB HD, use for storage, & keep a Ghost image of your original C:\ drive install here, along with a backup Ghost image you should create every couple weeks of C:\ drive as a temp backup. I keep two backup images of C:\ drive onhand & delete the oldest when I create a new one.

by b_pope

Most important thing to do first.
Create a Ghost image of your C:\ drive install & burn a couple copy's.

I make two important original Ghost images.
The 1st once Windows & system drives have been installed.
The 2nd after I've installed all the Windows updates, I aready have all the updates needed before hand, so I don't need to connect to the Interent to update Windows.

Now along with your regular Ghost images your able to recover from anything, whenever you want in just a few minutes, & have several starting points.

by wlbowers

First off dos doesn't do ntfs. You want to use ntfs with 2000 and xp. It manages better.

Second off I DO NOT PARTITION ANYTHING EXCEPT SERVERS. And then only if the client demands it. I install extra drives.

You can have a dozen partitions. If that drive dies you lose them all.

Xp doesn't recover gracefully. Your best bet is to purchase a second drive the same size. Put it on a removable carrier.

Now on a regular, yea regular basis, use ghost or partition magic 8 to copy the image to the second drive. Decide on what you are willing to loose. That will be your time between backups.

To recover when things go bad you install the drive in the tray as the primary and the only drive in the system.

Boot to a win98 boot floppy with fdisk on it. Type fdisk /mbr and press enter.

Keep your antivirus and firewall up to date. Use Spybot, AdAware by lavasoft, Microsoft's new trojan program.

Good Luck

Lee

by aidy sherwin

You don't need to install DOS at all - if things go pearshaped you can use repair function from Bootable WinXP CD or use recover manager to fix things.

I found best way to install is 2 partitions or 3 partitions - 1) Drive WinXP installation, 2) Drive Programs files, 3) Drive Documents

Once you have installed XP run regedit and goto HKey_Local_machine, software, microsoft, windows and click on current version and change location of program files and my docs path.

If you really wanted to you can have a forth partition on either same HD or a seperate one (usually pick a hd that os is not on) and change this to your paging file.

Now what you can do is always keep a good backup of your registery (backup to seperate filename or folder if necessary) - now if you os goes pearshape all you need to do is reinstall xp to drive c - reimport your last known good registery which will point to your program files and hey presto you haven't lost any program files or any of your documents.

I know this sounds like a really longwinded way to do things but when you use it, you'll never look back. What you could also do is when you have carried out your fresh install, and pointed your reg to other drives then take an image of you winxp drive using software like norton ghost.

You could also do what you had suggested and just have one large partition with everything on it and a small partition at the end of your hd - install norton ghost and periodically take an image of your drive c - at least when the os goes pearshaped on you - all you have to do is use norton boot disk and restore your drive c back again.

This discussion is closed to new replies.