I haven't found that there is one product that is equally strong in all areas and a lot of the decision should be based on what you'll be managing and whether there are agents for it for the product you're considering.
For example, in managing a Cisco infrastructure, I'm fond of HP OpenView with CiscoWorks. On the other hand, for managing Compaq servers, I like Compaq's Insight Manager software. In an IBM shop with a SAN, I might choose Tivoli. I'm not fond of Unicenter but that is more from bad experience with CA rather than any particular weakness of the product.
When I need to tie it all together with custom reporting, I prefer to write my own SNMP tools and use such tools as MRTG to handle the graphical display functions.
So I tend towards the best-of-breed solution rather than the all-in-one.
paul