Discussion Locked

converting from 10/100 mbps

0 helpful
3 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I run a small Lan (35 people) at A CPA office. I am using a Novell 5.0 server and a TCP/IP connection to A GW 5.5 server in another location. Due to all the pull on the server for Tax based software I have considered upgrading any 10 mbps nic cardsto 100 mbps and replacing my 2 hubs to 3 com switches with a built in VPN. We have another office with 14 people running a Novell 4.1 server that would also be switched. The offices are not connected. I am planning on implemented a Citrix server with a WAN between offices. My question is.... Is it worth the price to change to switches and 100 mbps nic cards? I have researched the 3COM switches (superstack)and they are about $1500 (would need 3 switches.. 2 for my office and 1 for the other). The total not including purchasing new NIC cards would be $4500. I would appreciate any insight to making this upgrade. (some of my nic cards do support 100mbps)

thanks,
Rob (CNE5)

3 replies

by kevin anderson

Changing from Hubs to switches alone will be a big upgrade for a network with heavy traffic. The cheapest, and easiest route for you to go would be to go would be to replace the hubs with switches, and upgrade the servers to 100 Meg. This would give a dedicated 10 meg connection to each client, rather than sharing 10 between all 35 people. Speeding up the connection between the server and the hub would allow several people to use their full 10 meg bandwidth simultaneously. I would also suggest changing from 10 Meg Half Duplex to 10 Meg full on the desktops and going to 100 Full for the servers. (may or may not be supported on your NICs) This would almost completely eliminate collisions on your network and would show a huge improvement. 100 Meg on the desktops is generally overkill. If you have a few power users, then move their desktops to 100 Full, but hold off on it until you need it. Phase 1, (100Full to the Hubs, and 10 Full SWITCHED to the desktops will make a noticable improvement, especially if you have alot of network traffic.
If you don't have alot of network traffic, then this isn't going to make much difference, and you'd be better off adding RAM to your server.
Check into cheaper switches too, if budget isa concern. 100 Meg has been around for a while now, so you should be OK with just about any switch. Whatever you do, DON'T buy a 100 Meg hub. The price difference is nothing, and the performance difference is massive.

Kev.

This discussion is closed to new replies.