Discussion Locked

Comparison of Mandrake vs. Red Hat

0 helpful
9 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Any significant differences in terms of stability / reliability / scalability / other? Opinions? Rules of thumb? Evidence? Thanks in advance.

9 replies

by thiostan

I have installed and used them both. Redhat in my opinion seems more stable, more mainstream. Mandrake on the other hand is a LOT more bleeding edge and has many more features and abilities. Several people I know have experienced problems with Redhat and getting samba to work. Mandrake on the other hand has some wizards that will walk you through configuring everything from e-mail to samba.

Redhat is more mainstream, and if you pay for it has better support. Mandrake support is not whatit could be. However, with the download edition of Mandrake there is very little you can't do. I would recommend Mandrake to first time users who aren't sure exactly what they want and Redhat to companies who need the support and would like to remain mainstream. Behind the scenes the two are very similiar.

by techpro

mandrake is for first timers, it has a lot of eye candy and unstable applications in order to stay "the most current", it aims the desktop market

redhat has a lot of eyecandy too, includes some of the lastest crap out there (rh 7.1 comes to mind,which shipped with BETA qt and gcc) but it generally considered stable enough for a production environement

my personal favorite is debian, no more ugly RPM packages, it's all DEBs, a new software most of the time only requires typing apt-getinstall packagename. debian also provides you with three versions to choose from (upgrading only requires changing a few words in a file and typing apt-get update && apt-get dist-upgrade): a rock stable but somewhat outdated version (potato, 2 yearsold), a pretty recent one (woody) which is considered "testing" (currently in a features freeze, nearing stable) or the lastest, bleeding edge version (sid), considered unstable and not recommended in a production environement (altough i find it's more stable than even redhat, it's fine for a desktop, wouldn't run it on a server).

you can also choose between the mirads of other distros out there. pick your poison, it's all linux in the end

by jaqui

it actually boils down to which you, as the person operating, prefer.
I personally like mandrake over red hat, partly because of the number of options their ditribution offers.
it is as stable as red hat, in the last six months I had to run a boot utility while system running to cause the only system-wide crash of mandrake for that six month period. ( only had mandrake running for six months. ) lucky me, it is a home network that I did this to. ~g~

best bet is look at any ditribution that you want, pick which one suits your needs best. ignore advertising and hype, just go with what you see while trying them out for final decision. it is your opinion of the ditribution that matters most.

This discussion is closed to new replies.