Discussion Locked

Dealing with the competition

0 helpful
19 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
If a client is considering switching to another consultant who isn't qualified -- is it fair game to point out their shortcomings to the client?

19 replies

by bryan bowers

I would advise the client to examine the areas of strengths that I have in relation to the current project. If they feel that the new consultant is more qualified, then gracefuly bow out.

One of two things will happen. The new consultant may actually do well, and you have come off as professional for not putting up a fight. Two, the person will not do well, and you will be hired back to finish the project.

by stan

This is a very delicate question. I personally do not like dirty politics and feel mud slinging should not be allowed, however, the client (your client?) is considering switching to another consultant and the question should be why? If they truly are your client you should have developed the kind of relationship (translate to trust) which would cause the client to ask your opinion. If the client is requesting input from you, you are obligated to be honest. If, however, you are trying to save face (read keep the money coming in) talking up your strengths and advantages (i.e. current and historical knowledge of their business and projects) the only way to go. Sell yourself, do not try to sell the other guy short.

by budnelson

I always say there is enough work to go around , that I do not speak poorly of the competition , that in our business we stand on our reputation. The client can read that anyway they want.

by leehlc

Did you find out if they were considering switching through "the grapevine" or is this out in the open? You might consider asking them what has prompted this condsideration, what do they think they will gain, really what you want to know is why theyare unhappy with you. Pointing out your competitions shortcomings certainly won't help your standing but perhaps by assertively showing your strengths, their shortcomings will become apparent. You certainly don't want to sling accusations but you certainly want to make sure your client clearly understands your strenghts, abilities and your commitment to their issues.--Good Luck

by plantogo2000

NO!
If the opportunity presents itself you should point out what your approach is and why your approach is better than some others. Make sure that the unqualified consultant's approach is camouflaged in the alternatives you have discounted.
In addition, use the scope, quality and cost pyramid approach and let the client know that you are willing to work with anyone they want to work on the project that they may also prefer and in case there is a need they can call on you for support on short notice.

by jcparkerconsulting

I would gracefully accept the clients judgement, if they want to hire another consultant I gracefully bow out. Often I am in the position of a client wanting to use someone else because they are cheeper. I can only offer my experience and good name.

I have a reputation of being able to salvage a project and usually get anumber of such jobs from which my clients call me back and recomend others. I have no problem if they want to use someone else, however I always leave my card and ask that they call if they need me.

I do not make coments aloud or in writing reguarding any other consultant or companies work or results. I will offer sugestions to improve equipment or services where I see tat a problem exists.

by mindbump

You should be diplomatic in finding out why your client is interested in switching. Is it due to budget issues, changes in management, dissatifaction with results, or a basic philosophy to rotate partners periodically.

Once you have more insight into their motivation you can tailor a response that advances why your retention can still be beneficial. I would focus on your strengths and present them in a way that makes it apparent you are stronger than the competition without directly assaulting the other party.

If the change cannot be avoided despite general satisfaction with your work, you might want to pursue a strategy of offering services to a different part of the organization, a business partner of theirs (so that you can still be quasi-engaged and able to assist if it is needed indirectly), or kept on a partial retainer for a short period during the transition, while they evaluate their new partner.

If you are seriosuly concerned about the potential new consultant's quality, then I would pe

by rpallen

This is certainly a judgement call and some questions need to be answered before making the decision. How do you know the other consultant isn't qualified? What is their deficiency that makes them unqualified and how easily can they overcome this deficiency (by learning what is needed, by hiring new personnel or by subcontracting some of the work)? Has this consultant been unscrupulous or unethical in some way? I think a consultant has an obligation to advise his or her clients. If that involves showing why you are better by showing why someone else is not as good, so be it. If your competitor has been unethical and you can show it, you certainly have an obligation to do so. However, if this is just a case of honest competition, give your best shot, find out why they want to replace you (though, chances are they'll never actually tell you-they'll give you some face saving excuse) and move on to the next client. Be gracious and let them know you'll still be available should they decide they want to

by rmgorilla

Since this is your client you should know best what their needs are and should be meeting their expectations. You need to look to youself first and see if you are meeting their expectations. If you are not ask where you need to improve to meet their requirments. If this is a smaller business they may be changing for economic reasons and the shortcomings of your competition are less important than your cost. I have also seen the you scratch my back I'll scratch yours, again if this is a small company your competition may have been referred by the owners friend or close associate who has a small business. Your competition may have contracted both at a less cost. Does this mean you should point out shortcomins, I believe no, because the shortcomings will come forth and one of two things will happen especially if it's a small business.
1. They will hire you back.
2. They will eventually go under due to poor management. In this case you don't want to work for them due to lack of stability.
3. There are so many business that need consultants why worry about losing one, just find another.

God Bless
R

This discussion is closed to new replies.