Question Locked

Eco Cooling small server room

0 helpful
7 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hi all,

We have a small server room 1.1M(W) x 1.8M(L) x 2.5M(H). The building was designed to be eco friendly, and as such, at the moment we have an extraction unit which directs the warm air downstairs in Winter and outside in Summer. Our only issue with this is it moves the smallest amount of air I have ever seen.
We have to keep the server room door open at all times and, approaching summer I am not sure that is even enough.
The obvious option is a Wall mounted split air con unit, the ducting etc will not be easy, but it is the only long term solution I can see. The architect (and I think some of the people I work with though) do not see this as a Eco friendly solution. The architect wants to put in a floor level duct to bring in cool outside air, though we would then be concerned about humidity. He believes with a small increase in draw from the ceiling extraction fan and this extra duct we will be able to keep the room cool.
We have four servers which according to Dell's calculation are spitting out around 5000 BTU p/hr.

Does anyone know a calculation which will be able to show that the anmount of air required is far more eco unfriendly than the energy consumed by an AC unit?

P.S although I cannot prove it was heat, we recently had 2x48 Port GB switches die on the same day.

7 replies

by robo_dev

Someone needs to calculate the amount of heat generated versus the actual airflow required.

You need to put your foot down and specify the operational parameters you need: what the max temperature and humidity your servers can handle. Humidity is worse than heat for electronic gear, and other elements such as backup tapes are very vulnerable to moisture.

While using outside air can be helpful, humidity control, obviously, is a problem, and, obviously, you're at the mercy of the ambient temperature.

5000 btuH has to go somewhere....

Is there air conditioning in the building?

by cmiller5400

Well some sort of it. Doesn't matter how you get it done, but you need to keep that room between 68 - 75 degree's (Fahrenheit) and between 45-55% relative humidity.

Edit: Clarity

by unhappyuser

If the server room does not stay within specs, as noted in another post, you will have some form of equipment failure (use the switches as an example).

Tell them that if you have to replace equipment damaged by the high heat or humidity you will be sending more hazardous waste to the landfill (e.g motherboard).

The AC unit may not be eco friendly to them but it will have less of an impact on the environment you have equipment failure. If you want more data to prove your point do a little research on what's in a motherboard or a power supply. I think you'll convince them.

Has anyone come up with the idea of using some form of geothermal cooling? Just a thought.

Good luck!

EMD

by thechas

Unless your summer outdoor air temperature never gets above say 18?C, you will need some form of additional cooling.

Perhaps the most eco-friendly way for a small room would be a ground water system. You need a well and a sump. The sump needs to be far enough from the well so that the returned water does not flow directly back into the well.

Pump the well water through a system of radiators in the server room and dump the warmed water into the sump.

To make the system more eco-friendly, use a DC pump motor and a wind generator or solar panels to charge a battery that powers the pump.

While this would be much more expensive to install than a simple window air conditioner, it has many eco benefits and a low operating cost.

You could also get similar performance with a thermal sump. Basically, you fill a deep underground room with dense rocks and pump air through the rocks and into your server room.

You may need to garner the aid of the buildings mechanical engineer to help show the architect that you have to move a LOT of even 18? air to remove 5000 BTU/Hr. from your server room.

Chas

by oh smeg

Throwing out Dead Hardware even if it is only a Switch isn't at all Eco Friendly and it will cause some form of Nasty Pollution due to what is in the Components on the Circuit Board/s.

Computers are considerably worse in that regard too.

But if you are between a Rock and a Hard Place you may have to dump the Problem back onto the Architect and make that person Responsible for any Hardware Failures till the company comes around to your Way of Thinking.

Though if you make someone carry the Can for a Poor Design they are very unlikely to want to accept that Responsibility and will duck the requirement to be responsible for a Poor or Inadequate Design.

As far as staying Eco Friendly with Lower Power Consumption than a AC Unit I'm not even sure that this is possible as I believe that to move enough air in Sumer with a reasonable Air Temp will be much more expensive than a AC unit but depending on what is required here you may just have to [b]Suck it and See What Happens.[/b] Though I firmly believe some sort of Heat Exchanger will be required to draw cooled air into the Floor Vent rather than normal Air at the then Air Temp of the Day. Something like what the Chas has suggested above will be required and it is going to be expensive but it is basically what most Commercial Buildings use as a AC System anyway only in this case more expensive to install and considerably more Expensive to Maintain. You'll need to treat the Water for Legionaries Disease as well to prevent Possible Contamination so something like Injecting Tea Tree Oil into the Water will be required that is if the Industrial Health & Safety allow it as they may require something more robust to protect the people who may walk into the building and the people who work there.

Col

This discussion is closed to new replies.