Discussion Locked

Cable Modem or DSL?

0 helpful
13 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
What is a faster/more reliable/more efficient broadband resource....cable modem or DSL?

13 replies

by matkinson

Cable modems are usually faster -- they typically run at 1.2 Mb/s versus 128-768Kb/s for DSL. But unlike DSL, cable modems give you shared bandwidth. That means in areas where many people have cable modems, they'll often be slower in peak usage periods.

The provider that you use seems to matter more than the connection type for reliability. With that said, everybody I've ever known who's had a cable modem has traded it for DSL because of reliability problems.

Because cable modem bandwidth is shared between you and your neighbors, they are much less secure. I wouldn't consider using one without a firewall of some kind.

With regard to efficiency, that depends on you. If you primarily use Internet resources during off-peak hours, you trust your cable company to provide reliable service, and you trust your neighbors not to try to break into your computer, then a cable modem may be right for you.

Me: I have DirecPC. Only because there's no DSL in my neighborhood.

by dlindber

Depends on a couple of things. DSL is a more consistant broadband choice if you are close to the phone company switching station. (Within 1-1 1/2 miles) in that your access speed is not effected by other users. You have a single unshared line. The further away from the switching station you get, the slower your connection speed. With cable modem there is no distance limitations, but there can be SEVERE speed loss based on the number of users attached to your cable segment, as this is a shared resource. So more users, less bandwidth per user. If you are on the outer limits of the DSL distance then your performance/speed will suffer. If you are in a crowded cable segment the same will be true - poor performance.
My recomendation is DSL over cable in most instances. The level of performance and speed will tend to be a fairly flat line, while cable can bounce all over the place depending on how many users are attached at any given point in time.

by dlindber

Depends on a couple of things. DSL is a more consistant broadband choice if you are close to the phone company switching station. (Within 1-1 1/2 miles) in that your access speed is not effected by other users. You have a single unshared line. The further away from the switching station you get, the slower your connection speed. With cable modem there is no distance limitations, but there can be SEVERE speed loss based on the number of users attached to your cable segment, as this is a shared resource. So more users, less bandwidth per user. If you are on the outer limits of the DSL distance then your performance/speed will suffer. If you are in a crowded cable segment the same will be true - poor performance.
My recomendation is DSL over cable in most instances. The level of performance and speed will tend to be a fairly flat line, while cable can bounce all over the place depending on how many users are attached at any given point in time.

by dcosgrove

Just to throw in the proverbial monkey wrench, check out star band. It's a satelite internet connection. It is in it's infancy and is claiming speeds of @500kbps down and 150 kbps up. I was waiting for DSL to become available in my area, but due to exceptionally long waiting periods, I'm seriously considering the dish. The web site is www.starband.com

by harvey_pediman

Something to also remember, is that many (if not all, not real sure on this) cable vendors only allow you to upload at 128k. DSL can allow you to push at speeds up to 7mbit in some areas. For me, I've found DSL to be more reliable, more stable, and more able to work in a business environment. Running cable to a business prolly is not your best bet, but its perfectly fine for home use.

by cisco_guy

The "true" answer, that everyone has eluded, is they both stink! Period! End of Story! There's no such thing as an "unshared line"! Everyone "shares" bandwidth! Don't care if your using Cable, ADSL, SDSL or ISDN, it is a "shared" pipe. When you use DSL, the only part of your connection that is unshared, is from your home to the CO (Central Office), from there my friends, you and thousands of other people, are going through the same backbone and hence are sharing that bandwidth. So please don't be fooled into thinking just because your using DSL, you don't have to worry about performance degrades, cause thats just not true. Quite frankly, if I had $1000 a month to blow, I would have a dedicated T1 in my home.

This discussion is closed to new replies.