9 replies
If you have a contract to perform specific work and it does not include training, then the request for training would (should) become its own contract. Therefor, you can set the price. If the business doesn't like it, too bad. You don't do the training.
If you have a contract to perform specific work and it does include training, then you may be out of luck.
If you have no contracts and work on an as-needed or hourly basis, then you can set your hourly rate for training, and a minimum number of training hours.
That's the life of a consultant. We're at the mercy of the businesses we consult to. It's a risk you take.
"If it isn't specifically stated in the contract or statement of work that training will be provided to employees by the consultant, can the consultant turn this into a legal matter by claiming breach of contract?"
The business can not force you to do work outside the contract without you expecting to be paid separately for it. But this wouldn't be a breach of contract. I would think it would be a failure to pay for services provided. There's a subtle difference, but it's important.
JPL()
by cg it
If training isn't part of the contract, in the scope of work, you don't have to do it. If they insist, then insist on a seperate contract for training [NO MODS to existing contract as that makes training within the scope of work for your existing consulting contract. then you'll have to train as part of your consulting work. you don't want that at all].
Be VERY specific on what the training will encompass, the DURATION of the training and what is EXCLUDED e.g. that the employee that is trained can do the job. you can not guarantee that an employee will be capable even with training.
The legal beagles will look for this out if you don't specify this exclusion.
Smack in the middle of your piece you say, "From a logical perspective,..."
Your perspective is unilateral self interest. The logic that follows, it does just that. It follows to organize the justification for your self interest.
What you ask is an appraisal of self interest and not the confirmation of your logic, which you readily supply -- both logic and confirmation.
Yours is still an inviting question, though. Do you, as JPL suggests, blunt or modify your self interest? Should you surrender it? After all, your livelihood rides on it.
Does and did on mine, too. I was asked to teach a fellow employee once. I did. Then they let me go, saying now that he knows what I know in addition to what else he knew, which I didn't, what further use did they have for me? I was redundant. That was early on and cold.
Lesson: either keep my mouth shut or keep learning until I return like V'ger, dragging the near entirety of it all behind me, affording easily to give. Even, I may add, to offer some as loss-leader.
Then, as employer, I've brought about a dozen younger ones up to speed from near nothing in multiple ways, only to see them leave and go down the road to earn more than what I could pay.
Lesson: either keep my mouth shut or take immense pride in what they did with what I gave. Business also came and keeps coming back from where they went to the well from whence they came.
I am consultant to customers. I can't keep my mouth shut. I think I talk my way out of money more than I do into it ("Knowing what I know, I don't think you want to do what you have in mind and here's why..."). Pushed, I pass. One fool is enough.
Lesson: either keep my mouth shut or smother them in my self interest.
I'm still in business (31 years).
missing "n"
by mjd420nova
There's no point in hording 'knowledge'. What do you really know, anyway, about the Client's business? You're a contractor, so you are there to do whatever the Client wants you to do. If you think you are not, get out and get a 'fulltime' job.
As for management picking the trainee, I guess this is where the difference comes in between a 'contractor' and a 'Consultant' (which is what I am). Management lets ME have a say in who gets my training, but I can take any beginner and train 'em up, right. Can't you? If you cannot, then you do not know your subject matter.
Train em and get a reference from the h.r. manager (not the 'hiring manager'). Why? Because the person wanting a reference is also in h.r. and is more likely to take on faith what the h.r. manager says. I have a number of friends who are h.r. managers. They give the BEST references, even when they are only allowed to say, legally, 'yes, she worked here' but oh! the tone of voice in which they say that has gotten me a lot of consultancies.
Bottom line: never horde knowledge, it won't do you any good in the short-term and in the long term that knowledge tends to end up 'on the cutting room floor', i.e. OBSOLETE, anyway.
If you come in as an extra resource to fill in for a shortage, then I don't believe you have an argument.
If your contract is more specific then you at least have the option of re-negotiating.
Is it a breach, only if they terminate before your contract period end because you've been 'replaced' without suitable recompense.
Looking at it fromthe employer's point of view, how do they know whether you can train, that the trainee, can be trained, and waht denotes trained ?
I've trained and then been released at the end of the contract period, (no roll on) once. I saw absolutely no benefit to me to be arsy about it, they invited me back sometime later for another job..
It's only business, just remember training is a valuable skill and you should be paid for it. :D
by dr dij
I was in the position where a friend who runs a company had a consultant in who setup some programs for generating scheduling info.
This person had told my friend it was 'too complicated' for him to train anyone else to run (total BS). Then this person is not available for x# of days and they need to run it.
There was only one thing I could tell my friend: can the guy for not making a usable system as the end result, either due to p*ss poor programming where hard to run or due to his leeching off this company by making them call him any time they wanted to run it.
Whichever the cause (I think is the second, he wanted to suck them dry of $) I had to recommend they trash him and his progs due to his pig headed-ness.
by absolutely
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Trending IT Employment posts
Sort by Trending