Discussion Locked

CA unicenter, Remedy, Magic, Bmc Service Desk Express

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

We are doing an analysis of software.

If you have worked with any. We would like to hear from you of what you liked or disliked about CA Unicenter, Remedy, Magic, BMC Service DEsk express.

Your help would allow us a good independent and informative analysis.

5 replies

by notsochiguy

...but I think Rememdy, Magic and BMC SDE are all pretty much the same thing, or at least, under the same corporate umbrella.

At any rate, I've used all of the software listed, and they have all been good-to-excellent in handling what we needed to handle at the particular time. It is all about taking the time upfront to properly scope, configure, train and administer the product.

Another one I'd throw in for consideration is HEAT. Really a good blend of functionality and ease-of-administration.

by tig2

Magic was the software in use at a small company of fewer than 100 employees. Although that environment was supposed to be Magic's sweet spot, end users would do just about anything to avoid it. It was klunky and only barely fit the need.

I have used Remedy off and on for over 10 years. It is easy to use, has an understandable user interface and we had good levels of compliance from our 2000 users. From a web client, an end user was led through a series of questions that generally provided the service tech with enough information to fix the users problem quickly and get them working again. Rarely did the tech have to call the user but often did as a courtesy to schedule an appointment desk side.

Remedy was also robust enough to allow us to manage collaborative scheduling such as Change Management.

I am not familiar with Unicenter or Service Desk Express.

by jmgarvin

HEAT and ITSM are also products you may want to consider. If you include Enteo and Centennial you also have a very robust client lifecycle management solutions as well.

Remedy and Magic are under BMC.

*I work for FrontRange

by brucewcameron

Most of these products are good at what they set out to do, but reporting and dashboards are rarely completed to user requirements. Hagrid Solutions offers a drag and drop design and interactive dashbaord interface for the user called Xtraction - www.hagridsolutions.com

by procond

I used to work with Magic (or SDE as it was later called). It was quite ok, but we always had some issues with it.
Lately I have been starting to work with VisionProject (www.visionproject.se). It doesn't have everything that SDE has, but is definitely worth looking at. It is much more stable and easy to work with. And, it has everything that we need.
We are working very strict towards our ITIL processes and feel that the system really supports us in an efficient and good way.

This discussion is closed to new replies.