Discussion Locked

Correct rights for drop box

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

We are trying to create teacher drop boxes for students to save or copy work into. There is a Shared directory within our Students directory that students see along with their own individual directory when they log on. We thought that all they needed was Create, but they are getting an error message when they copy a file into the teacher directory. They will see a status bar for copying, the error pops up telling them that they do not have access, but then the file is indeed in the directory and they are able to open it.
We are running a 5.0 box with a mixed Mac/PC environment.
Thank you............

5 replies

by tbradley

by 5.0 box, I assume you're talking Netware.

Your students will need

Read
FileScan
Write
Create
Modify

Novell is sorta backwards when it comes to descriptive terms, and what seems obvious it really befuddled and vice versa.

Read actually means they can open/execute the file, FileScan actually means they can see the file, Write means they can create the file, Create means they can copy a file, and Modify means that whatever attribute is on the file being written/copied is applied to the New file they wrote/copied.

P.S. erase does actually mean erase. Imagine that!!!!!

by alan

We had problems in the past with Macintoshes copying into drop box folders, which are at the same level as the data folders for each course. For Macs under NW3x, we had to give more than just Create; it may have been Modify (and for copying full folders, Access control was granted).
Currently under NW4.11, we only have students given Create for dropoff folders.
DOS/Windows structure folders are different, where the course folder contains the dropbox folder. Students have RF at the course folder and only C at the dropbox.
Faculty advise students to use unique names, and I've seen some that have students use their username and project number to insure the uniqueness since they can't see what exists in a dropoff.
There generally is a warning from Macintoshes stating that they will not have access to their file after copied into a dropoff folder. This should be regarded as only a warning, since the file does get copied in.
Faculty are given RWCEMF for their respective dropbox/dropoff folders and are responsible for cleaning out files after they've retrieved/graded them.
We won't be be moving to NW5 until this summer, but so far this part of NW has been consistent.
The most I would give students is CM on a dropbox iff the files are not being copied entirely. Otherwise, it may be just a warning that can be regarded as informational.

HTH

--alan

This discussion is closed to new replies.