.
If I had to choose between a "cataloged" Dell and some other "off the shelf" competitor, I'd choose the Dell. However, If I had to choose between a "cataloged and advertised" Dell and one that was custom built to my exact specifications, then I'd choose the custom built. Not knowing how involved you are with specifying exactly what you want (or your knowledge of such things), it's hard to make a recommendation.
Because of a change of ownership at my company, not too long ago, I was asked to justify the fact that I built my own computers. Why didn't I just buy Dells, I was asked? So I went through the process of really comparing apples to apples. For example, in my computers, I want a specific motherboard with a specific chip set with a specific FSB speed with specific features (or an approved equal); I want a specific processor and a specific amount of RAM installed exactly the way I want (1 stick of RAM instead of 3 or 4, for example); I want a specific graphics card with precise specifications (or an approved equal); I want to decide the type and speed of CD, DVD, etc; and I want to specify the monitor, keyboard and mouse (or, again, an approved equal); and so on. When I gave those specifications to a Dell representative for a quote, I discovered that my computer actually cost me almost $1,000 LESS than one Dell could build for me. Of course, the Dell came with a preloaded operating system and a variety of other preloaded software, which wasn't in my "specifications", but many people (myself included) don't like the Dell specific OEM software (or any other manufacturer) that they install, and would want to wipe it all clean anyway. Moreover, much of the OEM software can't be transferred to a different machine and remain compliant with the software license agreements. So for me, I would choose a custom-build every time. Even if I didn't build it myself, and I had to rely on a "small local PC shop", I would specify to them exactly what I wanted.
Why many of these local PC shops get a bad name, and why many of them turn out junk, is that they have to compete with the advertised brand names in price. So they, just like Dell, cut corners wherever they can. A customer will see an "advertised" 3.0 GB P4, for example, and expect the local PC shop to provide a 3.0 GB P4 for the same price (or less). But if you "look under the hood", so to speak, you'll realize that not all V-8s (computers) are built alike. To expand on the car/computer analogy, if you go shopping for a "just a car" (just a computer), with a V-8 engine (a P4 processor), equipped with a radio/CD player (CD-ROM/DVD), painted a certain color (graphics card), and so on, you could spend as little as $10,000 or as much as $50,000, $60,000, $70,000 (or more) for a brand new one. Why the huge difference in price? Because of the huge difference in what you're buying, whether it's a car or a computer.