Your side of the arguement.
A single partition is ok if you only have a small HD (40GB or smaller), but with 200GB to 300GB & larger HD's your system will take a performance hit as a single partition with the OS installed. Another problem is file corruption or viruses will affect everything on the single partition.
The other side.
Loading XP or any OS on the 2nd partition is just plain silly, you've just lost performance right off the bat, the HD has to travel father for reading & writing. While DOS can be usefull, it's not needed today when you have a program like Norton Ghost.
My choice.
Create a minimum of 3 partitions for drives 80GB & larger, only 2 partitions on 40GB & 60GB HD's
The 1st partition in the area of 15GB to 25GB. Base the size on what you plan on installing, if games & large programs like Auto Cad are being installed move towards the 25GB size, always keeping mind that to be able to properly defrag a partition it should have 25% free space.
The 2nd partition 10GB to 15GB, I use this for storing documents, system drivers & updates, along with the software I'm using & there updates, & other personal stuff. You need to backup the data on this partition, use CD-RW. The other reason for this partition is it's size & location, if you decide you need to expand your C:\ drive you can easily move the data from this drive to either CD/DVD's rewritables or to your 3rd partition.
The 3rd partition will be the balance of space left, which should be a minimum of 30GB on a 80GB HD, use for storage, & keep a Ghost image of your original C:\ drive install here, along with a backup Ghost image you should create every couple weeks of C:\ drive as a temp backup. I keep two backup images of C:\ drive onhand & delete the oldest when I create a new one.