Discussion Locked

Ethernet Maximums

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
My company is running Novell Netware and Windows NT 4.0 in an Ethernet. I am aware of the 5-4-3 rule for Ethernets, but I'm wondering what the effect generally is for having more than 3 hubs with computers on them. Does this typically generate errors? Does this typically generate collisions? Will the system simply explode?

5 replies

by jej1962

If these are truly hubs and not switches, you have to realize that anytime a host or desktop communicates, it is broadcasting across the hubs, basically across your Ethernet.
Does it generate errors? It only generates errors if the utilization is high enough to cause collisions (which is probably the case), or if there are inherent problems with your network (failing cards, drivers, lousy cabling).
Yes, it will generate a much higher rate of collisions than switches, which is why you shouldreplace the hubs with a higher density switch.
Your system will most likely not explode, but it will be amazingly slow at a high utilization rate.
Advice:
go to www.cisco.com - do a search on something like "hubs and switches and benchmark" orinclude those keywords in your search.
The results may surprise you.

by Former member

Hubs or switches, you would still have a problem-the more you daisy chain from a root hub or switch port, the less bandwidth you have throughout the one port to it's child hubs. The bandwidth degredation is equal to the sum divided by the number of shared ports. So, lets say you have a port on a hub, which is cross connected to another 24-port hub, which is cross connected to another 24-port hub, which is cross connected to another 24-port hub, which is cross connected to another 24-port hub. IN this scenario, you have basically 96 ports, supposing they were all populated, contending for 1 (10MB) port, which is the first hub's port making the first cross-connect. You can see that 10MB (if it is 10MB) divided by 96 equals somewhere around 104K. This is the bandwidth available to your users. In a hub environment, the collision rates would bring you network to a halt at high-useage.

THe good things about switches is that:

-High speed 100MB/Full Duplex
-Collision prevention at those speeds.

Buy some switches.

This discussion is closed to new replies.