Hello amcol:
>A small number of on point, thought provoking, information eliciting questions are all that's needed to determine if a candidate is the right fit for any job.<
Tha face-to-face interview is not very effective at identifying future successful employees. Here are the correlation coefficients I have seen reported for various methods of selecting future successful employees:
0.00 for a Flip of a Coin
0.14 for an Interview Only
0.26 after adding Background Checks
0.38 after adding Personality Testing
0.54 after adding Abilities Testing
0.66 after adding Interest Testing
0.75 after adding Talent Matching
plus a few random ones...
0.18 for Job Experience (years)
0.38 for Unstructured Interviews
0.41 for Integrity Tests
0.51 for General Mental Ability Tests
0.51 for Structured Interviews
0.54 for Work Sample Tests
>You're asking 318 questions and getting responses to all of them in an hour.<
Some people take more time while some people take less time.
>You either have a broken clock and you're actually taking a LOT more time than that, or you're getting only the most superficial of answers on which you can't possibly base an intelligent hiring decision.<
There is another alternative, you have no idea what we do or why it works.
>OK, let's say I'm wrong<
Keep an open mind.
>and you can actually do this.<
Every day there are more than 40,000 employers doing it as I described, see example below.
>As a candidate for one of your positions your speed interviewing technique<
It is not an interview. Candidates can select the best answer or leave the answer blank.
>says a lot to me about your management style and your corporate culture. No thanks, not interested.<
Yes, it speaks volumes about the culture. It takes a special person to get a job offer. Job applicants who get job offers become successful, long-term employees. For many employers that is worth the risk of losing a few obstreperous job seekers who think they are above being screened for job suitabiity.
A Software Development Example:
The HR Manager for a software development company hired for talent for over two years and then stopped for two years because the two owners thought they could do a better job of selecting successful Technical Support Analysts (TSA) than Sonja, their HR Manager. TSAs go to the client's workplace and identify the programming errors and then reprogram the software.
The owners felt too restricted by the talent selection process. After two years of doing it themselves they went to Sonja's office and told her "Start using the your talent method again, you are much more successful at hiring good TSAs than we are." The owners could not duplicate her success rate, not bad for just an HR Manager. Sonja took a risk when she first tried the talent selection process.
Employers over rely on face-to-face interviews and qualifications. The goal should be to hire competent people, not necessarily the most competent, who will become successful employees. The best I can tell a resume never actually does any work.