Regardless of the underlying disk technology being used (IDE, SCSI, RAIDx), the file system sees things in terms of LOGICAL clusters. Each and every partition starts at LOGICAL cluster 0 and goes for nnn clusters. Defragmenters work at the file system level - at the logical cluster level - and ensure that a file is LOGICALLY contiguous. If a file is LOGICALLY contiguous, then only 1 LOGICAL request has to be made to retrieve the file - that is where the performance benefit is achieved. Where that file actually ends up on the hard drive (which platter of which hard drive) is unknown. Even if a file is LOGICALLY contiguous, it may or may not be PHYSICALLY contiguous on the hard drive.
- Greg/Raxco Software
Disclaimer: I work for Raxco Software, the maker of PerfectDisk - a commercial defrag utility, as a systems engineer in the support department.