58 replies
by prefbid ii
I would LOVE to know the answer.
I don't know that I would put it in as dire terms as you have, but I agree whole heartily with the direction of the question.
I think part of the problem is that the bean counters are rewarded in the short term, so while they pay lip service to long term savings issues, those don't really stack up on their list of "important" issues.
The other side of the equation may be in the way technology changes business. Bean counters like to evaluate the world by "holding the world constant" and evaluating the new proposal as if it was the only change being made. They then become upset because their calculations did not come true. Example dialog:
CFO: "I thought you said you would get 4% market share when we introduced the new widget."
Tech: "Our competitors had the same great idea and we ended up only defending our market share."
CFO: "So you are telling me we wasted all that money on your lame widget."
Tech: "No, we kept from losingmarket share, that is still the same benefit as forcasted. I can not build a forcast on how the competition changes."
CFO (to secretary): "Make a note for annual evals that tech wasted money on lame widget."
The truth is that as technology changes, expectations rise faster than realized savings. Its easy to see in presentation software. In life before powerpoint, it was acceptable to have an internal meeting with hand drawn slides and a copy of notes. Now it is required that even minor meetings come with a full slide show. Was any cost saved with getting Powerpoint? No. Does it gain you a competitive advantage in a sales presentation? No. It's now the minimum standard. Was it originally justified based on cost or sales advantage? You bet. And that is the problem. The bean counters are still mad that you "suckered" them into buying Powerpoint.
You couldn't be more on the money with that one.
The latest one that we're still laughing about is that we've had a contractor here for just over a year. We tried to hire her after she had been here for 6 months, first of all to save our costs and second to retain her because she's GOOD. We went through all the channels, interviews, meetings and even prepared an offer that the CFO approved, then stopped a day before the offer was presented because he and the CIO didn't see eye to eye on the department's budget of 'new widgets' that are right now making us more efficient. Anyway, we kept her on as a contractor and ended up spending $76,000 to that company and now he's upset. When he asked why we spent so much on this person, my response was 'because you wouldn't let me hire her for $38,500 last year!'.
and this guy's the CFO!
by packratt
Our CFO's just say yes and then either refuse to pay or hold payment until the last minute as to get interest or delay costs in books as long as possible.
Ugh, corporate finance tricks and cheats make my brain hurt.
by james r linn
We look at the services we provide as a portfolio, and every service in the portfolio has a reason.
A new project can a) Save money, or avoid future costs, b) avoid risk, c) improve service, reliability(raising the bar). We classify them that way, and balance the number of each that we do. Too much money saving and you aren't improving service, and vice versa.
When we start any medium or large project we do the financial analysis, and invite finance to comment. They can also comment after the project is finished, as to whether we achieved what we intended.
This would help your finance folks understand your issues better, the challenge in your case might be getting them to participate.
James
by generalist
I have worked with a couple of companies where the financial types understand IT and are definitely not clueless.
These companies tend to look at both the long term and the short term and are willing to make short term sacrifices for long term benefits.
The CFO, or the equivalent, also tended to be technologically literate. But you still had to have solid justification for IT budget items, despite the friendlier environment.
by james r linn
Had a pretty good CFO.
When the CIO and half his director's were fired for a massive screwup, the CFO stepped in for a while, while keeping his CFO hat as well.
I enjoyed watching him interact with the IT staff, who had always assumed him a simple bean counter. The missed the iron ring he wore(sign of an engineer in Ontario).
He challenged their technological assumptions with thoughful questions, facilitated design meetings at the board with a marker writing flow diagrams. It was a real treat. In the end they all loved working with him and would have preferred he stay on.
James
by fluxit
There are ways to show financial people the best solutions. Internal rates of return are usually expected to be 18%+. Lay out the options and demonstrate the IROI.
The best approach I used was to non-dimensionalize the characteristics to coefficients of performance that can be compared and averaged. This removes all bias and is very a strong argument for the right option. This blows them out of the water. But to use this you need visibility beyond the controller and financial people. If IT is under the controller forget it.
Financial people have agendas beyond timing expenses or smoothing losses too. I wrote appropriation request for various projects and they sat on the controllers desk because he did not understand them, pride in past poor decisions, and other various emotional things. Yet a $9k notebook was bought for him to use.
After too many experiences with CPAs over the years and even working in a CPA firm I have come to have little respect for them professionally asI see the same behavior and mistakes repeatedly. In fact, I have seen several businesses fold because the 'CPA incharge' can not figure out how to run the operations.
I tried to build a consulting practice under a CPA firm once. I am not a financial whiz kid but I did successfully build 2 companies prior to them. One ran for 9 years then later started a small consulting practice that ran I for 2 years before coming to them.
Once under thier watchful eye I was informed that they knew moreabout building a business than me. They see all the mistakes I was told. Yet they failed to see thier own. I got no where under them. In fact, they directed that I benchmark with other firms across the US and everyone of them had relationship issueswith IT who always was bought out or walked.
In short, when dealing with CPA's you will always be outside the circle.
by http://stobie.home.sprynet.com/work/
Even these are not enough in many cases.
Many CFO's see their jobs as managing short-term financials. They oppose most strategic projects even with superb returns on investment. When these CFO's have the ear of the CEO, the company will really cut back on strategic investment, particular strategic IT investment, which most finance guys do not understand.
They are good tools and should be used to win over the CEO and maybe the CFO. Win the CEO and the CFO can be forced to go along with it.
by fluxit
There are several things that play into this here you need to be aware of.
First, Accounting was in general created and is charged by Congress to manage money for tax accounting purposes. During the 60's big gains were seen because companies had not managed the books as well prior to that. Today the the gains are not as great and in fact I would suggest that many problems are a direct result of Accounting. Many companies have become polarized having only accounting or financial people incharge at the top.
The Navy had a similiar problem in the 70's and 80's with a technocracy when they only recruited officers having engineering degrees. Today the Navy recruits liberal arts, criminology, and history majors to be fly planes and conduct warfare because they are not thinking about what is technically happening and push beyond the limits for greater returns.
Second, IT people need to organize formally into professional organizations like the AICPA for accountants. States governments need to be lobbied to require licensing of IT professionals so as to get rid of the seat-your-pants people and add credibility to the career.
Third, IT people need more cross training in financials and operations management early on in thier careers in order to unseat the strong hold CPAs have today.
by james r linn
Many good companies, my current one included, offer or even insist on these courses for new managers, including project managers.
Its vital to be able to "talk" finance, the same way we talk "techie" when we need to. When proposing a million dollar, multi year expernditure, it really helps to be able to do not only an ROI, but a discounted cash flow.
But we also have to be able to discuss things that don't have ROI - like Anti-Virus and security in general. You can spend a lot of time arguing about how many costs you will avoid with security, but in the end the argument should be fairly simple - what is the risk?
James
by fluxit
by sivam
I agree that the best way to get things through is to learn the rules of their game and beat (explain) them.
Apart from that, it is also essential that the support functions of pure IT firms understand the nuances of:
1. IT itself
2. The industry they operate in (Telecommunication, entertainment...)
It is like teaching them the rules of our game but it works out fine in the end as each is able to appreciate the role/need of the other.
It is high time the I and F cross-pollinate.
by generalist
Well if things get too bad there is always hope that you'll find a place with financial types that understand IT.
Unfortunately it doesn't solve your current problem, unless you can get this person to listen to his peers.
Are there any decent CFO oriented articles that focus on coordinating with IT and making cost effective investments in IT resources?
by jose mir
Abraham Maslow wrote: "IF THE ONLY TOOL YOU HAVE IS A HAMMER, YOU WILL TEND TO SEE EVERY PROBLEM AS A NAIL"
If you are in the IT business you will tend to see how IT is the "key element" in suriving in today's world ecomnomy; but maybe it could be only your perception.
Every organization is built on diferent task, and all of then are the foundation of the company. It seems hard to believe that a company can survive without IT, but remember that the financial aspects are also cusial for the business succes.
Company mortality is more related to finance-atack than to ITache!
We use to think that computers (and IT) had changed the world and the way global economy operates. Maybe that's not the whole truth; In Peter Drucker's words "IN A WORLS MANUFACTURING ECONOMY IN THE TRILLIONS -COMPUTER INDUSTRY- IS SMALL AND WILL REMAIN SO".
Don't misunderstandme, I'm an IT too! but the world is not drived for IT.
We, the IT people, MUST find the ways to realtionate with the rest of the world (organization, company, peers, etc.) and integrate with them to make business projects work and develop itself.
And to finish I will write something that I write very often: "NORMALY, THE ORGANIZATION'S MISSION IS RELATED TO MAKE SOME KIND OF BUSINESS AND TO OBTAIN SOME KIND OF PROFIT AND NOT TO DEVELOP AN STATE-OF-THE-ART INTERNAL NETWORK".
So, to answer the original question, WE MUST GIVE THEM ALL THE CLUES!
Jose P. Mir.-
by fluxit
You are thinking in older terms. You need to make a quantum shift. Fragmented tasks are going away. The old buzz word of managing change is fading. I once ran a MRO operation. My tire/wheel shop saw the plane as a flying wheel. My Engine shop saw a engine with wings. My Airframers saw a massive fuselage with tiny wheels and engines. I saw all the aspects of the plane equally as I ran the shop.
The business model for the future centers on Complex Adaptive Theory applied to organizations. It is an organic approach to chaos of the business world.
Information is the key to success today and IT people are in control of this information which is not uniquely financial information. It is marketing data, operations data, and statistical and trend data in addition to financial performance. As a IT guy as the MRO guy I see all pieces equally and attempt to apply technology to them all.
Accountants only work from three basic documents. The Balance sheet, income statement, and cash flow statement. From these spin the business ratios and financial performance of the company.
After some 20 yrs of being in over 200 manufacturing plants and another 100+ other companies there is little diference between them other than people THINKING they are different.
Because there are narrow minded IT people out there I am a proponent for standard industry licensing to fluch out that rif-raf and add credibility to our profession. Only then will we be able to make a difference.
by jose mir
Standard Industry Licensing? Whats next? Maybe a microchip to trace our movements in life? Or a machine that will give us a ticket when we say something wrong (like in the movie "Demolition Man")?
This is Old Thinking! If you believe that IT peopleare the owners of the information or the ones that knows more about it, you will not be able to see the world in a way other than your's.
Caos? you are talking about the "Unstable Aperiodic Behavior in Deterministic Nonlinear Dynamical Systems(in Kellert way)"?
Have you discovered a new concept in an idea that was popular in the 1970's (Chaos Theory) because in this old days this was the revolution-promise for technology an life?
(quantum physics, with Dirac, Schrodinger and Heisemberg, has stated this principies for almost a hundred years)? Well, you are not alone, many more like you are talking about it.
But think about it. Quantum efects occurs all the time, but you can't use it in your normal life because they sing the song of Plank's constant; maybe this is true for MacroBusiness (those biger than the size of a proton).
In the meantime, you beter try to integrate this CFOs to "your" corporative vision.
Remember that quantum theory does not invalidate all mechanic science; it just add a new, and sometimes more accurate, way of predicting the world, but you can still use Newton's Laws with very good results.
What is new today has been old yesterday and will be old again tomorrow; but organizations must find the ways of surviving.
Jose P. Mir.-
by james r linn
But where you have a problem is in calculating the probability.
Its not a benefit, until its a certainty.
If its uncertain, its a risk, and risk is measured by calculating probability and impact.
We did a calculation based on a virus attackwe had - it happened at 4:00 on Friday and the impact was minimal as it was corrected before 8:00 am on Monday. Whats the probability of the next attack occuring during "prime time". We just don't know. Thats not to say we should ignore it - we should talk about the risk - but can't claim it as a benefit.
James
by http://stobie.home.sprynet.com/work/
The problem is much larger than that. Large organization need people considering the entire picture, everything the organization does and everything that supports it together as a seamless whole.
I go into many specific suggestions on my webpage: http://freepages.work.rootsweb.com/~stobie/corp.htm
Currently many organizations (to the determent of their bottom lines) do not understand the need or the value of holistic thinking.
by fluxit
The problem is that people cannot think of every detail (holistic) impacting a business. We work in a world that is indeterminant yet perfectly ordered. This means we cannot predict the outcome of a system but we can mathematically model the system and apply its behavior. The basic premise is that every infinitesimal input has a catastrophic impact on the system. This is known as the butterfly effect.
CFO's are short sighted it is true and this is the problem in business. They are concerned with the end of the month close out or even the end of the day closeout.
by http://stobie.home.sprynet.com/work/
by http://stobie.home.sprynet.com/work/
One root cause of this is the investment community.
They place a lot of pressure to top management to deliver short-term results. The pressure for long term results is not there.
Very few take a long-term strategic view and seek the strategicthinking companies who will (or should) outperform their competitors in the future.
I would love to see a few strategic mutual funds that pressure top executives to think strategical and stop the excessive worrying about short-term results at anycost.
( http://freepages.work.rootsweb.com/~stobie/goodidea.htm#SMF )
by fluxit
This was what kicked us in the butt in the 70's. Japanese thinking was long term. Business's make no money in the long term. So strategically design for the long haul to ensure in the near term everyone is paid, has a job, and you have a comfortable life.
In the US it buy low and sell high. We have not only day traders we have second traders.
by http://stobie.home.sprynet.com/work/
by galyon
by fluxit
It is true that the theory of choas began in 1962 and was ignored in science circles until the late 70's. Then ignored in business until the late 90's. Today and emerging business model is an organic one. Dr Uri Merry wrote "Apply Complex Adaptive Theory to modern Organizations" It is good. Through databases, networks, and AI concepts a very useful application of technology can be applied to design responsive business architectures. The bottom line is we live in a universe that is mostly indeterminant yet perfectly ordered.
There is also a good book, "Survival is Not Enough" by Seth Godin. It also discusses the organic approach to industry.
Granted CFO's are short sighted. This could be a opportunity for entrepenuering IT guys to develop a product or service for industry.
Industry licensing is not a bad idea. It is done to manage the quality and quantity of Engineers, Doctors, CPA's, attorneys, real estate agents, and travel agents. I think it is an effective means to get rid of the fly-by-night people who under bill the real pros.
by jose mir
First of all I must appologize for my last comment about your industry licensig idea, but it sound to me not very easy to accept any kind of regulation that sooner or later could end up putting some kind of brake to freedom! You are right when you talk about the fly-by-night people who lower the income margin, but this is one of the variables of a free market interaction. If you focus on the right market segment, and deliver “value” to your costumers you should not worry about this not-so-ideal competitors. If you have a business idea based on a new product that can be oriented to the “upper segment” you will find the price diference a good marketing tool. Your principal concern must be oriented to distribution channel more than to lower price competitors! Sooner or later you will find the way.
What about an IT Professionals Association? The main diference is that this is not obligatory and, usualy, give more freedom to business oprtunities (leads, joint ventures, sponsors, etc.). This also could have some kind of industry and goverment recognition! Just think about it.
Jose P. Mir.-
by fluxit
The concept is to establish an industry construct somewhat like Accounting, Engineering, or Attorneys. You cannot open a practice unless you are certified by a regulating authority. I cannot be a partner in any of the above firms unless I myself passed thier cert.
How many doctors do you know who actually spend money on IT? They do not. In fact they spend no money on it. They hire those low rate guys whos solution is always to wipe the drive and reinstall.
Professional associations are good but they need to have no vendor bias and somehow the market must be willing pay for it and self regulate it. Do you think doctors will hire a cert guy at $100/hr or the $40/hr guy? I suppose if they get sick of problems they'll hire the $100/hr guy to fix the issues and then the $40/hr guy to support it.
by fluxit
You seem to be well educated and have a few certs. let's talk if you are interested in a business idea...
Develop a information system that is polymorphic at the information level for business. I have already been developing such an animal for the past 3 years but cannot get small minds to by into it. I just watch the drool drip from thier mouths and eyes roll back in thier slumber state.
by http://stobie.home.sprynet.com/work/
This is definitely the way to go, utilizing logically centralized, physically distributed data, according to a comprehensive enterprise model.
You want to sell the benefits, not the concept.
This is integration by design and positioning to address the strategic goals of the corporation/organzation.
Many people including many developers do not understand who powerful this can be.
by generalist
I suspect that the core of a 'perfect' polymorphic information system could consist of a 'perfect' database of fully normalized and carefully edited data with a huge selection of 'views' for the end user and easy access to all of the views. The enduser would be able to customize their selection of 'views' so they don't have to play menu option tag. Better still, they would be able to find new 'views' via a search engine, not a manual.
But I wouldn't mention the above to the average CFO orCEO when it comes to marketing the beast. For them, results count and it doesn't matter how you get those results as long as they are accurate, timely, easy to use and effective.
A bit of 'sex appeal' helps too. Even if the polymorphic information system is the best IT advance since the abacus, people won't buy it if it doesn't catch their eye and hold their attention long enough to see the real benefits.
You may want to look for a group that can help promote the product...
by fluxit
Skeptism? You amaze me. As IT people we should embrace advancements and strive to learn more.
Marketing is not the problem nor is plugging all kinds of bells and whistles just to sell it.
In fact, if I get to the level I desire I'll be able to reduce the lag time between learning and action. People will act on knowledge and not information. I have written nearly 30 papers on this.
There is a big difference between a system that reports red, house, car, garage as we do today AND 'The house has a red car in the garage'.
The biggest problem I am confronted with are technologically challenged people. Many who are nearing retirement or have retired but no one has told them to go home.
Much of the actual work and projects are here today. I am fusing the technologies and encouraging further development of the projects to embrace more advanced systems. In fact, I actually briefed very high level management who were impressed with the vision. They advanced my recommendations and funded them. But in that room were 100 people and only 5 understood it. The other 95 people did not even know of the 7 other projects being fused.
I get the feeling you may be one of the umemployed people in a few years because the world changed and you did not. As symbolic logic becomes pervasive you will see the face of systems morph drastically.
by jose mir
I’m allways open to business oportunities.
I am not a software developer. I use to develop some device drivers in C and assembler, and lead developers teams for commercial projects, but not code in them!
Do you think that business and sales background could be usefull in this moment of your project? My experience have showed me that when developers has their minds make up with some ideas about some product it is a real nightmare to make them change their approach to give the project a more viable shape (to improve marketing and sales; to find the proper distribution channel; and to make it more business-people oriented). If you have a wonderfull idea, are you ready to re-evaluate some aspects to make the product commercialy viable?
If I ask you to give me 3 reasons why mid-size companies “must” think in brand instead of megahertz or megabytes when choosing operative platform to run their business, can you do it? If you answer “yes” (even if your technical heart does not agree) you have a chance to succed in the real IT manufacturer’s business (when the real dolars are). The most renombrated products are not the best ones (if you don’t think this is true just look Microsoft), it is mandatory to know the game rules and move the pieces properly!
I use to work for a big company, neither small not red (do you know which is it?) in an external consulting role, and this could be very usefull, depending on the product you have in mind and the sale strategy you have choosen (if you have already done it).
Can you giveme more details? How do you think I can help your project? Have you got a working prototype? Or do you need pre-project R&D?
Regards,
Jose P. Mir.-
by fluxit
I already have reviewed my concepts for commercial viability. They are.
Brand is IT means:
1. Brand is more reliable and has better support.
2. Brand is stable and has been around for years.
3. Brand has the infrastructure to solve problems.
You have DB experieince, and project experieince which is good.
I need to have my papers reviewed before release. Only then i can give details.
by j.g.camp
Interesting that IT feels they are saving the company so much money. If that were the case, why do they buy IBM and Compaq w/ Intel inside, and continue to use PC133 memory. Clearly the choice in both terms of reliability and performance is to get the latest AMD Athlon XP w/ DDR Technology. Power Users are forced to sit behind older P3 cpu's, slower speed/less quantity of memory and smaller hdd's. Virtually everything that these Intel and Compaq machines provide in a package is slower and overpriced. Not to mention the cdrw I use has to be a HP model. Again overpriced and no more reliable than any other brand on the shelf. I've had Wearnes and Ricoh's on my home systems and never had a single problem. I've seen more HP's die and need servicing in the first 6 months of their usage than I've seen any other brand. There are days I feel it's a waste of my day and productivity to sit behind the corporate standard that the company has set. At home, I run my Athlon 1600+ XP 512 mb DDR systemalmost all day. At work I have a P3 733 256 mb PC133 system. I could underclock my system to 1/2 of what the 1.4 Ghz cpu will do and still have more machine than what I waste 8 hours of my life sitting behind everyday.
Another gripe, when the department I work for orders and pays for the full blown version of MS Office, why does IS&T feel that as a power user that I am not entitled to a full blown installation on my computer.
BTW, this is coming from an accountant that knows enough about building computers. The replacement upgrades the company gives us have to be configured anyway with the software and building one wouldn't take appreciably longer. Taking my time and building one every few years, it takes me all of an hour, if that and I don't even have power tools to make the job quicker.
by fluxit
There are several issues here. Is IT, the controller, or Info security making the decisions?
Many times decisions are made for emotional reasons. I have seen this done mostly by the CPAs more than others. I suppose the ones who screams the loudest about making sound decisions are the ones making the worst.
by generalist
Does IT control the budget they have for upgrades and new computers?
If they do, then maybe you need to see about getting competent people in the IT department, at least on the PC side of things.
On the other hand, IT may be working with budget constraints handed down from the CFO or equivalent non-IT position. What you're getting may be the best that IT can provide. Even worse, if the CFO TELLS the IT department to do something, they may be forced to do it, even if it results in the kludge you mentioned.
Logistics can also have an affect on what you get. Sometimes it may be more cost effective to spec out a generic system that you can swap out at a moment's notice, rather than cater to a few power users. This would kind of bethe equivalent of mass production in the information processing side of things. You won't have a top of the line sports car, but you'll be able to spend more time on the information highway because there will always be a car available.
If you truly feel that you need a 'sports car' level machine with full software options, do some sort of study showing the direct benefits. It sounds like you have the expertise to do such.
But be honest about the study. It may be that you only need the 'sports car' once a month...
by prefbid ii
You're post is absolutely the most fun on this string yet.
Here are some of the problems with your rationale:
1. You have a top of the line machine at home and want the same at work. If work is like mine and everyone had the same attitude as you, we would have to buy all 30,000 PCs each year. We keep costs down (you finance type talk a good talk, but won't fork over the money) by cycling those PCs with a 5 year turnover.
2. TCO and repair is much harder to control at 30,000 copies instead of just one. People abuse work PCs more that home PCs. Those PCs are hooked to networks, they must talk to each other all the time, and they have to have enforced security and backup -- all things that a home PC does not "have" to do. Even so, a 5% failure rate per year works out to 1500 failures. A 5% failure rate at home works out to a failure once every 20 years. It looks worse at work, but it is not.
3. Why should the company install tools on desktops that do not have a bonafide business need. Seems like you're whining to the wrong crowd. Prove to your boss that you have a business need and I'm sure you can get the tool put on your desktop.
by jose mir
The organization's business is not to make their employees feel the power at their fingertips.
The simpler the system the less failures it will have (MTBF).
The company executives must take care of the business. If they know the facts can act in consecuence. When the lack of comunication between the Finance and IT departments degenerate to the point to afect the organization's business, maybe it's time to go straight to the CEO and ask for help and guidance.
This is the so commented "Internal Sales Process".
Aristotle said that nobody choose the wrong options if knows the apropiated ones!
Jose P. Mir.-
by kuhlio
by j.g.camp
First off, the IS&T people are recommending the configurations of the corporate standard. Next on the answer list, the sportscar once a month, was bought and paid for, so it should be available everyday, whether it's been used 1 time or everyday of the month. AMD systems are every bit as reliable as the Intel ones and actually perform better in Office Applications across the board than P3's. I can get an Athlon XP 1600+ for less than $ 100 and about the same price as a P3 733. What's happening is that IBM is dumping crap into corporate America. When they replaced the P2 400 I had, the corporate standard was the P3 733 and this was the middle of last year. At the same time, I could've gotten the XP for less money, the motherboard for less money and DDR for less money. A corporate machine has a Savage chipset video card in it, that's worth $ 20 if that, why do the IBM's charge so much for crap ?
I've had discussions with IS on this and all they tell me is Intel is the best, yet the internet is littered with information that says otherwise. Even in the server market, AMD Dual MP's blow away P4's.
by hans p
Certainly NOT.
Either it's their job or they were born that way.
by http://stobie.home.sprynet.com/work/
I have worked with a few that can think outside the box of short-term results.
They are rare and should be valued when they are found. Unfortunately most finance departments do just the opposite.
by fluxit
by generalist
I would love to see your concept in action. And I consider myself to be a very advanced thinker, someone who lives with one foot in the future. Being an avid science fiction fan can do that to you.
What I was trying to point out was the fact that you aren't doing a good job of getting your concepts through to your market.
For example, in that high level management meeting, you only got 5% of the group to comprehend what you were promoting. And since it was a very high level management meeting, one would assume that the people in the meeting are in the top 5% of their professions.
So in effect, you only managed to get through to a group that comprises a quarter of a percent of the general population. That isn't a very good contact rate, especially for something that could be the next killer app.
You may need to find somebody who can, through various means, do a better job of marketing/presenting the concepts. That person would be the one who helps you get better buy in.
You might also try to be a little less insulting when making comments. That type of attitude can do more to kill a good idea than a thousand people who don't understand the concepts you promote.
It is a human relationships thing. If people hate the speaker because he insults them, they are not likely to support what the speaker is promoting.
by jose mir
You tell me how to follow from now on.
Maybe you'll find more apropiated to use mi personal emil instead of this discusion forum.
Regards,
Jose P. Mir
jpm@jpmir.net
by tomsal
The situation you describe is not all that different from what I've gone through in the last 5 1/2 years with the current company I'm with.
The three top dogs are all guys with next to zero understanding of technology and completely zero technical experience (unless you call sending email or playing minesweeper technical experience).
As the so-called "IT Manager" (my direct boss is given the title "VP of MIS") I have advised them more times than I can recall on what to buy/not buy or implement/not implement as far as technology issues and products are concerned --- each time I provide supporting reasons for my advice.
Let me tell you something, I've been well taught the virtue of being "humble" since I've been working here. If youdefine EGO as one who has (or at least THINKS he has) power - there's no way in hell I have an ego here. lol.
For the first few years my advice has been ignored so many times - it must of set some kind of odd world record for something. I'm happy(not I'm not dumb enough to gloat at work though) to report with honesty (and humbleness) that 9 out of 10 times - them going against my advice caused trouble or cost WAY more money than my solution would have.
The problem is the leadership here is very impulsive and the one guy in particular believes only what he reads in a magazine. If he reads an article on networking, the next day he walks the halls thinking he is a network engineer - it's that kind of a deal.
Their priorities are offtoo with some things they spend money on, but that's a different issue in itself and in past posts I've whined about that already.
Today? Today is much better now, they still have their moments of ignoring technology advice from their "technologypeople" - but I guess when you are the king of your own little kingdom there's an level of ego that you'll always possess.
by kuhlio
I can feel your pain. I am new to the IT field as an employee, but just in general, I have been right where you and probably countless others are. I personally enjoy being right just as much as the next guy, but it really becomes a drag when your great advice is always ignored.
As for the guy that only believes what he reads, just print up some of your posts in the discussions, maybe that will put him over the edge... ;)
by carmen110
I?ve read through a number of these posts and, as I finance person, feel I need to step in and defend my profession.
1) You forget the CFO has to manage a finite amount of resources (cash available for projects). That means he or she has to manage requests from Operations, Marketing, IT, HR, etc., etc. Your project may have a great ROI and it may be obvious to you that the project needs to be done, but other departments have initiatives that show great ROIs too. Not all the projects can be done. If the money is not there, the money is just not there.
2) IT folks often don?t help themselves. Finance people understand metrics, but remember not all metrics have a dollar sign associated with them. As a Finance person, I?m more than happy to evaluate a project that will improve help desk response if you show me what help desk response is now and how it will change. Then follow up after the project is done and show me how it has changed. One mantra of business is that you can?t manage what you can?t measure. It seems like too many IT people throw up their hands in frustration if they can?t measure their projects in dollars. Then they sit back and blame the Finance group for being short sighted. Well I say help yourself -- show the Finance group other kinds of operating metrics and start getting them to understand and embrace them.
3) You?ll have more luck getting projects approved if you work with Finance that you will if you work against them. Take the time to educate them on the intangible benefits of your projects and try to establish and publish as many non-financial metrics as makes sense.
by prefbid ii
I think you defined the problem and don't even realize it. Finance people want everything measured and yet not everything that is important to do can be measured or is worth measuring.
Sometimes I can come up with an analogy, sometimes an approximation, and sometimes I can show a huge market relationship, but I can not always measure the benefit. For example, I used to work for an airline. One project would have cut an average of 15 minutes of the amount of time that a customer waits in line. That was it's only benefit. The idea was that the customer would eventually reward us because we took an inconvenience out of his life. Did the CFO buy it? NO. Several other airlines got the idea and put it into action. I called them up andasked how they got their CFO to buy into it. I got the same response from all three that I called: The CEO told the CFO to stuff his formulas and do it anyway. The early leaders in that tool are having an easier time retaining their frequent fliers. The other airlines are playing catch up in that area.
The problem is that you can not equate one change with one response. Can I guarantee a 1% improvement in customer retention? Never. There are too many factors at play. Finance guys wantthe world to hold still and they want their books to come out straight. But I have yet to see a finance guy make it as an entrepeneur. They have no sense of risk and reward.
by fluxit
What qualifications does a CPA/MBA have to make unilateral decisions within a company?
As a business man with 20+ years experience in government, private industry, and business ownership. I have learned that a good account is one that works FOR you.
I have seen too many times where CPA make business decisions and noever consider the IT piece or how to manage information. When it comes time they spew make it work and never approve any appropriations at all for IT.
by blondinbux
by xpertdragon
This approach may not work for you, but in the 7 years I have been in the I.T. field it has worked 90% of the time for me, for forcasting budgets, and convincing the "bean counters" that budgeting for these needs is a smart decision.
I have foundthat if you want to get the attention of the "Upper Management" bean counters, cost accountants, controllers, senior controllers, and CFO's...(the List goes on and on), you need GRAPHICAL REPRESENTATIONS.
The higher up the corporate ladder they go, the more they enjoy all those pretty Charts, Pie Charts, Bar Graphs and Long-Term savings to the budget in terms of months and or years!
It is still very important How you choose to present your budget proposals, to whom, and When. You can use something as simple as the graph tools of Excel 2000/2002 to graph all that financial data that most accountants within the company are probably already using. This way, a Graph next to all that complex data makes more sense, and can be emailed to all important parties rather than mailed through inter-company mail or otherwise.
Presentation either way you look at it is the KEY....incorporate another type of presentation software if you have it as an alternative, like Corel Graphics or something similar.
Either way, the "Bean Counters" have to report a lot of that budgeting to the upper managment....they crunch the numbers but seldom ever make final budget approvals.
Best of Luck!
Paul M. Chavez
by jcyt
by blondinbux
by jcyt
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Trending IT Employment posts
Sort by Trending