Discussion Locked

Does disaster loom in RAIDS?

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I have used a free Web-mail service from www.mailandnews.com. They have now been down for more than a week, they claim that a RAID integrity rebuild is taking up many days - see their front-page right now (Mar 23, 2001). Is there a lesson for us to learn - RAID may be good for security, but useless when it comes to a disaster? Or are they just doing it wrong?

5 replies

by generalist

I've never heard that RAID is good for security. On the other hand, in theory it is good for disaster recovery if done correctly.

In fact, I've experienced a couple of hard disk failures on an AS/400, one with RAID 5 and one without. Recovery from the RAID 5 disaster involved a little bit of down time and a hot swap of drives. Recovery from the non-RAID disaster took several days of index rebuilding.

Of course, the type of RAID appears to have an impact. And on huge systems with lots of data, the integrity rebuild could take a while.

It would be useful to ask an expert though. And if RAID has a security impact, other than for potential disaster recovery, I'd love to know.

by jamesrl

Depends on the type of failure. If one RAID drive fails in a RAID 5 system, you swap out the dead drive and the whole system slows down for a bit while the drive rebuilds. But the idea is that since every bit of data is written twice, there is no "loss" of data, so no downtime to the user, only a slow down.

However it isn't unknown for a controller to fail or 2 drives to go down. When those things happen you have to rebuild the RAID from backup and this can be slow if your backup is on another server, especially if the LAN is 10MBit, and is already carrying substantial traffic. I have seen this take days.

James

by generalist

Thanks for the background information. My experience was limited to being a programmer/analyst who hadn't had much hardware training at the time.

Since then I've learned a lot more about LANs and such and can certainly see where the pipeline capacity could have an impact, assuming you are restoring through the LAN as opposed to tape. And even a tape restore could take a while.

It sounds like you really should have parallel systems running RAID 5 and a whole bunch of other things if you have any 24x7 application running. These systems should be separated by several hundred miles and have full infrastructure backup so that a natural disaster could hit one place and not affect the other.

Of course that would make the accountants have fits and further increase the theoretical shortage of IT workers. So we make do with what we think we can afford.

by shardy

When you refer to Raid , it is important to clarify some relative facts. Hardware or software? If hardware, whose raid card and what generation. Last but not least, if hardware, has the raid card been configured properly to suit the environment.I have personally seen a Compaq 3200 raid card rebuild a 9 gig drive, housing multiple sql databases (4.5 gig per drive)in about 20 minutes. The users never commented on a slowdown. Had I not checked the event log ,It could have existed for days.
If youare willing to take the risk,software
raid can be a security "feature" If nt's disk administrator has been involved in forming the volumes (including misconfigured
hardware raid) you will be dependant upon the SID token issued for this volume.

by sbworks

It sounds like the system setup wasn't paranoid enough. RAID rebuilds to take time but days?! From this tone:

"We have backup power, machines, parts etc, but when the RAID system reports corruption, there's no choice but to let its software attempt to repair itself.

The RAID system doesn't estimate a time to completion. We've made some guesses based on the fact that is reports its progress as a percentage during each of 3 phases. The progress isn't consistent, so our estimates have been off. (For instance it took 2 hours to complete 50% of phase one, so we guessed that it would take another 2 hours to complete that phase. We were wrong. In some cases it has taken 48 hours to complete just 1%.) "

Sounds like they're a little out of touch... or out of their depth.

This discussion is closed to new replies.