Discussion Locked

Communicating Security to Out-Source Partners

0 helpful
10 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

We live in a time of compliance and governance. In the company I work for, we are challenged in how to communicate our security practices to our Indian outsource partner.

As I see it, we have some pitfalls that we, as Americans, do not understand fully. But we do see that our security requirements are not being adhered to.

Start here- Indian culture is based in the caste system. It is unthinkable for a person of lower caste to try to pretend (read Identity Theft) to be of higher caste.

Add to this that there is no social security system in India... therefore no social security number.

How do we effectively communicate the requirements around security?

Just this week, I found a document from a partner on a shared space detailing his US SSN, address in US, address in India, and banking information- all in clear text. I took the step of eradicating this document after I discussed it with my manager. We cannot have information like this on open drives.

We know that we are taking the step of providing training in the actions that are acceptable and unacceptable. We have various sign-off requirements that tell us if a person has or has not received training. We even request feedback about the training and what information is helpful. We get all the right answers back but we still have the problems.

I am doing everything I can to find cultural barriers to successfully communicating. No matter what I personally might think, the earth is getting flatter and more and more we need to learn and communicate in the language of international business.

What are your thoughts on this and what should my next steps be in trying to overcome the problem?

10 replies

by deepsand

The problem you face is one that knows no home, but is common to all.

Without adequate [i]direct[/i] supervision by those who both fully understand that which is to be both accomplished and avoided, and have sufficient authority to require compliance, those without such understanding cannot be expected to act in a manner that well comports with your requirements.

In your instance, you will need people on the ground in India who are already well versed in the matters in question. Management from a distance will not serve as an adequate substitute.

by stress junkie

This seems to me to be a human character flaw more than a cultural issue. You can find the same kind of mishandling of confidential information in America or anywhere else.

I think that a good parallel situation in America is chain restaurants. You can go into one restaurant and find that all of the employees are working hard and treating the customers well. Then you can go into another restaurant of the same chain and the employees are lazy, rude, and dirty. Leadership from management makes all the difference.

by deepsand

One does not become fluent in any language merely by studing it, but rather by using it with those who are already fluent in it.

by tig2

But short of firing people, how do we effectively communicate about something that is perceived to be a time waster or hinderance to efectively completeing assignment?

The problem seems to be a lack of understanding. I don't have the same problem communicating requirements to American co-workers, I only find it when trying to communicate with other than American co-workers.

And we do have Americans in leadership roles overseas. And they are great at leading the group but fail when dealing with the cultural relationship. Cultural training is somewhat effective for those people but we must communicate effectively throughout the organisation.

Boy am I frustrated!

by vanessaj

Please email me asap at my work email address. I'm sure you have it. I don't have your new one. Awaiting your reply with happy news. (I got it and it's ready to send.)

by deepsand

As I said earlier, it is the [i]front line supervisors[/i] who needs to fully understand you needs. The aculturalization needs to be effected from the bottom up; top down will work only if you've the requisite and indeterminate time to allow for such.

by daveo2000

What you are lacking is a comparative dictionary. Nearly everybody understands security. Just about anyone will understand protecting credit card numbers. Not everybody will understand what a Social Security Number is and why it is different from a license plate number.

What you may really need to do is to make lists of things that need to be guarded and come up with cultural analogies to them. This can then become the field guide for your managers in India.

In India the SSN equivalent is the PAN number (in the IRS sense). Indians already know to protect Credit Card numbers.

I found these two out by asking one of my Indian direct reports. Once you have a list of things that need protecting, find somebody that you trust and can talk to that understands Indian culture and work on the Indian side of the analogies.

Who knows... maybe you can create a book to publish to help more people than just your company.

by jmgarvin

The problem is that in India, the culture doesn't allow for much in the way of thinking outside the box.* So, by providing strict documentation it becomes a non-issue.

Another question is that of need to know. What do the folks in India need to know and what do they not? Don't give any more information than is needed, or you will probably face more problems.

Do you have American managers on the ground there? If you don't it might be a good idea to see if you can't get at least one to go there every quater or so, just to check up on things.

The most important part is really SOPs. I know it is tedious and seems like the most boring task in the world (it's up there), but it will save you pain down the road.

* Yes, I know it's a huge generalization, hell I even work with an Indian PhD that not only thinks outside the box, but doesn't even know what a box is...However, generally this holds true.

by dspeacock

I know what you mean. I'm currently in the middle of a project auditing our third party partners/providers security. Some of them are outsourced off-shore, and unless these have detailed policies, procedures, and guidelines, signed business associate agreements and non-disclosure agreements that are not only monitored for compliance, but have VERY stiff penalties for non-compliance, they get a failing grade, and face sanctions.

Have not had one of them complain yet..they accept our recommendations and/or come upwith their own, and the problem is corrected. Or else :-)

This discussion is closed to new replies.