Discussion Locked

Consultant fees for "getting up to speed"

0 helpful
19 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hi, I hope this is an appropriate posting. This is my first time. I am an independent consultant, working in the areas of IT and organizational management. I have about 7 years of experience as a consultant, and an additional 7 years within a government agency and nonprofit organizations--in both management and IT. My current client focus is nonprofit organizations. I met with a new client today, a CEO of an organization. The project involves either customizing his current or getting him a more appropriate contacts management. *However*, the client today also mentioned he needs help integrating one of his complex projects with Covey software. And decided that should be my priority. I have not worked with this software, though am familiar with the Covey time-management philosophy and "system." I took a look at the Covey software, and it's not complicated. The majority of work I'll do for/with the client is scoping out the project (which is currently completely disorganized), nailing down specific tasks, benchmarks, timelines, outcomes, staffing, delegation, etc. However--I will need to get up to speed on the Covey software once the project requirements are fleshed out. The client, who has not worked with many consultants, suggested that maybe I get up to speed on the Covey software on my own time, since I may use this experience in the future with other clients (highly unlikely). I'm inclined to see the getting up to speed with the software as akin to getting up to speed with the operations of the organization, helping him scope out his project, and defining requirements. What do you-all think? Should playing with the software--with his needs in mind--be charged? at the same rate as usual? at a lower rate? Also, I suggested we might seek out an expert in the COvey software, but he is skeptical that would be a good use of time. Thanks so much for any feedback!!

but suggested that maybe I

19 replies

by house

I would not charge for learning the software. Perhaps if you were to hide it in your fee without him figuring it out.

Any research that I need to pursue will not be charged to my clients. It is however, a very unusual piece of software. I would simply add it to my roster and knock it up as a good learning experience. Even if you will never use it anywhere else, the fact that you could mention it to future clients doesn't hurt.

by jdmercha

Training and learing curves should never be specified as part of a contract. But you can build them in as suggested. When you outsource a job you outsorce it to subject matter experts. If they don't have the expertise, then they need to get it.

You have to ask yourself "What am I willing to do to get this contract?" and "What rate do I need to make this contract worthwile to me?"

by awfernald

Looking at both ends of the stick...

From the point of the IT Manager: he is helping you by basically forcing you to learn a new software that can buff up your resume, and yes, it is true that you might be able to use it with some other clients at a later date.

From your point of view: you can care less about this software outside of the current project as you don't think that it is a marketable skillset.

He needs it, and wants it cheap (i.e. let's get this consultant to spend his time and money learning it), and you of course want it (for him), but also don't want to invest your time and money in it.

So... Couple of ideas here:

1. Check with Covey software maker, and see what other companies in the area are using this product. This will tell you if there is indeed a minor market out there if you learn the software.

2. Negotiate with the client. Use his money and your time to learn the software. i.e. his company can purchase the training material from Covey, however, you will spend your time (no charge to client) learning the material. You can have the training material ONLY while working for them.

3. If there is a small market in the area, check with the other clients in the area if they have any need for consulting/support.

by limeginger

Hi all,

I wanted to get back to you and ket you know I really appreciate your feedback and advice. It's extremely interesting to see the range of opinions and "back-upable" perspectives, isn't it? Not having used the Covey software before--and never having worked with a client on using it, which seems to be more a "personal coaching" service--I am not convinced that it'll be a particularly lucrative/useful arrow in my quiver for the future. From a bird's eye view, the software seems OK but it is really an extension of the Covey philosophy, and I would probably advocate the use of another project management/tracking tool if it were up to me if the client weren't so wedded to it. *The crux is this: this issue is a red flag. I see that communication, and expectations, with this client is going to be even more important than usual. I'll let you-all know what happens. Thanks again!

don't see how I will derive benefit

by dafe2

A big mistake (IMO), is giving away anything when your a consultant, other than an odd pen here and there.:-)

In any case, negotiate a lower rate with your client. No VALUABLE client really expects you to work for nothing (He's testing), on the other hand, you where honest enough to tell him/her you where not familiar with the tool and would need a bit of time to get familiar with it - If he agrees to retain you anyway, be fair an reduce your rate. Allways bill for your time & NEVER 'pad' your invoices. Your reputation & integrity are more important than your month end.

Even Covey says time=money.

by amcol

I've been engaging consultants for many years, so here's the perspective from the other side of the table.

When I hire a consultant I expect him/her to have the skills needed to do the job. I would never take on a consultant who couldn't demonstrate expertise with the required tool set, so why you're being considered for this job (and why you're considering doing it) are beyond me.

In addition I would never, NEVER allow a consultant to learn a new skill on my nickel. If I knew you were charging me for your own learning curve you'd never work for me again. And, contrary to popular belief, we managers aren't as dumb as we appear...believe me when I tell you we know when you're building hidden costs into your estimates.

Covey software isn't exactly a mainstream skill but there are consultants who know it. That's who'd get my business.

My advice...take a pass on this contract.

by tomsal

I'd have to agree. I think if a consultant doesn't have full confidence in his skills to handle a project at current -- then he/she should pass. If he/she feels that a lot of contracts of a particular product are being passed by because of not having the skills to support that product -- its training time...and on the consultant's dime.

I'd be upset just as relkinjb@mcc.gov stated if I found out I was paying a consultant's training expenses for the contract I hired him to do.

Strike that....I'd be friggin' pissed. ;)

by dafe2

I understand exactly what your saying & nobody should be padding anything. I also agree with it but there are exeptions:

Let's say you trust me. You've done your homework but simply prefer to have me do the work for whatever reason. I've given you alternatives but your intent on using product ABC & I tell you flat out there's a learning curve. For whatever reason I want to do the job & maintain the relashionship.

Let's asume you prefer to give me the job because you don't want the grief of bringing in a 'new' consultant. That has it's pains too right?

I find it hard to believe you'd (not) work towards a reasonable fee, if only to show good faith from both sides. Business owners expect to pay for services. I expect you do too.

You have to agree that sometimes it's easier just to deal with someone you already have a relashionship with so:

Would you not agree that this guy should be paid something, if only to show good faith from both sides of the table?

by limeginger

Thanks all for your comments, and support. To restate the situation: I'm not underskilled, hoodwinking the client, or desperate for work. This client and I are still discussing the potential projects/needs. He brought me in to work on a contacts management system for him. As we spoke, it came out that he also needs a good project management or tracking system *and* needs help with scoping out the project (a major donors initiative for his very small organization). My expertise is both nonprofit management *and* IT. I have masters degrees in both and 7 years of experience. The contacts he needs "managed" are those who will be contacted to become donors. I said I could present him with a range of options of project systems that would also integrate contacts management functionality. That's when he said, "Oh yeah! I went to a training about Steven Covey's '7 Habits of Successful People' and I bought some software that I haven't looked at. I want to use that!" I told a bit about other options, but he's in a Covey mindset. That's when I told him I am not familiar with that software, and could help him find another consultant who's familiar with it, or would need to get up to speed with it myself before saying how or whether it would meet all his requirements. Although he told me he would rather work with me, and not add another consultant to the mix, I did some quick trolling around and inquiring locally of other IT consultants, and none of them service this software. Those who mention Covey are personal coaches, and that's not what he needs. I can competently scope out his major donor program with him and his staff, and can integrate his needs with *some* software. As mentioned, he suggested, rather subtly that maybe I could get up to speed with the software on my own time, and start charging when I'm ready to start working with it. I do not and will not pad my invoices. As any consultant knows, you end up eating time anyway--because you can't charge for time standing in the shower or walking down the street you spend working out the problems in your head (i.e., thinking and problem solving before you get to the programming, which, for me, is a significant amount of what I do). Hope that clarifies things.

Speaking of clarifying things, I'm not a guy ;->
>Would you not agree that this guy should be paid something

by jaqui

Mainframe Entertainment.

http://www.mainframe.ca

a digital animation house ( reboot, beasties, transformers among others )
they use a custom written application for thier office, if they were retaining a consultant they have zero possibility of finding one with experience with thier system.
would it be reasonable to refuse to pay for the consultant's time to learn thier custom app?

by jdclyde

When you are having someone come in to put in a new app, you are paying them to do it because they are the "expert" on that.

Coming in to work on existing custom apps is completely different as they have no way of being an expert on that package and you would know that up front.

by dafe2

Can't believe I did that, usually I force myself to do the 'person' thing.:-).

Actually, I did note your experience and your alternative offers to your client. Most of my comment(s) where directed at 'relkinjb' as his approach to this situation (IMO) was wrong. My 'padding' comment was in reference to another post.

Consultants should NEVER be expected to work for nothing. As I said, many people will 'test' you but all of them expect to be invoiced.

Many times I've been in similar situations as yourself. If the relashionship was good & my 'skill' for a particular task was lacking, we would allways work something out. Once again, provided the relashionship was good & I could complete the job for them.

Absolutely, sometimes you have to walk away. But IMO no GOOD client should expect a consultant to work for free.

by amcol

...to a point.

I have in the past more than once engaged consultants (and hired employees, for that matter...more on that later) who did not have the skill set required but did have a history with me. There's more to getting a job done than technical skill, and as the original poster pointed out in her last response she at least possesses the necessary business and process background.

She also pointed out that she candidly discussed her skill limitations with her prospective client. This is the correct, honorable, and ethical thing to do. The client can make an informed decision, and agreement can be reached on whether or not the consultant's learning curve should/will be subsidized.

That's the point at which you and I part company. I wouldn't provide such a subsidy under any set of circumstances, and I'm pretty sure I can figure out when a consultant hasn't been entirely forthcoming about what they do and do not know.

I don't expect my consultants to work for free. I believe in win-win...if you're doing a job for me, I should get a high quality product and you should get fair compensation. We both should feel satisfied when the job is done. Your compensation, however, may not be monetary...while I of course agree you as a consultant should be paid fairly for your work, you can also feel compensated by having added a skill to your repertoire or by having gained a valuable reference to assist in getting future opportunities with other clients.

When hiring a permanent employee I'm frankly more concerned about how that individual will fit the group and interpersonal dynamic than whether he/she has the exact technical skills needed for the work. Three reasons:

1. Assuming one has the proper background and motivation, you can teach anyone anything they need to know.

2. Hiring people who already know everything there is to know about getting the job done generally gets you bored, unproductive people with no upward mobility.

3. It's the height of management folly to hire a technically competent jerk who can perform independently but very effectively ruin a carefully constructed team dynamic, which is bad on so many levels.

BTW, I apologize in advance but I can't resist tweaking your nose just a little. You took yourself to task for referring to the original poster with a masculine pronoun, then you did the same to me in your prior response. How do you know I'm male?

by dafe2

Your comments make perfect sense of course.

And we part company on the same topic ....... I can't eat repertoire or a reference. Also, I sense we've (both) been doing this for 'awhile' too.

Your (words) remind me of a well respected 'friend' from one of my favorite accounts, hence my inadvertent reference to your gender. I suspect negotiating with you would be just as much of a 'challenge'.

Regardless which gender you speak from... you speak my (native) 'professional' tongue.
Very well said & I'll consider my nose tweaked.

:-)

by jdclyde

Decide how much time you would have to invest to get this software down.

Determine how much you will get for the rest of the contract.

Add in your training time and divide the total amount you will get from the contract. This is your true per hour and if it isn't enough then you have to say so. If the job is a good paying job that will lead to future work then that is also something to keep in mind.

Either way, I would have them pay for what you would need to train yourself, with the understanding of KEEPING the materials.

Good Luck.

by amcol

...but jacqui does pose an interesting question.

If a legacy app needs work of any kind, I'd first try to engage the professionals who did the original work. Assuming the app was developed by a consulting firm I'd go back to them. However, there are occasions where those consultants are no longer available, or more to the point situations where an app was developed by employees no longer with the company.

In that case I'd hire consultants who are experts in the underlying technology. These people by definition would have no knowledge of the app, therefore it would be reasonable to pay an incremental for their learning curve. As jdclyde correctly points out, this would be known up front.

I view this as a similar situation as that presented by the original poster, who did the ethical and honorable thing by being up front about her own knowledge gap. As long as the playing field is level all participants can have a good game.

by bsroufek

In my experience, clients stand the greatest benefit from your gaining a firm grip **not only on known, as well as not so well known products, which they use (!!!) AND HOW THEY USE THEM in their organization. This knowledge, which is indigenous and therefore outside the reach of any consultant by definition, is what you need to deliver his/her greatest benefit.

The Client knows this, I hope.

I think you're in for a ride; but I could be wrong--wouldn't be the first time.

Regards,
Brian Sroufek
http://www.geocities.com/bsroufek2121

by limeginger

Hi there! I just wanted to let everyone who posted know what happened with this project. After several meetings with the client, I opted to bow out. As I'd mentioned in my posts, I had suspected that communication might be an issue--things like nailing down the scope of the project(s) and determining priorities.

As much as I respected the client (who I've known socially for about 10 years), his style is very nonlinear and he had a lot of trouble focusing on priorities--and he frankly didn't want to. That's a style that may work for him in many circumstances, but it doesn't jive with hiring a consultant and spending multiple sessions of exploratory free-flowing brainstorming (which I couldn't charge for).

I put time into scoping out the project, writing it up, and providing a range of options. The scope of work delighted him--not because it allowed him to focus and select a way to go--but because it would spark wholly new and different ideas and possibilities that were unrelated to what we'd discussed previously.

A case in point: the Covey software turned out to be a flash-in-the-pan idea. I found a local consultant who was familiar with the Covey software (as a potential partner), but by the end of our discussion, the client was bored with it, and wanted to check out some other magical software that would help him be beter organized.

As any IT consultant knows, the technology or tool isn't going to completely solve a client's underlying issues. In this case, the inability to focus or prioritize was the root cause of many of the problems I was brought in to "solve." Many times I'm able to help a client with those other issues indirectly if I can first find an appropriate tool for them--but this was a case of continuously moving target, and I couldn't donate any more time on it.

Thanks again for all your great input! I am now working as a consultant for a major hardware/software company, and it's going great!!

This discussion is closed to new replies.