Question Locked

Difference between virtualization and client-server technology

0 helpful
37 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Server virtualization and desktop virtualization consolidate all the available resources in order to run multiple servers and desktop operating systems on fewer pieces of underlying hardwares. What about cloud computing and user state virtualization? These seem to run on a platform similar to client-server technology but in a bigger or improved scale. I am wondering why they are called virtualization. Isn't it a hype or a confusing term?

I don't know about Server virtualization as I have not installed and tried one yet. With desktop virtualization I have found there are some features that wouldn't work or available on a virtual system as on a regular operating system. I presume the server virtualization would have the same limitations. So virtualization is not everything. It is not something that could simply replace the regular systems so that we can save some resources. There are limitations. Where are all the documentation that would let us find out the difference in terms of features and functions that a virtual system won't have prior to installation. More often than not I didn't know the feature was not there until I installed the virtual system and tried to implement the desired feature.

37 replies

by seanferd

They are basically unrelated, and could be used together.

User state virtualization: User settings and data are not stored in the client machine of the user. E.g., the user profile is stored on a server, not the workstation. This is nothing to do with hardware/OS virtualization.

Ooh: http://www.microsoft.com/downloads/details.aspx?displaylang=en&FamilyID=fd01ed7a-c603-4f7c-8a60-8e4872b58bdf

in general: http://www.google.com/search?q=user+state+virtualization

Desktop virtualization generally has different uses from server virtualization. For desktops, the ability to run another OS to do things you cannot with the installed OS. For servers, the ability to run several servers on one hardware server. Generally in effort to avoid buying more hardware when the current hardware has enough spare resources to provide other services. E.g., run a database server, mailserver, etc., completely separately on one physical server.

Cloud computing is just a more amorphous way to provide services than a direct client-server relationship. You get service from whatever server or servers are available rather than depending on a dedicated server.

Your problems with desktop virtualization: It depends on how you created the virtual machine. If you, say, simply downloaded a pre-packaged VM and ran it on VMWare Player, you may be quite limited. You must build a VM according to your needs, and installing the appropriate tools to allow you to, e.g., share files between the VM and the native OS, or to install further software in the VM.

by healer

the term "virtualization" for the server and for the desktop but I am somewhat unconvinced on cloud computing and user state virtualization.

cloud computing
Cloud as I gather just refers to Internet. To me Internet is just a network that covers much greater distance. I believe we had non-dedicated server long time ago. Now networks are just getting much bigger scale and faster speed. So it is just a new name but somewhat old concept. It is only "new" in the sense that we now have more choices. And for some reason "cloud computing" also falls into the category of virtualization which is not quite correct to me. As far as I can see virtualization is only applicable to the technology applied to the server at the far end and probably the so-called "user state virtualization" at the near end.

user state virtualization
I thought I was pretty sure that similar functions were already available when I worked in an office years ago where they were using Windows 2000 or even NT4. All of us could have customised desktop, pre-set network path probably by running a batch file when the user logged on, and all the files were stored in the server. It didn't matter which computer in the office we logged on, we always got the desktop with the same look-and-feel, the same program options available on the start menu and same home directory and network path.

What is the difference in terms of the technology and of the upshot of the user state virtualization apart from faster machine and different operating system? Where does the virtualization fit in?

I've just set up a Windows XP Mode and Vista with Windows Virtual PC on a Windows 7 system trying to test some VPNs and they don't work. I've checked with Microsoft and they told me VPNs were not supported in the virtual machines and so weren't the USB devices with Hyper-V. There is no official documentation anywhere telling me what virtual OSes don't do as compared to the regular operating systems. Every time I can only find out the inadequacy after I spend all the time and resources to set them up and try them out.

When you say pre-packaged VM, I think you mean virtual appliance. I have just downloaded one appliance for the ubuntu desktop edition and run it on the VMWare player. Trying to share some folder from the host system, I have done what I am supposed to do but still can't see the shared folder. I can't find the USB devices either, having changed the setting and restarted the virtual system. I have managed to get the Windows counterparts in this respect to work though. There are limitation with VMWare in that I've got to download some readily available appliance. I can't install any OS with my DVD as I could with the Windows Virtual systems. There is no free software for making appliances. VMWare Studio has to run on some paid system. I hope I could save any change of setup or data with the vitual appliances though.

by seanferd

The "Cloud" might be a local cloud, a distributed cloud, or a cloud that is at the end of many internet "connections", or just one. An example of the latter would be like the cloud services MS or Amazon offer. You just buy time or cycles or whatever on their cloud - a buttload of servers doing whatever is requested by whatever job is doing the requesting at the moment. Great rental opportunity for those who have a temporary need of a lot of computing capacity. No need for your own servers.

The cloud is just distributed computing. Good for some things. For other things, why bother? Nothing inherently to do with virtualization, but virtualization, I'm sure, makes it easier to run a large cloud.

User state virtualization:

Stop thinking of this as having anything at all to do with virtual machines. Same last name, no relation. Simply encompasses a variety of ways that the MS Windows user profile are not tied to the local installed OS. Roaming profiles, whatever.

When you say pre-packaged VM, I think you mean virtual appliance.

Inclusive of the appliance-type VMs, yes.

As to Virtual PC and how well it works, and how well documented it is, you're right. I wouldn't even bother. Not yet at least. You must consider, regarding networking, that you are using a virtual NIC in the virtual machine, among other things. Bear also in mind that the hypervisor market is not really intended for the average consumer, but for those who have the experience, money, and time to deploy such things after deciding it is a solution for them. On the consumer side, VPC andd XP Mode are for people who just need XP to run some app or other. It isn't meant to be used as the normal OS all the time.

If you want more out of virtual machines, either wait a couple years, or learn how to tinker with them to get what you want. Use at least a VMWare product, if not something else. VPC isn't all that great, although I'm sure MS has made better features available in their enterprise-class offerings.

Trying to share some folder from the host system, I have done what I am supposed to do but still can't see the shared folder.

Well, if that appliance doesn't have the appropriate VMWare tools installed, it won't work.

There are limitation with VMWare in that I've got to download some readily available appliance. I can't install any OS with my DVD as I could with the Windows Virtual systems.

You want something other than VMWare Player to make VMs. Another VMWare product (e.g., Workstation), or another virtualization solution.
http://www.vmware.com/products/workstation/

Anything with all the features will cost some money, sure. Or, you could go Open Source & Free with a different solution.
http://www.labnol.org/software/free-virtualization-software-comparison/10968/

"I hope I could save any change of setup or data with the vitual appliances though. "

Again, it pretty much depends on how the appliance was built. The Ubuntu Appliance one, for instance, is designed specifically to not save anything at all.

by nexs

There are some considerations when talking about virtualization.
1. It is often used, not to save on costs/space/anything, but to make disaster recovery and redundancy more efficient.
2. Some vendors will not support server/client applications or services if they are running on a virtual environment

If anything, virtualization is more expensive than physically having a server in a rack. So you really have to weigh up your needs/options.

by healer

virtualization for disaster recovery and redundancy. I think the http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/sysinternals/ee656415.aspx about Disk2vhd is a good one for backing up disk. I suppose we can just create the disk image for future restore. I hope there would be application readily available for free to convert the virtual disk image to a physical image so that if we choose we can simpily and easily restore it back to the hard disk.

I wonder which vendors will not support server/client applicationsor or services. So what would be the use of such virtual environment?

by nexs

For certain than IBM have an application server that they refused to support.

I can only imagine that something that converts virtual to physical would be costly. And rightly so. I don't think I'd trust my servers integrity on something dodgy.

by waharleyguy

I hate to burst your bubbles guys, but system virtualization is already a reality in more than just the IT world. It is already installed in process control environments (process manufacturing, waste/water, power generation). And there is a significant cost savings in both hardware and maintenance. In a typical medium process control system, it is possible to have eight physical server nodes (4 x 2 for redundancy). With VMWare ESX software we can reduce the physical nodes to two! Four Primary VMWare images on one node and Four Redundant VMWare images on the second physical node.

by seanferd

has very good descriptions of the things which fall under user state virtualization. Realize, however, that none of them are remotely new.

As the article notes, virtualization refers to some sort of decoupling. User state virtualization decouples, in some manner, some or all user data and/or settings from the workstation. E.g., a user can log into any machine on the network and have her profile available, because it is stored on a server. OS virtualization decouples the OS installed in a VM from the hardware.

It is this decoupleing which causes some of the problems you have encountered in the free commercial products like VMWare Player and Virtual PC. I don't know as much about VPC, but if you build a VMWare VM with the appropriate settings and tools, you can share files easily between the native OS and the VM after sharing is set up.

Overall, though, if you want to experiment with making your own VMs, look into VirtualBox. As with any guest OS VM creation methods, you will have to learn how to create VMs with the capabilities you want. Far more flexible than VPC, and free, unlike the more advanced VMWare products. Runs on Windows host OS, so no problem for you there.

Whatever you do, have fun learning. :)

by healer

Thanks for your kind response.

I just feel odd with the term user state virutlization. What virtualization? With the traditional server-client systems, there is also some sort of decoupling too I believe.

The only difference I can see is now one can connect to many more servers far and near, wired or wireless.

by healer

you gave me http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virtualization. I know I've got to learn and accept the terminalogy. I've just liked to talk with somebody so that I get convinced and reinforced in my mind. It's just like language, enough people use the wrong word for the wrong meaning, the wrong word would become the correct word. There's no logic.

If the client/server technology didn't exist prior, I would probably be more ready to take it.

Have a good day! I am happy I have reached some conclusion.

by seanferd

I understand your way of thinking, especially since "virtualization" is so commonly used to describe hardware and OS virtualization. But the term cannot be limited in this way.

The virtualization in USV is simply decoupling of the user profile from the local workstation. You are correct: No hardware or software virtualization on a virtual machine is required. No processor virtualization extensions are required. This type of virtualization rather pre-dates the modern use of virtualization environments like VMWare.

For further considersations:
Java VM / MSjavaVM - Different kind of virtualization.
Virtual reality - all varieties.
Virtual particles (let's go waaaay back into physics history ;) )
Virtual keyboard
Virtual FileSystem
Virtual memory: your swap/paging file is part of this
Virtual foldsers

Ooh, ahh: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virtualization

But again, I see where you are coming from. Virtualization is just a far more generic term than how you, perhaps, are used to hearing it used. And what with the way the industry likes to throw around jargon and popularize a concept of the week, this is not at all surprising.

Best wishes to you in pursuing your interests. I hope they become slightly less confusing. :)

by seanferd

And I know how uncomfortable it is to keep having word usages redefined or used in a manner somewhat contrary to the meaning to which you have been most exposed.

There have been quite a few threads here about use of the word "hacker" here lately, in which several people, including myself, take exception to its use with negative-only connotations.

I'm glad that you have reached some sort of conclusion to your quest. Take care. :)

by seanferd

http://www.grouppolicy.biz/2010/08/best-practice-roaming-profiles-and-folder-redirection-a-k-a-user-virtualization/

Virtualization is currently a buzz word and it seems that Microsoft is falling over itself to brand as many products as possible with the ?V? word (e.g. Hyper-V, App-V & Med-V). So ?User State Virtualization? is the term that Microsoft now uses to describe what used to be call Roaming Profiles and/or Folder Redirection.

I think that is sort of vindicating for your position. :D As a matter of fact, and I don't think I ever actually said this, I rather agree that the use of the term virtualization in this case can be sort of confusing, misleading, or just buzzy, even though I accept the use as valid.

So, I thought you might enjoy that. :)

by nexs

But not I.

Roaming profiles are Roaming profiles. I'll not succumb to the newly appointed standard when everyone else starts calling them V-Profiles.

No way, no how.

I've let myself slip enough all ready; I hate the acronym 'PC', but as of recent, I've been using it more and more.
That's it! No more 'PC'ing from me....
Except that last one there...

by healer

when too many people make the same "mistakes" in a language the mistakes will no longer be mistakes.

In order to show that you are on the same page, same wavelength as other people in the same field you might have to speak the same language in order to have people readily understand you.

by seanferd

of posting that excerpt. One more soul who understands the Buzzy McBuzzword effect, in support of Healer's contention. Particularly since it seems that buzzwordiness is why MS started referring to roaming/redirection as USV, and not for any other real consideration.

Even though I "get" the usage, it is pretty much just obfuscatory.

by healer

That's what I had been trying to get across. Glad that you get my drift.

by seanferd

I just didn't spend enough text acknowledging that, while spending a lot of text trying to explain why the term is used that way.

Cheers!

by nexs

I'll be happy be on a further page than others if it means keeping my pride and my sanity.

If others don't understand me, then I'll explain it in more detail. Maybe people don't like that, but Tough Biscuits/T1tties.

by nexs

Is now one of my favourite word(s)s.

Time for us all to use words with respect to their dictionary meaning. I'm sure we could conceive a following without much limb twisting.

by healer

Since you said most computer servers use only 20% of the resources at one time one might ask why don't we then have computers only 20% as powerful. Then you might say we need computers run fast when they run regardless of how much idle time is left unused.

What if more then one servers on the same computer need to do their jobs with the same priority efficiently? Somebody needs to give in. Don't we think sharing resources still slow down some systems regardlesss.

by waharleyguy

I have been using VMWare packages (VMWorkstation, VMPlayer)for over 4 years now. I use it to provide training classes for systems that require different Microsoft O.S. platforms. We also like it because the VM Image is indepent of the host that we are using (desktops, laptops, etc...). It is true that you will need to get a licensed version of VMWorkstation to create your own VM images. And I agree that you must install the latest version of VMTools. We have created images that use multiple networks, USB, multiple hard drives and even multiple monitors. You can copy and paste files from the host to the VM Image and back. With VMWorkstation there is also a "snapshot" feature that lets you capture a safe point to restart in case you crash the image. In over 4 years of heavy use, we have found the VMWare products to be stable, resilient, and relatively fast. VPC doesn't even come close to matching the features of VMWare. It also makes sense to join the VMWare Users Group and receive a wealth of information at your fingertips. Hope this helps with your questions.

by healer

I had some issues that I couldn't solved. I posted the question at the forum and didn't get any response. So I had started to use VirtualBox.

by waharleyguy

VMPlayer is just that, a player of VM images. While it is possible to modify and edit your settings by opening the filename.VMX file with Notepad, you will need some understanding of the file settings.
If you don't want to spend the money on VMWorkstation, there are some 3rd party software packages that will allow you to create and edit VMWare images.

by healer

for the same processes you have done? I am using Windows Virtual PC and Virtualbox.

by waharleyguy

I'm not familiar with Virtualbox and as I mentioned earlier, we found VPC to be way behind in features compared to VMWare.

by cg it

but in the same light, it also creates a larger set of points of failure.

I'm working right now on a heavily VM'd network where 2 of the 4 physical servers they have died, of which 4 vm servers were hosted on each of those 2 physical servers. that equates to 8 servers being down, all at one time.

you can't imagine the havoc that resulted.

the upside is it's realitly easy to get the show back up and running because the virtual servers are all images. The downside is, unless you take snapshots of the images daily, there is data loss.

I'm also working on a project with a large insurance company that uses VMs for their workstations. Insurance companies have been using VMs for workstations for a couple years now as it's easy to deploy new features. users muck up their desktop or laptop, just push the new image and restore from backups [that's to a virtual server].

but in the server room, if redundancy is not planned right, when the physical server that hosts the VM servers goes south, it can cause a mess.

While there's a lot of variety of how to use virtual machines, the bottom line is VMs take the place of individual physical hardware. 8 physical servers can be reduced down to 1 or 2 servers depending upon the physical hardware capabilities.

by healer

disaster recovery takes virtual machine for prompt restore. Some proprietary software provides quick restore to physical machine or virtual machine from backup. And the backup can be done up to the minute.

With the virtualbox, the snapshot can only be created manually. I am too sure of the VMWare though. What virtual machine do you use, Windows, VMWare, or Virtualbox?

by healer

will allow me to create and edit VMWare images? Could you please let me know?

by waharleyguy

I believe that the shareware is called VMXBuilder. Realize that it has its limitations. The latest version of VMWorkstation and Player (7.0) have added many advanced features so I stopped using VMXBuilder.

This discussion is closed to new replies.