Discussion Locked

Entering the Information Security Field

0 helpful
13 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I am a recent graduate with a B.S. in Management Information Security (Systems sorry I have Security on my mind lol). I have always been interested in Information Security, but I understand that I need to get more experience under my belt to reach my goal.

I just had a few questions. Which would be the best route to get into Information Security? Right now I have been offered three options for certification courses:

Package One: A+, Network+, MCP Windows XP Professional, Security+, and CCNA
Package Two: A+, Network+, Security+

Which would be the best value to attempt to get an entry level job in Information Security? I know certifications do not guarantee a job, but it will help in my experience.

My second question would be related to the second. Should I just skip both packages and aim for MCSA (or MCSE?) I see that they both include the Security+ information.

Also if you want to input any more comments about getting into IS for future references would be excellent. Thank you.

13 replies

by tig2

I am in Data Security. My primary focus is from the governance and compliance view.

If you are primarily interested in network security, you want to look at Security+ and possibly the Cisco security cert.

You don't meed the A+. I have one but only because I used to do warranty support for IBM and Compaq/HP.

If you want to work on the compliance/governance side, you want to be looking at CISSP for starters.

The MCP and CCNA won't do you much good. Neither will the A+ or Network+. A professional org will be more help as will a grounding in risk management.

Check this link: https://www.isc2.org/cgi-bin/index.cgi for some good information and use Google. Google is your friend.

Ask me anything on security, always happy to help any way I can.

Good luck!

by dspeacock

As usual, Tigger has good advice. The only thing I would suggest you do differently, without knowing your background, is forgo the Network+/Security+ and go for the SSCP (also from isc2.org) if networking is your thing. It covers most of the CISSP CBK, but is more geared to the operational side of the house, unlike the CISSP which is more managerial in focus.

Figure out where you want to go, and what you'd like your focus to be, and ask questions (remembering that the only dumb question is the one you don't ask). Like Tigger, I'd be happy to answer any I can, or point you in the right direction.

by c l kerr

isc2 will not give you a CISSP without work experience though.

You can also check ISACA's CISM.

by grimmjow

Thank you very much, each of you have helped me with some sight of which way I want to go. I want to work more on the network security side of things and then I'll see from there.

Thank you again, hopefully this thread will be able to help someone else in the future.

by zdnet4clgomez

You're a little a head of me with finished in your BS in MIS, am still going to school to earn my BS in IT, and looking for the right path to becoming a professonial in infosec with networking-management. I have the same desire that you're going through, want to be in the infosec field, earn numerous certs and especially obtaining CISSP cert.
Your questions in the blog, give me a direction to follow, want to thank you and other that replied.
Let help each other out and good luck.

Chris

by dspeacock

This is true. I had to submit a resume as well as certification from another CISSP or C Level executive in my company before I could use the title.

What IS available is the "Associate" of CISSP which means you've passed the test, but don't have the requisite experience yet. Once that is gained, you can use the title.

by tig2

Has been to find a mentor now (CISSP) who will validate my experience in addition to my resume and work with that individual on certification pathing.

I am fortunate to have the requisite experience but will likely stay with the ISC's recommendation that I work closely with a mentor for at least a year.

You can also submit additional proofs of competency with your background.

by dspeacock

Tigger

You are so right in this approach. My immediate supervisor here has been a CISSP for almost 10 years and I'm looking at this contract as one great big learning and validation experience. She even has me prepping for the CISA in June (she's taking it too).

I knew a fair bit, but only in 3-4 of the areas of the CBK....now I'm getting hands on in the other areas and this can ONLY be a positive thing. Too bad this is such a short contract :-(

by it cowgirl

I have worked with several groups of security persons with their Security certs, but had no idea where to place their security devices on their network.

If you do not understand how the network actually functions, then knowing only security is not enough. You need to know and understand both.

I am earning my CCNA, then CCNP, then the CCSP and more Security from there.

by jdlane

Your choices for certification paths may be of use. Like the other's have suggested, experience is required for the higher level certs i.e CISSP. Even CCNA could prove difficult if you don't have the knowledge required of the Network+ exam.

If you are already well versed in the networking world but are completely new to the security world I would check out Security +, and along the way as you get experienced, look at CISSP.

by zbatia

Being in the IT field for more than 15 years and teaching folks since 1993, I know quite a bit about the IT, and particularly about IT security. I began my journey in that field by taking the responsibility for managing one firewall. It was a good start. It gave me a lot of exposure to the IT security, forced me to read about various protocols in depth, concepts, and it forced me to learn UNIX.

The common mistake is to start the career by taking the certification classes or exams. The concept "certification" is about certifying the skills you already have. So, my suggestion (if you really want to be a high-level professional), start with hands-on experience.
If you want to know more about certifications, read my article published in 2002 that (some people believe) still has some value:
http://www.rtek2000.com/Good/Why_we_have_to_fight_with_hypes.pdf

Find the way to get some exposure to the security appliances (firewalls, proxy servers, content filters, IDS), software (basically the same but software-based), tools (scanners, packet capturing/analyzing, sniffers, etc), and as a ?must? read the literature and security-related articles that will expand your horizon. Be a volunteer, find a mentor, or at least build a small network at home and play with the evaluation copies (or freeware) of various software utilities/programs/firewalls. Learn how to harden the OS or web server, etc. Build a Linux server and workstation. Talk to your management and express your interest to get more exposure/responsibilities to IT security. Show it as a potential benefit to your organization.

Another suggestion is not taking the short-term training classes but rather buying the multimedia-based self-training software with live instructors that present the topics you want to learn. There are many benefits (like repeating, stopping, portability, rewinding, pausing, etc). Some of the vendors also offer online mentoring in addition to the software. All this works fine if you have enough self-discipline.

If you follow the path that I suggest, the certifications will be achieved easier and will add the value to your hands-on experience. Don?t forget that in the security field the employers are looking for real-world experience. So, the abbreviation letters after your last name will be more powerful if you have something in your resume that highlights your hands-on skills.

I would not suggest the CISSP certification at all at this stage of your career. The CISSP certification is valuable when you have substantial experience (5-7 years) in the information security field. It is mostly designed for the management (or at least, senior-level) security professionals. That certification can give you more opportunities to get better paying job but at the right time. If some of the folks disagree with me I would forward them to the article above where I describe the dentist who just got certified.

If you still seriously consider CISSP as one of your choices, at least you can get more information and links about it here: http://www.800-security.com/corporate.html (this site also has a comprehensive Index of free IT security resources) and here (about the exam itself): http://securecyber.blogspot.com.

Best of luck in your career!

by bradhola

Wondering what you recommend for multimedia self study training as there are so many out there? Thanks

This discussion is closed to new replies.