Discussion Locked

Better use of form controls

0 helpful
4 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

In this week's Design and Usability Tactics newsletter, author Michael Meadhra adds his voice to the general call for better use of form controls, and elaborates on a few of Jakob Nielsen's usage suggestions.

Can you think of examples of misused check boxes and radio buttons that make a form confusing and hard to use? What other form controls do designers sometimes misuse? Do you have other guidelines to suggest for the successful use of form controls? Let us know.

If you aren't subscribed to the free Design and Usability Tactics newsletter, click the following link to automatically sign up:
http://nl.com.com/MiniFormHandler?brand=builder&subs_channel=bldr_front_door&list_id=e614&tag=fb

4 replies

by cstick

I see the ease of using a single checkbox for yes/no questions. But, I disagree with that being a best method in all cases. When using a checkbox, a default answer is set to either yes or no. The problem here is that a user might not see the checkbox and therefore provide the default answer on submission.

In some cases, you need to know for sure that the answer provided was infact the answer the user chose and the checkbox would not be able to provide this. I prefer to use a radiobutton list without a selected listitem and validation. Therefore, if the user does not provide an answer, they are alerted to choose and once they do choose, you can be assured that it was there choice.

by etaoin shrdlu

Precisely, I agree with Cstick.

Encouraging or forcing the user to actually make a positive selection is a real problem with radio buttons--and not just with Yes/No questions.

A very common technique used with a dropdown menu is to insert instruction text for the first option in the menu, along the lines of:

====== Select One =====

I don't think Nielsen addresses this problem.

I think you can set up a radio button so that it starts with no items selected, and you can make it clear in the instructions that the user must select something. This partially addresses the problem.

There are good reasons, as described by both Michael Meadhra and Cstick, why develoeprs like to use dropdowns in some situations.

by omlyman

The reason radio buttons are called radio buttons is because they are based on the old fashioned radios that we used to have in cars, where only one button (ie one station) was allowed to be pressed in at a time.

Now, back to the agrument against using them in place of check/tick boxes. In the event where you require a user to make a decision and you must to test for it, I am afraid there is no way to test for an unticked check box.

Does anybody have any other ideas?

by meadhra

Form validation can be a challenge, and the ability to validate responses can influence the choice of form controls. However, validation issues don't favor radio buttons over checkboxes as heavily as you might think.

One of the simplest and most effective validation measures is to present visitors with a summary of their submitted form selections and require them to confirm those choices before recording the results. This confirmation step can include checkbox selections as easily as it does radio buttons.

This discussion is closed to new replies.