Discussion Locked

DOWNLOAD: Should you kick the Microsoft Word habit?

0 helpful
14 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5138-10877-5918103.html

After you take a look at this download, please post your feedback, ideas for improvements, or further thoughts on this topic.

Thanks,
--The TechRepublic Downloads Team

14 replies

by jmgarvin

Ya, I agree...Ditch Word. abiword for Linux is lightweight and robust and there is Open Office, while it is heavier, that is quite like MS Office.

Oh, and MS stop trying to block Open Document Format

Thanks

The Consumer

by newby7718

Mainframe mentality at its worst! No consideration of the user and the fact that over 80% of the world uses Word today. Remember the pains when the legal community moved from Word Perfect to Word? Now you are suggesting that we go through that again. No way Jose! Take your open sources stuff (see I'm being nice)and shove it! I evaluated Open Office and it SUCKS! And thats from a guy who has been doing computing since 1959, before Tony Bove was even born.
Show me something better and I'll go with it -- until then please don't bore me with your shallow opinions of Open Source alternatives to the REAL THING!

by john

99% of Word users need 1% of the funtionality.

Most users only need to write things. Word can do many more things than they will ever need or want. For these people, any word processor will work fine. OO and Ami are free, and they work.

But, for most businesses, Word is the tool they use. Because they use it, everybody else they deal with needs it too. Word can do more than Ami and OO and with paying attention to security Word is safe.

All in all, writing is more in the realm of the author than the tool/

by jmgarvin

Since you evaluated it, please enlighten us as to why it sucks.

Have you tried Abiword?

by brandon.aiken

I have four problems with OOo:
1. No Outlook equivalent. Evolution has not yet been ported to Windows. Thunderbird is just email.

2. Extreme bloat. You know it's bad when it makes MS Office look good. It has a memory footprint about 5 times the size of an Office footprint. I've opened Excel documents in Calc and had it load for literally two minutes. The same file opened almost instantly in Excel 2003.

3. Calc is grossly outclassed by Excel in simple usability.

4. Visio. 'Nuff said.

OOo isn't bad, but I would only use it if I didn't already own MS Office 2000, XP, or 2003. If all I needed was a word processor, I'd probably use AbiWord over instaling OOo.

Sorry, OOo. MS Office is the de facto standard right now. Until you produce a demonstrably *better* product (not just a *cheaper* one) you will not probably not appreciably affect the market share for MS Office. Especially considering the enterprise tools available for deploying and managing Office.

Firefox didn't begin to make a dent in IE 6 until they showed they had a *better* product (reduced security risks, better browsing exerience) as well.

by tonyaaa4

Just to set the record straight, I was born in 1955 -- before you
were doing computing. At 4, I was already using Words.

I've posted some new info about OpenOffice vs. MS Office in my
blog, Get Off Microsoft (www.tonybove.com/getoffmicrosoft).
Thanks for reading the sample chapter.

by noorman

I won't join in the discussion about Word being better or worse than Open Office or another open-source alternative.

Word is just too expensive and is never (really) been backwards compatible. It 's just been built in so as to make others upgrade when a few already have ...

It 's not for nothing that, a few years ago, the city of Munich dumped the whole M$ lot because too expensive (with over 1000 computers to run) ...

Then there was the WORD-'bug' where you got a different layout with a different printer driver !!!??? (Office97 days)
That was a happy working time !

by mentorctl

Have you priced the alternatives mentioned?
$995.00 for QuarkXpress is cheap!

If you are ONLY doing basic word processing (think Selectric/r/ Typrwriter, if you've heard of it) then there are innumerable editors which can fulfill your needs. (Heck, ed, edlin and sh will work, let alone NotePad and WordPad.)

If you need the full range of flexibility a suite can offer you might want to consider the Open Source suite OpenOffice.org produces. They've done some fine cloning, mimicing, MS's Word/tm/. Before you commit though you might read George Ou's blog comparing the current versions at http://blogs.zdnet.com/Ou/index.php?p=119&tag=nl.e539

Happy pecking, er-ah, Thanksdiving!

by capt.brad

I didn't see any suggestion of using Quark to replace Word. Sure it was mentioned in passing early on in a historical reference but the real emphasis of the piece was legitimate free or less expensive safer and more reliable alternatives to %(*$@!& Word.

by xuriwan

I understand from the extract that the main concern is using Word to write literature. I know Ted Nelson got stuck here with Xanadu and so forth, so I want to steer clear of that; but I sympathise with what was written.

However very large amounts of people use office suites and CAD in their day to day work. This is the puzzle. Surrounded by object-based efficiences in banking, ticketting, supermarketing and, incredibly, FEDEX, the majority are lumbered with a paper-style method of working not so very different from my title.

OK Word may be a can of worms (at least it comes with a bar code). But who is questioning whether word processing, spreadsheets, presentations and so forth are the omnificent hitech solutions to ease the daily burden. Me for one, how about you?

by rknrlkid

I agree with most of what has been said, but my main gripe has been with the whole "Office Suite" idea in the first place.

MS Office, to me, has all these features and bonuses that the average user will never need. I like the idea, in theory, of collaboration, but to be honest most people will never use it, especially since you must also have a server running all these other neat Microsoft products. The average user, in my experience, does not want a networked environment, but a stand-alone environment. (Which is a whole 'nother subject!)

At home, Word/Office is such over kill its like using a 500lbs bomb to kill a cockroach. It will work, but not the most efficient. My recommendation for those who use it to write letters to family, or for kids to write reports, is to use something else that could be easier. (Lately, I have been recommending AbiWord. Its one of the few stand-alone word processors I have been impressed with.)

Office 97 was the pinacle of the Office series. It was everything the majority of users needed and wanted. Since its gotten so bloated and over-featured, my suggestion is the next best thing, Open Office. With version 2.0 I think they are getting it right.

Just my two cents.

by michael_orton9

>>>>And files created in Word usually aren't readable by other word processing software, because Microsoft keeps Word's document format proprietary.>>>.
This statement is just plain untrue.
MS Word ( and excel and Powerpoint and even access) files can easily be opened, edited saved as practically anything, including pdfs by using Open Office in either win98-xp or Linux.
In linux I can even open password protected word files.
This does suggest that in every establishment there is a neeed for a dual boot Xp-Linux with a HD caddy, then you can recover nearly all Microsofy Saved work, even if the operating system is thoroughly trashed.
Just got the latest Suse Linux ?8 for all the 5 cds, took under an hour to upgrade on triple boot system.

by angelo.jordan

I think that competition is a good thing. It keeps companies on their toes.

However, I am hearing people say that most users don't need 99% of the features in Word.

I think it's truer to say most users DONT KNOW 99% of the features in Word, and therefore "think" they don't need them.

While it's true there are features most don't need such as collaboration and master documents ECT, many features are very helpful if people just knew how to use them.

Thanks
btw, I am a applications trainer with the State of Oregon. :)

by rknrlkid

I agree that many of the problems with the overdose of features is not that they exist, but that people have no clue what they are about. Training IS the answer. Unfortunately, training is something that 99% of people will never get.

I work at a school where we train people to use Office applications. Do you think our people go to these classes? Nope. There is no excuse for NOT being trained, because the school picks up the tab if any employee wants to take any of the classes! Employees like myself who are trained and certified are pretty rare. (Its one of my few gripes about where I work; this is a great place to work at!).

Training is the solution, but most places are pretty fast paced and the train doesn't want to slow for the Training Station.

This discussion is closed to new replies.