If you follow the thread, the question was. is there a good certification program for PMs.
I never said certification made a good project manager.
But if you contrast the PMI process with A+ or MSCE or CNE, the PMI process demands a) years ofwork experience and b) experience in each of the major phases of a project.
The PMI certification requires you to learn a certain style and nomenclature, but its certainly easier for "good" project managers to get the concepts.
In my current role, I mentor IT project managers. None of them have PMI certification, and as you can imagine, there are good ones and bad ones.
PMI is well respected, and I haven't met too many PMPs who turned out to be poor project managers. But I think its thatgood project managers become PMPs, not that PMP makes them good project managers.
But certification in anything, and I include the professions like doctors, lawyers and others, is no guarentee of relevant experience or competancy.
James Linn