There is no right answer to this question. What is right for one is not for another. The first thing you have to do is sit down and figure out which PART of IT you want to work in. Once you decide that important part, you're halfway there. You have the degrees, now it's just a matter of the hands on experience and the certs in your chosen field.
Personally, I think the security and audit field is the place to be, and that's where my focus has been for many years (with numerous detours along the way).
Think of what you like to do, ask questions and go from there. This forum is a good place to ask specific questions, or even start a discussion on the relative merits of various parts of the IT field. People here are NOT shy about putting their $0.02 worth in. (and this is a good thing). If I can answer any specific questions, send me a message.
Good Luck
Dave