Discussion Locked

Do undegraduates with experience stand a chance to get hired?

0 helpful
262 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I was just wondrin to hear comments from the group based from their experiences and locales if a person who happens to be an undergraduate but with experience stands a chance in the IT industry compared to newly Grads and degree holder?

262 replies

by admin

a person that is already hands on trained and doing well in a position than a person who needs unlearning before they can start to get hands on training.

It really comes down to the individual though.

I would prefer a person who lived, slept and breathed networking in or out of school and had both verified excellent work performance and could demonstrate a deep understanding and knowledge in the field. School doesn't really have a lot to do with it. Conversely, to get to me through HR is a lot easier if you have a degree. They will also approve paying you more.

by jimhm

I have found that a college education gives a good rounded experence base - so this person can stand up infront of executives and give a presentation - or write white papers - or do independent investigations and write a research paper -

I have found the certification folks are locked into one thing - that certification and need hand holded through a presentation or white paper or any other non-cert assignment they are tasked with.

And like you said it depends on the job - but give me that well rounded education - and I will show you a top performer in all tasks... give me a certification and I'll show you a performer in that certification only ...

This guys in the cat bird seat as they say... if the manager isn't affraid of his/her skills and talent...

by ramrod

To say that the only type of individual that you can put in front of management is a very small minded view. It will always come down to the individual. Sadly though these are the type of misconceptions that are being perpetuated throughout the industry that somehow a person who holds a degree is more intelligent than an individual without. There are many intelligent, efficient and highly disciplined IT professionals with certifications and no degrees and just like that person with a degree they have to keep their knowledge up to date otherwise they would not survive either. And to do this also takes the same skills it would to earn a degree.

by cclef

The bottom line is experience. If you can demonstrate, or explain how your class/lab experience gave you a real life experience, and then translate to how that will enable you to perform on a day to day job, that will be a great positive. Unfortunately, a lot of employers are still looking for the degree to back up anything you have. If you are fortunate enough to get a face to face, and explain your life experience, then the degree may not weigh in as much. But still in these times, HR still looks for the degrees.

by nicknielsen

You have got to be kidding. The ability to communicate _clearly_ is not automatically bestowed with a college degree. In fact, based on some of the work I've seem from many college graduates, I would sooner allow a high school student who paid attention in English class to write papers and give presentations.

It doesn't matter how many degrees they have if they can't speak without, uh, well, like, uh, you know or if they can't write without confusing nouns and verbs, their/there, or its/it's.

It's not about education or certification, it's about learning.

by bronzemouse2003

I've known "HONOR" students who couldn't articulate the time on their watch. And the most valulable employee I ever met never completed the 8th grade, but essentially ran the manufacturing/assembly department at Big Blue.

Degree, experience - it doesn't matter. Impress me with your knowledge, then show me what you can do.

THINK - Thomas J. Watson, Sr.

by ddissent

Well ... I must say that's a pretty bold assessment. So what you are saying is that someone who has proven that they can regurgitate information from texbook pages of our broken educational system can outperform someone who has been working in the field for as many years? How about I show you a Vet with NO degree and NO certification who has 10+ years experience in the IT field who could smoke your very best employee - especially at giving presentations in front of the suit squads?

Sure, a degree might make it through HR easier and get you paid more but for me? If you have a degree and no experience .... I'll give you a chance to earn the experience but please leave the 100% processed American Cheese Degree at the door. I need people who can recover a crashed server or network QUICKLY .... not people who can tell me how many bits are in a byte or if the socket packet pocket has an error to report.

So much for my penny 1/2

by dkeggins

I don't know about some places but around here, the most of the people with a degree don't really know squat. It's seems like it is just a piece of paper with some letters on it. The knowledge level in general isn't any better, but usually worse. (I just had to explain to an IT Manager the difference between a hub and a switch! Degree knowledge?!) I didn't have the chance to go to collage right out of HS and seem to be fairing better than some that has. It really depends on what field you are going in, but when it comes to computers, experience is the best. Certifications, however, isn't a bad help, but I will always stand by experience to be equivalent, or better.

by mjnunzio

You forget that when in school what the student knows is what's published in their text books.
I have seem college grads come out of college and watch them be over whlemed with the task of actually doing the practiced tasks at school on a live system. What a IT professional without a college degree knows is real life experience that a college grad can't get right away. Give me a mature IT pro with 5+ years of IT systems experience anytime.

by timeros

I replaced a guy with a degree in my office when he had no clue with a Win NT 4 machine and wiped out a client's system. I have no degree or cert, though I do take classes to keep myself up-to-date.

Ironically, I think the problem with education in the IT industry is that it's out of date when it's being taught. In any case, there's nothing I can't do with freedom and a good knowledge base . . seasoned with common sense. (i.e. don't put a Win NT CD in the drive then click OK a few times, then cancel)

BTW, the Engineer with the degree . . he has his own car detail service now. LOL!

by rstoebe1

If you are using the Internet for your job search having a degree or a certification opens doors. If your involved in networking your experience will be more highly regarded and the lack of a degree or a certification is less of a factor. People that get to know you will be more aware of what you can do and not concerned about what degree you hold. And experience can definitely help you keep a job.

by usdoj

the most important piece of knowledge that I can impart upon anyone who is currently persuing an IT field of study is this. All the books and labs in the world will not prepare you for what you WILL encounter in Real Time situations. Do well in schiool, but also get into the workforce and learn hands on while you are in school. Then you can apply what the real world teaches you to the lessons learned from the book and become far more usefull when all is said and done. I am a 15 yr Network Professional who never finished his degree and have remained employed in the field from day one because of one simple reason.. I am one with the network :-)

by mharbert

Two things to consider are you hiring for a corporate environment or a mom & pop shop? If I am hiring someone for a corporation I would like someone with a degree. If I am hiring someone for a mom & pop shop I would look for the experience.
I have personally found that my associate degree can only take me only so far. At some point in your career you will be asked if you want to take the next step and go into management or become a team lead. This is where a degree will help you accelerate your career. I can?t count the times when I have had to explain a major problem to upper management and the impact of an outage to a business unit. That?s again where that degree comes in handy. I have returned to college part time to finish my BS degree because the limitations of my Associate degree. So my suggestion is to get the certifications and experience first than let the business pay for your degree.

by kiero

I myself have worked with many people in technical roles, similar to myself. And they have been lazy and generally complacent, merely because they have "a meal ticket" in the form of an IT degree.

Some of the best people I have worked with have been NON-degree educated, but highly skilled and motivated non-the less.

As well as the fact that recent UK Government surveys have detailed that degrees are worth LESS in the modern market place then ever before, and the debt you face getting one is higher than ever before.

Meaning that people from less fortunate backgrounds, who may be just as skilled and talented, stand to get a worse job, because the well-off people CAN afford university or college.

You want to hire people? Make your own mind up and don't just rely on a piece of paper to make the decision for you. Generally people with something to prove can be more willing, skilled and motivated, then people that think they deserve it by default.

If they have a degree and are the best person for the job, fair enough. But employeers - don't get complacent, just because they DO have a degree.

by tony hopkinson

18 years in this trade, working all that period except for about three months between contracts. Fortunately a degree is far less important in the contract market, otherwise I'd be rounding up trolleys in a supermarket car park. Cannot get a sniff at a permanent role. Now I seem to be almost too experienced, even if I was prepared to drop down to a role where academic recognition was considered less important I would not be able to afford to take it. The big stumbling block is not that you haven't got a degree but that most people in HR, Agencies etc know less than nothing about the discipline and so rely on an external appraisal of your knowledge. The fact that a mathematical or science degree qualifies you to write software probably explains my successful career as I've spent a good deal of time doing their work properly. No point in fighting the system though, if you are in a position to take time and earnings out to go get one then do it. If like me you've kids, house etc then you'll have to tag along behind the academically recognised and clear up after them.

by Member 31674154

I completely agree. I completed three years of college in Accounting. I was on the Dean's List every semester. Then the kids came and life demanded that the education stop. I discovered that Accounting was totally boring and I loved computers. Started my own consulting business and was fairly successful. I gave that up for a job with a Global Fortune 500 company. I have been in IT for 12 years, but have never completed my degree or gotten any certs. Many of the people I work with have degrees and certs and I am constantly cleaning up the mess they create because the did something "cool" that had a negative impact to the business. Every corporate team I get put on I find I am the only non-degreed person. Many of these people are narrow minded and focused on what they can do with computers, not what they can do for the business with computers.

If you want to hire a truly successful individual or you want to be a successful IT pro, learn/show what you can do for the business with the skills you have! Not what piece of paper you have aquired.

by saborbas

I am an IT Pro with 18 Years of Experience, I have a 2 year degree and no certifications, but at every position I have ever had, I am alway taeching the College grads and the MCSE and CNE how to do the job. The Degree dosn't mean anything with out the experience.

by jimhm

I would rate a person with Education and Experence as a prime canidate - over someone that is uneducated and experenced or Certified and Experenced - or uneducated and unexperenced.

You're in the cat bird seat with those quals..

by kensmi

Some time ago I worked for an organization in Canada where my manager always hired his staff based on experience in the industry. If he hired straight out of an educational institution then it was always a vocational college, such as Radio College of Canada, or DeVry. Never would he consider hiring a university grad without experience.

His division was taken over by another company, and he was directed to hire university grads. He refuses as long as he could, but his superiors insisted and he had to relent. He hired 4 university grads to fill positions in a very stressful Network Operations environment. They were all gone in 8 months. They had the knowledge, but did not have the ability to use it properly and to think on their feet in times of stress. Needless to say, he had proven his point and hiring policy was changed.

I think in some environments in the IT industry someone with a degree straight out of university will do well. In others, experience is vital. It's one thing to have a high degree of knowledge, but another thing all together to be able to apply that knowledge and to think on your feet.
Cheers

by nd_it

Most of the people in the company don't realize that I only have a associates degree in information systems, since I am invloved in other aspects of the company; project management, engineering, supply chain, etc. Some employees think I am an engineer (not an network engineer, but a Industrial Engineer) or even have a Masters. I have no issue with standing in front of management to give a presentation, in fact I enjoy representing our department and to show the things that we can do and have done. I never forget my roots as I started out as of college as a technician and continue to learn more as the industry changes, but I also think that I have become a more rounded individual from my experience here, just from getting invloved in other aspects of the company. I gained an internship during my last year of college and that is what really has gotten me where I am today.

by jimhm

The question of how that will count will come into play if you ever switch companies.

Like the other poster said - his hiring manager was force to only look at College Grads - most position say - BS required - So how do you even get in the door to sell your excellent skills and talents -

Thats the problem when HR sets a policy - you reduce your talent pool by 1/3.. Its not the education - but the ability to educate - that counts...

by jimhm

I agree with you - on the College grad without experence is certain fields within IT is a bad thing. But the same person in the right position in IT will do much better than the person from a tech trade school. So that is all part of the hiring managers job and job requirements matching.

But this person is an undergrad with experence in IT - thats kind of the glowing stick you need in a person - the round education and experence..

by ebon234

It will be better to hire somebody with an experience than to hire a fresh graduate who has no experience. In an It firm where training of fresher is not considered, hiring of a graduate without prior experience will disrupt the working of the entire network. Though a graduate is better in term of knowledge, but he has to get the practical know-how to get started.

Thanks.

by nd_it

I have been very fortuante here at my company and I am currently looking into the possibility of continuing my education with online classes or some other format. When I came out of school, experience is what really mattered, not education. I know many people that couldn't find jobs because of lack of experience, they had CS degrees, but nothing to show for it. Now the trend is different because of the dot com bust, the economy, and the flood of new IT people. HR has to look at all those things, which is why education is looked at for a requirement, but what really gets me is the hiring managers posting jobs with skills for everything under the sun, and all for only 30K again. It's tough enough to get money to keep my current skills up to date. But I think it will improve again, when companies start spending more on IT, the hiring managers will look at the skills needed for that particular job.

by pgm554

I have degree in political science, which has absolutely nothing to do with the industry that I am in today.
I had a professor that I asked what I could do with the degree, his reply was ?What you should have developed, is the ability to read write and reason.?
The degree is secondary.

Unfortunately,corporate America is too hung up on paper,and too many times ignores experience.

by cfc01

I personally would prefer a degree with experience, but just a degree will do fine. When you invest in people, it should not be seen as a short term - get as much as you can out of the person, but rather as a long term relationship.

People with degrees show me a few things:

1. They have started something that required serious cost, time and intellectual investment and have completed it.
2. They can be educated.
3. They can think, read, write and more importantly, do research if the answer is not directly available to them.
4. They have been placed in situations where they must relate to, and explain things to peers and senior educational staff with a lot less tolerance than you would find in your average business.

I have found personally, that degreed persons with no experience struggle initially but in a space of six months can accelerate their learning past those that have just got the experience.

That is not to say that experience only is less desired. In my field, IT, experience only just not cut it. IT changes at such a tremendous rate that ongoing education and futher studies are our perpetual lot.

Regarding Certification: Certification is useful but persons with only a certification generally treat problems in the way that can be explained by the analogy: If your only tool is a hammer, all of your problems tend to resemble a nail.

Whether you pick someone with a degree or with experience is not woth much in the long term if you are not willing to invest learning into that person.

by happy

Could you not apply your four points to someone who has got certifications and has taken the time trouble and expense (sometimes) on their own? I'm sure you can

Here in the UK it is unusual for a job spec. to say a degree is a requirement most ask for related experience.

I'm sure a degree helps in boosting your salary but that is about all.

by lizziebg

When I hire someone I need to know they are going to be able to do the job technically, communicate well with clients and have previous experience. Therefore I only take on people who can demonstrate all those things. That usually means a graduate who is literate and has worked in the industry before. I also write off anyone who can't spell. If they can't see their mistakes on a CV, how on earth are they going to spot errors in software? Several people have written posts here with errors that would have made me think twice about hiring them.

by cfc01

This forum is not limited to english speaking countries. Please remember that some participants may have English as a second or even third language.

by arleenw

It's true, what you have your degree in is really irrelevant - except for highly specialized degrees like law and medical science. A college education makes you a more rounded individual. It is a foundation upon which to build wherever life may take you.
In IT experience is essential. Sure, a CS degree is a great foundation, but anyone can buy the books at Barnes and Noble and set up a lab at home if they have the interest. However, when an employer is looking at candidates - or even looking to promote from within - they are going to look to those people with degrees first, even if that degree is in something different.

by chubert

In my mind, we put way too much emphasis on paper. I believe College is beneficial for various careers, but lets face it, most people go to College and come out with fancy degrees and end up in a career that has nothing to do with the degree. As far as I'm concerned, these are the following attributes that make any individual an asset: Experience, being self-directed, motivated and being able to write and communicate well!

by titssni

churbert, you could have said it any better. It all comes down to the individual and his/her drive to excel and achieve a higher level of accomplishment. Many college grads end up with lower level jobs because they do not have the drive and ambition to excel. They sit back on the degree and think it'll get em through life without any effort on there part. They are very educated and well taught but lack the inner mtivation when they get into the work environment without being pushed or forced to do more.

On the flip side, the certified professionals try to stay abreast with the technical field they are in and some do excel to other levels, some stay only to what they get certified for and nothing else. Unless pushed or forced into a situation where they have to adjust and adapt, some people with degrees and certifications will never grow past the level they are unless they have the inner motivation and drive to go the next step/level.

My true feeling on this.

We need to stop paying so much attention to the paper and not the individual. We need to look at them together as both needed and both similarly important. They must go together to provide the perfect solution for the required environment.

by tom.howarth

you will find that if there is no HR interference then the degree issue will not raise its head. I will always take experience over qualifications. quals are an indicator of ability. experience a much better guidelline.

it must be said that in trainee positions it irritates me that graduate degree required now seems to be a pre-requisite, I personally know several excellent techies who are not graduates and know a hell of a lots of graduates that i would not trust to tie their own laces, never mind design and install critical systems

by alexlee

My core competency was in IT for over 18 years. through the past 3 years, i have been able to get in the HR and IT roles.
Currently, both stands as my primary role and function.

I'll hire a college guy with experience anytime over a experience person without a degreehowever, having said that. The level and type of experience is just as important a consideration over a degree.

That college guy without the experience now will get it over the next years and he will have both the expertises and the paper to back it up later.

Experiences and a degree will be common. maybe not now. it will down the years.

what does it takes to stay employable?

by l p mohan

From my experience, I can strongly say experience is the best way than theoretical. I am the best example of this as I joined Mitsubishi as a Steno and now I am Executive-IT taking care of 4 offices in all communication related matters.

by l p mohan

From my experience, I can strongly say experience is the best way than theoretical. I am the best example of this as I joined Mitsubishi as a Steno and now I am Executive-IT taking care of 4 offices in all communication related matters.

by paul

I am currently working as a CIO for a technology company, and also own a technology consulting business. I started out in the IT industry as a sales support person, and worked my way through a variety of sales management, and IT management roles all the way to senior exec management.

I have no degree, although at this point in my career I am considering doing an MBA to enhance my grounding in business in general...

When I recruit, experience counts, and a proven ability to do the job... I have hired qualified people and to be honest most of the non-qual people have actually worked out better because of their experience.

Some people say, and I would agree, that while you are at school getting your degree, there are others actually doing the work and gaining experience - the end result being that you can do the work (in theory), while others have proven that they can do it.

by stevenberkholz

In order for high end pos.:

1. Experience.
2. Cert.s
3. Degree.

In order for entry pos.:

1. Experience.
2. Motivation and interview gut feeling.
2. Cert.s
3. Degree.

by i.hilliard

Experience is what lets you get the job done. Unfortunately, most companies have an HR department which is responsible for hiring. These people don't have a clue about the job. They are unable to tell whether the experience matches the job. This selection is done by the technical people, who in many cases don't have a lot of time for interviewing.

Before it even comes to the interview stage, HR has already filtered out most of the candidates. The easiest way to filter is based on the qualifications. Without the degree, it is quite likely that you won't even get to the interview stage.

Ian

by willh

For IT support and development roles I would expect to hire someone with experience unless I was specifically looking for a trainee.
In answer to the specific question I guess the issue here is whether I would hire someone who was on a degree course but wasn't going to finish.
Personally I don't think that dropping out of a course is a good advert for the sort of characteristics I expect in my staff: commitment, staying power and self-discipline.

by btshabe

I'm a recent IT graduate from South Africa and I can say that prospects of recent graduates are perhaps the same as those with experience. It might seem as if recent graduates have difficulty breaking into the industry. In our country more and more companies are offering internships to recent graduates but then a graduate still has to compete with other graduates for the same internship. It doesn't hurt to have experience when looking for a job but the question still lies in "As a recent graduate. Where are you to get the experience from?" One way may be to volunteer your services in exchange for the experience but government has made it difficult to be able to do that with bigger companies. The challange for a recent graduate looking for employment is how to sharpen your skills and gain experience at the same time while looking for employment? I wish to ask those who already have passed this hard stage to share some advise in light of the question I have posed.

by pwhistler

To a large extent it depends on the sector you try to enter. The banking and finance sector tends to recruit from the Graduate / undergraduate pool and usually grant internships. Whereas manufacturing / service sector tends to look for those with hands on experience. Salary expectations can be a problem. I think that graduates have to sacrifice earnings, at least initially to gain the experience. The real difficulty is getting relavent experience. I was lucky, I think in so much that the company I went to for work experience eventually employed me.

by dolivier

It is a hard position to be in, i've been there myself, it seems like you mostly need luck ;p Its probably easier to register a CC and run your own small business just to get some experiance. Otherwise its all about connections or luck :/

by q2digital

Having left school aged 16 with almost no qualifications, but a fierce interest in computers, I have consistently managed to find work as an IT consultant throughout the UK and, in the last 12 years, in Madrid, Spain. That's not to say a degree wouldn't have found me better or more lucrative contracts, but I'd say that you simply cannot beat experience when it comes to dealing with "real world, real time, real IT" (where did I hear that catchy slogan?! :-)

by sediking82

you knw the difference between the two is that in a degree a person get taught many different things about the industry at large.As for a person with experience he will start of knowing what that company requires only.So a person with a degree when hired has a broader view of everything hence can modify develop and think of other ways to solve the problem after he got to learn what the company is all about.i.e,what is expected of him.and this will take him les time compared to a person without a degree.

by cloudedyoda

I've read all the postings and I find Sediking to have the best reasoning. A person with degree with have wider coverage and good grounding. With the foundation laid over 3 years, it takes lesser time to adapt and apply IT solutions.

But if I may add, LUCK plays a big role. The success stories that you heard of ppl with experience who got hired is due to "luck".. the same goes for the degree person.. right person, right time, right place.

So I wouldn't worry too much either way. Just do your best and hope the best comes to you.

by ozpenguin

I have over 15 years IT experience and no degree.

There are a number of jobs I know that I can walk into easily (in the private sector)

But I also know that I would have lesser chances of getting into a multi-national company, and next to no chance with the goverment sector.

So, it really just knowing the market you are prepared to work in.

Chris King
Australia

by mary.armijo

I have been in the situation where I had a hard time finding a good job because I lacked the experience but had the education. I luckily got into a very good position and have proved myself. In fact I will be applying for a Director position. I think personality and knowledge have a lot to do with it as well as work ethic. How can you possibly judge a person by education or experience. During the interview it is what the individual brings to the table. Certifications and degrees show that the person can make a commitment and complete it, however in my experience I have found that those with experience and no degree and limited in knowledge and only know what they have learned. Education does make you a well rounded person. If it weren't for my degree I would have not been as successful with my new job.

by leketee

Of course you can be successful with either situation. It's up to the interested party who has the need to do a thorough and good enough investigation into the abilities of the candidates.

But I agree that a good education should have it's advantages, and does, and will almost all the time give you a well rounded individual who could successfully meet most of your challenges.

Overall, mixing your knowledge and skills with faith in God will get you the best results.

by trevor.clere

I have the education. Decided to switch geers and went back for a Masters degre, MBA. Even earned two "specializations". However, when it came time to interview, my lack of experience in my newly chosen field was very evident and EVERY employer wanted to hire me at entry level. I had already worked 8 years in Healthcare and spent an extra 3 yrs in grad school. A Pay cut was out of the question. Education is the foundation. Gave me a macro view of many things. Experience pays the bills. Hopefully my education will provide more opportunities in the long run. Experience is more valuable when job hunting (period).

by eschlangen

We have MANY degreed individuals that not only do not have a "broader view of everything" but are barely able to function in their area of specialization with supervision. I have found that the good people are good with or without a piece of paper (either degree OR certification). You MUST look at the individual instead of being lazy and only looking at a piece of paper.

by joel

I have seen all kinds of people come into this field. Some have taken their degree and undelying abilities and have done great. On the other hand. I have seen some very top notch programmers (and other IT people) who don't have a degree and are at the top of their field. Love him or hate him, Bill Gates did pretty well for no degree.

Just for the record I have an associates degree in business and never finished my 4 year degree, because it was in another field and this is the field that I belong in. I've been successful for an awful lot of years.

by unixdude

What I see is that when a position opens up, whether new or as a replacement, management is looking for the qualifications and capabilities to do that job immediately. The candidate with experience is the person who can jump right in and contribute immediately, as opposed to the person with only a degree, who will take much longer to learn the ropes. The candidate with a degree does have a more well-rounded education, and is "teachable", but the way technology changes from day to day, a lot of the college technical training is obsolete when he graduates. There are technical colleges in my local area that are still teaching obsolete material! I would prefer the experienced person, but you do have to look at personality and work ethics to get the right person as well.

by tux_vader

While I do agree that a College education should provide you a well-rounded education, any individual with initiative can get that and more without pursuing a degree. Just for the record, I do not have a degree, however, I have taken numerous college courses covering many different subjects from advanced English literature to organizational management. I've actually taken so many courses that I could complete my degree with six more classes.

In the time that I've taken courses, I've also been gaining experience by working. And although I've been in the IT field for the last 10 years, I've also held positions in marketing and operations management. I've learned about the industry I support from all aspects. So while someone else may have been toiling away in the business management class, I was gaining both experience and education at the same time.

Ultimately, I believe that it's up to each individual to determine the best path for them. Don't pursue a degree only because you think there may be a larger pot of gold at the end of the rainbow. Because by the time you get to the end, there will be a larger pot at the end of someother rainbow. You see this mentality with technical certification: "What cert is going to make me the most money...and where's the nearest bootcamp?"

by comptech3

I turned wrenches for 15 years before I decided to make a career change. I take college courses part-time, but like you, I'm also getting experience on the job.

My major is management. The reason for this is that even if I don't become a manager, what I learn will increase my perspective of the big picture and give me soft skills that will transfer with me wherever I go. Another motivation is that my employer is a college and provides free tuition vouchers. I'd be stupid not to take advantage of them.

You are right. A degree should be pursued because it will benefit you in the big picture, not as a ticket to the biggest salary.

by bwilson

Judging by your reply, I would guess that you missed English 101. I personally would not want to put this type of reply in front of an executive or a customer.

by brian hertziger

Two sides definitely exist for this debate:

Colleges usually lag behind current technologies when businesses have embraced them.

Companies don't implement some technologies because the older ones work

Some students come through college thinking what they learned was the only way, without the benefit of experience to understand the difference.

Most recent grads needed to be taught everything, like they had no knowledge.

Often the way things are taught in schools must be completely or partially discarded to work in the business environment.

I've had a more than a few experiences with those who were exceptional students, but failed to comprehend.

Experience tends to create some adaptability which is critical when dealing with issues.

I would usually rate experience as the more valuable side of the equation as it does imply exposure in real world situations. I also generally give experience a 1:2 ratio -- one year experience is like 2 years of college.

Further, those who gain certifications like the MSCE that we call the "paper MSCE" tend to drive down the value of that certification for those who have it and generally understand it. For that reason, I tend to pass on "overly certified" candidates.

Lastly, those going through school tend to get lofty expectations regarding salary that cause them to ask for salaries that are beyond pratical. In the post dot-bust, slower economy, and shrinking IT budgets those high expectations are just not feasible

Of course, like anything there always exist exceptions to the rule, but I've hired many people and this has served me well.

by mypride

While it is the best practice for a job aspirant to have blended complements of these two career requirements, in my occupational field the educated is more favoured than the experienced who does not have requisite qualifications. This is because it is a belief that the educationally qualified has the capacity to learn faster as a result of the theoretical knowledge of their job functions.

Of course, often times educated recruits display inexperience even with their utmost secrecy. But to save this situation, top management provides on-the-job training for such recruits to leverage the experience gap.

'Yemi Oyebola
Lagos, Nigeria

I advise experienced hands to upgrade their education, so they can be better positioned for greater heights in their careers.

by rob

Personally if somebody has been just completed his certification then I wouldn't really give them a look in. Simply due to so many certifications being full of fantacy / perfect world shit.
How many certifications have you found that in the real world the answer is not correct or just doesn't cut it in reality.
Therefore if I have a choice I would definately take a body with Experience over a freshman graduate.
But if you have the oportunity to get somebody that is educated / certified and has a few years hands on .. FANTASTICO

by langstonha1

I'm trying to get hired now and I have a degree and cert. The folks that interview me would like me to have more experience. I have over five years but this is my second career and I think they would also like a little younger person (I'm 47) even though they can't say that.

by cfc01

Congratulations on having the courage to change your career.

A pointer - If you are good, you are good. Age does not come into it.

If the job market does not pan out - do freelance work until you have proven experience, and maybe by then, the entrepreneurial bug might have bitten you and you may choose to stay with your own business.

Been there - done it - Sold the T shirt and consulting services to the to the guys that did not want to employ me!

by hanrahan99

I am 54 years old, I have never spent a single day in a college classroom. I have been in the IT industry since 1972. I have led many technial projects with IT professionals who had doctorates, masters etc... Conclusion: The most productive IT professionals are the ones who LOVE what they are doing and possesing certifications or degrees is unrelated. Another comment: I prefer well rounded core competent professionals over specialists.

by richard.gossett

Ideally, experience in a related job will win over education only. Expecially if the job requires special skills. In most cases, individuals gain that knowledge not only on hands on, but through a solid base of basic education.
I think that most will agree that you can't be technical unless you can read and understand technical manuals and apply mathematical equations to such things as binary, octal, etc.
You never stop learning, and to advance in our field, experience needs to be balanced by higher education in order to advance.
Final note: For those interested in gaining both an education and experience. The govt does hire "co-ops". These are individuals going to school and working at the hospitals in their related field. Pay is not the highest, but it beats Burger King.

by problemslayer

Somebody correct me if I am wrong, but I believe Bill Gates dropped out of college. Now I am not suggesting anyone emulate him per say, but I do know of some very successful people who did not have a formal degree. I think it really comes down to initiative on the individual to learn, gain experience, broaden their horizons. If you can find such an individual you should hire them, degree or not.

by unhappyuser

I almost lost a job once because I didn't have the "proper degree" but my experience of 10+ years, and an excellent interview in front of 8 people, got me the job. After a year, and a major transformation from Novell to MS, No one questioned if they had made the right choice. I moved on to another job after fours years to get into software development only to be laid off four months later when IT went bust. I went out and got three certs (A+, Network+ and MS) because I knew I'd need every advantage out there. I got my current job because of my experience but the certs helped us move from NT to 2000 without having to hire outside help (thus saving us big bucks). The bottom line: Get everything that you can get. Each of the aforementioned individually may get you an okay job with okay pay but having 2 of the 3 or all 3 (Degree, experience and Certs) will get you what you want at a quality salary.

by calais_norman

Let's be realistic: You should have both! Either can be used to get you in the door, but you first priority after learning your new job responsibilities should be to devote the time and effort needed to shore up your short-comings. Nothing beats hard earned experience in your field (that is a given) and that will always have you in contention for a position. But college degrees and certs speak volumnes to a potential employer about your personal strengths and your ability to complete personal tasks and meet individual goals (also known as discipline). Afterall, those will be the same strengths that the employer will be depending on you to use on the job. It's nice to give them the impression that you've got that covered.
And lets not forget that certs let an employer know that you are up on the latest technology. Even if you are just a "paper cert," you still have the theory of that technology in your head, which makes it a hell of alot easier to turn into skill than someone with no specialized knowledge and who has to start from scratch. Experience is good, but technology changes and you have to change with it.
And what about salary? Compare two candidates who have ten years experience, but one comes to the table with a IS degree, a CCNA, and MCSE. Who gets the nod? And even if they both get hired, who can demand the biggest salary?
Lets face it: Neither you nor I know what the next employer who interviews you will be looking for. Some rely on experience, some on degrees and certs, and some look for both. Don't you owe it to yourself to ensure that you are covered no matter what that employer is looking for? I think so. That is indeed PART of why our foreign friends are so successful in our workforce.
There would be a lot less confusion on this issue if we take our "personal" oppinion out of the equation. This really has nothing to do with what we "think;" it is more of a practical consideration. Picture yourself as an employer and approach this issue and you'll be fine.

by usdoj

The most important point is to CONTINUE learning. What you learn from Classroom education is static but the field you are about to enter is anything BUT static. Never stop aquiring knowledge.

by cleanjoe

You know, sometimes we forget that humans have the way of overcoming surtain situations of life, I know from working in a big corporation. You grow where you are. Degree or experience, it all depends on the person. Some Degree holders will let that degree go to there heads and that can be bad for a corporation, while experience people will do what you ask them and get the job done. It's all in the person and his or her's attitude and what they want to learn. We all have the ability to adapt and overcome, that'a our nature. So saying that one person is better then the other is wrong. Yes Education is great,the whole world is one big classroom, so in saying all this, Degree holders and Experience people are one and the same, Overcoming in any situation. That is a good employee. One that can stay focused on what they are there for, to get the job done.

by usdoj

4 years in an accredited school is worth about 1 year's worth of "working in the field" experience.

by wdoliver

I am basing my comments on my 30 years experience in the IT arena and as a manager. I do not think it is a matter of which is more important education or experience. It is balance that counts. My comments are based upon the majority of professionals I?ve come in contact and there has always been exceptions.

When hiring for entry level or junior positions it is a level playing ground. How you present yourself will be the deciding factor. If you are hiring for a senior technical position and one of the candidates just has education and the other experience then the experience is going to win hands down. When I am looking to fill a senior position it is important that the person has been successful in applying the desired skills in a ?real world? setting. The candidate with just education has a broader knowledge base and probably current with new methodologies. The problem is that many people just education and no experience find it extremely difficult to adapt its application to ?real world? situations. The major risk is the experience only person is successful; however, is not current on methodology and is more adapt to resist change in the way they apply their skills.

If I am hiring for a junior management or leadership position and one of the candidates just has a degree and the other experience I lean towards the degree. The individual usually has a broader information based, better communication skills, and adapts more readily to change. If the technology position involves complex R&D work or devising the next technological jump then I look for PHDs.

The person who has the edge when applying for a position with me is one who has ?verifiable? experience and has demonstrated they regularly seek to improve his or her education weather it be formal, CBT, online courses, or certifications. I have found the best professionals are those who recognize that both education and experience are equally important. Of course, I think most managers will agree that the deciding factor is often how the person presents themselves.

by kjohnson

I'd hire the right person for the job. If they have trench experience over a degree and their experience is relitive to the job I'm hiring for then I'd hire them. I've been in it for 13yrs and the key here is the way a degreed person is payed vs an experienced person. It's usually quite lower...and since the IT bubble pop all IT positions for the most part are lower paying. I guess the decision is in finding the right fit of personnel for the position that your hiring.

by alphastate

I have found that having a degree will open a lot more doors, ie., oportunities, than with experience alone. Consider things from the Human Resources point of view. Suppose they hire a guy who doesn't or can't live up to his claims. Then they have to fire him or find some way of getting rid of them, which is a can of worms in and of itself, and THEN they have to go through the whole search and hire process again. Lots of wasted time and money.

If a person has a degree, the probability that the individual, especially if he (or she) has good grades, knows what they are doing is greater. And even if they don't know, how fast can they learn? Hiring good qualified people is a crap shoot at best, and they just want to up the odds in their favor as much as possible.

But consider this, throughout my career, I have seen over and over and over guys get promoted who were way less qualified technically than their co-workers. Why? Because they knew how to schmooze. They played golf with the boss, went to the bosses parties, brown nosed, the whole bit. People with good social skills will almost always get ahead of the people who are very technically superior and who are absolute pricks to live with.

by bronzemouse2003

Always seemed your chances were the same whether degree or experience when you submit a resume or application. Although, you probably need 2-5 years experience to compete directly with an Associate Degree candidate. And pay scale is usually less without the degree.

In either case, your chance of hire increases dramatically by acquiring a personal contact within the company. Being able to articulate your experience verbally to the person hiring is what truly gets you the job. If you don't leave them with a good impression after an interview, it doesn't matter what degrees or experience you have - your done.

by stinphilly

Experience, attitude, work ethic and skill all play a role in evaluating a candidate. A degree is a good indicator in many of these areas, however an individual person, with all of his or her strengths and weaknesses, is who you eventually hire. It is that individual and what they can do moving forward, not their academic accomplishments of the past, that will bring value to your organization. To exclude from consideration those who may have much to offer just because they lack a degree seems foolish to my way of thinking.

by adc24

If you are in an area with a high concentration of degreed applicants, it will be harder to get work if you are not degreed also, no matter how good you are. But 90% of it depends on the person doing the hiring. Bottom line, get the degree you'll be better of in the long run. I know from experience.

by rolf gitt

Ironically, I think those with degrees in CS probably have the skill-sets that will prepare them for the LATER part of their career, rather than for the early years in IT.
The first few years in IT are when you build your knowledge of real-world (not textbook-optimized) environments and systems - the "pay your dues" years with all-nighters, etc... It's great hands-on learning that cannot be achieved through a University education alone or Certifications.
If I were hiring, I would prefer someone who is articulate and provides rational answers to interview questions. I think the "what would you do if this system goes down" or "how would you deal with an aggressive client" type questions are most telling. Once hired, I would ensure he/she gets exposed to a diverse range of IT sub-fields (networking, sys admin, programming, webmaster, etc...) and try to find the person's forte.
The CS degree skills will more likely be put to use once the employee has 5+ years of experience and starts doing Project Lead work. This is where the organizational skills, and more theoretical knowledge comes into play in terms of project planning, etc.. Of course by this point in his/her career, they'll already have the real-world skills to avoid underestimating complexities or time required to complete tasks - critical skills for completing projects on time, and within budget.
So....personally I don't think degrees are critical - and certainly it doesn't have to be a CS degree. All-in-all, the most important thing is "can the person think and understand fairly advanced concepts?" In my view, there's no dependency on degrees or certifications. Just give me an intelligent, well-rounded, solution-oriented person, and they should do well in IT as long as they're truly interested in the field.
The hardest part is always getting past the front-line HR staff who filter out resumes based on specific "key words" - I think companies miss out on some potentially excellent employees through that process. A more holistic approach to skills review would be better for the IT industry in general.

by psu-curt

I graduated with a BS in Informations Systems Mgmt. and got my first job in IT a few months later. 20 yrs later, after many ups & downs in my career, I went back for an MBA in Business Mgmt. Now I'm a part-time Adjunct Professor of Informantion Science & Technology at a major 4-yr University, as well as manager of Tech Support with over 30yrs professional experience.
I have found that experience is the primary consideration - the employer wants to know, in a practical sense, what you have done and what you can do. Education is the bonus for the applicant - it makes the difference between the entry-level and the 2nd or 3rd level starting position. If a manager sees 2 resumes - one with only experience and one with experience plus a degree, the degree makes the difference in who get the better job. Many of my students (especially in the Masters degree program) work full time and take classes in the evening. They are either working on a 2nd degree in IST or toward an advanced degree to supplement a BS in Computer Science.
My advice - find a company that pays tuition reimbursement (full or partial) and get the degree. Without a doubt the candidate with both experience and education has a definite edge in the marketplace.

by christinepa2001

I am in the 40 plus age group, when no one but the rich when to University. I have over 20 years of working with computers, programming, Helpdesk Support and Technical Authoring and no Degree.

Everything I know I have taught myself, I did go to college for a year, 4 years ago to take an Access to University Computer course and came top of the class, therefore allowing my progression to University. (which I did not take).

Experience is the best way forward, learn the job from teh bottom up and don't try to jump straight on top of the mountain.

by bichelmo

and I have found that the experience outweighs the degree. To know the theory behind it is far from being able to nuts&bolts make it work. But a lot of that depends on the school and the professor. I do agree that the degreed individual is more well rounded but usually lacks in technical abilities.

by toddah

I was a Senior Controls Design Engineer for 15 years without a degree. In 1993 I switched to IT and have held a Network Administrator position since,I have two people working for me that hold Masters in computer science, and 3 that do not. I think the largest problem is some of the people who hold degrees are convinced they are a smarter just because of the degree. And it hurts the team, they discount the opinions of other team members based on holding or not holding a degree. Yes they can create content and present it but is the recipent really connecting with the speaker?
It takes education AND people skills to do this job and many fail at one or the other and that the real problem. The degree tells me they are trainable and had the ability to stay the course for a number of years, but thats it.

by prohta

I graduated in June w/a BS in Technology and in July was hired as a webmaster and marketing manager for an online residential land sales company. This has turned out to be my dream job. With my IT experience that I had before returning to school after working for 30 years and getting my undergrad degree I was able to get my dream job in a month. I know people who are still looking for work after 6 months because they did not have the degree. That is why I went back to school in the first place. Working in IT for 18 years and not having the undergrad degree kept me out of the workforce and out of the jobs I qualified for.

I live on the west coast and work in Portland, Oregon.

by sue's comment

You will find a job without a degree but you may not be able to work in a large IT department without one. The problem is that larger companies have HR departments and HR want a simple life!

If you want a job and you have experience to offer look for a company small enough not to have a HR department!

by triturador

But, in a country like mine, education is too expensive for many to get it. The knowledge and experience can be obtained in other ways.

My lack of a degree does not let me get a raise (money or job) in my workplace, doesn't matter my job is pretty important in here. My boss knows it, but even he can't do something. For the HR deparment my experience is not valuable enough.

by phall659

The best advice I can offer is the same I am following. Continue your education! Work on certs, work on honing your skills, but finish the degree. You can attend many colleges online now. I attend Troy State full time and work full time. If I can do it anyone can!

Good Luck!!!

by spankyb

I am one of three partners in an IT service/consulting business. I am also the person who has final say on hiring technical people. I will always hire someone who has experience before I hire someone who only has a pretty sheepskin with his or her name on it. I am responsible for generating income dollars for our concern, what value is a person with a degree and NO experience to me? None. Having said that, how do you get experience when you have none and nobody will hire you? I do hire people with no experience; in that case I look for a person with a good attitude that I can put in front of clients, who has an aptitude for what I want to train them to do. I?ve been in IT for 25 years now, I can honestly say that most people that come to me with recent IT degrees know very little about what really needs to be done these days. In almost all cases they need to be UN-trained most of what they?ve learned at the ?Alter of Higher Education?.

So to answer the original question, hold your head up high and go show potential employers what you can do, and what value you bring to the table. That?s what?s important.

by michael.odicho

I am a manager of a team of 10 and would prefer hiring someone who can do the job because of previous experience rather than someone who knows the theory and passed some exams, as I did in uni for my degree in Computer Science. I had to go through a process of relearning because 95% of what I learnt I have yet to use in the iT industry. Personally I have done a degree and have got the job but in hindsight would have got job hunting immediately.

by michael.brodock

I have worked for 15 years in IT without a degree. I broke in at the bottom with little more than some programming experience from school and had to prove myself ever since. I am currently working on my BS in CIS simply because the larger organizations will not even look at you without a degree regardless of certifications or experience, at least it seems that way to me. IT is a tough field in that you cannot rest on your laurels, you must continue to train yourself all the time and I have.

So to answer your question, yes you can get hired but most likely at a small shop. From there you need to continue your training and work your way up. Get a degree, it will help in getting better jobs. Get certifications, it will help you in doing your job and competing against those who do not have certs. Get experience because there is no substitute, I don't care how much training you have or how much you know, practical application in the trenches is where the rubber meets the road. And by all means, understand that unless you life is on the line, don't stress otherwise you life is on the line. ;>
Mike

by mikencove

In my personal experience and observation of a number of people entering the market, experience matters a lot more than the piece of paper. HOWEVER, lack of a degree (or even the right kind of degree) will limit the ability to get an interview where your experience and knowledge would come out. I prefer to hire experience, ot a degree. That works in a small company, but most big companies with big HR departments will short-stop someone without a degree.

by csco

I've been in the business for over 19 years without a degree. But my certs are up to date. I am currently working for the state of Idaho as a senior network admin. Certs and experience are what employers look for around here. I know of several who have degree's with no experience. Most of them are slinging hash or have some other unrelated job. A CIO is not going to put a rookie in front of a console, only if there's a seasoned IT Pro to back him or her up, or if they have some kind of OJT/Carreer Development program withing the company.

by kingzanj

It is a known fact that undergraduates with experience stand a better chance of landing a job than those undergrads who don't have practical work experience. In IT field hands on experience matters. I got my first hands on experience by volunteering at the college computer lab.

by lkarnis

Invest in yourself - get a degree. Prove to your (potential) employer that you have the drive, smarts and staying power to achieve something significant.

Next, work in your chosen field. Even if you are underemployed. Find tasks that will challenge you and improve your skill. Solve problems. Get experience in a broad range of IT areas of practice.

Finally, get certified. That way, HR and IT managers can see that vendors have verified your skill.

If you can help it, do not go for certification first... Certification was originally intended to verify a high level of technical competency. Many training organizations have cheapened certification by teaching people how to pass an exam (but not deliver the underlying skills and experience). Consequently, if the best thing your resume says is that you are certified, you will probably be passed over when applying for a job.

Just my humble opinion.

Larry

by theundertaker

Yes. In fact, you have a better chance than most!
I am more impressed by someone that can actually do something, rather than someone that can theoretically discuss it. Show me someone that learned something on their own, and I will be even more pleased. I need experience, someone who can do, not soneone that only says, "no, I never did that, but I am willing to learn". Do not drop the aspirations for the degree. Get that by all means. But if you can add valuable, real world expeience to the degree (or while attaining the degree), you will do well.

by problemslayer

I think a degree often helps you get in the door. It says you committed yourself to something and saw it through. Hopefully you learned a few things along the way as well. Ultimately I think experience is more valuable once you get the job.
I believe it also depends on the individual. I now have a degree, but when I first got my job I did not. I sold myself by telling my future boss at the time, among other things how I made a working network hub out of broken parts and a power supply from an old Gateway computer. I got the job not because of a degree, but because of the way I sold my capabilities and work ethic to my prospective employer.

As far as my job is concerned, I learned more about business, networking, computers, and banking (I am in the financial industry), in one year on the job, then I did in the many years of college. I am not saying that college is of no value, but I am saying that I think it is over rated. A whole lot of buck, not much bang. And once I did get my degree? well I am still waiting for that ethereal raise.

To sum it up, College is helpful, experience is great, but ultimately it?s going to come down to the make up of the individual and the ?personality? of the company. Some companies require degrees, some don?t. So do, but will bend the rules.

by stephen

Cons

I have been in the business since 1989 when I finished high school. It took me quit a while to work my way up with out a degree. I got my MCSE in 1996 and finely got a job as a Network administrator in 1998. It was a hard row to how but it can be done.

Pros

I now am the Sir Network administrator for a small telecom company in Florida. Of the 10 or 12 people in our IT department 2 have degrees. One of the degrees is in art and that person works as a web designer and the other has a degree in Computers and works as an Application Developer. Or boss, the IT director, has no degree, me, the Network Administrator, has no degree; Our Oracle DBA has no degree. None of our other programmers have degrees. Even our Telecom manager does not have a degree.

Our company functions very well. In the 3 years I have been here we have doubled in size and are preparing to double again. This is while we are ?in the worst economy since Herbert Hover? as some like to say. Where big telecom companies are closing there doors. We are expanding, hiring, and building new buildings.

by mmcmanus

Having worked with many people over the years, I must say that to me, a degree means nothing, especially when you consider that the people that are teaching in most schools are teaching it because they can't do it.....and most schools can't keep up with the changes in IT anyway....
Give me an experienced person any day....

by toddlemen9

A degree demonstrates commitment to a field, and the ability to carry through a chosen course of action. Generally admirable traits. Certificaitons demonstrate exposure to and training in very specific issues and software. May be considered to shorten a "learning curve". But there's a catch... Hiring managers want generally want some assurance that you know how to handle day-to-day operational issues, so they tend to prefer experience.
Experience demonstrates "hands-on" familiarity with whatever you've been working with, and may also demonstrate that you know how to work with others. Most valuable traits. But there's a catch - you may be viewed a limited by your experience, and therefore, hiring managers tend to want certifications (and degrees) to demonstrate "range".
If you are an undergrad, keep going! Don't cut short the "I can see something through" aspect of actually finishing a degree. But by all means, find a way to get into the field. Internships, work/study programs in related work fields, part-time work in the field (if you can find it).
In short, experience and degrees are NOT an "either/or" proposition; in today's environment; "both/and" is the order of the day!
Good luck!

by luis_a_delgado

I would test them to see if they have the ability to tshoot. That matters more than any paper. Of course, a degree with experience would be the ultimate.

by delbertpgh

Getting a job depends on more than education and experience; luck and personality make a difference, too. But you can certainly get good jobs based on experience and some education.

Without a degree, though, you will always be less valued than if you had one. There will always be a ceiling you cannot rise above, limiting your promotion and career possibilities. It will make a difference to your pay for the rest of your working career, at least 5%, often more.

by a.d.e.p.t

The only training I have received equates with what professional schoold offer - no colllege, no university.

But my desire to keep learning and to undertake new projects and new skills has given me a reputation as an uncanny problem solver.

I am now sysadmin for a national organization, specializing in SMS2003 and BlackBerry handhelds (with experience in Win servers, Netware and Unix) - fields where the habitual MCSE hunters don't usually like to graze.

Willingness to keep learning is more appreciated of employers, I think, than an actual degree.