Discussion Locked

European IT industry is going under in about a year or two

0 helpful
31 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

http://www.euractiv.com/en/infosociety/high-ICT-salaries-hamper-eu-digital-market-news-493719

Time from skill shortage lobbyist conference to PR campaign is 3-6 months, and time from its peak to next wave of layoffs is 6 months to a year. That means I probably have 2 years to start the alternative career.

I got to admit I'm pretty surprised by the bluntness of the European skill shortage lobbyists. They stated loud and clear, that they want to kick the IT wages down.

31 replies

by ansugisalas

Get people moving to get heard.
Or better yet. Pull the plug; declare a europe-wide IT strike, forcing companies responsible to stick it where the sun doesn't shine, because, let's face it, someone is paying the lobbyists, and those people can be hurt, but only right now. Cut them where it bleeds, i.e. harm or threaten their passage to the "depression bounceback gravytrain", and they can be made to dump their wet dreams. But it requires immediate action, and it requires showing willingness to let their systems crash if they keep thinking bad thoughts.

by charliespencer

Everything I see in it says IT / ICT skills will continue in high demand, and that a shortage of qualified people will keep salaries up.

by jkameleon

It's about salaries being too high. It's about creating a talent glut to lower the salaries. The article is very clear about it.

Skill shortage shouting is usually the loudest about a year before economic crash & mass layoffs.

The best example of this phenomena is Harris Miller & ITAA "critical programmer shortage" campaign in 1998 and 1999. Dotcom crash happened soon afterwards, and hundreds of thousands of programmer jobs were lost, never to return.

The next shortage shouting wave came in 2006 and 2007. If you google "i(c)t skill shortage", "i(c)t talent shortage", "it talent pipeline", "it careers" "young people", "computer science enrollment" in various combinations, you'll get the picture, I think.

As far as I was able to figure out, it goes as follows. Economic situation gets a bit more tense, profit margins narrow, companies begin to struggle, and management has to justify less than stellar results. One of the best excuses is lack of adequate talent, like: "We are reluctant to expand our business, to sign new contracts, because we can't find the right people to do the technical part. Yeah, there are tons of unemployed techies out there, sure enough, but none of them is good enough for us. They simply lack the exact skill set we need. And yeah, they demand too much money as well." Once repeated often enough, this starts to echo around the politics and media even without the deliberate campaign.

Shortage shouting is a sort of early warning of impending economic troubles. A sort of proactive, covert cost-cutting measure, if you will.

by ed woychowsky

Read Mark Twain's Life on the Mississippi, it's available online. I particularly recommend the chapters on learning to be a cub pilot. It seems even though more and more pilots were needed salaries were going down. This oddity was due to pilots creating too many cubs, which in two or three years became pilots themselves.

Twain, covers how this problem was resolved, makes for an interesting read.

by charliespencer

Apparently my two semesters of economics aren't going to aid me in following this one. Forget I said anything and I'll butt out.

by ansugisalas

Means, they won't drop.
I think this is fallout from the wage-pressures that the US is seeing. Someone wants to join the bandwagon.

by ansugisalas

"According to industry analysts, Europe is set to have a shortage of 300.000 experts in the information and communication technologies (ICT) sector by 2015, as it is expected that 90% of all jobs, across sectors, will require the use of digital expertise."

- See?
They're entering a completely grabbed-out-of-ass "expectation" (suuure, welders will need microsoft certifications in 2015... as will lunch ladies, truck drivers and streetsweepers... and farmers!), and following from this totally bogus expectation they produce an equally bogus "shortage".

Since the expectation is false, the whole campaign amounts to making governments train excess techs, creating widespread unemployment which serves to artificially lower wages for all techs.

by ansugisalas

About needing Microsoft certifications?Seriously?
But yes, unfortunately all linguists will indeed need certifications, as many as possible.

by charliespencer

How is a 300,000 man shortage going to cause layoffs?

Where are you getting the certification requirement? There's no mention of certification anywhere in the article.

Maybe the EU economy works radically different from that of the US. Maybe your training system is capable of cranking out 300,000 (or even 100,000) qualified ICT technicians by 2015; ours isn't. A shortage of trained IT technicians here is generating jobs in India like crazy, along with fast-track 'H1-B' visas for qualified immigrants.

Do EU governments actively recruit and train based on reported shortages like this report? Is that the difference and why I'm not following you? Here, such a report would be viewed by students as a lucrative field of study to go into. Our government would not have an role in filling such a job market shortage beyond passively reporting it.

by jkameleon

> I don't know what 'IOW' is an abbreviation for.

In Other Words

> If a shortage doesn't get reported, how do you know when one exists? Are legitimate shortages not reported?

Legitimate (skill) shortages don't exist. There is only shortage of money for wages.

> If you don't keep the engineer salaries competitive, why would anyone enter or remain in the field? If no one enters the field, if people are leaving it, how can you compete with India, China, or anyone else?

Good reasoning. "Entering the field" is rather costly endeavour, in terms of time, effort, and tuitions. Salaries and job opportunities in the field, current and expected, have to justify the time and money invested into study. Alas, companies can't afford salaries that high in order to remain competitive on the global market.

Quite a nasty problem, but there is a solution: Conning people into the field by the means of phony skill shortage reporting. It's an old trick. The earliest known case is an article in Times magazine somewhere in the 1950s, warning about the impending nuclear scientist shortage.

EU doesn't need 300,000 new IT professionals, its economy will never produce that many IT jobs. It needs 300,000 unemployed IT professionals to drive the wages down.

by ansugisalas

As I see it, is that the basis for the projected shortage is bogus.
The EU does have clout, even if in ways it says it doesn't. It can influence a large number of intergovernmental bodies, and if they make IT-education boosts part of prerequisites for f.ex. loans or other such, then there's going to be an effect. They can also tweak the giving of exchange scholarships.
The US federal government is in many ways in opposition to the state governments, but the EU is more of a social club, the member states are not so much opposed to each other in that forum, as they are playing power games with each other, deciding on ways to go, etc.
The EU is also different in that it encompasses a wider wealth range than the US, the EU has very price-competitive formerly eastern block countries, so an appeal to salaries being prohibitively high is strange. Said companies can just invest in the eastern parts, they need the investments there, and some good can come of it.
But what I think gets their shorts in a twist is, that while many Indians are good at english, not so many are good at french, german, italian, spanish, etc. etc. Outsourcing overseas is not as viable, and they think it stinks.
I feel no sympathy. They can go invest in Czech, or Slovakia, or Estonia, etc. etc... or suck it up and compete on quality.
Either way is good.

by ansugisalas

I have gotten the impression that overseas outsourcing is costing jobs in the US, moving them overseas, rather than generating them there.
Obviously, it might be that there is a net growth in positions, and that more are created in India than are terminated in the US. But that doesn't mean that there is not a net loss in the US. It's complex.
But, the low-cost Indian techie is a disappearing resource. Their prices will go up, and by that time, they'll have us all by the nuts. Not that that's a bad thing. Maybe they'll be a better hegemony.

by ansugisalas

Linguists being generally unemployable, we really are the lowest of the low, at least commercially speaking. Buying power not that great either. :(
But [_]3 I'm ok with it.
I realized after the fact that I made a list that could be construed as a list of crap jobs. Such a construction is no product of mine, but of the prejudices of the construer.
I just don't see how an increase in the percentage of jobs requiring the use of a computer (90%, seriously?) can lead to an increased need for IT pros equalling a full 1% of the total population of the european union.

by ansugisalas

They're employable like ... like ... well, they can get jobs as guides at most any museum, like that *snap*.
That's so out of the league of linguists.
We can get jobs at McDonalds if we manage to keep our wiseass comments in line during the interview... that's a big if, right there.

by av .

They need ICT people, but they don't want to pay for them so they are encouraging more people to get training so they can undervalue the job.

I don't know what the EU IT field is like now, but I think it sort of mirrors what has happened to IT in the US over the past 10 years. In the US, citizens were laid off from their high-paying IT jobs and replaced with super-cheap, overseas labor. Maybe the EU doesn't want to use foreign labor, but if you go into IT, you're not going to make any real money in the future.

My job as a US Net Admin now also includes the phone system, smartphones, digital copiers, etc. Its double the work for the same salary. I don't like it, but thats the way it is. If you're a "lucky" US IT person that has a job, you are doing, at least, two jobs.

At least the EU came out and said it. In the US, they lied and said Americans were not as qualified as the cheap overseas labor.

Still, the writing is on the wall. Low pay, more productivity and more competition. You can stay in the field, but yes, there will be layoffs. Out with the old high paid workers, and in with the cheaper ones.

IT can still be good, even in a down economy, if you find the right niche.

AV

by jkameleon

> At least the EU came out and said it. In the US, they lied and said Americans were not as qualified as the cheap overseas labor.

That's not the only lie. There's another, even bigger: That only low level technical jobs get offshored.

Being an Eastern European, I went full circle from "stealing" your jobs to fearing for my own, I've seen both sides of offshoring 1st hand. In the beginning of the 1990s, our economy was in shambles, our salaries miserable, and consequently, we were offshoring destination. Back then, we got all the good stuff: Highly technical, easy to specify, hard core R&D. But, the moment that infamous H1B visa of yours wasn't worth applying for anymore- whooosh, everything went further South.

> IT can still be good, even in a down economy, if you find the right niche.

Yup, that's all that's left.

by av .

I forgot about the bigger lie. It wasn't just the help desk stuff. All jobs in IT are fair game.

I've spent 25 years in IT. I worked for several years as a Network Admin in a large pharmaceutical company, but ended up working in a law firm. At the time, it was a huge step down from what I was used to technically, but I've done it for 15 years without a layoff or being replaced by cheap overseas labor.

My husband is also a Network Admin that has worked primarily for Fortune 500 companies. He has been laid off at least 5 times in the past 15 years, sometimes forced to train his H1b replacements in order to get his severance pay.

You definitely can get more job security at a smaller place, at least in the US.

When I started out in IT in the '80s, I thought I'd never have to worry about finding work, ever. IT had endless opportunities. It was so much fun.

Today, the IT industry has matured and been devalued by cheap labor and a whole lot of paper tigers. The problem is that you have to compete globally now and it isn't fair because the jobs always go to the cheapest labor.

AV

by charliespencer

how do you know when one exists? Are legitimate shortages not reported?

I don't know what 'IOW' is an abbreviation for. If you don't keep the engineer salaries competitive, why would anyone enter or remain in the field? If no one enters the field, if people are leaving it, how can you compete with India, China, or anyone else?

I'm going back to my original theory, that the same sentence in the same language is interpreted differently in the US than in Europe. Here, a shortage in a job market is a shortage in a job market.

Right now, we need hundreds of thousands of people in the health care field. This in all positions, from professionals, support, clerical, administrative, even IT. This shortage can be easily traced to the advancing age of our 'Baby Boom' generation, the massive surge in US birth rates in the '50s and '60s. The increase in their ages drives the shortage in two ways: people require more medical services as they get older, and those 'Boomers' in the medical profession are beginning to retire. It's a legitimate shortage in a field that will continue expanding for the next 15-20 years, and schools are working to fill it.

by jkameleon

> I don't know what 'IOW' is an abbreviation for.

In Other Words

> If a shortage doesn't get reported, how do you know when one exists? Are legitimate shortages not reported?

Legitimate (skill) shortages don't exist. There is only shortage of money for wages.

> If you don't keep the engineer salaries competitive, why would anyone enter or remain in the field? If no one enters the field, if people are leaving it, how can you compete with India, China, or anyone else?

Good reasoning. "Entering the field" is rather costly endeavour, in terms of time, effort, and tuitions. Salaries and job opportunities in the field, current and expected, have to justify the time and money invested into study. Alas, companies can't afford salaries that high in order to remain competitive on the global market.

Quite a nasty problem, but there is a solution: Conning people into the field by the means of phony skill shortage reporting. It's an old trick. The earliest known case is an article in Times magazine somewhere in the 1950s, warning about the impending nuclear scientist shortage.

EU doesn't need 300,000 new IT professionals, its economy will never produce that many IT jobs. It needs 300,000 unemployed IT professionals to drive the wages down.

by jkameleon

Before offshoring hit, I was writing specilized compilers, and developing wireless protocols. Now, I work in financial services.

My former boss worked in HP's offshore branch for a while. He told me it was pure dilbertism. After he was proclaimed "employee of the month", he quit in disgust even before the branch was closed. Later he found a job at a small family firm, where he remained until his pension.

As far as I was able to figure out, the dividing factor between in-house development and outsourcing/offshoring is ease of specification. Projects, that can be easily specified, are the most mobile, they are the first to be offshored, regardless of how technically demanding they are. There are innovative people everywhere. Typical example is development of communication modem algorithms.

The least mobile, and consequently least offshoreable is highly interactive, hard to specify development work, for example developing & maintaining core business applications.

by the 'g-man.'

I say lower people like Neelie Kroes salary or even get rif of them as there is no real need for a EU Information Society Commissioner as they have no jurisdiction anyway.

This discussion is closed to new replies.