Discussion Locked

Bypassed for a Promotion

0 helpful
23 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I am level II Technician providing network and Desktop Support. I work as a consultant for a New York city government agency. recently a member of my group was promoted to Level III. He is also a consultant just like me. we both have the MCSE in NT and I recently started to update my cert so I am now a Win2k/Win2003 MCP. I am not so upset that he was given the position, as I am at the fact that I can't begin to imagine the criteria that was used to determine who should be promoted. He is late all the time at least twice or three times a week. I always get in at least 15 minutes early and stay late if the need arises.
I wnat to talk to my manager but knowing from past experience I know it will not change a thing. My question is should I speak with my manager about how I am feeling, or should I just keep doing my job and start to look for another job opportunity. I also want to ask which certification path should I follow? Be it MCSE Linux and or CCNA

23 replies

by secure_lockdown9

yes. approach the manager and tell him/her exactly how you feel about it all.

also, don't forget to mention to them how "dumb & blind" they are for promoting the other guy and not you. this will ensure that you are remembered - come next promotions.

:-)

by attech

May be I did not include enough details, but from your response I conclude you are assuming I am "stupid". You can only do what you are suggesting if you have another job secured or want to commit career suicide at your present company... Thanks but no thanks for your advice

by vltiii

If you didn't see his post for what it is perhaps you should try his recommendations. He clearly was being sarcastic about your approach to this issue. In plain language it would be professional suicide to go to management with how you feel. You sound as if you're entitled...and you're not. Ideally management chose the person whom they felt would best fulfill their needs. Perhaps you should do some inner reflection and go from there.

by keithbluebird

I think someone is using this discussion page to gleen information for a paper or something, It is a good idea, but whom ever you are fess up.

by attech

Sorry to disappoint you but I graduated with a Bachelors in Business Administration in 1998 and minored in CIS. So the paper writing and research days for me have been over for quiet some time. I my heart and mind I know what I need to do, I just wanted to hear some other opinions out there about similar situations. To provide you with more info about my situation let me just say that the individual promoted never graduated high school, he got his GED (Good Enough Diploma) and he never went on to college. Before working here he drove a delivery truck for a living the only thing he did right in my view was get his MCSE. I have the same certification and I am in the process of upgrading it to MCSE 2000/2003 something I know he was not doing. He will be doing so now because he will be going to training... something that the company does not provide to consultants (we both are consultants). I have never been one to use the race card, because until now I never experienced any thing like that in the work place. However I think this fits into it. Oh yeah! By the way he is White I am South American.

by magneittech

You should 1st ask the criteria and check what you can do yourself to get promoted. Don?t envy someones else promotion. He might have done night college courses or improved more than you on the companies certifications.

by jimhm

Yes talk to the Manager - Say you just want to know why you were promoted since you have X, Y and Z and just finished A, B, and C...

What is thier criteria for the next position -

You may also not if this other person was a minority - or x-military - some companies give points when two people are equal for a promotion or position...

So there are a number of possibilities - including they don't like you - you don't dress right - your fat - you smoke - you drink - little things sneek into the mix, that the manager will not even realize are there... Promotions and reviews are very subjective - and not objective

by toms45

And be prepared to leave in 30 minutes. Those who question the decisions of incompentence are usually handled by dismissal. However, if your firm has published job descriptions, then get a copy and read it. The quals may not be listed, but, by reading between the lines, you can figure tham out. Menawhile, don't change a thing about your job performance. Post any certs or other course completion where they can be seen by anyone entering your workspace. Casually mention to co-workers your recent accomplishments, but DON'T BRAG! Eventually, you'll become the recognized "go to" person for answers. If nothing else, you'll have the satisfaction of knowing you don't have to seek retribution - you're too good for that.

by vltiii

I cannot emphasize how bad of a decision this would be. Having all the credentials in the world does not make you the best candidate for the position. If you've been with the company for a while you should have some idea of the company's culture. It's not uncommon to promote lesser qualified individuals if in the eyes of management they will ultimately be better for the company. People need to understand there is more to moving up the food chain than qualifications.

by jimhm

How many times have you PNA'ed the next level (if enlisted) - do they still have the tests and courses you had to take to get to the next level... E2 ..E3..E4..E5..and on.... ???

It's been a long time (30 years) ...

by vltiii

It would be hard to answer this question without more information. You mentioned that you've spoken with your manager before. How did you approach this? Did your manager see you as coming off as complaining and hostile. Ultimately you probably should talk with your manager, but limit it to what his/her expectations are of you in performing your duties.

by attech

I do communicate with my manager in a regular basis. That's why I can't understand how I never saw this coming. Thanks for your advice.
However, No I have not spoken to him about this situation and how I feel about it. I do know from past events that have happen here within the company that once a decision is made and they feel is the right one there is no going back. I was planning to speak to him because I wanted to make my feelings known. I don't want them to think that everything is OK with me. Just to give you some more info?.. here read the following

I graduated with a Bachelors in Business Administration in 1998 and minored in CIS. So the paper writing and research days for me have been over for quiet some time. I my heart and mind I know what I need to do, I just wanted to hear some other opinions out there about similar situations. To provide you with more info about my situation let me just say that the individual promoted never graduated high school, he got his GED (Good Enough Diploma) and he never went on to college. Before working here he drove a delivery truck for a living the only thing he did right in my view was get his MCSE. I have the same certification and I am in the process of upgrading it to MCSE 2000/2003 something I know he was not doing. He will be doing so now because he will be going to training... something that the company does not provide to consultants (we both are consultants). I have never been one to use the race card, because until now I never experienced any thing like that in the work place. However I think this fits into it. Oh yeah! By the way he is White I am South American.

by secure_lockdown9

attitude.

http://www.attitudeiseverything.com/
http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/1891279017/qid=1088474720/sr=1-1/ref=sr_1_1/104-6446227-4427130?v=glance&s=books

to quote you, "I graduated with a Bachelors in Business Administration in 1998 and minored in CIS. So the paper writing and research days for me have been over for quiet some time."

the paper writing, research, testing, upgrading, personal advancemnt, learning days NEVER END and they are NEVER OVER. you will always have to keep upgrading. especially in an industry like IT where things change much faster than other industries.

also, finishing school in 1998, does not qualify as "quite some time ago". there are people on here with over 20 years work experience in IT.

by black panther

Do you have performance appraisals, kpi's. On your last performance appraisal did your manager mention any shortcomings? Ask your manager what areas you need to improve on for consideration of a promotion. Be aware that all may not be revealed - other factors may come into consideration that you will not be told of such as personality etc etc.

No matter where you work you will find this happening. As long as you are fair to yourself, do the best you can, try not to upset the pie cart to much - your reward will be personal happiness instead of status and materialistic happiness.

by attech

That is how I am looking at the situation. As long as I am happy. However, my eyes are now open and I will be abele to see what I must have been missing before.

by wjones

Now that everyones ego is out of the way, things seem to be clear to you as to what you want to do. Asking will be the only real way of finding out, it shouldn't hurt you if it's sincere. I say give it a shot, it's not carreer suicide. Don't listen to others interperate what hasn't happened yet. only you make it possible for growth within the company if your communication is kept alive with those above you.

by secure_lockdown9

Absolutely! :-)

atTech, didn't mean to rub you the wrong way. Just trying to keep a light air about the subject. If you lurk around here, you will notice a few posts similar to yours. And you will notice that most of the advice is, "someone above made the decision to hire/promote that person you think doesn't deserve it."

if you approach the person that made that decision, they will usually interpret it that you think they are incompetent for chosing to promote someone else over you. not a very good recepie for a good working relationship.

by attech

You miss understood. I pasted my reply to someone who question my posting by saying that I was just trying to get info, or research for a paper. Of course learning never ends, That's why I chose to go into the IT field. I do not want a career that does not allow your mind to expand...

I just wanted to provide you additional info about my situation.

by dc_guy

You say you are both consultants. Does that mean you are a contractor rather than a civil service employee? If so, then you have absolutely no rights. Your boss could fire you simply for walking into his office and complaining about this situation, or for no reason at all. All he would owe you is two weeks' severance pay and a legal obligation to never tell anyone that you were "terminated for cause."

Government organizations hire contractors for the precise reason that they are exempt from civil service. They want to be able to replace people quickly if they're not satisfactory, rather than going through the agonizing ritual of performance evaluations, counseling, and hearings that often result in giving the employee his job plus back pay.

Face it, there's some reason your boss doesn't want you to have the job in question. Maybe it's personal, maybe it's professional. In either case you have very little power to alter his behavior. Either make peace with this or move on.

By the way, does the job you want require strong communication skills? I notice that your writing skill is a little weak. You would be well advised to take some classes or tutoring in business and technical writing. This weakness WILL hold you back some day. . . . if it's not already doing so.

by jsfald

If it bothers you then talk to your manager with the right attitude. Ask what your weaknesses are and work on them. Don't mention anything about the other employee.

If it doesn't bother you then keep your eyes open, like you mentioned in another post, and work on the weaknesses you see.

I have a good enough relationship with my manager that I could talk to him about my performance and would not commit job suicide. You know your own manager best and will have to decide how it will affect your job and relationship with him or her.

by secure_lockdown9

i think the issue and the question at hand is, how do you approach the manager about why your co-worker got promoted and not you, without you coming accross like sounding like a complainer, "sour grape", or jelous of another co-workers success and accomplishments.

i think it's much wiser to just take more innitiaive at work and try to do a better job and get noticed than it is to question why things aren't fair or equal and trying to go about making them "fairer".

by lost_in_ny

Although I agree with the folks in this thread that encourage you to approach your manager to understand what he/she perceives that you need to improve upon to be considered for a promotional opportunity (without any reference whatsoever to the individual who did get the recent promotion), I noticed your emphasis on (a) professional and education credentials and (b) being on-tinme for work as important attributes. Unless I am hiring someone for an entry-level position, I only use professional/educational certs as one of several tie-breaker criteria, if all other factors about the candidates are equal. What's most important to me in making a promotion decision is how effective are you in both your technical proficiency (not how well-educated you are on paper) and in partnering with the business users (I'd rather have a desktop tech who take 10% longer and leaves the business users feeling good about the experience with my tech then one who's quicker at the job and lousy at human interaction). I look for creativity in devising solutions, which aren't necessarily found in certification courses, ability to listen to and mesh well with colleagues and business users, and reliability in determining who has potential to advance. Beyond that, depending on the position, the qualifications can vary dramatically (e.g., project management skills are essential for, well, PM type positions, but matter far less if I'm looking for a senior network admin).

Find out what your boss perceives as essential for the next level, talk to him/her about where he/she thinks you have opportunities to improve and then act upon it.

This discussion is closed to new replies.