I agree about the single carrier if all possible. That is why I believe the players I have listed are capable of those activities. We are currently an AT&T customer, so "getting lost in the shuffle" is the norm ;) jk... they have done pretty well for us and we have had a reliable network for several years. It is just that now it is a time for some changes and want to be sure that we consider all alternatives.
Issues to consider:
1. Change management. We must maintain configurations and documentation showing existing configuration across the enterprise. Changes must be well-managed and documented as part of the network lifecycle and to ensure compliance documentation is maintained. This also includes the ability to remotely manage devices and services.
- Addressing the risk: Use change management tools such as helpdesk for taking and documenting change requests. Other necessary items would include configuration documentation repositories to provide storage for running configurations as well
as OS images for the network devices. Remote (out of band) access will be necessary in some cases to perform maintenance and management. Standard architecture designs are easier to maintain. In addition there should be centralized change management controlling what a site is allowed to expose to the internet using their local connection.
2. Resource management. The network must provide reliable communication services between sites. This means that the performance must be measured and monitored to ensure that the network meets the communication needs of the site.
- Addressing the risk: Implement devices with the ability to track performance and usage information for reporting purposes. Implement network monitoring services to ensure uptime is maintained and downtime is reported as quickly as possible to begin any resolution activities.
3. Contingency management. Network connections are not capable of 100% uptime. There will be issues due to local infrastructure and telco (wiring) problems. Other issues may include weather or other communication interruptions. There should be an alternative means of communication between sites to maintain data services in a secure and managed manner.
- Addressing the risk: Provide a secure alternative communication method for a site to
communicate with the rest of the organization if their primary connection is down for some period of time.
4. Security management. The communication network must be secured from compromise by outside forces as well as secure from unauthorized internal changes. A compromise at one site may cause integrity issues at other sites. Alexander the Great: "Upon the conduct of each depends the fate of all."
- Addressing the risk: Implement a consistent security posture at each network communication point. This is required to ensure the ability to manage, report and reduce risks to the data architecture. A distributed network increases the amount of perimeter services that we have to securely manage and document for compliance purposes.
5. Data integrity. Private data and network services must ensure that the data and
servers will not be exposed to manipulation or capture by unauthorized parties.
- Addressing the risk: Secure the data in transit between facilities and ensure that the endpoints are secure from unauthorized capture and manipulation. Provide secure remote access to internal services for mobile users.
6. Technology skills. There is limited routing knowledge and skills within the organization.
Further training and additional staffing may be required to manage this infrastructure.
- Addressing the risk: Train some additional staff (2-3 people worldwide) in WAN technologies. May need to bring additional staff on board initially to roll out the architecture until it reaches a maturity level requiring little management other than small lifecycle changes.
7. Client communication services. There are services implemented at a Corporate level that will need to be maintained in a distributed environment. Such services include: ftp, secure e-mail (virus/spam-free), internet, data sharing (e.g. EDI and data transmissions), VPN.
- Addressing the risk: This is an unclear issue as to how to manage these services in a such a distributed environment. Some centralized services will be needed, but what, where and how are the questions.