That was not meant to be personal against you, so thanks for not taking it that way. and no I don't mean to appear as 'ranting', although it could appear to be blunt. The point is the clairity of what exactly you're looking for. If you want, or are looking for, validation of a specific concept you happen to be fond of... it probably won't happen. If you're asking for dialog of justification for or against a particular concept, that can happen.
On- "??could advance the process of collaboration with others - who may not have a (or current?) copy?? (of ours for their insight)" Why counln't that e-mail just be forwarded to the person that needed the information. That's done all the time.
On- "??may be a repeat of another 'conversation' elsewhere? - or could be the answer that others are still seeking in another forum...(silo).?" This one has me a little confused as to what you're looking for. I'm thinking of the practice of sending a reply to an e-mail, containing the original. After a while the e-mail grows, and becomes a monster. Or 40 e-mails, from 40 different people, containing the same informational message, in one's inbox. X-( That can, and does become problematic.
On your "case in point"s- #1) Re-explain? Why? Why would you not just reference them to this site? Then alow them to choise what information they feel is important to them. That would be more effective.
#2) You're totally correct. Many conversations (to say the least) have been on going concerning this very topic.
I think I understand this concept you're trying to grasp. The differences are in the time factor. Real-Time vs. Some-Time. If that's what you're trying to get set. Many modern Programs now realeased, I'm thinking "Eclipse" and most of the top end CAD Programs include an IM sub-program built into their programs. For the specific purpose of "Real-Time" colaboration. What has had me confused about your questioning, is that in the speed of the progress in computing in todays world, this topic is now old news. It's already been used. If you want to know how one example of this is approached, I suggest you check out the Eclipse web site. -d
Anyway, I think this conversation is going along just fine. :| (If you want to see how hostility is showed around here~ stick around, but it's not for the faint of heart. :0 ) :^0 -d