Discussion Locked

Change hubs to switches

0 helpful
11 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I've considered swapping out my 4 hubbed connected network with switches. I'm hoping to get rid of the slowness on our network. I understand by make this swap it would provide greater throughput for all users. Is this as easy as disconnecting the hubs, replacing them with switches and plugging everyone back into the switches. Or is there configuration involved. I'm considering either Cisco, 3Com or HP switches. What's your take on this?

11 replies

by rsoft

The trick with switches is as follows:

A newly installed switch starts just as a hub. Some packet arrives at a port and is sent to every other port in the network. The switch notes that IP so-and-so is on switch-port so-and-so. Next time a packetmust go to that IP, it instantaniously goes to that port. This means that traffic on switch 1 doesn't affect switch 2, 3 and 4 (unless it has to travel across switches).

So, it's self learning (It just lacks a GUI, so it's no Windows).

I'd consider 3Com, but CISCO does sound good, but I've no experience with their switches.

by rickh9

The answer depends greatly on how your network is configured.
Of course switches will probably help and if cost is not an issue - go for it. I would highly recommend Cisco, HP is ok - pricy, 3Com has a nice product but some of the odd behaviour wehave been experiencing has been traced back to our 3300 switches, Cisco's are almost the same price, steeper learning curve but worth it.
Keep in mind that the main advantage to a switch is to partition traffic, so that if for example you have a busy server at the end of a single uplink/hub you may not gain anything by putting in all switches. Your traffic will still be concentrated through a single link. Better to put in a single switch and run your hubs and servers directly off of that. Fora really busy server use two NIC's off of the switch.
If you consider that a switches job is to direct traffic and if all of your traffic is directed outside of the hub in question then the gain is limited if any. If on the otherhand you have a number of very busy workgroups and not a lot of traffic between them then replacing the hubs with switches will probably help.

Have fun...

by pam_greenup

We are in the middle of installing Cisco 3524 XL switches. We have replaced 2 and have 10 to go. For the first install we employeed a Cisco engineer for 3 hours for the initial config of the switches, training and deployement. Glad we did. It is notas easy as unplugging and plugging back in. The only glitch we had was an issue with spanning tree. It was already turned on on our network so we also enabled spanning tree on the Cisco switches. Bad move. The 2 spanning trees were not compatible and duplicate objects were automatically created in our tree. This mainly effected our HPDirect print servers. This was a printing nightmare for 3 days. Disabled spanning tree on the Cisco switches. Problem went away. Cisco is a very good product and you know that they are going to be around for a long time. Once we have all the Cisco hardware in place we will turn spanning tree back on.

by positive64

I'm in the process of changing from hubs to switches. I just bought a HP2524 Procurve switch. It is a 24 port switch and can one for around $800. The thing the differntiates HP switches from 3com and Cisco is that it comes with HP toptools software.This software will provide you some internal control over your network as well as controlling broadcasts.I think HP is worth a look.

by estebandelatorre

Its as simple as you describe! Unplug from the hub and plug into the switch!!!
The difference is very important.The only problem may become with old nic's. Consider that you will have to restart your servers.
Save money, try this first!!!
1.- Buyonly one switch (an entry level one 10/100 automatic - that is: without Layer III)
2.- Plug here the servers only (and your workstation of course)
3.- Plug the hubs into the switch using a cross-cable
It?s enough performance gain for you ?

edt@bancobgn.com

This discussion is closed to new replies.