So you weren't the favorite candidate, eh?
Been there.... :-)
If I recall correctly, there was a time that DLC was required by HP network printers and OS support for IP printing was poor anyway.
But I don't ever recall thinking there was a PRO to DLC other than you had to use it to get the printers to work. I suppose that if you were running out of IP addresses or were running another protocol like IPX, you might be able to come up with a few more positives.
On the CON side, if I have to make a choice between support one protocol or many, I'll take supporting one. A pure IP solution gives you broad access to the printers across the system, doesn't require special handling at the routers or firewalls and allows you some choice in where you spool the printer jobs.
That's the technical part. In view of your final comment, the social part is "choose your battles wisely". If compromising on a printer protocol buys you some peace you can use to accomplish other things, it may be an acceptable tradeoff.
regards!
paul