58 replies
by 1bn0
Were they rude or abusive? What did they do that indicates they think your wife is an idiot, other than question the third-party diagnosis she brought them?
Do they know you personally and your level of skills? If not, I don't see anything unprofessional about their questioning your call. I get handed misdiagnosed problems all the time. "My spouse / friend / significant other works on computers and he / she said the problem is ... ".
These guys may have been unprofessional, but the only evidence you've cited is that they didn't agree with the solution offered by a complete stranger.
by juan18_c
by mjd420nova
by mr.wiz
I work tech support for a k-12 school district. I try to make sure my users can ask me anything without worrying that I'll think badly of them.
The outlook among techs that I've noticed is an arrogance because of our technical skills. Technology doesn't come easily to everyone. The ones that bother me personally are the ones who won't make any attempt to learn about the technology they are using. Many give me the "its not my job" attitude. Those are the ones who are the biggest challenge.
I feel that my job is not just to fix customer problems, it is also to educate my customers. Generally that has been a successful strategy and I've been able to cut my support calls down.
Your problem with your wife's help desk people is understandable. However, criticizing them for following their own procedures and not just taking her word for what the problems were is uncalled for. They don't know who you are or what your qualifications are. If they are like many of our users, you can't just take a users word as truth without verification. I get people all the time telling me what their friend, husband, etc. has told them about what is wrong. Sometimes they are right, many times they are wrong or still missed additional problems.
All we can do is the best we can and try to get along.
by mr.wiz
by shellbot
Although I completely understand what your saying, I am also agreeing with most others here.
I am a DBA, but I also do applciation support for my Users. I treat them as if they are Stars and would NEVER talk down to them. However, they may have to wait 3-5 days for me to get thier problem fixed, because I'm extremley busy, and unless its critical, you just have to wait. I also get calls such as " i can't send an email"..the old "you use computers therefore you should help me fix this regardless"
Anyways, put yerself in this guys shoes.
Maybe he has to document everything he does. I know lots of people in this position.
Maybe his boss is a jerk, and if he puts "mary's husband says this is the problem" he is going to look like a right d1ck head in his bosses eyes.
Maybe they've had similar problems and need to try all resolutions to document them as they are looking for a refund form the vendor.
Maybe they've just had 15 people show up with a laptop that isn't working..and god knows the user didn't do anything, nope, it was just sitting there and decided not to work. Honestly, the user did nothing..yet when the tech looks into it, they've downloaded 40 viruses in the past 6 hours..
Sometimes people feel "brushed off", and yes this happens, I'm guilty of giving this impression I'd say..but you know, when i've got 6 people on call waiting, 2 servers down, a stack of documentation to do and my boss breathing down my neck..i've said "are you sure your doing it right. Go try again/this way and come back to me if its still not working."
At least she got it fixed in the end which is more than i can say for some support teams :)
by tumbras
Worry -
i can appreciate the type of experience your wife had with her Co's IT staff. I can also appreciate the fact that even family members can recognize individual IT member's attitude probably needed an adjustment.
Having said that, let me say that i am an IT consultant myself, and have worked for several years in Server/Desktop support for large size companies = large size bureaucracy.
There will always be two sides to every story - both valid for each party involved. Each with their own perspective - which we are ALL entitled to.
One thing experience has taught me is this - as you have stated - IT Desktop Support ARE primarily two things (hopefully) 1. Educators for the "End-User" community, and 2. Troubleshooters with a boat-load of Customer Service thrown in. Let's face it, IT staff at that level are "user-facing" so they SHOULD, as you and your wife have the right to expect - be prompt, polite and efficient. In a rosy-colored world, that makes perfect sense. In reality though....
It staff is ALWAYS, (at least in medium and large Co's) inundated with several different tasks, more often than not, requiring individual IT members to put on the "Hat" of several different roles. Speaking from my own experience - ive participated in vendor negotiations, project leads, technical writing, training, image design and maintenance, server/kiosk creation, just to name a few. Notice i have not even begin to mention "troubleshooting". There is a reason why, and that is because the average IT guy is relatively underpaid, and WAY over worked, and that can only = disaster for both the IT guy and the end-user. I've never seen a ticketing system (Remedy, Heat, etc..) where their ticket bin was empty - never. They are ALWAYS going to be behind - that's just the way it is for most of us. As for "just reimage it" - i can totally appreciate that - and if it were ever up to me personally, i would have ALWAYS gone that route. BUT, management has that ugly way of throwing wrenches in your plan - and they want things done a certain way, in a certain order - so if ONE person has a bad experience, so what. Believe it or not, it happens like that. The company is ALWAYS going to look out for it's bottom line, and unless your wife is an executive with her company, and if her problem is ONLY impacting her, guess what? she's going to wait, period. That's why there should be in place contracts with each dept on what is going to be prioritized, and an issue impacting just one person, isn't going to be placed too high. It's unpleasant, uncalled for, but it is for the majority of us who've worked this business - reality. We IT guys are ALWAYS stuck in the middle, playing referee/negotiator for the management that is so demanding of us, and the end-user who has deadlines to meet.
What im getting at, is that it's not so much the IT guys fault, and certainly NOT your wifes either. Its the way in which her Co has probably chosen to delegate PRIORITY of incoming trouble issues - compounded by PROCEDURE, because as you probably know, we too have to abide by the Co's S.O.P and and contractual agreements we have with each department. That is what governs how and when things get done.
I cant think of anyone in that position that willingly wants to be berated by an end-user for "taking so long", but the truth is, they are attempting to do the impossible, and still make everyone happy, (or at least try to).
I hope your wife doesn't have another experience like that, she certainly didn't deserve it. It's stories like this one that always sticks in the back of my mind when i AM working with an end-user - it's my internal gauge that evaluates on how im doing with a user - and i try to keep an even-keel about myself always. Number one thing to remember, we are ALL people, not the job-role we play out, but an individual, mother or father, husband or wife - that;s how i look at each of my users.
regards,
Nicholas
by nhahajn
by borginva
Support people should at least get a basic idea of what someone knows and what was done, before going on. I had people on the phone tell me how to empty my cache, reboot, clean temps, etc.
ME
"Buddy! I have been dealing with computers for years. What you suggest, my PC does once a day on its own. My problem is the NIC is not working."
TECH
"A NIC?"
ME
"The network interface card".
TECH
"Okay, let me tell you how to uninstall AOL".
Thay may not be a good example, but it is always good for them to ask questions before assuming anything.
by mr.wiz
And I don't think they're right. But I didn't see any evidence in your original posting indicating unprofessional behavior. You posted your version of someone else's version of what happened, with almost no possibility of the technician telling his side. I'm not in any way trying to put your wife in a bad light, but neither you nor I were there.
What you describe as a "brush-off" may have been her interpretation of the technician's request that he deal with a more critical task first. We don't know if the the tech has seen a rash of problems with this model of laptop that were due to something other than a bad drive. We don't know that all data was on the server, as you state below. I always assume there is data on the drive; users put files on the desktop, some apps put the data where they want, etc. I also consider assuming all data is on the server to be professionally negligent, even if that's where it's "supposed" to be. Frankly, and I'm not trying to be rude, we don't know if your wife has a history of reporting problems that turn out to be user error.
And yes, I am "one of those Desktop Support techs."
by mrivera
by mr.wiz
If you'd read my earlier post, you'd know that I agree with most of what you say. The manner that you address other professionals is unprofessional and denigrates your argument. I've dealt with both arrogant techs and arrogant users. You're no better than any of them and just as arrogant in your attitude. If you choose to continue this in this vein, I feel sorry for you.
And yes, I'm proud to be a "Desktop Support Tech" as you put it. I know that most of my job is customer service and training. I also know how to keep my frustrations and anger from showing to my users and other techs.
by mr.wiz
by shellbot
now i'm sure someones going to have a go at me for this, but the system works great.
P1ss me off and your work goes to the very deep dark bottom of the pile.
Be halfway pleasant and nice about it, it gets done quick enough.
Be proactive, respond to my queries for more info on the problem, its gets done within the day if possible.
A few users have actually figured this out and are a joy to work with.
Then i have the one that gets frustrated and yells at me..you'd think after 2 years she'd figure out her work always gets done last, and i do just what i need to..no extra.. Ok, i could forgive her the first time she raised her voice and i hung up. But come on..she's done it about 20 times now..God there is no better feeling than hanging up on a Manager and then ringing her back in 30 minutes and saying "if you're a bit more relaxed, maybe we can sort this problem out now, if not how about you call me tomorrow"
Priorities:
0) Things my boss tells me overrides other tasks (3-4 times a year).
1) Shipping department during the last week of the financial month (need to meet the sales quota).
2) Payroll.
3) Network / infrastructure problems that keep multiple people from working.
4) Single user unable to work and I can fix quickly.
5) Single user able to work and I can fix quickly
6) Single user unable to work and I can't fix quickly.
7) Single user able to work and I can't fix quickly.
8) Nice but not essential
9) Any self-inflicted injury regardless of whether it fits any of the previous categories.
I think you really see this from a subjective perspective, first of all becuase your wife is involved, and second because you were not there to interpret the moods or tones of the involved actors.
So I agree with the ones here that are finding attenuating circumstances for the tech guys, especially that you mention it's about a large company. The larger, the more procedures and policies you have to follow, the more problems and helpDesk tickets you will have, and the more time it will take for problems to be fixed.
For me, hearing you complain that your wife's case was not fixed in half a day is just out of proportion. Unless your wife's the company's CEO I don't think her laptop could've been fixed in half day.
the only question is why did she not get a spare laptop, or a spare workstation to work, for the time being ??? Be that half a day or a week.
by w2ktechman
but I would think that loaner systems would have been available.
I work in a large corp and deskside has loaners, and for my dept. I have a few as well (specialty apps installed alerady).
This means that I can have a loaner setup in a short time (usually 30 min to 1 hour) with basic functionality + more.
so, why did they not have spare laptops than, especially if it's a basic image involved ?
Of course we make assumptions, and so do you, you are just mentioning now the importance of your wife's position and task at that point.
by absolutely
"It would have been quicker to give her a replacement laptop instead of their desktop support guys wasting half a day on troubleshooting, preventing her from doing her work and jeaporadizing the project, [b]which could have potentially looked very bad in front of the client.[/b]No, she is not the CEO, but her ability to get work done on time [b]impacts the company's bottom line and reputation.[/b]"
How to get your entire company working on serving the customer, especially those whose "customers" are all fellow employees, is an interesting challenge, which is not specific to help desk IT folk.
by jamesrl
Priority one:
major systems failure of a key business system - going to lose money/credibility with customers.
Priority two
Major systems failure that impacts a number of people and makes them unable to do their job
Priority three
Major failure that impacts one person, and makes it impossible for them to do their job.
Everything else.
Self inflicted, I don't judge necessarily as if the CFO is about to go to an annual meeting, its pretty stupid to be petty about the cause, the company needs you to fix it. Blame can come later.
I also don't worry about how quickly I can fix it - the impact to the company should come first. If I need to I can co-operate with my peers to ensure fairness.
Now, I haven't been a tech for a decade. But I did manage 20 of them....
James
Everything else.
by w2ktechman
I also partly do not agree.
As I do partly work in support, but moving away from it a bit, I do get all kinds of things. Some I pre-diagnose as user problems, yes, and sometimes I am wrong.
I get told by people consistantly that they have done nothing, or that all they did was open Outlook, or the like. Then I find out that they downloaded a 3rd party program or tried installing a webcam or some other crap.
Although, as a support professional, I do try to minimise anything that could be considered offensive, and often downplay any fault on their part. This usually makes them feel better, and, they were often just playing around anyway (I do it).
But, I cannot rely on anyones word of what happened. If I cannot find out the problem quickly, I setup a loaner system and take their system until it is fixed. Then I have all the time I need in order to diagnose the problem(s).
And 1/2 a day to reinstall the system is nothing here where I work. First I need to use an image, then I need to configure the system, then I need to install apps that are special for their job, then I need to transfer data from the old system/hdd, then I need to setup the backup service and retreive/backup the system.
usually, for a new hire this takes a day, but for someone that has been here a while, 2 days is not unheard of (or 3 if they do not give me the information that I need).
Diagnosing, reimaging and transferring data in 1 day is not bad at all.
by av .
Without a doubt, I have worked with desktop support people that have the IT God attitude and are just not helpful. Most are usually not like that though.
Looking at what happened to your wife from the IT support person's point of view though, I'd have to do my own testing regardless of what you said about the laptop because thats my job. I wouldn't have my job for too long if wrote on my trouble ticket that someone's husband said he scanned the hard disk and found it was bad so I replaced it. If I took the word of every user, I'd be re-imaging laptops or replacing disk drives on a daily basis.
1/2 day turnaround really isn't bad. Sure, your wife was inconvenienced and you would think a large company would have loaner laptops to accommodate her, but maybe you're taking their response too personal because they didn't follow your advice without question.
Desktop support is always a slippery slope because you're dealing with people that are aggravated to begin with because their computer isn't working and they can't get their work done.
by absolutely
& everybody should assume that they are replaceable. But, there is an unspoken collective agreement to resent our work & underachieve, so that no boss can easily fire you because your boss can't depend on the field of applicants having any better attitude than the conceited, rude mediocrity she wants to fire. Your later post, in which you imply that rudeness at the DMV is expected, therefore acceptable, proves my point. Every job I have ever done has included introduction to the work by the boss, and indoctrination by some or all peers to the collective expectation of laziness & contempt for the work. Better employers have less of this, but I have yet to find an employer totally free of this atmosphere. And as long as people expect to be treated like sh*t when they're customers at the DMV, they'll expect to also get away with the same quality of service, to at least some of their customers.
A thought snack before I close: if you were to complain about the service at the DMV, would you feel like an a**hole? Your taxes pay their wages. Your wife doesn't pay for the support of her employer's IT department, she receives money from that employer. Your expectations are higher of somebody who pays money to your household than somebody who receives money from you, who is effectively your employee.
by now left tr
When people get 'others' who have no right to be using or looking at equipment to scan / diagnose problems. They have no right to use the system (legally - will be in contracts) and by showing another, such an act can result in the person being fired for gross misconduct.
If I was the IT department I would report your wife and get her fired for allowing 'this' to happen to company owned equipment!
This is the other side of your coin!!!!
by now left tr
and the policy about comapny owned IT equipment.
You KNOW I am correct in my statement so what are you taking such an issue to it. I was only showing the other side of the coin.
You could have 1,000,000 years experience but under the employment contract you have no right to 'look' at the machine in question.
I am siding with company policy. Would it be OK for me to take a look at one of your machines without you knowing or allowing???
You also Say:
"I have over 15 years of experience in this stuff and the so called IT gurus who run her company's desktop support staff are all inexperienced kids fresh out of college and don't understand the business side of IT"
*********
NOTE: Your profile says:
I am a CNE with over 10+ years of IT experience
You joined in 2005 - so how over 15 years IT experience?
(if it was 15 you would have say 15, not 10+ - human nature)
*********
I'd fire the idiot in desktop support who wasted her time instead of giving her a new laptop"
So you are firing people because they lack experience now? Despie the fact that they are, as you state, 'kids' and again, as you state, just out of 'college'????? - geeez...glad I never worked for somebody like you when I started 12 years ago.
I feel sorry that you have built up such a twisted attitude towards support staff. I guess you were never one in your 15! years.
Hope you don't get a trainee docor at any time - by your standards you would be better of on a slab than see their likes.
by b.mojo
by absolutely
"How come I was able to find problems with the machine and her desktop guys didn't find anything wrong, assuming they performed a thorough analysis of the machine?"
It's quite possible that they work from a "troubleshooting" [i]script[/i] that requires certain actions, regardless of technological sub-category of reported malfunction.
Customer: "I checked my NIC status and I am getting an IP address, Gateway, and DNS server"
Technician: "Please be going to start-run, and type cmd, followed by enter key. Then type ipconfig /all"
Customer: "But I already told you I have a valid IP address, that's not the problem I am having"
Technician: "Please be rebooting your PC"
Customer: "I've done that numerous times already, but that does not address the problem"
Technician: "Please be following directions or I cannot assist you otherwise"
Customer: "Stop wasting my f*****g time because your troubleshooting skills suck..goodbye"
That's the point I am making here. They follow some script for troubleshooting as if they are a bunch of trained monkeys, yet refuse to use their brains and logical analysis to pinpoint the source of the problem. This is what distinguishes us seasoned IT pros from these amateur wannabes who are trained to perform their jobs like robots.
by w2ktechman
that is policy.
I used to work for a company as a deskside lead. There were certain people on the helpdesk that knew me well and other deskside people. B ut unfortunately, they did not last long at the helpdesk because they took our word on what we did rather than follow the script in front of them.
Even though we were trained pro's in the same company, they still had to follow the script to a 'T' or face write-ups and possible terminations.
Some of these people suck, but the majority are trying to keep their jobs long enough to get enough experience to find a new job.
by absolutely
"Maybe I am being too objective, but..."
Yes, there is a popular epidemic of locally excessive objectivity, which deprives morons of the opportunity to stumble upon the correct answer by random chance and also be first to arrive at that correct answer. On behalf of morons everywhere, "Please stop". On behalf of myself, please continue.
by now left tr
It may be the other guy is has an actual off-line life for the weekend. It may mean his system or connection are down. It may mean his job responsibilities require him to do some actual work for a while.
It may just mean he's decided you're a twit. I quit responding to the "Irish new members" in January for this reason.
Mind you, I think you're right too, but not getting a response doesn't prove either of us right.
by now left tr
by shuubz
as my wife says, computer people are like hairdressers, they rarely like or trust each other's work.
just because you know what you're doing, doesn't mean that their IT staff has to buy your diagnosis. when it comes out of the mouth of a non-IT user, it is no better than hearsay. add to that the grim stats on computer literacy (most adults over 30 are using computers at a 4th-grade level, if that, and management is usually worse), and it becomes reasonable to assume that the user has no competence in diagnosing IT problems.
i understand your annoyance, since your wife is the user in question, but such assumptions are usually correct, and justified by operational necessity. they could certainly have handled the situation better in terms of communication and setting expectations. i don't know the competence level or the tools available to their IT department, so i can't judge that side of the incident.
it usually helps to step back and judge such things without sentiment, though when it comes to my own wife, i have a hard time remaining detached as well.
by d50041
by now left tr
by shellbot
i don't know where you work, but this is pretty much how it is most places.
My manager makes my descions for me, yet doesn't even have enough knowledge to sort her email by date or name.. I'm no expert, but at least i've got several years experience with databases and programming. I have my users begging me for some alterations to our application, and i wholeheartedly agree with them, however, manager won't sign off on it, as she doesn't understand the importance of it.
Such is life..maybe those idiot kids out of college are simply trying to do the best the can within an environment which limits them? Obvioulsy if there are no loaners and other things you say are true, its pretty obvious that the management is doing things how they want to , not how they should be done. If its that bad, i bet they are all planning on moving on when they can.
Maybe those kids feel like your wife, frustrated by those who they lok to for help?
With my little bit of experience in Tech Support in Reatil (which i no longer do) i have had so many people that have had their best friend "the plumber" diagnose their problem. It was taken as a valid point of view, but we still HAD to REPEAT the problem IN HOUSE. I personally do not accept a diagnosis from someone that I do not know or who does not work for the company. Not saying that they are wrong, but have to see the problem for myself.
For the problem with the timeline, how do you know that there weren't 3 other systems that were needing repair before this one? If the company does have loner systems they may all in use because of the 3 other systems that are in.
Where I worked there were times that it took WEEKS to get parts in if they needed to be replaced and yes customers were frusterated but it was out of our control. Anything warranty we had to get parts form that supplier.
I also agree with the post about the service contract (I don't remember the name of the poster) on a lot of systems the warranty can be VOID if an unauthorised person works on the system. Not to mention the information that is on the system being possibly seen by an unauthorised 3rd party.
I'm not saying that it was a problem for your Wife to have a possible solution, but they will have to be able to do their job in the way that they are told by their management. If they have to follow a guide then that is what they do. Just because you have "found" the solution you don't have any authority over them and should stay off their backs.
When you started out I'm sure you had people with experience looking down on you and thinking that you were holding back progress.
Everyone has to start somewhere, the only way to get experience is to do it yourself, and not have to listen to someone elses husband rant about the half day that his wife couldn't do work.
by absolutely
And what I can control, but don't, I choose not to control because I have no need to control it. What's left, if I'm going to worry about anything at all, the only logical choice is that which I [i]cannot[/i] control.
:p
by mrivera
by gphalpin
Sounds like the IT people there are sick and tired of their jobs and users. Here's a site dedicated to unruly users--not that your wife falls in that category.
www.helpdeskrevenge.com
by nhahajn
by computrtek
I must say I understand where your coming from.... however, I've been doing this for 14 years and I can honestly say that the amount of computer savvy people compared to the computer illiterate is small indeed.
We as support technician are lied to on a consistant basis, for instance. " No I didn't download anything ... it just stopped working" :| sure... whatever.
Also... when people assume they know more than the man/woman trying to fix things...if that is the case... fix it yourself and stop wasting our time.
We run into a lot a people who blame the machine when it is clearly their fault. running third party software is never a good idea since they have no idea what has been done on the back end.
I know some peiople are condescending... but they are few. when we get met with the whole "you serve me" attitude, it is like being in retail... most people don't work there because it it the end user/customer that looks down at us. SO this is actually on both sides of the fence.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Trending Software posts
Sort by Trending