Discussion Locked

Dell or Generic Brand PCs for the Small Business

0 helpful
23 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I am the IT Manager/NetAdmin at a small business with around 50 workstations/laptops and 4 servers. About 3 years ago we purchased custom built PCs from a small local PC shop. I was not too happy with them after about a year. I began the process of replacing these systems with Dells. We purchased 4 Dell workstations and 1 Dell laptop. So far that's not too many. As we began to replace the rest of the workstations I'm wondering if I should just go with TigerDirect and Systemax and save a few hundred per workstation instead of going with Dell. What should I do? I am the only fulltime technician on-site so I have to handle all the desktop support.

Thanks.
-Matt

23 replies

by thechas

If Systemax from Tiger is your only other option, I recommend that you stick with Dell.

I would be surprised if you found the Systemax to be any more reliable than the PCs you got from your local source.

These are "price-point" systems along the lines of an e-Machine.

Chas

by oz_media

Well in brief, I would pick DELL over the 'custom cheapo' builds any day, if only on a support and warranty level.

If choosing to use OEM's I wouldn't choose DELL though. This is probably due to the much higher level of support (so I'm told) and quality found in Canadian OEM's from Compaq, HP and IBM but DELL is usually seen as a second rate, bottom feeder for the cheapskate around here, no offense to yourself intended.

by pgm554

Dell has a non-branded line of PC's called Whitebox(basically OEM Dell's sold through a dealer).

If can find a dealer that sells and supports these ,it might be a cheaper way to go.

by jamesrl

I regularly go to a dealer which sells Whitebox or "de-branded" PCs for my personal stuff.

These PCs are sometimes refurbished, but most often they are overstocks. When a manufacturer comes out with new models which make their existing models obselete, the manufacturer often buys back(not at full purchase price) the excess inventory, and then turns around and sells these to some selected dealers and wholesalers.

These PCs are good value, but if consistency is part of your support criteria, its kind of hit and miss - the deal with these PCs is that they are often in limited supply and once they are gone they are gone. They also may or may not have any warranty -no manufacturers warranty anyway- thats why these models are debranded, though quite obvious that just obscuring the logo doesn't mean you can't tell which model it is. They also tend to be more the consumer model rather than the business model.

Given that the total cost of ownership of a PC is usually 3 or 4 times that of the purchase price, think about what drives up the rest of those costs - support. I would focus on getting a good PC thats easy to support.

James Linn

by adely

Hi Matt... considering that you're the only person providing techsupport full-time, you'd might as well stick with Dell. Their customer service is usually top-notch, meaning that you'll be able to free yourself from needing to attend to all those nitty gritty support issues as they arise (especially when the organization grows). It may be a bit pricier, but in the long run is well worth it. Unless there are more full-time techsupport staff to assist in daily support for those "clone" PCs, you'd probably be better of sticking with Dell.

by hal 9000

As if the units actually need to be returned you have to make absolutely sure that you have a total backup of any important and seemly unimportant data before allowing them to leave the office. Dell will just bulk erase these units fit any required parts and send them back working but without your data.

Now anyone here can and will be able to tell you that any part or even the total network is easily replaceable in a relatively short time if required like if you suffer a lighting strike or something similar but without a excellent DR plan in place your stuffed as the data held on the HDD is the most valuable part of any computer/network as it is impossible to replace at all. So no matter what else you do YOU MUST have the absolute BEST DR PLAN in place otherwise it is all just a waste of your time and the bosses money!

Col

by maxwell edison

.
If I had to choose between a "cataloged" Dell and some other "off the shelf" competitor, I'd choose the Dell. However, If I had to choose between a "cataloged and advertised" Dell and one that was custom built to my exact specifications, then I'd choose the custom built. Not knowing how involved you are with specifying exactly what you want (or your knowledge of such things), it's hard to make a recommendation.

Because of a change of ownership at my company, not too long ago, I was asked to justify the fact that I built my own computers. Why didn't I just buy Dells, I was asked? So I went through the process of really comparing apples to apples. For example, in my computers, I want a specific motherboard with a specific chip set with a specific FSB speed with specific features (or an approved equal); I want a specific processor and a specific amount of RAM installed exactly the way I want (1 stick of RAM instead of 3 or 4, for example); I want a specific graphics card with precise specifications (or an approved equal); I want to decide the type and speed of CD, DVD, etc; and I want to specify the monitor, keyboard and mouse (or, again, an approved equal); and so on. When I gave those specifications to a Dell representative for a quote, I discovered that my computer actually cost me almost $1,000 LESS than one Dell could build for me. Of course, the Dell came with a preloaded operating system and a variety of other preloaded software, which wasn't in my "specifications", but many people (myself included) don't like the Dell specific OEM software (or any other manufacturer) that they install, and would want to wipe it all clean anyway. Moreover, much of the OEM software can't be transferred to a different machine and remain compliant with the software license agreements. So for me, I would choose a custom-build every time. Even if I didn't build it myself, and I had to rely on a "small local PC shop", I would specify to them exactly what I wanted.

Why many of these local PC shops get a bad name, and why many of them turn out junk, is that they have to compete with the advertised brand names in price. So they, just like Dell, cut corners wherever they can. A customer will see an "advertised" 3.0 GB P4, for example, and expect the local PC shop to provide a 3.0 GB P4 for the same price (or less). But if you "look under the hood", so to speak, you'll realize that not all V-8s (computers) are built alike. To expand on the car/computer analogy, if you go shopping for a "just a car" (just a computer), with a V-8 engine (a P4 processor), equipped with a radio/CD player (CD-ROM/DVD), painted a certain color (graphics card), and so on, you could spend as little as $10,000 or as much as $50,000, $60,000, $70,000 (or more) for a brand new one. Why the huge difference in price? Because of the huge difference in what you're buying, whether it's a car or a computer.

by maxwell edison

.
I suppose I went of on my own little tangent, there, and I didn't really answer your question. You asked if you should buy from, "TigerDirect and Systemax and save a few hundred per workstation instead of going with Dell".

Given only those two options, I'd buy the Dell.

by thechas

Max, I fully agree.

PCs built to our specifications is the "best" way to go.

If you look into Systemax's history you will find that the owners made a number of opportunistic purchases of struggling PC builders.

I don't even recommend Systemax (or e-Machines) for home use.

I can usually throw together a more reliable system from surplus and refurbished parts for someone on a tight budget.

Chas

by oz_media

From what I can see Max, you are referring to retail OEM PC's from a local computer store.

These PC's are NOT designed for business tuse to begin with and yes will be quite cut down models of good working PC's.

I use a dealer that only carries the desktop OEM's and professional workstations that you can't but at the local electronics store, which I would highly recommend as opposed to an over the counter unit.

You can find them by visiting the manufacturers websites and selecting Business Desktops etc.

by hal 9000

I would go with "Custom Built" to my spec's and instead of just buying of the shelf specify exactly what you need in all the boxes. At least that way if you are ever required to do a complete reload you are not constantly looking around for different drivers for all the parts that are not supported by whatever OS yo are using. Believe me 300 computers built exactly the same are a lot easier to maintain than a hooch pooch of different units with whatever individual parts where cheapest that week when you ordered them. You for instance will get total junk if you accept some of the bottom of the range units that have everything on one board as they perform very slowly compared to what these things are capable of doing. I actually see a lot of M'Boards where the CPU is doing the work of the GPU and stealing system memory as well to support the video, these things are absolute junk and if you willing bought things like this then you have got exactly what you deserved.

I would find a very professional shop or techie to build my systems and exactly to my spec's that way you know exactly what you have got and what is likely to happen. Of course this requires a certain level of knowledge about the parts involved and how they work together and this type of knowledge you do not get from reading Computer Magazines and then just choosing what they recommend as you can end up with a bunch of mismatched components that do not want to play nicely together and no end of headaches for you to keep them all running.

Now if you have absolutely no knowledge of components go with the Dell's as they will at least make something that is likely to work even if you are stuck with the supplied OS as you do not know exactly what is inside and what drivers you will need to change to a different OS LT's are particularly bad for this and the Toshiba's are particularly bad for this as they do not provide a list of internal components or provide a set of drivers on their Web Site for the various models of their LT's you only have the recovery disks and if you need to change the OS you first need to make a list of every driver required and then make sure that it is available before attempting to change the OS. What you have to remember here is that you will almost have to do this on every unit as internal pieces may vary between production runs so the same model unit may have different parts inside of it requiring different drivers. Things like this are a nightmare when you have a lot of them to keep running as you have to keep the recovery disks labeled and somehow connected them to the unit that they came with. Things like this are great if you are an accountant but for the average Sys Admin come Techie this is a lot of paperwork that you really do not need.

Col

by jamesrl

I've worked for a number of orgs where we bought the "Business" class PCs from vendors such as Dell, Compaq and IBM.

The way we did it is to pick a line with a fairly long roadmap(mid priced business line), get one of them into the shop, tweak all the settings, download the latest drivers, configure the network settings, load the corporate standard software etc.

Then we would create an image using Ghost. We would ship that image to our vendor, who would charge $25 to load that image onto every PC we bought. Anytime a new model came out, we tested the existing image on it to see if we needed to change. This became a certification process.

This process dramatically improved the hardware delivery process and helped the troubleshooting process. If a particularly stubborn problem presented itself, backing up the data and re-imaging resolved many issues.

Compaq was particularly good at letting us know when one line would be ending and another beginning so that we had hardware in hand and images prepared before the current model became obselete.

One of the issues with consumer grade computers is that because of price sensitivity, they tend to make many hardware changes on the fly, even for the same model, so making images becomes problematic.

The "business" grade computers also tend to use better MBs, have better cooling, better power supplies etc.

While I used to build my own computers at home, I now just buy previously used corporate computers. Its cheaper in the end.

james

by oz_media

Mainly Colin, you state that a custom box will be easier to update than an OEM. In my experience, this is a good argument for CHOOSING OEM's over white boxes.

In the case of my IBM Thinkpad, I just press F11 it reformats, updatres the BIOS, installs ALL hardware and (OEM)software and drivers. If I need updates, the Thinkpad manager checks the IBM site for my model and sees if there are updates available. It is almost TOO easy.

With white boxes, you will need to build your own restore and reformat CD's. If you need a driver update, you will need to visit the hardware manufacturer (whether BIOS, Sound Graphics etc.) and find the updates individually.

In one shop I manage, I have about 40 Compaq EVO D500 desktops. ANY problems needing a reformat and I can have the client do it over the phone without me needed to visit onsite. You slip the CDROM in, go for lunch and it is ready and up to date when you return, how is that harder than manually updating a white box??

That coupled with a 5 yr P&L onsite warranty and level two support desk service from your first call, you can't lose.

The most problematic and time consuming PC's on my client networks are those which were home built or white boxes ordered through a third party, they are being phased out now but a few still remind me of my headaches.

by hal 9000

You would already have your data backed up wouldn't you? The same goes for the Compaq reinstall it has to workable to save the data first if not you do have a problem.

Now granted in the ideal world everyone would follow best practice DR systems but unfortunately in the real world I very rarely see this ad it is a constant fight to recover the data before doing a reformat and if like me you are disinfecting an infected computer where you just can not remove the infected files the hidden partition approach doesn't work once you hit the drive with something like IBM's "Wipe" as it writes 0's to every sector so your hidden partition has disappeared. What I do in a large roll out is to just clone a HDD and keep in available and with Ghost it is an easy thing to recover very fast and very cheap as well.

But of course all this falls to bits on the "One Offs" as they are nothing but a headache and if this guy was only replacing a couple of units I would go with the Dell's but if it is a full scale refit I'd still personally go with the custom built approach however I'm probably biased here as that is what I do for a living so my opinion's are in all likelihood colored.

Col

by hal 9000

Dell's from the makers distributer here not the junk that you see for the home market if that was my only other option it would be the Custom Built ones every time.

Remember this side of the pond we don't have all the nice things that you have over there.

Col

by gbrownlee

Having spent a considerable amount of time trying to get Dell, to actually do something constructive, regarding a clients Inspiron 5100 and getting nowhere; if you should need a warranty claim, you may well find it to be an exercise in futility. I recomend you stay away from the cheap stuff!

by djent

I'll take a "good" custom box any day. I want branded parts with driver support, real VRAM, good cooling, enough power, vendors that honor warranties, real OS install disks, drives that exceed the life span of an ice cream bar. Most auto Mfgs. warranty their cars for 50K miles or more and are compelled to honor them. When computer OEMs are held to the same standard by customers and the law this business will have matured. The primary spec in an OEM box is price (low bid) all other specs are subserviant to the first. If you want a Yugo buy one, but don't claim it is as good as a Buick. The claim that every user in an enterprise should use a common config is dumb, users have different tasks, skill sets, software, job titles and therfore different requirements. You don't want your salesman taking his clients to lunch in a Yugo anymore then you would run Quark or Photo Shop on a $400 Dell.

by oz_media

I agree wholly that the retail garbage you get from the shelf isn't worth a dine. Then again, all these manufacturers also provide professional workstations and desktops through dealers and you get great hardware, 24/7 support or ONSITE service for 5 years. This may cost you 200.00 more but saving an hour or two of your time easily pays that back.

I wouldn't go buy a presario from London Drugs, Staples or Office depot but I will happily pay for a EVO desktop or high-end Intellistation through a dealer, get a better warranty and hardware than the retail PC's.

From what I see here, people are refrerring to the over the counter PC's as the OEM's whereas they are not designed for business use to begin with, they often have cheap hardwaer etc just to kepe price low. These same manufacturers make an entire line of professional builds and offer unsurpassed support ONSITE for them.

by john

I have about 300 Dell Dimension 2400 (Cel 2.7/512ddr/DVDRom/FD/40GB/SND/VID/K&M with a New Dell E773 17" CRT Monitor's. These were slated for a large roll out that was downsized - so these are extra's - still with Dell Warranty. I would be happy to sell off some in 20+ unit lot's if anyone is interested. I would also be interested in taking your old equipment in on trade in as well as I have a need for used equipment right now. Feel free to contact me regarding any of this info :)

Thanks,

John@resourcelogics.com

by oz_media

I like the Aussie gals, they are usually a little less pristine and falsely stuck up compared to North American women who think they are really something. You should see the clubs here, the girls think the sun sets in their ass or something. I find Australian gals much more down to earth and grounded to reality.

Anyhow, I keep a backup disk ususally once every two or three months that has all the NON included software and files on it. With a partitioned PC here, you generally get a reformat disk too so you can max out your HD size if you choose. If you don't get one with the PC, they will send you one no cost in a day or two.

A few weeks back I went to a Netware seminar in Vancouver, before I left my laptop was slowing down, so I het reformat and left for the ferry. As I got to the ferry I slipped in my latest software and files disk, by the time I had eaten breakfast (Great pacific salmon buffet)everything was restored and up to date. It is so easy, I often refomat instead of defragging.

As for white boxes, in my experience, I get called out and spend 6 hours onsite pulling cards and identifying drivers and hardware, reinstalling the OS, updating drivers from everywhere on the web you can think of and then spend MORE time updating and patching.
Sure time is money but if I can spend 1 hour onsite and then go for a kayak in the afternoon as opposed to spending 6 hours rebuilding some antiquated junk white box, I'll take the one hour and the kayak. I don't need to stuff my mattress that much. 2-3 hours a day at full rate is all I need.

by hal 9000

And I thought the AMD Vs Intel would be a real bun fight.

I also understand that we have better beer over here as well.

Col

by worker bee

While Dell still gives first class support to large corporations that buy thousands of boxes at a time, small businesses get decidedly second class support. If you have a problem you will wind up speaking to someone in India working from a script who knows less than you do and good luck if you need a piece of hardware replaced.

I had a hard drive go bad in a Dell server at a small business I was working contract for and they would not replace it because their diagnostic software did not detect the problem. This was an obvious hardware failure to anyone with any experience or any willingness to research the error messages but they would not budge. It was not until a former Dell technician told me to make up some bogus SMART error message that I got my replacement hard drive.

This was a real eye-opener for me since my previous experience with Dell was working contract at the Department of Homeland Security where Dell would respond immediately when we had a problem.

If you are going to buy some machines I suggest you look at MPC (formerly Micron). Their machines get good reviews and their tech support is in Idaho, not Bangalore.

by supermonch

I'm really beginning to dislike Dell machines. Within a very short period of time, I've had many problems with the Dell's I have in my shop. Within a 3 month period, about 10 hard disks failed. That problem was further complicated by the poor support I received when calling their help center. Dell machines are quickly becoming the de facto standard in many shops, but they're almost out the door in mine. I suggest you check out www.mpc.com.

This discussion is closed to new replies.