Discussion Locked

Can TWO similar PCI modems be installed in XP?

0 helpful
7 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have a good working Windows XP Pro machine running 1 GHz with 384 RAM, 80 GIG Hard drive, and a 56K DLink PCI Internal Modem (Rockwell-Conexant) dedicated for a dialup internet connection that works fine.

I need to install a secondary modem for voice/fax functionality but I have encountered some problems.

First, after installing AZTECH 56 PCI Internal modem (MSP-3880SP-U), a Rockwell 98 chip, it installed as Generic Soft56k modem. I tried checking if it works by device manager's diagnostics it says it has a problem. Obviously I won't be able to use this simultaneously as I intended to. The system suddenly rebooted and scandisks, not once but a lot of times...only then I realized that it got a hardware conflict, after trying to install new drivers for it with no avail. It showed that it uses the same IRQs (irq 9) with other stuffs - about 6 of them. Tried assigning DLink's IRQ to a new one in the BIOS but XP won't allow - still the same IRQ. Finally uninstalled AZTECH modem as XP continues to be unstable.

HOW CAN I INSTALL A SECONDARY (almost similar rockwell) PCI FAX/Modem WITHOUT CONFLICTING EACH OTHER AND WORKING FINE IN XP, WITHOUT BUYING A NEW MODEM? Is this possible?

7 replies

by ozi eagle

Hi,
Unless you are wanting to use two separate telephone lines, there is no point in having two modems. Your existing one will work fine on voice/fax.

by jerri

YES, I'm definitely using a separate telephone line for my voice/fax program. As stated, the first modem is DEDICATED for the internet - which obviously won't be able to accept incoming voice/fax calls... A secondary modem & telephone line is required for this task.

by cg it

well, there are 5 IRQ assignments for general adapter 5,9,10,11, and 15. 3 of them are usually used for graphics card, USB and a modem. Devices on the general adapter IRQ assignments share that IRQ. you could try to assign the second modem to another IRQ different that what the first one is assigned to and use a different comm port. Problems arise when 2 modems try to use the same comm port [what does windows know right? modem? ah comm port 3, another modem? comm port 3] If you assigned a new IRQ in the BIOS and Windows says nope don't like it, disable the PnP aware O/S feature in the BIOS. That way Windows will take what the BIOS says instead of the BIOS saying, this is what is, you can change it if you want.

You also might want to not use a internal PCI modem but use an external one. There are multi line modems available on Ebay and could check those out.

by jerri

BTW, I forgot to mention that I did try assigning a different IRQ ADDRESS (irq3) on PCI slot 4 where the 1st modem is (dlink), and even DISABLED PLUG & PLAY "feature" in the BIOS of my Asus motherboard just to see IF XP would change it, but it is still the same - it's stuck with IRQ 9.
At this point, im not in favor of purchasing/installing an External modem for personal & budgetary reasons...

by sgt_shultz

so you have no other device trying to use com ports, yes? no serial mouse, internal modem, touchpad...like that?
i think you should be able to get two separate internal pci modems to work...it is the modems, not the idea that is problem causing, betcha. some are just gonna install easier...
i vote for the external modem also. go on ebay, try to find a us robotics courier v.everything. rock solid fax modem for you. about $400 new.
but if you are into trying to get this to work, here is my two cents:
i think your basic idea of installing two modems should work. it is good you noticed the shared interrupts, a feature of pci cards is that they can use same interrupt.
i agree sounds like hardware resource conflict...ironically we get lots less control now with 'plug and pray'. as you see, you were not able to change the irq. my take is: xp pnp not very good at assigning resources sometimes. modems especially. you can turn off pnp as suggersted but usually am able to fix by one of two methods:
first, you can maybe 'force' the modem to certain irq io settings by adding device driver line to config.sys (like in the good ol days). use the switches to predefine the irq and io base. this is opening can of worms and a hassle. just mentioning it to try to give you a feel for what is happening here with the resource assignments.
so other way to fix is: take out all the pci cards and disable all mboard based peripherals that you can, modem, touchpad, video if you are not using it... that you can, reboot to let windows free up resources. then put back cards in different sequence to trick xp into doing a better job. start with card it is having trouble assigning non-conflicting resource to: the second modem. then add the first modem. rinse, repeat.
so if it were me, i would disable/take out the first modem and just get the second one in and working. then add in the first one.

by jerri

The ASUS board has 1=AGP and 5=PCI slots. Video Card is AGP ATI Rage Pro that is closely beside PCI slot 1 that has a fan attached - taking away space for use on pci 1. So PCI 1 is NOT USED. PCI2 is lancard, PCI3 is soundcard, and PCI4 is the DLink modem. PCI5 is availble which is intended for a secondary modem.

I believe sgt_shultz suggestion on the last part of taking out all pci devices and reshuffle starting with the troublesome AZTECH modem, then Dlink, rinse and so on... should work. I guess in theory and practicality this might do the trick and should work, and I might just do this in an appropriate time as this machine acts our home network's internet gateway machine where family connects to the net via this PC.

So shutting down this machine needs an appointment, as this is almost always on all the time. Also awaiting some comments from friends who might just do an actual test.

More info pls... maybe an actual test from you guys??

by jerri

I've increased the points and willing to add more to anyone who can at least solve my immediate problem: change the IRQ's either of the PCI modems to work simultaneously, as current testing showed SAME IRQ 9 on both.

Will both work together? My pre-XP days tells me it won't allow 2 similar IRQs on devices such as modems. Has anyone of you tried this on XP? let me know... An actual test from you is welcome as I don't have the "spares" to do this at home.

This discussion is closed to new replies.