Question Locked

Empl'ee Private E mail access by Emp'er After EE has left job....

0 helpful
19 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hi: Don't know much about IT but think I know about privacy. I left a job in June. My private E mail (Hot mail) which i did access from Employer hardware is still somehow showing up on their PC. (from what I understand, when you go to hot mail, my acct name remains and somehow they've been able to get in...) So, What Ive been informed is since June 06 managers and others are accessing it and reading it.

My questions:

1) I am no longer an employee so these mails have nothing to do with the company

2) they are personal/not business (to them) in nature

3) Can I determine where my accounts were opened from (ie can MS determinine that on X date my mail was opened from Computer #4 at my old employer ...while I was in , say Cleveland??)

4) ...and although I did sign some notice that the use of PC would be business related...now that I am gone doesnt that become moot? ....and in the alternative, how do they justify cont. monitoring of my emails on a private account as "business"?

Just some things to throw out....I look forward to some community insight.

Thanks ,
Tony

19 replies

by charliespencer

I don't know squat about Hotmail, but I assume you have to enter a password to get into your account. It sounds like you logged into your Hotmail account on the company computer and answered "Yes" when IE prompted to save your password. If you change your password the problem should go away.

If MS tracks the IP address of the computer used to access the account, they probably won't give you the information without a lot of effort on your part.

You signed an agreement governing the use of company equipment. The agreement is not voided because of the change in your employment status. By saving your password on their computer, you have in effect granted the user of that computer unrestricted access to your account. I'm not a lawyer (and I don't play one on TV), but I suspect you don't have a legal leg to stand on.

by tonythetiger

[i]By saving your password on their computer, you have in effect granted the user of that computer unrestricted access to your account.[/i]

That implies permission. If I left my key in the ignition of my car, while it was in the company parking lot, do they have the right to search the trunk?

"Inadvertently left your account vulnerable to access" might have been more accurate.

by impossibletask

It's because of the above statement, "By saving your password on their computer, you have in effect granted the user of that computer access. Therefore all the intruder has to do is plant the password on a machine. Just log into a machine the former employee used and access their email account, so we can say they did it! That's so common it's not even funny.

I watched a young computer engineer right out of school get taught all these intrusion technics, he was trained to perform all this illegal activity to obtain pay raises and bonuses. It became a way of life for him and professional job. So he performed things like the above stated, with the belief that he was more clever then the legal system. He studied the law to determine how to manipulate the system. So the more he could manipulate private email accounts, the more skilled and more pay raises given. He in fact doesn't believe he's breaking the law, "it's his job".

Changing the password? they use W-2 identity theft to retain all information needed. The employer was telling people I still worked for their company(2)years after I started with another company (Europe). They also use their office in Asia to access accounts as well, I am certain everyone knows about this activity. This company uses a small office in Asia to access accounts in the US (I have visited this office). You better do some homework when it comes to email, they used this office to obtain contract information from my email. How did I find out, I worked in Asia and caught the engineer, he thought it was funny (It was a sales company for the other company). And the bad part is you can't do anything about it, just start another account for several months until that one is intruded.

by 1bn0

Now, before they do it for you.

Palmetto is probably right about IE caching your username and password. (it defaults to that all the time.)

If you change your Hotnail password, that should stop them from accessing and reading your email.

Getting proof the have been doing so may be impossible. not saying its doesn't exist somewhere, just that getting it may not be worth the hassle.

by tony hopkinson

change your password.

Privacy doesn't come into it, If I still worked there though I'd be worried. Either there is some weirdo in charge, or their internal security policies just suck.

by dcwold

Hi, wonder if you got some answers to above since i had similar situation. Had my private email (that i got 7 years before joining the company) forwarded via their server to my computer and (company) blackberry. One day i was told to leave at end of the day and had no more access to blackberry or computer. found that they maintained monitoring my private email account and used information between myself and my lawyer to minimize my severance pay and prepare a counter-law suit.

by older mycroft

YOU set up YOUR email to be forwarded via a company server to YOUR company computer terminal and YOUR company blackberry.

YOU then departed from the company.

YOU didn't change the forwarding on YOUR email settings!

YOU got stung in YOUR severance pay deal.

Access to the company computer/blackberry was not necessary, all YOU needed to do was cancel the email forwarding on YOUR email account.

The Company didn't do anything wrong because YOU kept forwarding copies of YOUR emails.

Are YOU in the corner yet and does the Dunce's hat fit YOUR head??? :D

by jdclyde

that it is a perfect fit on top of his pointy little head....

Do something that dumb and then try to blame others for it.

Should we feel worse about him getting shorted on his severence or on him being dumb? I know my choice....

by cmiller5400

Why would you forward your private e-mail to your work computer? This is your own fault for leaving the forward on, but I would still contact an attorney and find out what your legal rights are just in case they did something illegal...

by dcwold

The issue is not why i have private emails forwarded, a offer the employeer gave the whole dept, but what happens when you are forced to leave the office. Are both private postal mail and private email accounts 'company property' ? Secondly to really see what i was receiving on private email they where not happy with watching my private emails copied to my ex-blackberry/computer but had to 'hacked' into my earthlink account and had the private email account setup so it forward to a 3rd person within the company for 're-view'. Only when a friend sent a message with 'receipt request' was it found that earthlink account setup had been changed to this 3rd person.
Earthlink is 'unable' to say how many messages where forwardeed , despite giving them ip address of receiving terminal.

by robo_dev

If an employee of your former employer is logging into your private email account without your consent, then they have violated the law, pure and simple. Unauthorized access to a computer system is a felony, and is subject to both state and federal laws.

From a prosecution standpoint, most jurisdictions would not bother with such a case unless the amount of monetary damages were large or if the breach happened as part of another crime.

If you could get a court to issue a warrant to obtain access logs from your ISP, then the evidence of unauthorized access would be fairly clear: You can prove when you stopped working there, you can easily determine the IP address of your former employer. The ISP would typically have records showing the IP address of the computer accessing their system to read email. They would not release that information to anyone without a warrant.

by dcwold

Thanks, as some of the emails sent to me after i had left the company had 'return receipt' we did optain the IP address of the machine that physcically did access my private email. It was different then the one that i worked on when i was employed. But Earthlink are not willing to play 'ball' and confirm or explain how long they had been conveying copies to this IP address. Via lawyer i have obtained confirmation that my ex-company had obtained copies of emails to/from me, but not yet how they obtained same. The cost of obtaining a warrant has been described as 'thousands' since Earthlink might appeal etc.. Anybody have any experience on this issue ?

by impossibletask

About (7) years ago I worked for a small company on International Projects, they were breaking into my email in the office and showing other employees'. And thereafter have broke into my private email for (7) years. I contacted several State and Federal Departments, they would provide no assistance. I provided evidence of the breakins, including screen messages of more than one commputer connected to email account. No government office assigned to investigate would acknowledge anything in my state. I am now on my (8th) email account, tested it by sending 190 emails during the weekend. By Monday at the end of the work day I recieved (6) returns, thereafter zero. Because of changes in the law, most of the government offices won't investigate, they simply state you have to prove you lost at least $50,000 dollars. The problem with one office that performs these investigations, is I worked with them during an investigation. The office Federal knows my emails were being broke into and were told to stop their investigation. Thereafter the office would not check my emails for the breakin.

by older mycroft

You ought to have the theme for 'Mission Impossible' running in the background if you want to continue typing this pap.

Honestly, any fool who sat watching his/her emails being intercepted for SEVEN YEARS! - That wouldn't pass muster for a Mission Impossible script, but it would probably make for great viewing in a CARRY ON film. ;)

by impossibletask

Email break-in for (7) years. Anyone who believes just making simple changes in password or other would prevent cyber-stalking, you?re living in an imaginary world. I am a Senior Electronic Engineer and veteran who served on counter-terrorist team (Special Operations) some years ago.

Why is this twisted manager stalking me? This company has about 15 people, quite small, and relocated me from another state to work on their projects. I was later assigned to work abroad in a large western country, and thereafter discovered they were exporting sensitive components without approval. They made shipments to this country, and then assigned me to work on the projects (measurement systems). I discovered things weren?t correct, strange activities and this included this company being investigated by a Federal Agency. Executives at this company didn?t inform anyone of this investigation, reckless endangerment by the company. Later while in this country and attending a meeting, one of their executive officers established an agreement with a secret weapons company. Thereafter, I decided to leave this company and clearly understood why one manager didn?t answer any emails I sent from the country (He ignored everything). After this company partnered with the secret weapons company, I wanted nothing to do with them, and quickly started pursing other jobs. One manager from this company became obsessed with my private emails and cyber-stalking me on the Internet. This manager wanted to stop my pursuit of jobs and leaving the company to force me in the middle, because no one would work for a company involved in this activity. However, later while travelling to this country was attacked at the airport, this occurred shortly after this manager discovered my pursuit of other work. I reported this to Federal Agency and they spoke with me several times, however months later one person came to my home and said our investigation is stopped, because there?s too much business in this country (A Federal Agency says weren?t stopping an investigation regarding the illegal export of sensitive components and threats made to me, because the US does to much business in this country?). This is the truth! Thereafter, I knew something was seriously wrong, this Agency knew the company was threatening me. This wasn?t a weapons company!

Another software engineer who worked for this company for some years travelled to the country to perform some software work, so I asked him why the company partnered with a secret weapons company? He replied and said, ?Don?t tell me that?, and then covered his ears as if he wished to ignore. After the Federal Agency stopped their investigation, the stalking increased even though I no longer worked for the company. One manager at this company is so obsessed with me, that he?s been stalking me for years. I discovered later the information discussed with the State Federal Agency was not passed to other Federal Agencies. What this company was doing was illegal, and in 2005 it was ignored, and someone stopped an investigation. Later the company continued to make threats to me, the state Federal Agency ignored the information sent to them. Because they were told to ignore, the executives involved in this activity quickly sold the small company to a European company in 2008, before the next administration took office.

It?s that serious, and this isn?t a joke. The country on the receiving end also supplies technology to some Middle Eastern countries.

So if anyone believes you?re truly protected under the law, you may discover it doesn?t quite work that way.

The only reason I posted this, is to provide a warning to people. Laugh now, but if activity like this continues, you'll discover what happens when the wrong people get the right technology.

by impossibletask

Fast Story,

Service provider goes to big Asian market, to implement their service but it must be approved by the government. Government say's yes, but you must provide us with email of specific people and information we request. Company agree's.

Not much different then what they practice in US, but with a different twist. This country is interested in any of their people discussing Democratic ideals, and hate this concept.

Company provides them with private emails, then governement starts arresting people. They believe in (2) things, arrest and execute quickly. It takes time before the big company releases what was taking place. They though it was like the US.

They had absolutely "NO" ideal how their information would be used. They though it was just business as usual.

by cmiller5400

While you were in their employ, any e-mail you had forwarded to [b]company equipment[/b] is subject to surveillance by your employer. Once you were no longer an employee, it was up to [b]you[/b] to make sure that your private e-mail was not being forwarded to them. Changing passwords would have been on the top of my list. Now if someone from your former employer changed something not on their systems that affected your personal e-mail after you were terminated/severed/quit/fired, without your consent, you may have a legal case against them. It is a felony for unauthorized computer intrusions. Consult an attorney for advice on your options to sue them and/or have the case possibly referred to the local District Attorney for criminal prosecution.

Earthlink will only release information with a court order, subpoena, etc.

EDIT: I just reread your post and why you would ever have your personal postal mail delivered to your work? I am not a lawyer so I can't answer whether or not they could open it or not...

by dcwold

Thanks and understand that i was naive to just ask them to discontinue the forwarding capacity with Earthlink, but done is done.
What i found out by way of 'return receipt' is that the private emails where no longer read by 'my' ex-terminal - but by a 'newly appointed' IP address that happen to be assigned to a central person in the whole conflict. The company later confirmed that they 'had obtained' copies of 'some' of the correspondance - not showing how they had obtained same. But getting court order towards Earthlink to release information as when it started/how much was transmitted etc.. can be rather costy - according to lawyers.

This discussion is closed to new replies.